How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think wrs means "hundreds of dollars". It appears that the price of bitcoin is volatile. :yikes:

I meant in the last few days. Wrs has been consistent in his doom-saying about BTC. He kept claiming that it would go down to 150, but played fast and loose with the definition of "prediction" once I pressed him for one back in December, so his opinion about how volatile BTC are is not particularily interesting to me.
 
Your admission of lying is accepted; of course, this isn't anything new since you usually respond to your own strawmen, rather than what people actually say. You now need to admit an additional lie of yours:
Seriously. Who cares if grandma's a little slow on the ball these days and gets a huge chunk of her savings scammed away from her in one swoop? She was obviously too stupid to handle Magical Internet Money!
Well what do you know? You did post about grandmothers. That is something you actually said. That makes me the truth-teller and you the liar.


As you can see, this is not a claim -- I asked a question.
What are you looking for? A section of the penal code that specifically mentions bitcoin by name?

Do you seriously believe that a contract would be ruled void for consideration if bitcoin was the only consideration offered by one of the parties? Is data theft not a crime where you live? Do you think that if the police don't investigate the report of a particular theft or swindle then there is no law that covers the activity?

See? I can ask questions too. Of course, an honest person would admit that he thinks that existing laws can't be applied to bitcoin rather than try to disguise that opinion as a series of questions instead.

Of course, since bitcoin doesn't know international boundaries, some kinds of frauds or thefts might be difficult to prosecute. MtGox might be one example but I don't have much sympathy for those who would deal with an institution with such a doubtful history (except for grandmothers who were conned into dealing with MtGox).

If Bitcoin can't make at least the basic concepts of this understandable to an elderly grandmother... of which we have rather a lot in the USA..., then Bitcoin is doomed to its speculative Internet-gambling status, its legacy likely to only be the underlying technology created to support it.
It's a good thing you are not posting about grandmothers.
 
I meant in the last few days. Wrs has been consistent in his doom-saying about BTC. He kept claiming that it would go down to 150, but played fast and loose with the definition of "prediction" once I pressed him for one back in December, so his opinion about how volatile BTC are is not particularily interesting to me.

Except that you managed to make a comment on it. Seems that bitcoin is on a long slide back to 150. My prediction was for 150 to 500 by the end of December and it fell below 500. That in no way invalidates 150 as a target and I have a prediction for Meg that 150 will be reached on MtGox before 1242 and that 150 will be reached on Bitstamp before 1167 I think it is. I stand by that prediction.

MtGox is at 260 right now.
 
Except that you managed to make a comment on it. Seems that bitcoin is on a long slide back to 150. My prediction was for 150 to 500 by the end of December and it fell below 500. That in no way invalidates 150 as a target and I have a prediction for Meg that 150 will be reached on MtGox before 1242 and that 150 will be reached on Bitstamp before 1167 I think it is. I stand by that prediction.

MtGox is at 260 right now.

I think you have to accept that your prediction failed in this instance. Nevertheless, I think it is a matter of whether bitcoin will go with a bang or a whimper.
 
Except that you managed to make a comment on it. Seems that bitcoin is on a long slide back to 150. My prediction was for 150 to 500 by the end of December and it fell below 500. That in no way invalidates 150 as a target and I have a prediction for Meg that 150 will be reached on MtGox before 1242 and that 150 will be reached on Bitstamp before 1167 I think it is. I stand by that prediction.

MtGox is at 260 right now.

wbf51s.jpg
 
Well what do you know? You did post about grandmothers. That is something you actually said. That makes me the truth-teller and you the liar.

The level of cognitive impairment required to make this statement and actually believe it leads me to conclude that you're no longer arguing seriously and have conceded the point. Thanks; next time leave the ad hominems at home and just address the argument.

What are you looking for? A section of the penal code that specifically mentions bitcoin by name?
Just answer the questions, please. Alternately, see below, where you admit that the laws weren't designed to deal with circumstances like Bitcoin, and there's a big grey area about which Bitcoin transactions are actually legally protected -- not to mention that the irreversibility of Bitcoin makes it trivial for the fraudster to get the coins and turn them into real money at his leisure.

See? I can ask questions too. Of course, an honest person would admit that he thinks that existing laws can't be applied to bitcoin rather than try to disguise that opinion as a series of questions instead.
*sigh* Are you literally incapable of reading the words in front of you?

me said:
I don't know the answers to these questions, and I seriously doubt that some of them even _have_ answers right now. If you don't even know where to begin answering these questions, then I would say that your assertion that Bitcoin transactions are somehow protected under either currency or contract laws greatly falls short of the practical reality.

Again, please respond to what I actually say rather than what you wish I had said.
 
I think you have to accept that your prediction failed in this instance. Nevertheless, I think it is a matter of whether bitcoin will go with a bang or a whimper.

How did it fail? I gave a range for December and it hit that range, BTC went below $400 (maybe $375) in December, well below $500 so I am not sure why you would say this. I never said the price would go down and stay down. In collapses the price always bounces just like it always drops on the way up. The difference is in how the dips and bounces are played. In a decline the bounces are sold, in a rise the dips are bought. When the market is in the process of changing the trend, it's less clear that the bounces are to be sold and a lot of people lose money because they waited too late to buy the dip but even the dipsters get hosed. Look what happened to those that bought dip to $800 back in early December, they are way underwater now if they held and didn't sell on the bounce to $1000.

I stand by the $150 prediction, it's just not going to get there overnight and I never said it would.
 
Last edited:
How did it fail? I gave a range for December and it hit that range, BTC went below $400 (maybe $375) in December, well below $500 so I am not sure why you would say this. I never said the price would go down and stay down. In collapses the price always bounces just like it always drops on the way up. The difference is in how the dips and bounces are played. In a decline the bounces are sold, in a rise the dips are bought. When the market is in the process of changing the trend, it's less clear that the bounces are to be sold and a lot of people lose money because they waited too late to buy the dip but even the dipsters get hosed. Look what happened to those that bought dip to $800 back in early December, they are way underwater now if they held and didn't sell on the bounce to $1000.

I stand by the $150 prediction, it's just not going to get there overnight and I never said it would.
150 by the end of December was your prediction. It didn't happen. Don't get me wrong. I think you are correct, just off in the timing. And that is not a big failing, timing is a bugger to predict. My only critique would be that it is occurring more slowly than you predicted.

The current scenario is that I should be able to buy from gox and sell to any other at enormous profit. This is not allowed. It is a controlled, artificial market. We agree on this. Try not to take a massive dump upon those who support you. I have enjoyed analysing your graphs. I generally agree. But gee it helps not your case to hand out slaps to those who might support you. It is almost as if you really, really want to be isolated.
 
150 by the end of December was your prediction. It didn't happen. Don't get me wrong. I think you are correct, just off in the timing. And that is not a big failing, timing is a bugger to predict. My only critique would be that it is occurring more slowly than you predicted.

The current scenario is that I should be able to buy from gox and sell to any other at enormous profit. This is not allowed. It is a controlled, artificial market. We agree on this. Try not to take a massive dump upon those who support you. I have enjoyed analysing your graphs. I generally agree. But gee it helps not your case to hand out slaps to those who might support you. It is almost as if you really, really want to be isolated.

No, I didn't mean to dump on you, don't take it that way.. I see that a lot of people took me for saying that $150 by the end of December was my prediction. It was part of it and I realized that it was likely that it wouldn't make it that far that fast which is why I gave the range. It wasn't as certain a prediction as if I had just said $500 but I did think it had a chance at going as low as $150 that quickly. Still, I never imagined that there wouldn't be a strong bounce. What is a little different here than in most collapses is that they managed to hold the $800 level for quite a long time which took some of the energy out of the decline. It seems to be returning though. If Gox doesn't reopen in the morning, it could get ugly. If it does, people will move their coins from Gox to elsewhere and sell them I bet. The smart ones will sell into the relief rally.

Bitcoin has legitimate competitors and so I don't think there is anything so great about it as a crypto currency that gives it a big advantage other than it was first. For that reason alone, it should be going back down to where LTC is now.
 
Unbelievable! After all this time there are still posters who can't distinguish between a bitcoin and a bitcoin exchange.

I'm well aware of the difference. Perhaps the wild fluctuations between Mt.Gox, the most well known exchange, and the other well known exchanges should tip you off to the problems.

If you seriously believe that it is possible to write open source software but include secrets that fool every single programmer in the whole world then you have a lot to learn about "open source".

Its not the code that bothers me. But, this is unlike any other open source project. This isn't LibreOffice or OpenVPN. If those stopped being produced or started becoming more common, it doesn't hurt what I'm using right now.

If the Document foundation decides they are done with LibreOffice, I still have a working version of it.

If Nakamoto decides to bounce on bitcoin...

There are only secrets to those who don't understand software and have never bothered to learn anything about bitcoin.

OK, so who is Nakamoto and where was Bitcoin first mined? What is stopping him/her/them from dumping all of their BTC and destroying the value? What are the failsafes? What makes BTC any better than Mickey Mouse dollars?
 
OK, so who is Nakamoto and where was Bitcoin first mined? What is stopping him/her/them from dumping all of their BTC and destroying the value? What are the failsafes? What makes BTC any better than Mickey Mouse dollars?

Disney will sue your ass if you try to print Mickey Mouse dollars.

(probably not the answer you were looking for)
 
I'm well aware of the difference. Perhaps the wild fluctuations between Mt.Gox, the most well known exchange, and the other well known exchanges should tip you off to the problems.
Obviously not since you discuss bitcoin exchanges as if they were bitcoin itself.

Its not the code that bothers me. [.................] If Nakamoto decides to bounce on bitcoin...
More ignorance. No individual could impose a change in the bitcoin source code on the rest of the bitcoin community.

OK, so who is Nakamoto and where was Bitcoin first mined? What is stopping him/her/them from dumping all of their BTC and destroying the value? What are the failsafes? What makes BTC any better than Mickey Mouse dollars?
This has all been thrashed out before. Read about it yourself. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/History

As for why the largest bitcoin holders aren't committing financial suicide by crashing bitcoin, check out the 1000 or so posts in this thread that have debated this very point.
 
I've never been worried that the largest bitcoin holders would wipe out the market by crashing bitcoin... but they could certainly institute timed instabilities that they can profit from and that most others would lose being unaware of the planned timing.
 
Obviously not since you discuss bitcoin exchanges as if they were bitcoin itself.

Ya, they are only the lone way o actually exchange them or establish their exchange rate. No connection or influence on BTC at all

More ignorance. No individual could impose a change in the bitcoin source code on the rest of the bitcoin community.
Not what I said. I get the code is solid. Its the implementation that is worrying.

However, about 1/4 of BTC are reportedly in the possession Nakamoto. Should this person or group decide to just dump all 1 million+ BTC in one move, what would happen to BTC?

This has all been thrashed out before. Read about it yourself. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/History
Does not answer 1 single question

As for why the largest bitcoin holders aren't committing financial suicide by crashing bitcoin, check out the 1000 or so posts in this thread that have debated this very point.
It wouldn't be suicide for Nakamoto. Why would it be? He/she/they would be the first one out. The very top of the pyramid scheme. Since Nakamoto would no longer have money tied up in BTC they would make out like bandits and everyone else who bought in would be screwed. See the problem? They are a de facto central bank with no regulation and no mandate to watch out for BTC economy.
 
Last edited:
Ya, they are only the lone way o actually exchange them or establish their exchange rate. No connection or influence on BTC at all
What does the price you may (or may not) get at a bitcoin exchange have to do with bitcoin itself?

However, about 1/4 of BTC are reportedly in the possession Nakamoto. Should this person or group decide to just dump all 1 million+ BTC in one move, what would happen to BTC?
This is what happens when you make up facts. 1/4 of 11 million BTC is not 1 million BTC.

If anybody was foolish to dump 1M+ BTC he would get nothing for his efforts since the price would collapse long before he had sold a significant number.

Does not answer 1 single question
You actually have to read it. You would have found that Bitcoin 0.1 was released 1 week after the establishment of the Genesis block. That doesn't leave much time to personally acquire 1 million+ BTC (and even if it was possible, it was worth nothing).

The very top of the pyramid scheme.
Yet another "I think bitcoin is bad therefore I will call it a pyramid scheme" poster appears on this forum.
 
You got that wrong. They say "Bitcoin shows some characteristics of a pyramid scheme, so I will call it one." That's a lot different. Not quite correct, really, but it's a lot better than your accustation would have it.
 
You got that wrong. They say "Bitcoin shows some characteristics of a pyramid scheme, so I will call it one." That's a lot different. Not quite correct, really, but it's a lot better than your accustation would have it.
No, I am right. "They say" that not because they have identified any characteristics of bitcoin that are similar to those of a pyramid scheme but because they think bitcoin or bitcoin exchanges are bad (it doesn't matter which to them).

It doesn't seem all that likely but even if MtGox is just a ponzi scheme instead of the brokerage firm it purports to be, that still has nothing to do with bitcoin itself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom