Sure you are trying to mock me. I didn't make a prediction, I made a comment and I didn't even make a guess. You haven't shown anything other than you are attempting to paint a picture of me making some kind of claim which I didn't. Where did I say the feds were trying to push the price down? I said IF THEY WERE. I didn't even say I guessed they were, that is you fishing for some kind of way to discredit the technical indicators.
I made no guess. I will let you know when I do. I think you should note that I guessed the top within a few hours of it being the top. I also correctly guessed on the collapse of bitcoin and set a fairly successful range of price targets for it to achieve, which it did. All that using technical analysis to inform my guesses.
Cherry picking out only your correct guesses is not how it works. You've got to add up ALL your guesses to see if your system is actually worth anything.
What is so amusing to me is that on investing sites when I suggest that good trading is about guessing right I am derided because everyone knows systems will work because blah, blah, blah. Here I have you deriding me because I am suggesting that technical indicators are a tool to aid in "guessing" right. Not sure why "guess" needs quotes.
I put “guess” into quotations because I was trying to use the word the same way you did, which apparently is differently from how the word is defined.
guess**(gĕs)
v.*guessed,*guess·ing,*guess·es
v.tr.
1.
a.*To predict (a result or an event) without sufficient information.
b.*To assume, presume, or assert (a fact) without sufficient information.
However, you said:
Like I said, the indicators are about guessing right, not predicting.
Now, what you said before, which you now say is not a guess, was
All this is happening at the most opportune time in the technical situation if you want to knock the price down. I know people here don't believe that technical analysis is meaningful but that doesn't mean it isn't. The fact is, I find it quite interesting that each of these govt sponsored announcements is timed when the technical indicators are at a critical point. The 2hr 50ma just crossed the 200ma last night and the daily close yesterday was under the 50dma. So this is the perfect time to attack the price because traders that do pay attention to technical indicators may sell and thus simply make the technical story into a self-reinforcing self-fulfilling predictor.
I do not believe it is unreasonable to think that someone could read your statement and think that it meant that you believed that the Fed intentionally made their statements at that time to intentionally influence the bitcoin price downward. I have no doubt whatsoever that if the price had gone down, you would be pointing back to that statement, say “See? I told you so!”.
However, not only did the announcements not cause a panic sell among technical traders, the price has barely moved for over a week.
Therefore:
What you thought was a critical point was not actually a critical point at all.
And other technical traders do not follow the same rules as you, and you are not as able to predict their behavior as you thought.
OR
There are other factors affecting the price of bitcoin, strong enough to overcome even critical points, or the rules that technical traders follow, that you do not understand.
EITHER WAY, it means that your technical analysis was useless there. You guessed wrong.
BTW, bitcoin is currently down 35% from it's high of late November, that qualifies as a crash. I tried to start a bitcoin crash thread where we could be discussing this back when bitcoin was at it's highs. That was merged back into this thread. I am still looking for bitcoin to hit 150 before it makes new highs. TWT and that is a guess you can hang on to.
Just want to make sure we're clear on what you're saying here.
I understand this to mean that bitcoin must drop to 150 before it reaches above 1163. If it does so, you will have “guessed right”.
If bitcoin reaches above 1163 without having dropped to 150, you will be wrong.
Is that correct?
Edited to add: I am/was using the numbers from BitStamp found here:
http://thegenesisblock.com/markets/ . Is there a different exchange or chart you would rather use?