How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I see you have no answer to my serious questions. It's easier when you can instead alter someone's post and then claim that this is what they really said.
 
What makes you think that centralized exchanges are the be all and end all of bitcoin transactions?

I don't. I'm just saying that use of a centralized bitcoin wallet service defeats the original purpose behind the creation of bitcoins.

The very first line of the abstract of the original bitcoin proposal says: "A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution."

An online bitcoin wallet service is, in effect, a defacto financial institution.

(I don't think it's really a big deal, I just brought it up because I thought it was mildly amusing.)

So why would the creation of "bitcoin banks" defeat the purpose of bitcoin?

It doesn't, but using them sort-of does. (See above answer.)
 
Those who got into mining early had no foreseeable benefit because there was no opportunity to cash the BTC in and it wasn't worth a cracker anyway. The only people who would benefit from the early acquision of bitcoins were those who were prepared to hold on to them for at least two years (as it turned out) and since the software was released within a week of the creation of the inaugural block, that was any member of the public who correctly guessed that bitcoin might be worth money some day.

It's no different to saying that a public float of a company is designed to benefit those who buy the shares first. If the company goes well then those early shareholders might make a packet but there are no guarantees. (Those early shareholders might well lose money)..

Why are you comparing bitcoins with a company?
 
I don't. I'm just saying that use of a centralized bitcoin wallet service defeats the original purpose behind the creation of bitcoins.

At some point you have to be able to convert bitcoins to cash and cash to bitcoins. Without this possibility bitcoins would not work as a currency. Exchanges like Mt Gox are one option to do this and "banks" like coinbase are another. Adding a wallet service on top makes perfect sense for coinbase because it allows users to transfer bitcoins out of their accounts. Now this can be used to buy something directly from someone else or they could just send it to their own private wallet for later. There's not a contradiction here.
 
(I don't think it's really a big deal, I just brought it up because I thought it was mildly amusing.)
It might be ironic but certainly not illogical nor unexpected that currency conversions would require the co-operation of trusted third parties.

Maybe in time, bots will perform the third party role and trust will no longer be an issue.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure you know what a CT is, then.

I lurk on this thread but don't participate much. I also have never done anything with bitcoin though I've been following it for years. I just wanted to say, based on your posts these last couple pages i'm not sure you know what bitcoin is or its history. The people don't bother answering your questions or complaints because it's been done already a hundred times in this thread and elsewhere. In fact that seems to be at least half this thread. People unwilling to take the time to learn about bitcoin or read the previous discussion and come in here all smug on the "skeptic" bitcoins a scheme for fools bandwagon thinking they are pointing out some great argument that to anyone who has been following this all along just makes us :rolleyes:
 
Wrong link?

ETA: and/or wrong thread? Nothing there says what you describe the link as saying. On the other had, it references some pretty stupid SJW standpoints. Maybe FTB thread is more appropriate to laugh at them.

Yeah, looks like a blog post just taking to task the ridiculous argument against bitcoin that because white males are the primary demo, it must be bad. It makes no sense as an argument against bitcoin, yet it has been made many times, including from a senior editor at thinkprogress.
 
I lurk on this thread but don't participate much. I also have never done anything with bitcoin though I've been following it for years. I just wanted to say, based on your posts these last couple pages i'm not sure you know what bitcoin is or its history. The people don't bother answering your questions or complaints because it's been done already a hundred times in this thread and elsewhere. In fact that seems to be at least half this thread. People unwilling to take the time to learn about bitcoin or read the previous discussion and come in here all smug on the "skeptic" bitcoins a scheme for fools bandwagon thinking they are pointing out some great argument that to anyone who has been following this all along just makes us :rolleyes:

Did you mean to post this to someone else ?

I ask because all I mentioned is that some of the features of BTC as, as I said, "suspect". BTC seems engineered to benefit early adopters, which I find odd. Certainly, the possibility that BTC is a scam by itself has been greatly diminished since we discussed that topic (a year go ?), and I believe I said so at that time, but the possibility has not been eliminated, in my humble opinion, which was my point. I simply answered TeapotCavalry's request for clarifying what I meant by "suspect", and then somehow people started reading between the line, which is also not very "skeptical". I'll remind you that I've been following this thread since the beginning.
 
Last edited:
Did you mean to post this to someone else ?
No, that post was aimed at you and everybody else who makes up silly nonsense about bitcoin.

Bitcoin was NOT created by reptilian aliens* and I don't know why you are so desperate for people to believe otherwise.

* Your particular brand of nonsense might not be identical to that but it all looks the same after it has been passed through one's rear end.
 
Last edited:
No one is making silly nonsense, except maybe Wrs. Some of us have concerns about the people behind it. It's not my fault if you're unable to deal with uncertainty.
The objective data is that the ownership of bitcoin is highly concentrated. If you want to discuss the consequences of that - especially in an expanded bitcoin economy - then fine.

If you want to discuss what psychic powers Satoshi and his "team of designers" used to come up with a way to enrich the Illuminati then start a thread in the appropriate section.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom