Ten days have passed and I have yet to see any discussion on this finding.
Hmmmm. I wonder why.
It's a bit longer than ten days. The video is Nov 15. Have you got the latest information.
Ten days have passed and I have yet to see any discussion on this finding.
Hmmmm. I wonder why.
It's a bit longer than ten days. The video is Nov 15. Have you got the latest information.
I meant that my original post was 10 days ago and there have not been any comments. I don't have any new information. Does anyone want to comment on the video?
The thread was started in Nov 15 maybe it's already been discussed ?
Like you say, there is no further information.
In my OP I ask where it has been discussed. No one pointed that out, either.
Why not wait until there is something to talk about ?
Nothing has happened yet.
There is something to talk about. I posted a link to the issue in question, and no one has commented.
Perhaps pin point in detail what you want people to comment on, you may get a better responce.
I did in this post - http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11186867&postcount=1594
I know there are lots of posts, so I understand why you might not have seen it at first.
Let me think about this. Has column 79 been discussed before ?
Good point. I'm sure there are thousands of posts discussing column 79.
Let me be more specific. Is there any discussion, in this thread, about the following two statements made by Dr. Hulsey and his researchers?
1. Frame connections have limited influence on global stiffness.
2. Loading and heating at column 79 will not result in large movement at column 79.
Let me be even more specific. There are researchers who have created a computer model of WTC7 using publicly available blueprints. They have made their preliminary findings public. Two of their findings are listed above. Has anyone in this thread, or anywhere else, made specific comments on the above two findings made by the researchers performing the WTC7 evaluation project? If so, where are the comments, and what are they? Or, since most skeptics won't like statement number 2, is everyone just burying their head in the sand and ignoring this?
Let me a bit more specific. As far as I can see, there has been a fund raiser for the project you have mentioned which I believe will take somewhere in the region of two years ( funding permitting)
It would appear they have not done it yet and have not come to any valid conclusion. If they have a valid conclusion why are they undertaking the project?
I'm sure there will be plenty to discuss when the project is complete if it does get completed.
I missed that post. There's nothing to comment on it. I don't know of anyone that claims that heating of column 79 caused collapse.
I hadn't seen that video. I'm watching it now.
What tricks?Clever dodge. The statement was that "loading and heating of column 79 will not cause large movement."
Again, your tricks won't work on me.
What tricks?
No one claims that the loading of column 79 caused the collapse either.
Eventually, a girder on Floor 13 lost its connection to a critical column, Column 79, that provided support for the long floor spans on the east side of the building (see Diagram 1). The displaced girder and other local fire-induced damage caused Floor 13 to collapse, beginning a cascade of floor failures down to the 5th floor. Many of these floors had already been at least partially weakened by the fires in the vicinity of Column 79. This collapse of floors left Column 79 insufficiently supported in the east-west direction over nine stories.
The unsupported Column 79 then buckled and triggered an upward progression of floor system failures that reached the building's east penthouse. What followed in rapid succession was a series of structural failures. Failure first occurred all the way to the roof line—involving all three interior columns on the easternmost side of the building (79, 80, and 81). Then, progressing from east to west across WTC 7, all of the columns failed in the core of the building (58 through 78). Finally, the entire façade collapsed.
That doesn't say what you say it says.Yes, they did.
From - http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/faqs_wtc7.cfm
Are we going to play another semantics game now with the word "loading"?
That doesn't say what you say it says.