If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

That's one reason, but I would think that reason would apply more to atheists. Theists would have the added benefit of a possible afterlife reward which would not apply to atheists.

It would also seem that Theists would have more of the guilt factor that they were violating one of God's rules that a atheist would be less likely to have. It would seem rational to conclude that less guilty feelings means more crime.

If a man wants to steal an old woman's purse but does not simply because a police officer is standing near his only route of escape, is he really behaving morally?

You are doing a huge disservice to the vast majority of Christians by implying that they would rather do immoral things, but only refrain out of fear of being punished.

If what you say is true then it also follows that religious people will gladly commit horrific crimes, including genocide, as long as they believe their god will reward them for doing so.
 
Last edited:
Why do you need to be so Darn pendantic.

I can see your point there, but take DOC's original title (correcting for grammar):

"If everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime?"

Vs.

"If everyone in the world was atheist would there be more or less crime?"

It says the exact same thing, but the latter seems to flow better.
 
Last edited:
I can see your point there, but take DOC's original title (correcting for grammar):

"If everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime?"

Vs.

"If everyone in the world was atheist would there be more or less crime?"

It says the exact same thing, but the latter seems to flow better.

I think what Joobz meant to ask was: Why do you need to be so darn pendantic?
 
Last edited:
I can see your point there, but take DOC's original title (correcting for grammar):
I had a point? I was just cracking a joke while simultaneoustly avoiding the grant that I need to work on.


However, I will say that in my mind atheistic sounds better. But my grammar's terrible, so don't listen to me.


ETA: Foster Zygote it correct. I didn't highlight the end of the word to maintain a level of subtly to the joke, which helps the funny go down easier.
 
Last edited:
You are doing a huge disservice to the vast majority of Christians by implying that they would rather do immoral things, but only refrain out of fear of being punished.

Indeed, DOC has, with a single post, denigrated the whole of humanity by implying that we're all murderous, rapinous, thieves ready to loose anarchy, pain, and destruction upon one another unless they are made to believe that we'll be sentenced to sadistic torture for all eternity by a invisible autocrat who "loves" us.

BTW, what's the point of punishment if it's eternal? What lesson are you trying to impart upon a wrong-doer if there is never a chance for them to act upon that lesson? What good is punishment, in this life or a hypothetical afterlife, if there is no chance for even the worst offender to make a fresh start?

The only thing that the concept of Hell satisfies is the believer's lust for some kind of cosmic vengeance where Hell becomes an extension of the believer's bigotries. If those filthy sec-u-lar laws won't allow them to murder gays, abortion providers, liberals, and atheists in THIS reality(like the "Good Book" tells them to do, they can take solace that their celestial tyrant will inflict suffering upon the individuals that dislike after they die.

It's a sick, evil belief, and those who believe it are just as twisted.
 
Last edited:
BTW, what's the point of punishment if it's eternal? What lesson are you trying to impart upon a wrong-doer if there is never a chance for them to act upon that lesson? What good is punishment, in this life or a hypothetical afterlife, if there is no chance for even the worst offender to make a fresh start?
The only thing that the concept of Hell satisfies is the believer's lust for some kind of cosmic vengeance where Hell becomes an extension of the believer's bigotries. If those filthy sec-u-lar laws won't allow them to murder gays, abortion providers, liberals, and atheists in THIS reality(like the "Good Book" tells them to do, they can take solace that their celestial tyrant will inflict suffering upon the individuals that dislike after they die.
That's a rather good point.
 
Meh. Far too often I hear the battlecry: "Atheists don't have morals!" "If you don't believe in god, then you're going to commit crimes because you don't care!" Ignorance isn't bliss. I counter that I do good things because I WANT to, not because I somehow think I HAVE to. I take responsibility for ALL of my actions, both good and bad. I don't hide behind a Bible and say, "Well, it tells me to do it in here, so it's okay."
 
BTW, what's the point of punishment if it's eternal? What lesson are you trying to impart upon a wrong-doer if there is never a chance for them to act upon that lesson? What good is punishment, in this life or a hypothetical afterlife, if there is no chance for even the worst offender to make a fresh start?

FYI:
It depends on how you view the punishment and it's purpose. Is it simply judicial (like a jail sentence) or a punishment that is remedial (to bring change)? There are Christians that believe in each type and there are Christians who don't believe it is eternal for all or even any.
 
Meh. Far too often I hear the battlecry: "Atheists don't have morals!" "If you don't believe in god, then you're going to commit crimes because you don't care!" Ignorance isn't bliss. I counter that I do good things because I WANT to, not because I somehow think I HAVE to. I take responsibility for ALL of my actions, both good and bad. I don't hide behind a Bible and say, "Well, it tells me to do it in here, so it's okay."

That gives me an idea...

Sound OFF fellow atheists! What are your "crimes."* What terrible unlawful acts have you committed lately? Since we don't believe in a cosmic, abusive-father-figure to keep us mere mortals in line, we've HAD to have done something horrendous!

Let's see.... Oh! Last year, I WAS TWO MONTHS LATE WITH MY STATE AUTO-REGISTRATION FEE! :eek:

*I know this is line would be better when debating fredcarr, but I couldn't resist. Besides. all religion is Scientology to me.
 
Last edited:
That gives me an idea...

Sound OFF fellow atheists! What are your "crimes."* What terrible unlawful acts have you committed lately? Since we don't believe in a cosmic, abusive-father-figure to keep us mere mortals in line, we've HAD to have done something horrendous!

Let's see.... Oh! Last year, I WAS TWO MONTHS LATE WITH MY STATE AUTO-REGISTRATION FEE! :eek:

*I know this is line would be better when debating fredcarr, but I couldn't resist. Besides. all religion is Scientology to me.

Let's see... Today I drove 5 mph over the posted speed limit. Oh, and I abducted a hobo at the rail yard for the weekly human sacrifice to Athe.
 
FYI:
There are Christians that believe in each type and there are Christians who don't believe it is eternal for all or even any.

The topic at hand isn't whatever cherry-picked, salad bar, maudlin, hearts-and-flowers theology you cling to like an infant's security blanket, CS.

DOC is the one who is claiming that whoever steps out of line will face "the hellfire," so THAT is what we're talking about.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, DOC has, with a single post, denigrated the whole of humanity by implying that we're all murderous, rapinous, thieves ready to loose anarchy, pain, and destruction upon one another unless they are made to believe that we'll be sentenced to sadistic torture for all eternity by a invisible autocrat who "loves" us.
Don't you think that those sorts of comments say more about DOC, than it could ever say about humanity? DOC is the one who, deep down, wants to go out and rape and steal and murder, and only his fear of punishment keeps him from doing so. His definition of "Christian morality" seems to come down to "don't do bad things because you'll get in trouble", which is a completely morally bankrupt worldview.
 
Don't you think that those sorts of comments say more about DOC, than it could ever say about humanity?


Well, I did write...

It's a sick, evil belief, and those who believe it are just as twisted.
...and yes, that comment was directed at DOC.

I remember listening to an interview between Alan Combs and Richard Dawkins (see below) where a caller all but admitted that without a belief in God he would indeed murder, rape, and/or steal from his neighbors. Compare this oh-so-very Christian individual with Dawkins, a man of no religious beliefs who has done nothing morally questionable that we know about.

 
Last edited:
The topic at hand isn't whatever cherry-picked, salad bar, maudlin, hearts-and-flowers theology you cling to like an infant's security blanket, CS.
:duck: hahaha.

DOC is the one who is claiming that whoever steps out of line will face "the hellfire," so THAT is what we're talking about.

Well - it wasn't clear that it was directed towards DOC personally. Thanks for clearing that up.
 
That gives me an idea...

Sound OFF fellow atheists! What are your "crimes."* What terrible unlawful acts have you committed lately? Since we don't believe in a cosmic, abusive-father-figure to keep us mere mortals in line, we've HAD to have done something horrendous!

Let's see.... Oh! Last year, I WAS TWO MONTHS LATE WITH MY STATE AUTO-REGISTRATION FEE! :eek:

*I know this is line would be better when debating fredcarr, but I couldn't resist. Besides. all religion is Scientology to me.


I exceeded the speed limit, solely because I have not accepted Jesus Christ as my personal Lord and Savior.
 
That gives me an idea...

Sound OFF fellow atheists! What are your "crimes."* What terrible unlawful acts have you committed lately? Since we don't believe in a cosmic, abusive-father-figure to keep us mere mortals in line, we've HAD to have done something horrendous!

Let's see.... Oh! Last year, I WAS TWO MONTHS LATE WITH MY STATE AUTO-REGISTRATION FEE! :eek:

*I know this is line would be better when debating fredcarr, but I couldn't resist. Besides. all religion is Scientology to me.

Uhm, besides my occasional forays in producing distilled spirits...not much...
 
Yes, but all of those 4 countries have a higher suicide rate than the mostly Christian US. And the very rich Japan has more than double the rate of the US. Also it is no secret that atheistic Russia has extensive organized crime and corruption problems as well as other ex-Soviet satellites.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate

Also all those countries you mentioned are highly isolated from the rest of the world and aren't subject to the same multiracial and uneven income distribution pressures that say the US or France is.

And those countries you mentioned might even have a lower crime rate if everyone was theistic. Or a higher rate if everyone was atheistic for the reasons I've given in the above posts.

When nearly everyone in Japan was theistic, the warrior caste had the right to kill peasants for being irritating. Japan has a tradition of honorable suicide rooted deeply in the theistic side of its culture.

The atheists in the former Soviet Union were largely communists. The atheists elsewhere are largely humanists. It isn't the atheism per se that leads to low crime statistics for atheists, it is embracing a tradition of compassion. Atheism doesn't tell people how to behave, for that they need a philosophy. Communism isn't such a good philosophy, IMHO.

There may be a more direct link between atheists and suicide in other countries, it would be an interesting study to try to parse out the reasons that might be.

The 2nd paragraph undercuts the logic of using those countries to link atheism and suicide rates, too.

The 3rd paragraph basically says evidence doesn't matter.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom