Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

One of the comments:
According to some sources, there were micro nuclear bombs planted inside these buildings which clearly explained their sudden collapsed. These bombs were already used by Israeli army in the current Syrian conflict. Please refer to Zerohedge for more info.

Hmmm, nukes that were used on 9/11/01 were previously used in the present Syrian conflict...................:rolleyes:
 

I said he sounded like a nutcase woo 9/11 truth nut; and he is.

You don't do a paper to show someone wrong, you do a paper to show something. When fire was the only element besides WTC 7, it was fire. Hulsey is another failed nut, he works and teaches. '

Okay, maybe he is out for more money and knows Gage's fringe group is only good for funding, thus he has no morals.

Hulsey; Nuts, or no scruples?

Anyone tell the university they have a dumber than dirt professor who lies about 911, who has no evidence it was not fire...
 
The fires massively weakened the structure (which had already been pummelled with debris from the twin towers), gravity did the rest.
 
Last edited:
Of course this is another attempt to debunk the NIST and a bunch of others who look at one column, one girder on one floor and find that "fire" was inadequate to trigger a progressive collapse.

There was not discussion of the collapse itself... and the whole thrust is to leave the impression that as fire didn't fail the connection/girder/column on floor 13 col 19 the causes was the unstated assertion without a smidgen of evidence that something such as CD was the culprit. No analysis by this fellow's team of the building movement.

No discussion of progressive runaway system collapse.

Even if his conclusion is correct about how the connection under study performed... it does not rule out fire as cause acting other places at other members etc.

Very unimpressive performance by this guy who seems to have had a belief that NIST was wrong and set out to show it.
Pretty much spot on.

The only think I would add is he seems to be backing away from a full model as was originally proposed. I think they got out of their league with that claim in the first place, I doubt they have the computing power available.
 
Very embarrassing that he's still using the "steel is a very fire resistant material trope.

A real scientist would have distributed copies of a conference paper in advance and invited comments from the audience. Assuming, of course that any of them had enough of a science/engineering background to be able to comment intelligently.
 
Gage pitches for contributions at the end to "continue this important project". Surprise, surprise! :rolleyes: But if they've concluded that WTC 7 wasn't brought down by fires, what is there left to do but present their paper? It's relatively easy to present a conference paper at an engineering symposium.
 
Even if his conclusion is correct about how the connection under study performed... it does not rule out fire as cause acting other places at other members etc.

Very unimpressive performance by this guy who seems to have had a belief that NIST was wrong and set out to show it.


I agree!! He is desparate to pin the blame on explosives for which there is no evidence.
 
It seems there are potentially interesting aspects to Hulsey's study, but he loses much of his credibility by jumping from "we could not reproduce NIST's exact fire-induced collapse scenario using various different assumptions" to "fire did not destroy WTC 7". What???? The conclusion doesn't even come close to following from the research to date.

And from the sound of it, it appears the study is now moving on to testing the effects of various blast devices in the substation. (Spoiler alert: they will find that a blast device or combination of devices could bring down the building!)

But talk about getting ahead of themselves. Identifying a potential issue with the collapse mode NIST deemed most probable is not the same as disproving the possibility of a fire-induced collapse. After all, Dr. Bailey, Arup, and Weidlinger Associates have all identified alternative potential fire-induced failure modes than NIST's. (And I know Dr. Hulsey and his team had access to Bailey's and Arup's work because I sent those reports to him and his research team myself and got a response from his research team.) Come on, AE911Truth, try being just a little intellectually honest for once and see if that helps lead you to the truth you claim to be seeking. Yeesh.
 
Last edited:
Nobody seems to have made the obvious comment --- yet.

How come a University Professor is claiming to prove a negative?

AND

Showing ZERO respect for the "Scientific Method"?


It seems to be an endemic problem in academia - the need for publicity at any cost.
 
And there is a big difference between:
"We cannot prove it was brought down by fire"

AND

"We cannot explain HOW it was brought down by fire."

AND

"It was NOT brought down by fire"
 
A semi-serious question:

would the two PhD's resulting from this project and supervised by this professor be reduced in "marketable value"?

Would both candidates when applying for future jobs need to be coy about identifying what the topic and who the supervisor was?

I would expect "Yes" to both BUT academic ranking can be a funny business.
 
Last edited:
Nobody seems to have made the obvious comment --- yet.

How come a University Professor is claiming to prove a negative?

Well, it is possible to prove some negatives, if you can disprove the affirmative. In this case, for example, if you could conclusively prove that there wasn't really any fire, or if you could conclusively prove that something else initiated the collapses, then you've proved it wasn't fire. But of course, Hulsey hasn't done anything like that. Like the Harrit study, invalid conclusions will certainly disqualify the study in a legitimate and competent peer review, so I look for it to be published in an obscure "open" journal, if at all.
 
Well, it is possible to prove some negatives, if you can disprove the affirmative. In this case, for example, if you could conclusively prove that there wasn't really any fire, or if you could conclusively prove that something else initiated the collapses, then you've proved it wasn't fire. But of course, Hulsey hasn't done anything like that. Like the Harrit study, invalid conclusions will certainly disqualify the study in a legitimate and competent peer review, so I look for it to be published in an obscure "open" journal, if at all.
:thumbsup:
 
Well, it is possible to prove some negatives, if you can disprove the affirmative. In this case, for example, if you could conclusively prove that there wasn't really any fire, or if you could conclusively prove that something else initiated the collapses, then you've proved it wasn't fire. But of course, Hulsey hasn't done anything like that. Like the Harrit study, invalid conclusions will certainly disqualify the study in a legitimate and competent peer review, so I look for it to be published in an obscure "open" journal, if at all.

Vanity published with his students having Cracker Jack PHDs that no one will really respect,
way to go Hulsey destroy your students for political objectives.
 
Where was the attempt to relate the observed building movements, damage, fires etc to their root causes?

Why would the examination of one node based on assumed energy inputs in isolation from the rest of the structure with much of it engorged in flames for a 7 hr period and having suffered structural damage from steel panels from 1wtc falling on it show conclusively that fire was not the cause of the collapse?

This character really revealed his confirmation bias and his real objective was a NIST hit job...

Is this the sort of investigation AE wants to see? Seems so!
 
Where was the attempt to relate the observed building movements, damage, fires etc to their root causes?

Why would the examination of one node based on assumed energy inputs in isolation from the rest of the structure with much of it engorged in flames for a 7 hr period and having suffered structural damage from steel panels from 1wtc falling on it show conclusively that fire was not the cause of the collapse?

This character really revealed his confirmation bias and his real objective was a NIST hit job...

Is this the sort of investigation AE wants to see? Seems so!

AE are clearly nothing but hucksters, playing a con game.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom