If charlie only had guns

Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.

Keep in mind that the attackers expected their victims to be helpless. In this context the terrorists would likely retreat rather than engage in a gunfight.

Enemy solders in combat don't use the same tactics as terrorists killing helpless victims.
 
Pretty delicate nuance there. I mean, once you get to the "I'm dead" part, the rest just seems incidental.

Some people prefer to have the ability to at least put up a fight, whatever the result. Maybe not you, but some people might.
 
Already a thread on this.

Also in seven out of nine tests, they did shoot one of the terrorists and in one they saved several people. There is a lot of variables. Anyone who claims guns will either always help or always make things worse is not thinking critically.

Good point. People should keep in mind that simulations are of limited value in this context.

A good example is when a pilot saves an aircraft under unusual conditions and yet pilots with comparable skills have trouble duplicating the same events in a simulator. There is nothing quite like having to do it for real.
 
Okay, the people you mentioned were going to "fight back" with magnum feather dusters.

Please point to a post where I, a guy who is pro gun control and against an armed populace, mentioned that guns would have "made things better". Or worse. Or the same.
 
Badly stated or what?

Perfectly stated. If you think this comment has something, anything, to do with an opinion on how the presence of more guns would have affected the outcome of the situation, then I really don't know what you're reading. I'd think that the words "whatever the outcome" might have helped with that.
 
In a vain attempt to prove their manhood and their delusions a group of 2nd ammendment gun fools attempted to prove how much better the putcome would ahve been if the folks at charlie hebdo had guns.

I think you linked to the wrong video - I see nothing of the sort.

(insert eyeroll smiley here.)
 
Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.

When they kick at your front door
How you gonna come?
With your hands on your head
Or on the trigger of your gun
.

Guns of Brixton - The Clash

I just find it amazing that some seem to be making the case that they'd rather not have a gun if they were under attack. Better to hide or run than being empowered to take action.

Not me. I'm trained and proficient and would not go easily.
 
Last edited:
Ahhhhhh! The old better dead than dead argument. Do you not think your reaction is mostly based on watching too many Hollywood "Raw Raw USA!" movies growing up rather than a real knowledge of guns and your own capabilities?

IIrc, A .480 OR .454 Cassull trumps much body armor (possibly the S&W .460 does also). But, body armor trumps most individual carry weapons terrorists carry.
 
Like, if they knew the office workers were armed, would they have even tried it?


Maybe. Maybe not. Depends on how determined they were. As gun advocates like to say, if someone's determined enough, they'll find a way to kill their target.

Of course, surprise is probably the best "weapon" against an armed individual. Their weapon is useless if they're dead or subdued before they can use it. And if believe it's more likely than not that your target will themselves be armed, you plan accordingly.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps having guns would not have saved the victims but at least they would have been given the chance to defend themselves. I think going down with guns blazing is better than dying like some sort of helpless sacrificial lamb.

Yep saving lives is totally irrelevant, it is all about blaze of glory!
 
What if they did like airlines have done and put better locks on the doors, that would have seemed like it could be a useful way to save lives. But that isn't fun I guess.
 
But, body armor trumps most individual carry weapons terrorists carry.

No. The latest three attacks (the 2 Canadian ones and Charlie Hebdo) saw the individuals armed with weapons that would not have been stopped by body armour - the weapons used have been AKs, a .30-30 rifle and a car - generally, body armour will not stop rifle calibre rounds unless you add a ceramic shock plate.

Generally, the need for weapons when not actually in combat operations is rather rare.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom