How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bitcoin operates in an unregulated environment where the government doesn't protect people from their own stupidity. Anybody who thinks he can make money by dealing with MtGox in Bitcoin in spite of its recent negative publicity deserves whatever he gets.

FTFY. also, what is the protection against people, say whoever is behind Satoshi Nakamoto, pulling a pump and dump and lying to people about the nature of BTC?

If it is an OpenSource technology, why are there so many secrets around it?
 
That's a lot of empathy you got there.

Seriously. Who cares if grandma's a little slow on the ball these days and gets a huge chunk of her savings scammed away from her in one swoop? She was obviously too stupid to handle Magical Internet Money!
 
Unbelievable! After all this time there are still posters who can't distinguish between a bitcoin and a bitcoin exchange.

also, what is the protection against people, say whoever is behind Satoshi Nakamoto, pulling a pump and dump and lying to people about the nature of BTC?
If you seriously believe that it is possible to write open source software but include secrets that fool every single programmer in the whole world then you have a lot to learn about "open source".

If it is an OpenSource technology, why are there so many secrets around it?
There are only secrets to those who don't understand software and have never bothered to learn anything about bitcoin.
 
Seriously. Who cares if grandma's a little slow on the ball these days and gets a huge chunk of her savings scammed away from her in one swoop? She was obviously too stupid to handle Magical Internet Money!
I never knew your objection to bitcoin was based on grandmothers who might be "a little slow on the ball these days".

You have certainly never shown the same sort of sympathy to grandmothers who get scammed when using regular currency.
 
Last edited:
I never knew your objection to bitcoin was based on grandmothers who might be "a little slow on the ball these days".

One of my objections. Careful burning down these strawmen, you might hurt yourself.

You have certainly never shown the same sort of sympathy to grandmothers who get scammed when using regular currency.
[citation needed]

At what point have we been discussing grandmothers who get scammed using USD, and I displayed a lack of sympathy? Quotes now, or you'll be caught lying again, as well as committing tu quoque.

However, I am certainly less _concerned_ about Grandma getting scammed via USD. Not because she won't be targeted -- she will -- but because in many cases, the fraud is reversible and the money can be restored, especially if it was done over credit card. It's also still a lot easier to trace dollars than it is Bitcoin, and there's this whole set of laws and restrictions that actually make it _illegal_ to scam people with USD. Can you explain to me what part of the US judicial code makes it illegal to scam people out of their Bitcoins?

You keep trying to compare Bitcoin's security to USD, but you make the same mistake so many others do -- Bitcoin's equivalence is _cash_, which is only a single (and declining) form of USD. It's easy to teach Grandma to avoid the majority of USD scams -- tell her to never use cash or a money order for anything, ever. Not so clear with Bitcoin, though, since there's no reversibility... oh right, we've brought this up a bunch of times before and it got ignored then too. Unsinkable rubber duckie, man.

I haven't used cash more than 12 times in the past year, at most; I carry $20 on a random off-chance I happen to be in one of the few obscure places that doesn't accept credit/debit. I don't expect to use cash as many as 12 times in this coming year. I would recommend to Grandma the same thing.
 
If it was a currency why would you even need an exchange? I thought the whole point was to make transfering value easier and now you have all the same issues of value transfer in bitcoin.
The only thing that is certain (unless you make an "end of the internet" argument) is that you can transfer bitcoins from your wallet to another wallet and have the amount transferred and the two wallet ids recorded publicly.

Nothing else is guaranteed.

Of course, the fact that many people pay fortunes for bitcoin mining software or pay $100s for a single bitcoin suggest that many believe it has value now or has potential in the future.
 
Can you explain to me what part of the US judicial code makes it illegal to scam people out of their Bitcoins?
And to think that I thought you were reaching when you started shedding crocodile tears for grandmothers. Of course, emotional appeals are often effective against uncritical thinkers - even when based on faulty logic.

However, if you think that the laws relating to contracts exclude barter or bitcoins then you are the one who needs to scour the law books.
 
And to think that I thought you were reaching when you started shedding crocodile tears for grandmothers. .

So that's an admission that you were lying, then? Because I don't see any citations from you to support that ad hominem attack -- no surprise there.

However, if you think that the laws relating to contracts exclude barter or bitcoins then you are the one who needs to scour the law books.
I challenged you to provide a citation, not to try to shift the burden of proof.

Can you tell me who I should call if someone steals my Bitcoin?
What if someone sells me a stereo for Bitcoin and it doesn't work?
Who will do the investigating?
What are the appropriate sets of laws this is handled under?
Is it a currency? A commodity?
What prices are appropriate to determine penalties, time of theft or time of prosecution?
Where is all this laid out clearly? A court of law is going to want to know this sort of thing.

Unless your fraud directly involves USD in some way, guess what agencies aren't going to care about your Bitcoins vanishing because you traded them for some magic beans? Go on. Guess.

For that matter, you can already get that level of indifference today -- just try to go to the police and say "I paid a man on the street $100 cash for a stereo he said was fine, and I got it home and it wasn't working." and see how far _that_ gets you.
 
Aaaaaand... back down to $620.

This -- the spike is too fast and too sharp. Anyone purchasing Bitcoin right now without the intent of immediately getting out on short-term gains is an idiot, plain and simple. Even the ones who think they'll buy at $1000 and sell at $1100 are fools. I will admit that this current influx of idiots has definitely 'saved' the original idiots who bought in at $200, but this pattern is historically classic and it's just a matter of guessing when the crash comes now, and where Bitcoin will land when it stops.

I'll just leave this here. At this point, the people who bought at $1000 and above have either bailed and cut their losses or are drinking heavily and hoping that any good news shows up sometime soon.

me said:
This commodity is currently based on nothing and, most importantly, has nothing backing it to guarantee its value. What's going to happen the first time someone can't get their money back out of Bitcoin? :D

We have an answer to this now, just by looking at how Mt. Gox. is doing.
 
So that's an admission that you were lying, then?
LOL the way you carry on it's as if you never mentioned grandmothers.

I challenged you to provide a citation, not to try to shift the burden of proof.
You made the claim (that bitcoin is excluded from laws) so the burden is on you to prove it.

Otherwise, I could say that the moon is made out of green cheese and the burden is on you to prove it isn't.
 
LOL the way you carry on it's as if you never mentioned grandmothers.

Your admission of lying is accepted; of course, this isn't anything new since you usually respond to your own strawmen, rather than what people actually say. You now need to admit an additional lie of yours:

You made the claim (that bitcoin is excluded from laws) so the burden is on you to prove it.
me said:
Can you explain to me what part of the US judicial code makes it illegal to scam people out of their Bitcoins?

As you can see, this is not a claim -- I asked a question. You made a counterassertion, and I challenged you to back it up. I also asked a number of material questions, which you avoided answering by repeating your earlier lie. Here they are again:

Can you tell me who I should call if someone steals my Bitcoin?
What if someone sells me a stereo for Bitcoin and it doesn't work?
Who will do the investigating?
What are the appropriate sets of laws this is handled under?
Is it a currency? A commodity?
What prices are appropriate to determine penalties, time of theft or time of prosecution?
Where is all this laid out clearly? A court of law is going to want to know this sort of thing.
Is it theft? Fraud? Neither?

I don't know the answers to these questions, and I seriously doubt that some of them even _have_ answers right now. If you don't even know where to begin answering these questions, then I would say that your assertion that Bitcoin transactions are somehow protected under either currency or contract laws greatly falls short of the practical reality.

If I send a business a check for an item and they don't send me the item but claim they did, I can go to my bank and stop payment on that check. If someone breaks into a bank and empties the safe-deposit boxes, the police will chase him down and arrest him. Who's doing that for Bitcoin? What's the equivalent? If Bitcoin can't make at least the basic concepts of this understandable to an elderly grandmother... of which we have rather a lot in the USA..., then Bitcoin is doomed to its speculative Internet-gambling status, its legacy likely to only be the underlying technology created to support it.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom