Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Hulsey's presentation says that his finding was that the fully-braced column didn't move significantly off its position when floor 13 (and only floor 13) was heated evenly.

No one claims that the movement of column 79 by just loading or by even heating was the cause of the collapse, and it's not in the text that you have pasted.
 
Last edited:
It doesn’t matter. FF has decided that they have been 'got at' and silenced so there will never be a report anyway.
 
Hulsey's presentation says that his finding was that the fully-braced column didn't move significantly off its position when floor 13 (and only floor 13) was heated evenly.

No one claims that the movement of column 79 by just loading or by even heating was the cause of the collapse, and it's not in the text that you have pasted.


Again, you are playing games with the word "loading". What happens when a column is unsupported?

Actually, you can play your game by yourself. I'm sitting this one out. I hope for your sake that an NSL is stopping the investigation. It's going to be extremely hard to continue your nonsense when there is a computer model showing that NIST is wrong, and anyone can duplicate the results.
 
One bit of the Q&A section is also interesting. I don't fully understand the question, but it seems to me that a lady is asking if they're going to look into ways in which the building could come down the way it did.

Hulsey responds: "Well, if I'm asked to do that, I would do that. But I'm gonna try to avoid that because that <????> into that world that everybody says "ow", everybody's got <???> theories". He seems to be struggling to not directly say conspiracy theories.

He also adds "[...] The probability of it coming straight down is almost impossible. So then you have to ask yourself why did it". A classic insinuation.
 
Yes, they did.


From - http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/faqs_wtc7.cfm



Are we going to play another semantics game now with the word "loading"?

That's not Loading, that is loss of stability, that you don't understand the difference shows why you can't rationalize the structural failure.

Once the floor fails it's loading is removed from the Column not to it, so no additional loading is applied to the Column.

The column fails and changes the way the Loading to the other columns is distributed.

It is not a play on words just a correction of terms used.
 
Good point. I'm sure there are thousands of posts discussing column 79.

Let me be more specific. Is there any discussion, in this thread, about the following two statements made by Dr. Hulsey and his researchers?

1. Frame connections have limited influence on global stiffness.

2. Loading and heating at column 79 will not result in large movement at column 79.

Let me be even more specific. There are researchers who have created a computer model of WTC7 using publicly available blueprints. They have made their preliminary findings public. Two of their findings are listed above. Has anyone in this thread, or anywhere else, made specific comments on the above two findings made by the researchers performing the WTC7 evaluation project? If so, where are the comments, and what are they? Or, since most skeptics won't like statement number 2, is everyone just burying their head in the sand and ignoring this?

If you think there's something in those "preliminary findings" worth discussing, I think you should start the ball rolling by stating explicitly what you think Hulsey modeled, what he measured, what he compared it to, and what you think it proves. I can easily predict that you won't be able to do that, because in that video, Hulsey's description of these "preliminary findings" is so vague and disorganized that it sounds like the ramblings of a pseudo-scientist. Perhaps he just doesn't express himself clearly when speaking extemporaneously, but calling those claims "preliminary findings" without the slightest pretense of even explaining what he's done, much less substantiating any conclusions, raises serious doubts about Hulsey's credibility, not to mention his professional ethics.
 
This study is just another money making scam put together by Gage. It has nothing to do with the truth, it is a complete waste of time and money.

If you think there's something in those "preliminary findings" worth discussing, I think you should start the ball rolling by stating explicitly what you think Hulsey modeled, what he measured, what he compared it to, and what you think it proves. I can easily predict that you won't be able to do that, because in that video, Hulsey's description of these "preliminary findings" is so vague and disorganized that it sounds like the ramblings of a pseudo-scientist. Perhaps he just doesn't express himself clearly when speaking extemporaneously, but calling those claims "preliminary findings" without the slightest pretense of even explaining what he's done, much less substantiating any conclusions, raises serious doubts about Hulsey's credibility, not to mention his professional ethics.

It's going to be extremely hard to continue your nonsense when there is a computer model showing that NIST is wrong, and anyone can duplicate the results.
 
It's going to be extremely hard to continue your nonsense when there is a computer model showing that NIST is wrong, and anyone can duplicate the results.

In other words, as predicted, you are unable to discuss what Hulsey's "preliminary results" mean. Why, then, did you ask for discussion?
 
In other words, as predicted, you are unable to discuss what Hulsey's "preliminary results" mean. Why, then, did you ask for discussion?

Unlike skeptics, I can read something without arguing against it. My initial post simply asked if there was any discussion on the two points. I had no intent to debate the issue then, and I won't now. I know you can't understand that, but there is nothing I can do about your failure to understand a simple concept. I just wanted to know if anyone posted anything. The answer is "no".
 
Last edited:
I received an email from Dr. Harrit. Here is the relevant text from his email, copied verbatim:
All I know is, that the funding is scarce, but the project is alive.
However, as you suggest, Hulsey may very well be obstructed as we have seen many time before.

I also emailed ae911truth but I have yet to receive a reply.
 
Last edited:
It's going to be extremely hard to continue your nonsense when there is a computer model showing that NIST is wrong, and anyone can duplicate the results.

You can't show the NIST model is wrong, it is a model, its has no right or wrong. Add engineering to the things you fail to understand.

The model can't be wrong... it is based on data of 7 WTC. Unlike Coles models, which are based on delusional claptrap, NIST had to hire reality based engineers, like independent engineers to do their study and achieve their goals. Which they did. You can attack NIST, and it exposes a massive, no, an overwhelming level of ignorance of NIST goals, and their models.

Leroy appears to be a full fledged 9/11 truth nut, either acting to get funding from 9/11 truth nuts, or he is a 9/11 truth nut. I can see a professor pretending to be a 9/11 truth nut to get funding, but Leroy Hulsey seems to be walking the talk of 9/11 truth delusional claims...

And all you can do is lie, and think NIST model is wrong... do you understand the model can't be wrong, it is a model...

There were no explosives, no thermite, thus fire did it. NIST like the rest of the rational engineering community agree it was a result of effects of fire; and they don't agree on the probable cause. Only engineers in 9/11 truth lie about 7 WTC, and 9/11. A fringe few, less than 0.1 percent. Got math?

NO, you have paranoia.

... as you suggest, Hulsey may very well be obstructed as we have seen many time before.
Total nonsense based on paranoia and insanity on Harrit's part.
 
Last edited:
You can't show the NIST model is wrong, it is a model, its has no right or wrong. Add engineering to the things you fail to understand.

The model can't be wrong... it is based on data of 7 WTC.

I'm just going to leave this little gem out here on its own.
 
Unlike skeptics, I can read something without arguing against it. My initial post simply asked if there was any discussion on the two points. I had no intent to debate the issue then, and I won't now. I know you can't understand that, but there is nothing I can do about your failure to understand a simple concept. I just wanted to know if anyone posted anything. The answer is "no".

You're not fooling anyone :D. We all know you lack the education to discuss the merits (or lack thereof) when it comes to these topics; we've seen you dodge countless technical questions because you simply didn't understand them (and presumably Google couldn't help).
 
You're not fooling anyone :D. We all know you lack the education to discuss the merits (or lack thereof) when it comes to these topics; we've seen you dodge countless technical questions because you simply didn't understand them (and presumably Google couldn't help).

Are you suggesting that I should engage in an engineering discussion? This is not going to happen. Unlike most skeptics, I know my limits.

More than 10 days ago I posted a link to a video. The video showed the preliminary results of the WTC7 evaluation. I simply asked if the conclusions had already been discussed. Why? If they had been discussed I wanted to read the comments. That is all.

You refuse to accept this. Once again, you clearly prove that as a skeptic you must argue against every post made by a truther, no matter how stupid it makes you look.

Please, keep going. I don't mind. Again, I already know that I won't convince a skeptic of anything. I know this. You fail to realize this fact. What I am doing is showing lurkers just how absurd the skeptics are on this forum. You keep proving me right. Your posts not only destroy your credibility, but the credibility of the other skeptics on this forum. Keep going, though. I know you will no matter what I say. You just don't get it.
 
I'm just going to leave this little gem out here on its own.

yes, you are not an engineer, and fail to comprehend model, engineering model. My mom insisted I become an engineer; what are you?

No rational engineers deny fire caused the collapse. You have some failed engineers on your side of woo, less than 0.1 percent of all engineers.

Leave the gem, is exposes you don't understand engineering. I have only been an engineer since 1974, masters in 82, and I have an ATP, so the flying lies about 911 are all wrong on face value to me; like your failure with constant acceleration and the fantasy of CD.

You don't understand engineering. You don't understand models. Many don't.
It does not mean NIST probable collapse sequence happened. And attacking NIST exposes an ignorance of science and engineering.

You must prove your point, not attack NIST; when you prove your claims NIST becomes irrelevant. When did you graduate from engineering school, I am the class of 74 and 83, and not one of the hundreds of fellow engineers I graduated with believe 9/11 truth claims... and you have the support of what might be a subset of insane engineers, at less than 0.1 percent.

Not that we can vote on 9/11, but fire did it. Better luck with Bigfoot. 9/11 truth has no clue what engineering and physics is.

When will you prove NIST model is wrong? lol, never.
 
Are you suggesting that I should engage in an engineering discussion?

You've attempted/pretended to on several occasions. Your mistakes have been chuckle-worthy, but the real hilarity came when you didn't even understand the questions.

What I am doing is showing lurkers just how absurd the skeptics are on this forum. You keep proving me right. Your posts not only destroy your credibility, but the credibility of the other skeptics on this forum. Keep going, though. I know you will no matter what I say. You just don't get it.

You're a real high achiever! :D The truth movement must be so proud.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom