If charlie only had guns

The results are better than what would happen in reality. They knew no one would be killed and they were ready. In the real world neither would be true. Plus their training may be years out of date.

True about the training. Most of the cartoonists had probably graduated art school decades ago. I wonder if back then they even covered weaponized pencils?
 
So a bunch of journalists are sat round a table having a meeting two terrorists burst in and start shooting.

One of them has a pistol in a holster inside his jacket.
He hets over the shock and surprise in time to draw his weapon, aim and shoot the two men who are already shooting at him.

OK
 
So a bunch of journalists are sat round a table having a meeting two terrorists burst in and start shooting.

One of them has a pistol in a holster inside his jacket.
He hets over the shock and surprise in time to draw his weapon, aim and shoot the two men who are already shooting at him.

OK

Or he freezes like everybody else despite having a gun.

OR something somewhere in between those two, like shooting one terrorist and two co-workers.

Cloud Koo-kooland, it's a famous resort.
 
False dichotomy.

They also put into place armed Air Marshals.

And probably not just for "fun".

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_marshal

How is that a dichotomy? I was making a suggestion for a different type of simulation. I mean sure it isn't as much fun having people being locked out and not able to hurt you as it is to go down in a blaze of glory but I thought the idea was to save lives, not some personal sense of honor.
 
Or, one of the victims hears a commotion and rightfully seeks both cover and concealment, weapon drawn. As gunmen enter, he engages them, for better or worse.

Or Plan B is just to cower and await execution.

I find the mindset preferring the latter option odd, but I guess it's more prevalent than I imagined.
 
Last edited:
Or, one of the victims hears a commotion and rightfully seeks both cover and concealment, weapon drawn. As gunmen enter, he engages them, for better or worse.

Or Plan B is just to cower and await execution.

I find the mindset preferring the latter option odd, but I guess it's more prevalent than I imagined.

Ah, the Chaos Rules scenario.
 
Or, one of the victims hears a commotion and rightfully seeks both cover and concealment, weapon drawn. As gunmen enter, he engages them, for better or worse.

Or Plan B is just to cower and await execution.

I find the mindset preferring the latter option odd, but I guess it's more prevalent than I imagined.

Now for Mr. Godwin...

Some Jews in WWII decided armed resistance gave a better chance of survival than meekly lining up along a ditch or going to the showers.

So again it really isn't about what is most effective at saving lives then.
 
How is that a dichotomy? I was making a suggestion for a different type of simulation. I mean sure it isn't as much fun having people being locked out and not able to hurt you as it is to go down in a blaze of glory but I thought the idea was to save lives, not some personal sense of honor.

Better locks might delay, but would not stop a determined adversary.

But I respect your decision to rely on a lock and eventual response by armed police for your survival.

I, personally, possess the means and the ability to aid in my own defense.

But I suspect never the twain shall meet.
 
I commend you on your confidence although I don't know what training you have. Are people going about their everyday life supposed to undergo rigorous military training in both marksmanship and close quarter battle just in case a random terrorist decides to kick the door in unexpectedly?.
 
I commend you on your confidence although I don't know what training you have. Are people going about their everyday life supposed to undergo rigorous military training in both marksmanship and close quarter battle just in case a random terrorist decides to kick the door in unexpectedly?.

I've seen civilian combat course advertised. The quality of such courses is open to scrutiny. :rolleyes:
 
Or, one of the victims hears a commotion and rightfully seeks both cover and concealment, weapon drawn. As gunmen enter, he engages them, for better or worse

Die Hard was just a film and John McClane is just a fictional character (albeit one with relevant training).


edited to add.

Yippie-ki-yay mother-friender ;)
 
Last edited:
Better locks might delay, but would not stop a determined adversary.

But I respect your decision to rely on a lock and eventual response by armed police for your survival.

I, personally, possess the means and the ability to aid in my own defense.

But I suspect never the twain shall meet.

So as they are there to delay the attackers in a plane until the sky marshal on the plane can react they will delay until the police officers(like the sky marshals) can react.

Or we could just get rid of those silly security screenings blocking people from taking their weapons on the planes and let them defend themselves. That must be the ideologically best solution.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom