If charlie only had guns

Magyar

Graduate Poster
Joined
Oct 16, 2004
Messages
1,906
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHOFkOdpw58

In a vain attempt to prove their manhood and their delusions a group of 2nd ammendment gun fools attempted to prove how much better the putcome would ahve been if the folks at charlie hebdo had guns.

Result. TOTAL FAIL.

In a scenario where the "victims" KNEW exactly what was coming and from where they still only managed to kill one "terrorist" once out of of dozens of tries, BUT everyone of the guns will keep me safe" died every time!

Not to worry lessons have been learned, to quote one of the gun nuts.......

I couldnt hit my target, didnt remember to take cover and ran out of ammo, "I still got killed, but did much better than i thought"

I have to ask. What would count as a failure in these peoplse minds? I mean ok. You die taking out the terrorist and you save some folks. Sort of against the right wing meme about altruism is evil but i can se it. But again, in a setup where they knwo exactly who, how many and from where were coming they didns save a single person a sinlg e time and managed to get one bad guy once.


But all those innocent kids and people who suffer from gun violence sure is worth proving yet again that these boffuns couldnt protect squat and do nothing but endanger the rest of us.
 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHOFkOdpw58

In a vain attempt to prove their manhood and their delusions a group of 2nd ammendment gun fools attempted to prove how much better the putcome would ahve been if the folks at charlie hebdo had guns.

Result. TOTAL FAIL.

In a scenario where the "victims" KNEW exactly what was coming and from where they still only managed to kill one "terrorist" once out of of dozens of tries, BUT everyone of the guns will keep me safe" died every time!

Not to worry lessons have been learned, to quote one of the gun nuts.......

I couldnt hit my target, didnt remember to take cover and ran out of ammo, "I still got killed, but did much better than i thought"

I have to ask. What would count as a failure in these peoplse minds? I mean ok. You die taking out the terrorist and you save some folks. Sort of against the right wing meme about altruism is evil but i can se it. But again, in a setup where they knwo exactly who, how many and from where were coming they didns save a single person a sinlg e time and managed to get one bad guy once.


But all those innocent kids and people who suffer from gun violence sure is worth proving yet again that these boffuns couldnt protect squat and do nothing but endanger the rest of us.
Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.
 
Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.

Pretty delicate nuance there. I mean, once you get to the "I'm dead" part, the rest just seems incidental.
 
Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.

Then again who knows how may colleagues they could have killed or injured as they attempted to defend themselves.
 
Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.

Ahhhhhh! The old better dead than dead argument. Do you not think your reaction is mostly based on watching too many Hollywood "Raw Raw USA!" movies growing up rather than a real knowledge of guns and your own capabilities?
 
Already a thread on this.

Also in seven out of nine tests, they did shoot one of the terrorists and in one they saved several people. There is a lot of variables. Anyone who claims guns will either always help or always make things worse is not thinking critically.
 
Then again who knows how may colleagues they could have killed or injured as they attempted to defend themselves.

Because their colleagues would have been just fine if not for their cohorts attempting to defend themselves? Oh wait...
 
Just goes to show you, the best defence is a large number of dynamite sticks taped to your body and hooked to a suit with impact sensors. The first round that hits you, sets off the dynamite, which takes out everyone in a one block radius.

Sure, it takes out your friends and colleagues but they were probably going to die anyway. The important thing is the attackers get immediate feedback on their actions.
 
Just goes to show you, the best defence is a large number of dynamite sticks taped to your body and hooked to a suit with impact sensors. The first round that hits you, sets off the dynamite, which takes out everyone in a one block radius.

Sure, it takes out your friends and colleagues but they were probably going to die anyway. The important thing is the attackers get immediate feedback on their actions.



Autodestruct sequence armed!

Kruge.png
 
Last edited:
It would have never happened if the staff had a tank and a F35 jet fighter
 
The results are better than what would happen in reality. They knew no one would be killed and they were ready. In the real world neither would be true. Plus their training may be years out of date.
 
So, what would you recommend?

To be either armed or unarmed depending on one's circumstances. It is not simple, and blanket statement insult the discussion.

By fleeing, if I read correctly. It had nothing to do with being armed.

One did, if I remember correctly the one that saved several people was a head shot to one then covering the escape of the other victims. Civilian with gun died, saved others.
 
I take it this is based on a U-tube computer game?

What input would the terrorists have had? Like, if they knew the office workers were armed, would they have even tried it? Have they ever attacked armed people, or only murdered unarmed school kids?

Or maybe gone with a bomb instead, causing greater collateral damage?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom