How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Gox just changed addresses and they are supposed to reopen for withdrawals tomorrow or make another announcement. Hmmmm, what does this tell me?

Gox is currently at 264 and can't get over 300 and stay there. What happens if Gox reopens? Seems to me that there are a lot of coins that have turned over at these prices, they would most certainly be withdrawn and sold because Gox doesn't do USD withdrawals or really any fiat withdrawals in any reasonable time but they were doing 100 BTC/day before this malleability issue came up.

I can only conclude that people on the other exchanges do not believe Gox will reopen. I am not sure I see how Gox reopening could do anything but bad for the other exchanges. In the event that people want to buy Gox coins, they would sell one coin on the working exchanges, transfer money to Gox and buy two coins there. This would continue until the price stabilizes at a lower level on the other exchanges.

Either Gox is signalling that it will never reopen or it's going to be a catalyst for lower bitcoin prices unless new money is injected from the outside. That looks less likely given the rash of security issues that have come up lately.
 
Last edited:
No it hasn't banks fail all the time. It is that a subset of banks might be too big to fail with out undue damage to the economy. Insurance didn't cause that, as it only kicks in on failure. Poor regulation caused that.

When should a bank be stopped from growing any bigger?
It's not about artificially limiting the size of banks (but I think you knew that). Bank insurance (especially where the taxpayer is surety for any payout shortfall) enables banks to take bigger risks than they would otherwise take. If the risk pays off then the bank gets bigger than ever and if not then taxpayers to the rescue. The smaller banks might be allowed to fail or, more likely, be swallowed up by the bigger banks.

The same sort of artificial growth would happen if bitcoin exchanges were insured the same way. Bitcoin and how it is used is strictly an "at your risk" commodity.
 
"W.Avg:$267.97" -- https://www.mtgox.com/

Wow. Wasn't Bitcoin above $1000 just a month ago? And Bitcoin has been made illegal in China and Russia.

"On Jan. 29, the Central Bank of Russia issued an official warning stating that all Bitcoin transactions will be considered potentially suspicious and added that use of Bitcoins in Russia is illegal. The currency is already banned in China, and the Financial Supervisory Authority of Denmark has also issues a statement warning against its use." -- http://rbth.co.uk/business/2014/02/05/russia_becomes_the_second_country_to_ban_bitcoin_33871.html
 
It's not about artificially limiting the size of banks (but I think you knew that). Bank insurance (especially where the taxpayer is surety for any payout shortfall) enables banks to take bigger risks than they would otherwise take. If the risk pays off then the bank gets bigger than ever and if not then taxpayers to the rescue. The smaller banks might be allowed to fail or, more likely, be swallowed up by the bigger banks.

The same sort of artificial growth would happen if bitcoin exchanges were insured the same way. Bitcoin and how it is used is strictly an "at your risk" commodity.

This is profoundly incorrect. It is deregulation that allowed banks to become too big to fail. Certainly not FDIC insurance.
 
It seems that Bitcoin is alarmingly sensitive to psychology. Dropping like a rock at the sign of slightest disturbance. Too shaky for my taste.
 
Bitcoin has been made illegal in China and Russia.
That is only half right. The Chinese banks can no longer deal with bitcoin exchanges but the Chinese can still use bitcoin.

Of course, you would expect bitcoin to be banned in totalitarian states.

It seems that Bitcoin is alarmingly sensitive to psychology. Dropping like a rock at the sign of slightest disturbance. Too shaky for my taste.
That's the way to do it. Examine the evidence then decide if bitcoin is worth the risk to you.
 
That's the way to do it. Examine the evidence then decide if bitcoin is worth the risk to you.


I think we've all agreed that Bitcoin is most likely not "The Most Important Creation in the History of Man," so the idiotic title of this thread remains unfortunate.

Bitcoin has proven appealing, at times, to speculators, criminals, arbitrageurs and gamblers, with obvious overlaps.

To whom else who's rational is the risk of this "currency" appealing?
 
Last edited:
Bitcoin has proven appealing, at times, to speculators, criminals, arbitrageurs and gamblers, with obvious overlaps.

To whom else who's rational is the risk of this "currency" appealing?
That list pretty much covers anybody who would invest in anything (although more respectable sounding adjectives might be used).
 
It's not about artificially limiting the size of banks (but I think you knew that). Bank insurance (especially where the taxpayer is surety for any payout shortfall) enables banks to take bigger risks than they would otherwise take. If the risk pays off then the bank gets bigger than ever and if not then taxpayers to the rescue. The smaller banks might be allowed to fail or, more likely, be swallowed up by the bigger banks.

The same sort of artificial growth would happen if bitcoin exchanges were insured the same way. Bitcoin and how it is used is strictly an "at your risk" commodity.

But it is only the deposits that are insured, the banks owners take a total loss. It only helps me as a depositor as I don't need to worry if the bank is making goodc decisions with other portions of its activities or not.
 
But it is only the deposits that are insured, the banks owners take a total loss. It only helps me as a depositor as I don't need to worry if the bank is making goodc decisions with other portions of its activities or not.
That's the whole point. Ordinarily customers would vote with their feet if their bank was up to any shenanigans but this feeling of security enables banks to take unnecessary risks with their customers' money. You only end up with second rate bloated banks that way.

It would be outrageous to offer MtGox a similar deal. Bitcoin exchanges that can't cut the mustard must not be propped up. Bitcoin will be much better off when holders don't have to rely on these centralized dinosaurs to cash in.
 
Bitcoin has proven appealing, at times, to speculators, criminals, arbitrageurs and gamblers, with obvious overlaps.

To whom else who's rational is the risk of this "currency" appealing?

Merchants. You left out merchants and their customers. I guess bitcoin must be pretty appealing. Or maybe they're all out of their mind irrational. I bet a lot of posters here would be more at ease believing the latter.
 
Last edited:
$593 now.

www.preev.com

And you'll notice that the major vendors (Overstock and Wordpress IIRC) who "accept Bitcoin" have actually only agreed to do business with middlemen, who are paying them in stodgy old fiat. They've laid off the risk on the middlemen. Maybe that was a bad decision, if BTC goes back up to a thousand; maybe not. TWT.
 
Last edited:
$
And you'll notice that the major vendors (Overstock and Wordpress IIRC) who "accept Bitcoin" have actually only agreed to do business with middlemen,

IIRC, the only thing that we know is that coinbase is the middleman. Whether Overstock receives fiat, BTC or both has not been revealed. You may correct me on that.
 
Looks like the market was goxed again

As Golmer would say surprise, surprise, surprise

Price back below $600 and on Gox it's below $150 at 136 about a 50% discount from yesterday.

Ring a ding ding ding!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
How can MtGox have $160 when others have $600 for a bitcoin? :confused:

Because MtGox has stopped bitcoin withdrawals and people have been waiting months for cash withdrawals. Whatever MtGox has or doesn't have is locked up tight and only idiots put their money in. There are some of those according to the posts on reddit though. Guess now they realize they bet wrong buying goxcoins for $300 because now they don't have BTC or $ any longer.
 
Looks like the market was goxed again

As Golmer would say surprise, surprise, surprise

Hah, their incompetence is staggering. One would think being the nr 1 BTC trading site, they're wealthy enough to hire more (competent) staff and expand and resolve whatever technical and security concerns they have. Anyone know the size of the staff? I could understand transaction limitations imposed by banks, but this has no excuse. They seem to lack any business foresight.

Because MtGox has stopped bitcoin withdrawals and people have been waiting months for cash withdrawals. Whatever MtGox has or doesn't have is locked up tight and only idiots put their money in. There are some of those according to the posts on reddit though. Guess now they realize they bet wrong buying goxcoins for $300 because now they don't have BTC or $ any longer.

It's insanely high risk, but one could make a hefty profit buying btc in mtgox now. In any case it's interesting to see how that plays out.
 
It's insanely high risk, but one could make a hefty profit buying btc in mtgox now. In any case it's interesting to see how that plays out.

I think MtGox price represents the price if the exchange matches it's cash with it's bitcoins. That is to say that the bitcoin price*number of bitcoins/cash on hand is probably leveraged in the range of 10 to 1. It is pretty clear that MtGox has very little cash based on the fact that they just don't seem to be able to fulfil withdrawal in $ and now even other currencies are not being withdrawn.

If people decide that they want to cash out of bitcoin entirely, there isn't enough cash in accounts to buy bitcoin at those prices. It is my understanding that the cash in the exchange is in the customer accounts along with bitcoin. So if people with bitcoin sell them, take their cash and leave, they are no longer buying the dips and the liquidity in the dips fails so the price drops to another lower support level where the pump and dump game is continued.

I think this is what we have been seeing. Smart players are slowly but surely pulling the cash out and leaving less bitcoin in their accounts and less cash. The pump and dump game now works only at lower prices because there isn't enough cash to support it at higher price levels.

I doubt anyone will get out of Gox with more than $15/btc and that after many years of litigation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom