If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

Russia has extensive organized crime and corruption problems as well as other ex-Soviet satellites.

Your knowledge of Russia is lacking. I am in Russia on business and won't be leaving for over a month.

Organized religion here is in bad shape. This is, as you would expect, the result of communism. But I have observed that a great many people here have some sort of poorly defined belief system that may or may not include a higher power. Many are what would be called "spiritual" in the US these days.

I am sure that the orthodox church would consider these people atheists. Some call themselves atheists. Many are not at all atheists or would best be described as agnostics.

As for organized crime, I have no experience with that. But it should suffice to say that the centers of traditional organized crime in the US involve people who are definitely not atheists.
 
That gives me an idea...

Sound OFF fellow atheists! What are your "crimes."* What terrible unlawful acts have you committed lately? Since we don't believe in a cosmic, abusive-father-figure to keep us mere mortals in line, we've HAD to have done something horrendous!

Let's see.... Oh! Last year, I WAS TWO MONTHS LATE WITH MY STATE AUTO-REGISTRATION FEE! :eek:

*I know this is line would be better when debating fredcarr, but I couldn't resist. Besides. all religion is Scientology to me.

Hmm. I often drive faster than the posted speed limit, but not faster than the flow of traffic. I've smoked pot, but that was a long time ago. I shoplifted as a teenager but I believed in God then. I committed adultery once, but I didn't know she was married...the first time (I have trouble turning down sexual offers from women I'm attracted to, a weakness that has only rarely been an issue due to the infrequency of occurence), but she was a Christian and I'm not sure it's illegal.

No wonder my (Christian) niece has a much lower purity score, despite my 30-year head start!
 
Yes, but all of those 4 countries have a higher suicide rate than the mostly Christian US. And the very rich Japan has more than double the rate of the US. Also it is no secret that atheistic Russia has extensive organized crime and corruption problems as well as other ex-Soviet satellites.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate

Also all those countries you mentioned are highly isolated from the rest of the world and aren't subject to the same multiracial and uneven income distribution pressures that say the US or France is.

And those countries you mentioned might even have a lower crime rate if everyone was theistic. Or a higher rate if everyone was atheistic for the reasons I've given in the above posts.

I am not sure what the suicide rate has to do with crime but it is the case that many northern countries do have a high suicide rate - regardless of theism/atheism. This is generally considered to be a caused by the long dark winters which apparently affect the brain chemistry. Living in a country with long dark winters I can certainly see where they are coming from :( Japan has a culture of honourable suicide and consequently one has to take this into account when considering the role of suicide in Japanese society.

It is certainly true that Russia and a number of other former Soviet Bloc countries have embraced consumerism with a passion and along with it organised crime. However, the Russian Mafia is so called because of its resemblance to the Italian one. Italy was of course a very theistic country - and to an extent still is. Consequently I am not sure there is any direct connection between theism and lack of crime - not sure what Russia's church attendance is but it would not surprise me if it was higher than Western Europe.

It seems to me that cultural norms are the most important. If children are raised to respect other people and their property then it is academic whether this is due to religious doctrine or cultural norms. A dysfunctional society will tend to have more crime because there will be competing cultural norms. Now if a country was full of people who in accordance with their theism actually put their religious teachings into practice (assuming those teachings are benign) then it might be that it would be a very safe and peaceful country. However, I don't think attendance of religious ceremonies is much of an indication. What people do is a greater indication of what they really believe.
 
from http://www.fstdt.com/fundies/top100.aspx?archive=1
so you think if no one believed in any religion there would be no wars or fighting? i think it would be worse. i know if i didn't fear god's judgement i would have killed many many times.

Of-course religious people do bad things sometimes. But at least their religion forces them to acknowledge within themselves the evil they do. Atheists have no such guidance. They are just like psychopaths! Cold, mechanical, soul-dead!

I think there are a lot more cases of people being agnostic or atheistic, but then getting off drugs in order to become Christians. I don't know any Christians who actually do drugs.

I honestly don't care about your rights. If it were up to me, all Atheists would be burnt at the stake and or cast into a river with weights tied to their ankles and or placed before the firing squad, etc etc etc.

Seriously, does anybody ever cry at an Atheist's funeral?

I mean, since Atheists have no value whatsoever as human
beings (they're not even human, but only inhuman animals),
since Atheists are nothing but miserable Liars, Cowards
and Murderers, after all, why would anybody in their
right mind weep over the dead rotting corpse, or bone
chips and ashes (that get mixed together with those of
others from the crematory) of a worthless dead Atheist?

and one of my favorites...
What do the other human persons here think ?

No doubt someone will object, saying something obviously ridiculous like, but atheists are persons.

But clearly this is mistaken because anybody without a well developed belief in God is obviously not a full human person.

What could be more obvious than that ?

How many full human persons do you know without a well developed belief in God. Obviously none, because if they were full human person they would have a well developed belief in God.

Now some people might object to killing atheists for there (and obviously it is there and not thier as they are not whos but whats ) organs but think of all the full human persons that would benifit from the organs and the medical research that could be done on these non-persons.

How could anybody object, they are not human persons and if you think we should not kill them then that is just because of out dated ideas and because they must really just want people to suffer. For shame on you !

So what do people think ?

Should we kill these atheist human non-persons for the benifit of fully human persons ?

Perhaps DOC has been hanging out with these people...

Oh, and btw, I want to thank whoever posted this link in another thread, it's been a incredibly fun read!
 
What may be a better way to view data is to break it down by states within the US. There will still be cultural variances, but not as challenging as comparing Japan to Russia to the US. Please note, the religion map is showing the percentage of people claiming "no religion". This does not account for the religions that are not some form of Christianity. For example, christians are not the majority in the state of Hawai'i (a lot of buddhists and new age-types here), but there are still a large number of people who consider themselves religious. This makes it difficult to compare the "no god" to "god" types. As noted previously, it is possible to be both religious and an atheist.

Religious affiliation by state:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Religious_Belief_in_North_America.png

Crime rates by state:

http://www.disastercenter.com/crime/US_States_Rate_Ranking.html

Suicide rates by state:

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwR/preview/mmwrhtml/00049117.htm
 
I’m also wondering if Christian supremacy is functionally equivalent to racism. That is, that the claim of superiority some religious people make with respect to the a-religious is tantamount to the claim of superiority some people make with respect to other races.

Well, using that line of thinking, then Jesus was a racist.
 
It would seem rational only if you assume that people need the fear of punishment to feel guilty about harming others. You keep doing good things out of fear of punishment, and I'll keep doing good things because I take pleasure in the happiness of others and feel pain when others suffer.

Well that's great you feel that way, and like I said in the OP, I'm not saying there aren't ethical atheists. And concern about punishment is just "one" reason for me to do good deeds. I could talk a lot about the love factor but these threads don't feel like the right environment to do that.
 
So if the number of Americans calling themselves Christian is around 80%, and all nine Supreme Court Justices identify themselves as following a religion, and all modern U.S. presidents have been Christian, and the percentage of atheists has never risen above 12%, then why do you think murder and crime is a way of life here? Are you seriously suggesting that atheists have that much power that they can make murder and crime a way of life in a Christian nation?

James Kennedy has a book entitled "What if America was a Christian Nation, Again". That about sums it up. How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up. Saying your a Christian and being and living like one are two different things. I doubt if there is much murder and crime in Amish country. Their the ones who really walk the walk. For those in other countries look up Amish on the web.
 
Oh, but the Amish are so isolated and monocultural, right? If the Norwegians and Japanese gets excused that way, how come that doesn't count double for the Amish?
 
James Kennedy has a book entitled "What if America was a Christian Nation, Again". That about sums it up. How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up. Saying your a Christian and being and living like one are two different things. I doubt if there is much murder and crime in Amish country. Their the ones who really walk the walk. For those in other countries look up Amish on the web.


Yeah, those good old days in the USA. You could wander the streets freely and safely, allowed to do whatever you wished without fear of your fellow men . . .

. . . unless you were African-American, or female, or homosexual, or . . .
 
Well that's great you feel that way, and like I said in the OP, I'm not saying there aren't ethical atheists.
But you are implying that they are a minority of atheists. Substitute any other ethnic or social group for the word "atheist" in your above statement and it all boils down to the same things: bigotry and arrogance.


And concern about punishment is just "one" reason for me to do good deeds. I could talk a lot about the love factor but these threads don't feel like the right environment to do that.
Unfortunately for you, your argument is based on the premise that theist's fear of punishment in an after-life makes them more likely to not commit crimes. By admitting that there are other factors involved in lawful, ethical behavior you are admitting that atheists can be just as well behaved as theists. I think you don't want to talk about the love factor because it destroys your argument.
 
That's one reason, but I would think that reason would apply more to atheists. Theists would have the added benefit of a possible afterlife reward which would not apply to atheists.

It would also seem that Theists would have more of the guilt factor that they were violating one of God's rules that a atheist would be less likely to have. It would seem rational to conclude that less guilty feelings means more crime.


If people were taught that history demonstrates acts of good and evil. And they were taught that people choose their actions based on thier own choices, instead of mythical sources of evil influences, that people wouldn't be so quick to give up on the idea of always making the right choice -- the choice to do good.
Religions, instead, have built-in excuses for personal failings. Religion teaches you to aim low and accept innadequacy and that living perfection is impossible.
 
James Kennedy has a book entitled "What if America was a Christian Nation, Again". That about sums it up.
Well if James Kennedy said it it must be true.

How many times have you heard older people say that they never locked their doors when they grew up.
Not one single time.

Saying your a Christian and being and living like one are two different things. I doubt if there is much murder and crime in Amish country. Their the ones who really walk the walk. For those in other countries look up Amish on the web.
I'm sorry DOC, but the Amish are not as pure as you would like to believe. You'll have to scroll down to the first part of the journal and then read the second part at the top.

Excerpts from the Indiana Law Enforcement Academy Master Instructor Program.
Rumspringa is a period of time between the age of sixteen and when individuals decide if they are going to join the Amish church and become baptized. It is during this time that young adults are allowed to "test the waters" of mainstream society.

Weekends in the Amish juvenile community involve socializing with other Amish youth. Much of the socializing that takes place occurs at large group gatherings or parties or while cruising around on the dirt back roads drinking, also called graveling. It is not uncommon for Amish to gather in groups of five or six juveniles and cruise the back roads drinking, smoking, and possibly doing drugs.

At first glance, rumspringa appears as a stain on Amish culture. The Amish, however, feel as though this fling with worldliness gives them the strength to come back to the Amish religion and be strong standing members. It is believed that ninety percent of the Amish youth will return to the Amish Church.

The history of this practice dates back to very early Amish culture. In the Amish culture, it is accepted and even is expected of the young Amish people.

To many Amish youth, running from police is a game which they learn form friends and family.

An example of this attitude is demonstrated in a recent situation in Millersburg, Ohio, at a nearby Amish settlement with close ties to Shipshewana. A group of more than 100 Amish juveniles at a party threw rocks at police cars, causing police to enter the party, at which time juveniles attempted to take the handgun of an Ohio Deputy. There were juveniles from several different Amish settlements throughout the United States at the party. Twelve of the Amish juveniles arrested were from LaGrange County in the Shipshewana area. While on probation one of the juveniles explained a plan by local Amish youth to ambush a Shipshewana deputy and flip over his squad car.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry DOC, but the Amish are not as pure as you would like to believe. You'll have to scroll down to the first part of the journal and then read the second part at the top.

I saw a documentary about Rumspringa not long ago. Those kids were wild :eye-poppi

(And, yeah, DOC even here in the isolated Sweden we learn of people in other parts of the world.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom