How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is there anything indicating that this hypothesis is correct?

I can't say for sure, at this point.

In the first couple years, it sure looked that way, although that possibily got significantly reduced around last summer, if I remember correctly. Now, I'm not sure, but unlike Psi, I'm far from convinced that the possibility has been eliminated. Of course, he'd like to project that certainty onto me, but the only way he found to do it was to rewrite my post, which is possibly the most dishonest thing I've seen any member do on this forum.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm...


That sounds a lot like a centralized financial institution... exactly the thing Bitcoin was invented to avoid. Doesn't using services like this completely defeat the purpose of using Bitcoin in the first place?

No, because it's 100% optional.
 
I can't say for sure, at this point.

In the first couple years, it sure looked that way, although that possibily got significantly reduced around last summer, if I remember correctly. Now, I'm not sure, but unlike Psi, I'm far from convinced that the possibility has been eliminated. Of course, he'd like to project that certainty onto me, but the only way he found to do it was to rewrite my post, which is possibly the most dishonest thing I've seen any member do on this forum.

Most of the people that developed bitcoin are not anonymous and they are still working the project. Satoshi is the only mystery and he has not even touched his coins. Your suspicions are baseless. Bitcoin was developed out in the open, it's is a cypherpunk project. These people have been around for a long time. Take Hal Finney for example. He also developed PGP. Do you really think this guy was trying to come up with a scam? No. He's an ideologue.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(cypherpunk)
 
Last edited:
The exponentially increasing computing power needed for mining bitcoins is a feature, not a bug. The intent is to gradually increase the supply of bitcoins to 21 million over a period of 25 years, and the difficulty of mining the coins is continuously adjusted so that the number of bitcoins mined each year fits the schedule. If it wasn't for this intentional design feature, all the 21 million bitcoins would already be in circulation.
The highlighted part is incorrect. The mining difficulty has only to do with the aggregate amount of computing power devoted to mining and adjusts to ensure that only one block gets generated every 10 minutes. The number of new coins per block halves every 4 years.

You are right that this is a feature and not a bug but it is a worrying feature. Already, it is too expensive for the average user to buy equipment for mining bitcoins.
 
That sounds a lot like a centralized financial institution... exactly the thing Bitcoin was invented to avoid. Doesn't using services like this completely defeat the purpose of using Bitcoin in the first place?
Just like putting cash in a bank is 100% optional.
What makes you think that centralized exchanges are the be all and end all of bitcoin transactions?
 
Just like putting cash in a bank is 100% optional.

You cant use cash over the internet and there are restrictions on how to carry it physically. It is a fair comparison though, the existence of banks doesn't defeat the purpose of cash. So why would the creation of "bitcoin banks" defeat the purpose of bitcoin?

Like Mt. Gox , yes.

Not sure what your point is. Just another casual snipe without substantive content? Add a "herp derp" at the end next time so no one makes the mistake of assuming you spent mental energy on your post.
 
So using your logic, I could claim that Satoshi Nakamoto is probably a reptilian alien.

"Using my logic" ? What "logic" do you think I'm using, other than BTC features you yourself said are "worrying" ?

Seems to me like you're a true believer, and are unable to even consider that other people may be uncertain about something.
 
"Using my logic" ? What "logic" do you think I'm using, other than BTC features you yourself said are "worrying" ?
Maybe you have forgotten that in post #4992 you stated:
"BTC was designed specifically to benefit the early adopters, who were surely the ones who designed BTC. That's suspect in and of itself. I also suspect, with no proof, that the early adopters have already cashed out on most of their assets, and that BTC is now essentially dead to them".

You don't have a skerrick of evidence for these "suspicions" so they are entirely fanciful. I'm pointing out that I can also make up fanciful theories like that and then demand that others prove me wrong.

Seems to me like you're a true believer, and are unable to even consider that other people may be uncertain about something.
At least I discuss real issues with bitcoin. You certainly haven't bothered about issues such as the blockchain or mining difficulty. Since the above mentioned post, you haven't mentioned a single real issue but doggedly defended your right to insist that your fairy tale be taken seriously.

You obviously are so emotionally invested in the "bitcoin is bad" theme that you don't distinguish between reality and fancy anymore.
 
Maybe you have forgotten

What is it with posters and the belief that only they can remember stuff ?

"BTC was designed specifically to benefit the early adopters, who were surely the ones who designed BTC. That's suspect in and of itself. I also suspect, with no proof, that the early adopters have already cashed out on most of their assets, and that BTC is now essentially dead to them".

You left out the early part of the quote, which puts everything into perspective: "...the main concern was that BTC was designed specifically ...". Your continued dishonesty in quoting me makes it impossible for us to have a discussion. I also find it hilarious that any lack of certainty on my part is bad, just as certainty would be. There's just no winning with you faith-based folk.

You don't have a skerrick of evidence for these "suspicions" so they are entirely fanciful.

Another lie. BTC _does_ benefit early adopters by design.

You obviously are so emotionally invested in the "bitcoin is bad" theme that you don't distinguish between reality and fancy anymore.

You are a liar, and you prove it with every post you make. I have challenged wrs on his anti-BTC nonsense, but I don't see you pointing that out.
 
Last edited:
You left out the early part of the quote, which puts everything into perspective: "...the main concern was that BTC was designed specifically ...".
................
Another lie. BTC _does_ benefit early adopters by design.
Since you no longer consider that a "concern" but state it as an indisputable fact, the early part of the quote is irrelevant. Of course, repeating something is not the same as providing evidence.

You are a liar, and you prove it with every post you make. I have challenged wrs on his anti-BTC nonsense, but I don't see you pointing that out.
Whether wrs made statements you disagree with is not the issue (and neither is my integrity).

You originally complained about me altering words such as "concern" and "suspect" in your post but by digging your heels in, you have confirmed that your belief is a lot stronger than your post let on.
 
What do you think we have been doing for over a 100 pages?

Time to face reality;even if the basic idea behind bitcoin is good,bitcoin itself have pretty much wrecked itself by bad execution.

This seems the most unassailable comment in the past few pages - all that tolerate to read. The devolution into sniping, namecalling and smug unevidenced claims by propponents & detractors is predicable.

The main value of bitcoin at this point seems as example of both good & bad features that must be addressed by it's successor.
 
Since you no longer consider that a "concern" but state it as an indisputable fact, the early part of the quote is irrelevant. Of course, repeating something is not the same as providing evidence.

It was easier to mine early, and the amount of BTC mined decreases with time. How does it _not_ benefit early adopters ? You seemed to agree a few hours ago.

I also note that you are confusing the concerns that it was deliberate, with the indisputable fact that it does benefit early adopters. Gee, you have some trouble following discussions.

You originally complained about me altering words such as "concern" and "suspect" in your post but by digging your heels in, you have confirmed that your belief is a lot stronger than your post let on.

I have done no such thing. It's your delusion playing tricks on you. You don't get to project your certainty on others.
 
It was easier to mine early, and the amount of BTC mined decreases with time. How does it _not_ benefit early adopters ? (who were surely the ones who designed BTC.)
Those who got into mining early had no foreseeable benefit because there was no opportunity to cash the BTC in and it wasn't worth a cracker anyway. The only people who would benefit from the early acquision of bitcoins were those who were prepared to hold on to them for at least two years (as it turned out) and since the software was released within a week of the creation of the inaugural block, that was any member of the public who correctly guessed that bitcoin might be worth money some day.

It's no different to saying that a public float of a company is designed to benefit those who buy the shares first. If the company goes well then those early shareholders might make a packet but there are no guarantees. (Those early shareholders might well lose money).

The way the bitcoin generation rate works might not be the best way to do it. However, any suggestion that a digital currency should be subjected to inflation or demurrage does not seem to impress those who would buy into it. They seem to like the idea of an upper limit to how much of the currency will be around.

Awarding new bitcoins to those who have the most expensive computing equipment doesn't seem fair either. It helps to limit the opportunities to hog the new coins (eg by running multiple miners) but places an elitist spin on bitcoin. Perhaps awarding new blocks to those who were willing to spend BTC rather than CPU cycles (eg in a lottery/auction format) would have been a more equitable way to go.

These are valid concerns (now that bitcoin is worth money) but any suggestion that it was merely a scheme to make money mainly for the designers has no merit.
 
Those who got into mining early had no foreseeable benefit because there was no opportunity to cash the BTC in and it wasn't worth a cracker anyway.

Of course they had a foreseeable benefit. It was a currency, and they could cash in at some point. It doesn't matter how much they thought they would make, only that they believed it would benefit them. Do you seriously claim that the early adopters were getting into this BTC business for ***** and giggles ?

The only people who would benefit from the early acquision of bitcoins were those who were prepared to hold on to them for at least two years (as it turned out) and since the software was released within a week of the creation of the inaugural block, that was any member of the public who correctly guessed that bitcoin might be worth money some day.

Are you saying that the BTC designers are _not_ among early adopters ? That would sure be a weird move by them, seeing as it would cost them next to nothing to start with.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom