How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's the whole point. Ordinarily customers would vote with their feet if their bank was up to any shenanigans but this feeling of security enables banks to take unnecessary risks with their customers' money. You only end up with second rate bloated banks that way.

It would be outrageous to offer MtGox a similar deal. Bitcoin exchanges that can't cut the mustard must not be propped up. Bitcoin will be much better off when holders don't have to rely on these centralized dinosaurs to cash in.

Thus creating more bank failures. Hell all you need is a rumor to kill a bank after all.

But others feel a stable financial institution is good for the country and as the money does not come from taxes but from fees charged to the banks what is the problem?

Should I be paying for insurance on my money my self or keep it somewhere that provides that insurance for me?
 
Huge buy wall of 1300 coins at 120 on gox has been eaten in less than a minute. You can see zero on the bid stack and there are very few bids below $100. The price is collapsing rapidly now below $120.
 
Things are not looking up for BTC, and Mhaze's and psionl0's predictions.

My $150 has been met. But here is the thing for those other exchanges and the people crowing about how the price is still $580 or whatever. The problem is this, MtGox has about 500k bitcoins according to someone that has done the blockchain math. Today over 100k have changed hands so far at prices below $130...

If the BTC on Gox are allowed to leave, why wouldn't they be sold on the other exchanges and thus, drive the price down to $130 on those exchanges as well? The bid stacks on BtC-e and Bitstamp couldn't support a wave of 500k bitcoins being liquidated over even a month. The prices would simply collapse.

There are already complaints about bitstamp not allowing withdrawals today in either cash or BTC without further KYC info that has already been supplied.

The posters on reddit and bitcointalk are yapping about FUD but they have been doing that ever since the China announcement. I think it's not FUD that is driving BTC prices back to pre-October levels but liquidity issues. I have been pointing out that there was no way to liquidate the BTC at the ridiculous quoted prices without new money coming in. Apparently the new money coming in has started going the other way, old money coming out which means only one thing for the price of BTC.
 
Last edited:
Things are not looking up for BTC, and Mhaze's and psionl0's predictions.

Gox will certainly bottom out at this point; the question is how much damage it will do to the other exchanges on the way. As I suspected before, there are a TON of people currently buying BTC on Gox in an effort to get it out and sell it on the other exchanges -- that'll drive the other exchanges' price way down for awhile because who wants to buy a coin at 4x markup?

The questions will be: how many BTC can be gotten out of Gox before everything finishes going tits-up over there, and at what markup point will the buyers on the other exchanges figure that getting hold of some cheaper BTC is still worth it -- thus (relatively) stabilizing the crash at a new equilibrium? 1.5x, 2x premium over Gox' current price? No way to tell ahead of time there, just have to wait and see.
 
Gox will certainly bottom out at this point; the question is how much damage it will do to the other exchanges on the way. As I suspected before, there are a TON of people currently buying BTC on Gox in an effort to get it out and sell it on the other exchanges -- that'll drive the other exchanges' price way down for awhile because who wants to buy a coin at 4x markup?


Well if so, then why were 25,000 BTC sold before the announcement this morning?

qLYhzR3.jpg



The questions will be: how many BTC can be gotten out of Gox before everything finishes going tits-up over there, and at what markup point will the buyers on the other exchanges figure that getting hold of some cheaper BTC is still worth it -- thus (relatively) stabilizing the crash at a new equilibrium? 1.5x, 2x premium over Gox' current price? No way to tell ahead of time there, just have to wait and see.

There is apparently now going to be a class action suit to get fiat out of Gox. So maybe these people sold for fiat in order to get that suit going. In that way, they could recoup whatever fiat they can get by Gox being forced to liquidate whatever coins they own wherever they can get cash for them.
 
Last edited:
My $150 has been met.

No, your prediction was $500-$150 in a month. Given you were constantly claiming it was going to collapse and the price is so volatile, I don't think the brief drop below $500 before going back up for months is all that convincing. Further, I note your charts didn't actually predict this decline, and as I previously demonstrated they predicted false ones. Further, I could say it will fall before $100 within the month because of the lunar cycle. If that is met it says nothing about lunar cycles.
 
Last edited:
So if BTC collapses because no one can exchange it for BTC at MtGox and, presumably, other places, and therefore that its value is entirely based on your ability to convert it into cash, can we finally admit that BTC isn't a currency ?
 
My $150 has been met. But here is the thing for those other exchanges and the people crowing about how the price is still $580 or whatever. The problem is this, MtGox has about 500k bitcoins according to someone that has done the blockchain math. Today over 100k have changed hands so far at prices below $130...

If the BTC on Gox are allowed to leave, why wouldn't they be sold on the other exchanges and thus, drive the price down to $130 on those exchanges as well? The bid stacks on BtC-e and Bitstamp couldn't support a wave of 500k bitcoins being liquidated over even a month. The prices would simply collapse.

There are already complaints about bitstamp not allowing withdrawals today in either cash or BTC without further KYC info that has already been supplied.

The posters on reddit and bitcointalk are yapping about FUD but they have been doing that ever since the China announcement. I think it's not FUD that is driving BTC prices back to pre-October levels but liquidity issues. I have been pointing out that there was no way to liquidate the BTC at the ridiculous quoted prices without new money coming in. Apparently the new money coming in has started going the other way, old money coming out which means only one thing for the price of BTC.

Wait, I thought the collapse of Bitcoin was due to a NWO conspiracy.
 
No, your prediction was $500-$150 in a month. Given you were constantly claiming it was going to collapse and the price is so volatile, I don't think the brief drop below $500 before going back up for months is all that convincing. Further, I note your charts didn't actually predict this decline, and as I previously demonstrated they predicted false ones. Further, I could say it will fall before $100 within the month because of the lunar cycle. If that is met it says nothing about lunar cycles.

Wrong. I guessed $150, period. You can make all kinds of claims you could have would have should have made that would have been right but you predicted nothing. I guessed $500 in December with a possible low of $150 and the price went to $375, right in the middle of the range. I also called the top price of BTC at $1242 within a few hours.

I have a guess with Meg that BTC will be $150 before it hits $1242 on Gox or $1163 on Bitstamp. My guess for Gox is fulfilled, Bitstamp is still to follow.


Nope, bitstamp is fine. I will say also that I don't think MtGox is going to get above 1242 before any exchange price hits 150.
 
Last edited:
Well if so, then why were 25,000 BTC sold before the announcement this morning?

For every seller there has to be a buyer, ya know. _someone_ paid fiat for those BTC, and undoubtedly in an effort to take advantage of the action that's about to happen as soon as someone can get BTC out of Gox.
 
For every seller there has to be a buyer, ya know. _someone_ paid fiat for those BTC, and undoubtedly in an effort to take advantage of the action that's about to happen as soon as someone can get BTC out of Gox.

True, they paid goxfiat from a gox account purportedly containing fiat to the holders of the 25k goxbtc. Now those former goxbtc holders have a substantial goxfiat position for which they can file a class action lawsuit. If they don't use that goxfiat to buy more goxbtc then the buyers have goxbtc which they cannot transfer out and a lot less goxfiat with which to buy and pump the price. Currently the price is at 113 and no pump attempts have worked.

A 40% rebound from here only gets the price back up to slightly over $150. I think the people that sold at $260 probably did the right thing. Their best move is just to sit on the goxfiat and see which way the wind blows if they aren't part of the lawsuit.

I am just trying to piece together a picture here of what might be going on there. All of the reddit people think this was insider trading. I think that it's not.
 
I am just trying to piece together a picture here of what might be going on there. All of the reddit people think this was insider trading. I think that it's not.

Possible but implausible IMO; if you had inside knowledge of the announcement that was coming, you'd start selling slowly to avoid causing a huge dump like that. (Can't ever rule out panic, of course.)

The 1:30EST cliff looks like someone who spent a lot of time thinking about it, decided the announcement was going to be more bad news, said "Get me out NOW" and dumped all their coins.
 
I love how you "predict" things. Apparently you meant that 150$ was going to happen at some time, for some time, at some exchange.

No, it hasn't been met yet if you take the averaged values, even if you include MtGox.

Actually here is the first post I made about $150 back on Nov. 27th, not 3 months ago. It was wrt MTGox and where is MtGox now?

Here is another reference to $150 made the next day to mhaze and to which you responded asking for a specific prediction.

Here was my response to you where I said dates were unimportant. TWT and indeed it has.

It's customary to admit when you're wrong, so you look like a reasonable person.

The point of setting a time limit is to make sure you don't cop out if the crash doesn't happen. If you say "within 6 months" and it doesn't happen, your opposition can say "you were wrong". Otherwise your claim becomes unfalsifiable, and we tend to not like that here.

Here is your response to me pushing me again for a date certain. Of course you were willing to allow 6 months and it has happened in less than three months.

Here is my response to you where I honestly admit I can only guess. It is you that keeps putting prediction out there.

Here is the thing, given that I have no idea why it bounced the last month, I have no idea if it's sustainable so I can't place any timeframe on it. With the current price, it's going to take more money to sustain the same transaction volume of a month ago.

Just watching the Mt. Gox ticker I see that bitcoin doesn't sustain very high transaction volume without significant price swings. It's pretty clear to me that each time the price falls, it's driven back up again with incremental buying. This all looks like speculation and to me, that always ends with a collapse of some kind and $150 is just a guess, it may only be $500.

Here is my top call on Nov. 29 where I admit I could be wrong, but I haven't been.

Here is you again pressing me for a date and I say why?

Here is psion10 claiming I called for doomsday at $150 but that is his wording. Now I guess we have "doomsday" at least on Gox.

Here is where I actually set a date for you on .

It broke out of that long triangle and the channel at the very end of the triangle so it could run 300 points which would be around 1000 and since it already hit 982, I think it's done. This whole run was on very thin volume. We will see how it goes, this thing is way too expensive for what it is. This is a typical manipulation to try and bring suckers back in but it's too much too soon. Gold and silver made similar moves but not as extreme.

I am sticking with 500 or less by the end of the month, with 150 as the low end of the range.

I even explained why it might not make 150 right here:

I already did. 500 to 150 by the end of the month. Can't do better than that. I think this is a dead cat bounce on declining volume. It was a near perfect .62 retrace of the 666 point drop from 1242 t0 576. I guess it could still try to move higher but if it's A-B-C down, then we are about to do C and C=A plenty of times so that would be another 666 from around 1000 to 450 or less. Guess we will see if the bitbulls can roll the rock back up the hill or if it rolls back down on them.

Here you are complaining that you don't want to accept my conditions for my guess which you insist on calling a prediction. I started out calling it a guess which it was but it was also correct.

QED
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom