How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Assuming this is true: So what? It still is what bitcoin is.

Because when people criticize that aspect they ignore the actual reason people would want to use it as a currency: digital transactions w/o central authority. That's the base reason to use bitcoins. By mining bitcoins you are providing a service and being paid for it by the bitcoin users (by inflation). When all the bitcoins are mined out and there is no more inflation there is supposed to be transaction fees paid instead. Just because some crackpots want to get rich doesn't invalidate the real reason to use the currency.


It is essentially just that, regardless of what people were thinking when they build it.

And by similar logic so was the housing bubble...yet houses still serve a purpose other than getting rich.

... and thereby making the early adopters stinking rich.

Maybe, but we don't know. Even if the early adopters get rich, how would this matter to someone that wants to make purchases free from central authority? They will buy bitcoins at the going rate and then use them to purchase something. All that matter is that bitcoins work.

You could initially get a single bitcoin virtually for free. As I understand it, this is no longer possible or practical. The early adopters have free and whole bitcoins.

So what? If the currency works, it doesn't matter if some early adopters got rich.

If the currency should ever take off, one bitcoin will be worth a lot. The value the early adopters got for free will be paid by everyone who came to the game late.

We don't know what one bitcoin would be worth. Not that it matters.
 
Assuming this is true: So what? It still is what bitcoin is.
Because when people criticize that aspect they ignore the actual reason people would want to use it as a currency: digital transactions w/o central authority. That's the base reason to use bitcoins.


And why again would they want that? I mean, considering all the protections and stability that the "central authority" provides in our economy?


By mining bitcoins you are providing a service


What service? The earliest adopters (who generated the majority of bitcoins currently in existence within the first few months of the system's launch) performed little or no service at all.

Granted, they helped get the system off the ground merely by virtue of their participation, but in those earliest months there was almost no trade (no merchants even accepted bitcoin as payment yet), so the transaction load was negligible.

They accumulated a huge percentage of the available currency at no cost to themselves, instead foisting all the real-world costs on future participants who are buying into the system now. In other words, the early adopters got in on the ground floor of an opportunity to make a lot of free money off the backs of the speculators who came later to buy in with real dollars.

That dynamic, of paying the initial investors with money contributed by growing numbers of later investors, is called a pyramid, or Ponzi scheme, in case you didn't know. It's a popular and illegal scam. The upside is, it doesn't take a genius to spot one when all the mechanics are out in the open, as they are with Bitcoin.


and being paid for it by the bitcoin users (by inflation).


It's not inflation. It's deflation, excessive, runaway deflation.

When all the bitcoins are mined out and there is no more inflation there is supposed to be transaction fees paid instead. Just because some crackpots want to get rich doesn't invalidate the real reason to use the currency.


Bitcoin is too volatile to use as a currency, because of the excessive deflation.

The speculators who gamble their hard-earned money hoping to get rich off a useless fake currency are the marks in this huge pyramid scheme.

You may not believe it, but the mechanics of this system are not dissimilar to Bernie Madoff's fraudulent hedge fund.


And by similar logic so was the housing bubble...yet houses still serve a purpose other than getting rich.


But Bitcoin doesn't. How many things do you buy every day using bitcoins? How many people do you know who buy stuff with bitcoins?


Maybe, but we don't know. Even if the early adopters get rich, how would this matter to someone that wants to make purchases free from central authority? They will buy bitcoins at the going rate and then use them to purchase something. All that matter is that bitcoins work.


Go back and read through this thread. There are a lot of very intelligent people on this forum, and plenty of valid reasons have already given to show why this thing will probably never work as a practical currency on any significant scale.
 
Last edited:
Because when people criticize that aspect they ignore the actual reason people would want to use it as a currency: digital transactions w/o central authority.

No, that's why you, and a few others, want to use bitcoins. Most people don't give a toss about that, and a currency that only has appeal to a small subset is never going to be generally adopted.

Maybe, but we don't know. Even if the early adopters get rich, how would this matter to someone that wants to make purchases free from central authority?

Because it affects the stability of the market. The early adopters are basically in control of the world's supply of bitcoins: any one of them can, at any time, flood the market to the point of a crash without any consequence to themselves, whatsoever. Any time one of the early adopters decide to cut loose and have some fun, your stash of bitcoins become practically value-less over night.
 
Because when people criticize that aspect they ignore the actual reason people would want to use it as a currency: digital transactions w/o central authority.

And how exactly is this an advantage to anyone other than rabid anti-government types? Even if we don't treat bitcoin as a true alternative currency but as an alternative method of making online payments, it's horribly flawed. If I buy something online with my credit card through Paypal, there are two organisations I can take the matter up with if something goes wrong with the transaction. There are laws in places to help protect me. If I buy with bitcoin, all I've got is caveat emptor. Why on earth would I want to use bitcoin?
 
And how exactly is this an advantage to anyone other than rabid anti-government types? [...] Why on earth would I want to use bitcoin?

"Nae King! Nae Quin! Nae Laird! Nae Master! We Willnae be fooled again!"
 
And how exactly is this an advantage to anyone other than rabid anti-government types? Even if we don't treat bitcoin as a true alternative currency but as an alternative method of making online payments, it's horribly flawed. If I buy something online with my credit card through Paypal, there are two organisations I can take the matter up with if something goes wrong with the transaction. There are laws in places to help protect me. If I buy with bitcoin, all I've got is caveat emptor. Why on earth would I want to use bitcoin?
And lets not forget the Secret Service, who's main job is to combat counterfeiting and maintain the integrity of the US's currency and financial institutions. I'd feel so much better handing that over to a bunch of anonymous nerds spread across the globe. :rolleyes:
 
There's another problem with Bitcoin: its entire security model is based around an exceedingly complex mathematical problem. Mathematics is a science that is constantly progressing.

At some point, SHA2 will be cracked. This isn't a matter of "if," it's a matter of "when." It's inevitable, especially if the incentive exists to hijack an entire economic system worth billions of dollars.

If Bitcoin is already an established, functioning currency when that happens, then a lot of people are going to be in for some serious financial trouble.
 
That's assuming it can't be cracked already. I find it interesting that the same people who distrust governments are taking their word for it that this system can't be cracked.
 
That's assuming it can't be cracked already. I find it interesting that the same people who distrust governments are taking their word for it that this system can't be cracked.

Well they don't want to let out that they've cracked it (or created some backdoor into it).
 
It's not inflation. It's deflation, excessive, runaway deflation.

Bitcoin mining generates new bitcoins into existence. That is inflation. Once all of the bitcoins are mined out it will be deflation (but not runaway deflation) due to various ways bitcoins can be lost.

You may not believe it, but the mechanics of this system are not dissimilar to Bernie Madoff's fraudulent hedge fund.

I'm guessing you don't understand the mechanics of either.


But Bitcoin doesn't. How many things do you buy every day using bitcoins? How many people do you know who buy stuff with bitcoins?

It just started. What could you buy with paypal on day1? I dont personally use bitcoins, but if I had them I could convert them to money and buy whatever I wanted... So I would have no problem selling things for bitcoins and immediately converting the bitcoins to real money.

Go back and read through this thread. There are a lot of very intelligent people on this forum, and plenty of valid reasons have already given to show why this thing will probably never work as a practical currency on any significant scale.

I was here at the beginning. I am not saying bitcoins will work, but 90% of the criticism of bitcoins in this thread are about it as a get rich quick scheme not the actual intended use of it.
 
I was here at the beginning. I am not saying bitcoins will work, but 90% of the criticism of bitcoins in this thread are about it as a get rich quick scheme not the actual intended use of it.

That's like saying that 90% of the criticism of asbestos is of its carciogenic properties and not of its intended use as building insulation.
 
No, that's why you, and a few others, want to use bitcoins. Most people don't give a toss about that, and a currency that only has appeal to a small subset is never going to be generally adopted.

It's the actual purpose. If people do not care for that, then bitcoins wont be successful. If people do care, then it might be successful. That's the point I have been making.

Because it affects the stability of the market. The early adopters are basically in control of the world's supply of bitcoins: any one of them can, at any time, flood the market to the point of a crash without any consequence to themselves, whatsoever. Any time one of the early adopters decide to cut loose and have some fun, your stash of bitcoins become practically value-less over night.

You know how much of the bitcoins are tied up in the early adopters? What percent of bitcoins are tied up in the top percent of users vs some other currency? There's been no flooding of the market yet so your argument seems as valid as china selling off all it's US debt.
 
That's like saying that 90% of the criticism of asbestos is of its carciogenic properties and not of its intended use as building insulation.

More like criticizing the health consequences of sleeping on asbestos rather than using it for insulation.
 
More like criticizing the health consequences of sleeping on asbestos rather than using it for insulation.

No, see, the problem with asbestos is that it's not fit for its intended purpose because of its carciogenic properties. Likewise, bitcoins are not fit for its intended purpose for a multitude of reasons we've already covered in this thread.
 
Bitcoin mining generates new bitcoins into existence. That is inflation. Once all of the bitcoins are mined out it will be deflation (but not runaway deflation) due to various ways bitcoins can be lost.


An increase in the money supply alone does not constitute inflation. "Inflation" deals with the price of goods, specifically an increase in the price of goods.

In the Bitcoin economy, new money is generated at a slow and steady pace, regardless of the amount of demand. As the demand rises faster than the generation of new coin, the value of each coin artificially rises relative to the price of goods. When the value of the currency goes up, the prices come down. That represents a situation of deflation, caused by overvaluation of the currency.

Bitcoin is engineered to maintain an extremely scarce supply of monetary units at all times, even as its value outstrips that of other currencies severalfold. According to basic laws of supply and demand, that overvaluation creates an opportunity for speculation. You can blame the speculators themselves all you want, but they're just reacting to market dynamics that have been well-known for centuries.

The whole system is set up to reward the first adopters with a huge percentage of all the coins that will ever exist for absolutely free, then suddenly blow up with extreme overvaluation as Internet hype draws popular attention to its ostensible use as a currency. This of course causes the early adopters' holdings to artificially skyrocket in value. If you don't see the scam in that, then by all means, go ahead and start conducting your business in Bitcoin.

Just remember I told you so.


I'm guessing you don't understand the mechanics of either.


Sorry, I don't respond to ad hominem attacks.


It just started. What could you buy with paypal on day1?


It's been in business for over 2 years!


I dont personally use bitcoins...


Of course you don't! That's a major part of my argument. Nobody uses Bitcoins as a currency! Most of the people in it are in it to get rich.

Why do you think so few people trade in them? Why do you think so few merchants accept them, and no large, established companies bother with them? The extreme market volatility makes it entirely too unstable to rely on. The deflation punishes merchants by devaluing their goods and services over time, and also discourages spending because everybody wants to hold onto their stack to see how high it will go in value. It's been going for only 2 years and it's already rife with scams, theft and hacking. Why would anybody trade in Bitcoin when they can be safer and more secure using real money?

It's tailor-made to appeal to anti-government malcontents, criminals, currency cranks and libertarian/anarchist ideologues. In other words, people with limited capacity for critical thinking. Just like MLMs are tailored to appeal to people too loopy to hold down a real job.


...but if I had them I could convert them to money and buy whatever I wanted... So I would have no problem selling things for bitcoins and immediately converting the bitcoins to real money.


What a great currency that nobody wants to actually trade in! Everyone wants to cash them out for real money. Why do you think that is?


I was here at the beginning. I am not saying bitcoins will work, but 90% of the criticism of bitcoins in this thread are about it as a get rich quick scheme not the actual intended use of it.


As others have pointed out, that may or may not be the actual intended purpose. Of course the originators insist that their motives are altruistic, but a close look at the mechanics of the thing strongly suggests otherwise.


You know how much of the bitcoins are tied up in the early adopters?


According to this, as recently as June 7, 2011 100 people held 30% of all the coins in existence.


What percent of bitcoins are tied up in the top percent of users vs some other currency? There's been no flooding of the market yet so your argument seems as valid as china selling off all it's US debt.


The market has crashed how many times over the last couple months? I haven't followed it for a few weeks now, but it was happening a few times a week for awhile there. A sudden drop in the value of BTC indicates somebody was dumping a huge number of bitcoins on the market for the speculators to snap up.
 
Last edited:
You know how much of the bitcoins are tied up in the early adopters? What percent of bitcoins are tied up in the top percent of users vs some other currency? There's been no flooding of the market yet so your argument seems as valid as china selling off all it's US debt.

We don't know, but it's easy to guess based on the amount of Bitcoins mined so far vs the number of miners. It seems clear that almost 6 million coins were mined by a few early adopters, in fact, the 6 millionth coin was mined earlier this year when adoption was low. Moreover, 3 million coins were mined in the first year alone. This means that at least 70% (I'm being extremely generous with this estimate) of all BTCs in existence is in very few hands. This can be corroborated by the lack of liquidity in the Bitcoin marketplace. Nobody is using Bitcoins.

A system that leaves so much power in a very few early adopters is doomed to fail, nobody with any financial knowledge will touch them.
 
It just started. What could you buy with paypal on day1? I dont personally use bitcoins, but if I had them I could convert them to money and buy whatever I wanted... So I would have no problem selling things for bitcoins and immediately converting the bitcoins to real money.

I joined x.com, which became PayPal. I joined it for one reason: they had a 0.01% load S&P index fund, but you could also send money to people via email. The fund got people to put money into it, and was a real fund. I earned money on that. They dropped that once they hit critical mass.

But the basic service of being able to send money via email was there since the beginning, and worked fine. It was only later that merchants started integrating PayPal into their sites once the infrastructure and accounts were in place.

There is no comparison whatsoever between Bitcoin and PayPal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom