Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

The majority of the structure came "straight down".....
Where was it suppose to go? UP? Gravity acts in what direction? How much was straight down; do you literally mean straight down? You mean column x was exactly straight down from where column x was before it collapsed? Thus the majority of stuff from WTC 7 was straight down from where it began on 9/11? Is that your statement, or are you trying to apologize for Leroy.

What is the next 9/11 truth card of woo to be played?
The symmetry card next.
Or, the "path of least resistance law" card, 9/11 truth's super-nano-woo new laws of physics.

Leroy Hulsey, is he acting like a 9/11 truth failed BS artist to get funding, or is Leroy Hulsey a 9/11 truth failed faith based follower.
Got any evidence for CD on 911? No, you never will. Exactly straight down? Or what?
 
The wtc7evaluation.org website does not appear to have any recent updates.

Here is a theory of mine, and it is just a theory. I have no proof, other than my own opinion, which is based on observations of other events.

I think it was a mistake for Richard Gage to hire an American, working at an American university, to do the research. I think the US government has issued a National Security Letter to Dr. Hulsey and his assistants. NIST has said they won't release the data they used for their computer model for "National Security reasons". It would be very easy for the government to claim that investigating the collapse of WTC7 has national security implications and must stop.

If Dr. Hulsey actually did receive a NSL, he would be under a gag order, and he could not talk about it at all. The only thing he could do is appeal the decision in a FISA court, and we all know how that will turn out.

Again, I do NOT know this as a fact; it is nothing more than my opinion. I just find it very hard to believe that the investigation would be allowed to continue considering the possible implications.

I know for a fact that NSL's exist. It is what killed Trucrypt. I feel confident I am right about this.

:dl: :dl: :dl:
 
I received an email from Dr. Harrit. Here is the relevant text from his email, copied verbatim:


I also emailed ae911truth but I have yet to receive a reply.

Well instead of embarrassing yourself here ad infinitum, why don't you go get a part-time job and help fund this endeavour? You are interested in finding out the "truth" right?

Chop Chop, time's a wasting!

We don't want to add another year of failure to the 14 we've seen already!
 
I received an email from Dr. Harrit. Here is the relevant text from his email, copied verbatim:


I also emailed ae911truth but I have yet to receive a reply.
The funding issue is not a big surprise. AE's been having donation issues (especially from the big ticket) for a couple years.

FF, you and your friends really need to pony up. :rolleyes:
 
FF, you and your friends really need to pony up. :rolleyes:

That sentence could be a useful standard format DGM.

Fill in the blank space:

FF, you and your friends really need to _____ up. :rolleyes:

There are many valid alternates to "pony" starting with "wake"; "grow", "give" and "shut"

.. and those are only some of the four letter ones. :rolleyes:
 
I considered he might be another poe, but I'm quite certain he isn't nearly clever enough to pull it off this well.
Only the best can manage and sustain Poeing - e.g. "TelltaleTom"

Trolling Poe was my call in the first weeks of his posting.

IMO we have seen a dramatic drop in the quality of both classes of spam - trolling and Poeing - over recent years.

And "trolling efficiency" has also dropped away.

Based on raw index of trolling efficiency (number of "bites" per single trolling post) he is way down in the 1:1 range.

Most trolls in the era when trolling took over from serious discussion as the major activity. AKA 2012-13-14>> The end of the reign of Bill Smith, emergence of Clayton Moore, ergo - also C7 but he was a special case - most would routinely manage 5:1. And in what I think is the record - I recall ONE single post "spurt" by ergo which landed 27 responses. By anyone's standard that is high efficiency.

But the quality of trolling had already dropped. Back in 2006-7-8 whatever small amount of trolling there was had to be clever twisting of words or logic or it would mostly get ignored - there was too much serious discussion for anyone to waste time with trolls. And the forum I frequented in those days sanctioned trolling.

We probably reached the pits with the arrival of MM who relied on snide comments and insults as the main irritant to get responses. Little or no content to discuss.

And I still rank C7 as the cleverest troll of recent years. His trick of occasionally conceding a point or making a technically true statement seemed to keep members interested. (Excuse the diplomatic euphemism -- I didn't want to say "fooled quite a few people" :o )
 
Last edited:
Only the best can manage and sustain Poeing - e.g. "TelltaleTom"

Trolling Poe was my call in the first weeks of his posting.

IMO we have seen a dramatic drop in the quality of both classes of spam - trolling and Poeing - over recent years.

And "trolling efficiency" has also dropped away.

Based on raw index of trolling efficiency (number of "bites" per single trolling post) he is way down in the 1:1 range.

Most trolls in the era when trolling took over from serious discussion as the major activity. AKA 2012-13-14>> The end of the reign of Bill Smith, emergence of Clayton Moore, ergo - also C7 but he was a special case - most would routinely manage 5:1. And in what I think is the record - I recall ONE single post "spurt" by ergo which landed 27 responses. By anyone's standard that is high efficiency.

But the quality of trolling had already dropped. Back in 2006-7-8 whatever small amount of trolling there was had to be clever twisting of words or logic or it would mostly get ignored - there was too much serious discussion for anyone to waste time with trolls. And the forum I frequented in those days sanctioned trolling.

We probably reached the pits with the arrival of MM who relied on snide comments and insults as he main irritant to get responses. Little or no content to discuss.

And I still rank C7 as the cleverest troll of recent years. His trick of occasionally conceding a point or making a technically true statement seemed to keep members interested. (Excuse the diplomatic euphemism -- I didn't want to say "fooled quite a few people" :o )

C7, regardless of if he was a troll or not, was at least invested in his cause; his name still pops up from time to time on Truther materials. MSPaintFire was one of my first discussions as a member of this forum, though, so for that highly entertaining episode, I will always be grateful to him, in a sense.
 
Only the best can manage and sustain Poeing - e.g. "TelltaleTom"

Trolling Poe was my call in the first weeks of his posting.

IMO we have seen a dramatic drop in the quality of both classes of spam - trolling and Poeing - over recent years.........................

This is best explain by the fact there are very few "truth" believers left.

I doubt debunking had much to do with it. It was likely most grew up............(or moved on). What's left is what we see.
 
C7, regardless of if he was a troll or not, was at least invested in his cause; his name still pops up from time to time on Truther materials. MSPaintFire was one of my first discussions as a member of this forum, though, so for that highly entertaining episode, I will always be grateful to him, in a sense.
Agreed.
Those were the days when a few moderately challenging "genuine truthers" helped me to improve my own understanding of 9/11 events. Especially my own area of expertise - the engineering applied physics of the WTC Collapse mechanisms. Sadly IMO progress in that arena has stalled.
 
This is best explain by the fact there are very few "truth" believers left.

I doubt debunking had much to do with it. It was likely most grew up............(or moved on). What's left is what we see.
Agreed fully. Despite differences of terminology - I refer to them as "Genuine Truthers" - the ones who doubted but bottom line they were prepared to learn. Some acknowledged and learned. Many more simply faded away - left the scene - it is not likely that they had all "seen the light" but I judge that many had in fact accepted reality.

The current scenario is dominated by game playing poes/trolls/spammers and among them a small number of truly obsessed believers.

It is hard to accept that many of them truly believe the idiocies they assert. But.....
 
You won't get a reply, that would mean giving an answer that ties something down. That's not how a CT proponent works. It's more important to keep the discussion circling for the benefit of the suppsed lurkers. Actualy advancing it and coming to any conclusions isn't the gsme.

:thumbsup: Jay Whindley had it right.
 
I found that funny myself. I didn't want to explain a NSL to him because he would only ignore it. The post is clueless at the heart.
OK. Explain what an NSL is, and explain how I am wrong.

You claim that I am clueless. Prove it. Prove that you know something about NSL's that I don't.
 
It is hard to accept that many of them truly believe the idiocies they assert. But.....
That's the problem, they really do. It's Poe's law at its best: you can't believe they're serious.

But do you see any of the current posters coming out the closet with something like this? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7534421#post7534421

These are not Poes (people posing as the opposite side for ridicule purposes), these are genuinely deluded people.
 
Originally Posted by Redwood
It ain't semantics, kiddo. It's fact.

FACT: Hulsey claimed it came "straight down".

FACT: It didn't.

This in and of itself raises serious questions about Hulsey's competence, amongst other things. Add to that his previous statements that steel is a very fire resistant material, and you're stuck in a very bad alliance, IMHO.


The majority of the structure came "straight down".

Your opinion, and ensuing semantics game, is desperate.


Sent from our shared looking glass platform

Sorry, kiddo: You lose again.

Classic Truther argument:

1. In a controlled demolition, the building always falls straight down. (A false premise, BTW)

2. WTC 7 fell straight down
. (Also false)

3, Ergo, WTC 7 was a controlled demolition. (The classic logical fallacy of "affirming the consequent".)

So we had a classic Truther argument of two false premises linked by a logical fallacy. SOP.

But it now seems that Truthers admit that WTC 7 only "mostly" fell straight down. (As Beachnut says, "Is it supposed to fall UP?")

But any demolition company that demolished a building and did the damage that WTC 7 did to Fiterman Hall and the Verizon Building would go bankrupt straightaway.

So I guess that the NEW Truther argument is, "WTC 7 MOSTLY fell straight down, but the Vast Conspiracy deliberately botched the demolition so as to damage other buildings to make it look like it actually fell by fire, except that every engineer knows that a structure like WTC 7 can't collapse from fire, but they've all been bribed or intimidated into silence."

And Truthers wonder why everyone thinks they're :crazy:
 

Attachments

  • Fiterman Hall Damage from WTC & Collapse.jpg
    Fiterman Hall Damage from WTC & Collapse.jpg
    64.4 KB · Views: 4

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom