How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again: how did you read that into my post since I was careful to WORD it in a way that showed that it was a suspicion ? You're trying real hard to make me more extreme and convinced that I really am. Why ?
Well my suspicion could of course be wrong. The way BTC works simply invites suspicion for some of us who are a bit familiar with certain forms of scam, though it could be a coincidence. Also bear in mind that these are things we were discussing about a year ago, or more, when BTC were far less valuable.
If you didn't believe this "suspicion" then you wouldn't have repeated it no matter how carefully you chose your words.

Bitcoin wasn't worth anything for the first 2 years of its life. It was just a technical curiosity for computer geeks. That means that any dreams that the early adopters had of getting rich from bitcoin were just that - dreams. Therefore, any talk of it being a conspiracy to fleece the public belongs in the other section.

Of course, you know all about this because the "suspicion" was thoroughly debunked years ago and you have been following this thread for a long time. Yet you decided to revive this nonsense as though it was a valid concern.
 
Well my suspicion could of course be wrong. The way BTC works simply invites suspicion for some of us who are a bit familiar with certain forms of scam, though it could be a coincidence. Also bear in mind that these are things we were discussing about a year ago, or more, when BTC were far less valuable.

Bitcoin has been around for 5 years. It was started out in the open in front of everyone. It's not a scam, it's a bubble. Very early adopters (like satoshi) got their coins by mining them, others just bought stashes of coin for a very low price. Now you cannot get anything from mining unless you have millions of dollars to invest in hashing computers. Some very early adopters did probably liquidate, but that was before the run up in price over the last 18 months. They probably regret it. Lot of people with large stakes are actively involved in setting up bitcoin businesses/infrastructure. These people are true believers.
 
If you didn't believe this "suspicion" then you wouldn't have repeated it no matter how carefully you chose your words.

That's a ridiculous assertion. We can speculate about various possibilities, and do most of the time on this board. That I find it likely doesn't mean I'm certain. Don't project your own sense of certainty on me.

Of course, you know all about this because the "suspicion" was thoroughly debunked years ago and you have been following this thread for a long time.

It wasn't "debunked". It was made significantly less probable.

Yet you decided to revive this nonsense as though it was a valid concern.

It is a valid concern for anyone not emotionally-invested in BTC.
 
So why don't you discuss the economics of it?

What do you think we have been doing for over a 100 pages?

Time to face reality;even if the basic idea behind bitcoin is good,bitcoin itself have pretty much wrecked itself by bad execution.
 
Has anyone updated the figures on what percentage of all mined Bitcoins have now been stolen? That has to be well over 10% now, you'd think.

Someone had to do it, so I totaled up the largest heists shown on the Bitcoin forum thread specifically started for that purpose, and added in the 850K from Mt. Gox and the 96K from the sheep business, and got slightly under 1.5 million BTC (excluding the FBI seizure). So, unofficially, that means about 12 percent of all BTC ever mined have been stolen. That doesn't speak well to Bitcoin's security.
 
I think the issue is that there is little or nothing you can actually do with it. Hell, you can't even leave the game at this point. One might be a bitcoin millionaire, but what does that really mean when one can't use any of it for anything?
...and what research have you done to make this claim?
 
I also suspect, with no proof, that the early adopters have already cashed out on most of their assets, and that BTC is now essentially dead to them.
I dare you to look honestly at your own behavior and tell me what you see and how you and others on your side are acting.
 
Last edited:
Is it just me or are the bitcoin supporters here behaving a lot like strong religious beleivers when confronted with evidence that they basic beliefs are simply wrong?
 
Someone had to do it, so I totaled up the largest heists shown on the Bitcoin forum thread specifically started for that purpose, and added in the 850K from Mt. Gox and the 96K from the sheep business, and got slightly under 1.5 million BTC (excluding the FBI seizure). So, unofficially, that means about 12 percent of all BTC ever mined have been stolen. That doesn't speak well to Bitcoin's security.

It's still not clear what happened at MtGox. They may never even have had the coins (ponzi style) and it appears they may still control ~200K in BTC. Also, did you count the losses from the Trendon T. Shavers case (another ponzi)?

Is it just me or are the bitcoin supporters here behaving a lot like strong religious beleivers when confronted with evidence that they basic beliefs are simply wrong?

I certainly haven't seen anything substantive from the BTC critics in this thread (except the few times I made criticism of course). Most of them, like yourself, just come by to snipe. Care to actually point out some of that evidence?
 
Someone had to do it, so I totaled up the largest heists shown on the Bitcoin forum thread specifically started for that purpose, and added in the 850K from Mt. Gox and the 96K from the sheep business, and got slightly under 1.5 million BTC (excluding the FBI seizure). So, unofficially, that means about 12 percent of all BTC ever mined have been stolen. That doesn't speak well to Bitcoin's security.
This article suggests 4% of bitcoins are stolen each year; that'd be ~50 billion dollars if it was the same proportion of US currency. Thankfully DK's have little actual share.

...and what research have you done to make this claim?
:rolleyes: Have you been watching the problems with turning the Dunning Krugerrands into real money?

Is it just me or are the bitcoin supporters here behaving a lot like strong religious beleivers when confronted with evidence that they basic beliefs are simply wrong?
Nope, it's pretty typical 'believer' behaviour.
 
It seems that bc isn't the only pseudo-currency with problems.
Cryptsy, which handles a number of such but mainly dogecoin has also crashed.
Link.
 
How can BS be a valid concern for anybody?

I've already explained it to you: it has not been demonstrated that it's BS, just that it's less likely than we initially thought. Why did you snip that part of my post, I wonder ?

I dare you to look honestly at your own behavior and tell me what you see

I see honesty.

Get to the point.
 
I've already explained it to you: it has not been demonstrated that it's BS, just that it's less likely than we initially thought. Why did you snip that part of my post, I wonder ?
It's either true or false. It can't be a "little bit" true.

You can't fool anybody. You made up (or rather, repeated) complete and utter BS and got caught out when the facts were presented.
 
I've already explained it to you: it has not been demonstrated that it's BS, just that it's less likely than we initially thought.

Is there anything indicating that this hypothesis is correct? And additionally, let's assume it is correct - early adopters were involved in the creation of BTC and have all cashed out by now, so what? Just more suspicion? This seems like an attempt of poisoning the well, instead of judging BTC by its own merits. Maybe you think early adopters and creators know something we don't and that's why they abandoned the ship? Secret knowledge?

The way BTC works simply invites suspicion for some of us who are a bit familiar with certain forms of scam, though it could be a coincidence.

I think most of us are familiar with certain forms of scam here in JREF forum, so that argument just doesn't fly.

Is it just me or are the bitcoin supporters here behaving a lot like strong religious beleivers when confronted with evidence that they basic beliefs are simply wrong?

Been waiting for that 'evidence' for dozens of pages now. What I've seen are mostly same conspiracies and confusions that have been debunked and corrected time and time again. And a few rare valid criticisms.

Maybe you care to turn this hollow observation into something constructive and explain what are those basic beliefs bitcoin supporters have that are wrong?


It's curious, how we supposedly read the same set of facts and come to the opposite conclusions. From where I stand, if anyone is being religiously dogmatic here, it's the anti-bitcoiners of this thread. There are many valid concerns with bitcoin, but the MO is misdirection, conspiracies and belittling quasi-personal attacks as if reading them off some pamphlet. "Ponzi this, sucker that, believers be scammed." My favourites of course are "you can't buy anything with bitcoin" and "you can't get out of the game!!!omg!11!", which are either deliberate lies or gross misconceptions. Logically speaking, I guess it's cherry picking only the worst cases, and ignoring the satisfied customers. But satisfied customers can always be explained away with another conspiracy. Or I dunno, maybe it's because of reading only a certain kind of headlines without trying to understand the content.

And I reckon the anti-bitcoiners think the same about me. :) What can we do to work this out?
 
Is there anything indicating that this hypothesis is correct?
It's a tactic that comes straight from the Religion and Philosophy section. Make a claim that is not verified by any of the existing data. In fact, the existing data will more than likely negate the claim to some extent at least.

Then point out that the existing data doesn't disprove the claim to a mathematical certainty so the claim might be true after all.
 
Last edited:
You don't need to go through exchanges at all. I explained this earlier. You can sell your coins for money on something like coinbase (not an exchange), you can sell directly to someone else without using an exchange, or you can save your bitcoins to purchase things directly with them. People have lived off of only bitcoins (without using normal money) for periods of time.


Hmmm...
https://coinbase.com said:
Coinbase is an international digital wallet that allows you to securely buy, use, and accept bitcoin currency

That sounds a lot like a centralized financial institution... exactly the thing Bitcoin was invented to avoid. Doesn't using services like this completely defeat the purpose of using Bitcoin in the first place?

Had you listed the rapidly growing blockchain or the exponentially increasing computing power needed for mining as undesirable features of bitcoin, you would have been on solid ground.

The exponentially increasing computing power needed for mining bitcoins is a feature, not a bug. The intent is to gradually increase the supply of bitcoins to 21 million over a period of 25 years, and the difficulty of mining the coins is continuously adjusted so that the number of bitcoins mined each year fits the schedule. If it wasn't for this intentional design feature, all the 21 million bitcoins would already be in circulation.

I'm almost tempted to buy one for novelty value. But the current price of bitcoins far exceeds the value of their novelty, and the idea of buying a handful of millibitcoins isn't nearly as appealing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom