How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because those old-fashioned fiat currencies that are due to collapse any moment now are still working. I am aware that imminent fiat collapse is not one of your arguments, meg. :)

The USD's value has plummeted 95% since its inception, by conservative measures. How does that not qualify as a collapse?
 
Teetering at $800 tonight on Bitstamp. Seems to be a heavily defended level.
 
The USD's value has plummeted 95% since its inception, by conservative measures. How does that not qualify as a collapse?

Assuming I've done the arithmetic right (always open to question), you're saying that we've averaged 1.4 percent inflation per year. That's probably not what most folks think of as a collapse.

Say the dollar's been around 220 years. Then
0.05 = (1+r)^ -220, r=0.0137, no?
 
Say the dollar's been around 220 years. Then
0.05 = (1+r)^ -220, r=0.0137, no?
I think Tippit is referring to the inception of the Fed in 1913 (a 100 year span which gives an inflation rate of 3%) or the end of the gold standard in 1933 (an 80 year span which gives an inflation rate of 3.8%).
 
I think Tippit is referring to the inception of the Fed in 1913 (a 100 year span which gives an inflation rate of 3%) or the end of the gold standard in 1933 (an 80 year span which gives an inflation rate of 3.8%).

Probably right. The large part of that inflation being in the 70s and early 80s, inflation having been much tamer for the last 20 years or so.
 
Teetering at $800 tonight on Bitstamp. Seems to be a heavily defended level.

How could this be, wrs? The technical indicators were at a critical point last week. The 2hr 50ma crossed the 200ma and the daily close was under the 50dma on Jan 16. A critical point!

Is this what all those technical indicators were technically indicating? That the price would pretty much just critically and pointedly hover in the same area for several more days?
 
How could this be, wrs? The technical indicators were at a critical point last week. The 2hr 50ma crossed the 200ma and the daily close was under the 50dma on Jan 16. A critical point!

The negative cross on the 2hr chart has been maintained and the price tested the 200ma from below and failed. Price managed to move back above the 50dma but not by much. Last night it fell back below the 50dma.


Is this what all those technical indicators were technically indicating? That the price would pretty much just critically and pointedly hover in the same area for several more days?

What they indicated was that price wasn't bullish and that if someone wanted to try and push it down, the time was right. In any case, 800 seems to be the level for bulls vs bears now. It has been support for a while but now that the price is under, it should probably become resistance.

Like I said, the indicators are about guessing right, not predicting. If you want to keep mocking me, feel free. Doesn't bother me a bit because I am not trading bitcoin, I am just an interested bystander.

Here is the chart though.
 

Attachments

  • meg800.jpg
    meg800.jpg
    27 KB · Views: 13
  • meg800a.jpg
    meg800a.jpg
    18.7 KB · Views: 10
Last edited:
The negative cross on the 2hr chart has been maintained and the price tested the 200ma from below and failed. Price managed to move back above the 50dma but not by much. Last night it fell back below the 50dma.

What they indicated was that price wasn't bullish and that if someone wanted to try and push it down, the time was right. In any case, 800 seems to be the level for bulls vs bears now. It has been support for a while but now that the price is under, it should probably become resistance.

Like I said, the indicators are about guessing right, not predicting. If you want to keep mocking me, feel free. Doesn't bother me a bit because I am not trading bitcoin, I am just an interested bystander.

Here is the chart though.

Your TA led you to “guess” that the feds were trying to push the price down at exactly the right time to push the price down. The price, however, has remained fairly steady.

How successful was your “guess”? Did your indicators lead you to “guess right”?

I'm not trying to mock you. I'm trying to get you to see that your indicators are no more useful than tarot cards.
 
Your TA led you to “guess” that the feds were trying to push the price down at exactly the right time to push the price down. The price, however, has remained fairly steady.

How successful was your “guess”? Did your indicators lead you to “guess right”?

I'm not trying to mock you. I'm trying to get you to see that your indicators are no more useful than tarot cards.

Sure you are trying to mock me. I didn't make a prediction, I made a comment and I didn't even make a guess. You haven't shown anything other than you are attempting to paint a picture of me making some kind of claim which I didn't. Where did I say the feds were trying to push the price down? I said IF THEY WERE. I didn't even say I guessed they were, that is you fishing for some kind of way to discredit the technical indicators.

I made no guess. I will let you know when I do. I think you should note that I guessed the top within a few hours of it being the top. I also correctly guessed on the collapse of bitcoin and set a fairly successful range of price targets for it to achieve, which it did. All that using technical analysis to inform my guesses.

What is so amusing to me is that on investing sites when I suggest that good trading is about guessing right I am derided because everyone knows systems will work because blah, blah, blah. Here I have you deriding me because I am suggesting that technical indicators are a tool to aid in "guessing" right. Not sure why "guess" needs quotes.

BTW, bitcoin is currently down 35% from it's high of late November, that qualifies as a crash. I tried to start a bitcoin crash thread where we could be discussing this back when bitcoin was at it's highs. That was merged back into this thread. I am still looking for bitcoin to hit 150 before it makes new highs. TWT and that is a guess you can hang on to.
 
Sure you are trying to mock me. I didn't make a prediction, I made a comment and I didn't even make a guess. You haven't shown anything other than you are attempting to paint a picture of me making some kind of claim which I didn't. Where did I say the feds were trying to push the price down? I said IF THEY WERE. I didn't even say I guessed they were, that is you fishing for some kind of way to discredit the technical indicators.

I made no guess. I will let you know when I do. I think you should note that I guessed the top within a few hours of it being the top. I also correctly guessed on the collapse of bitcoin and set a fairly successful range of price targets for it to achieve, which it did. All that using technical analysis to inform my guesses.

Cherry picking out only your correct guesses is not how it works. You've got to add up ALL your guesses to see if your system is actually worth anything.

What is so amusing to me is that on investing sites when I suggest that good trading is about guessing right I am derided because everyone knows systems will work because blah, blah, blah. Here I have you deriding me because I am suggesting that technical indicators are a tool to aid in "guessing" right. Not sure why "guess" needs quotes.

I put “guess” into quotations because I was trying to use the word the same way you did, which apparently is differently from how the word is defined.
guess**(gĕs)
v.*guessed,*guess·ing,*guess·es
v.tr.
1.
a.*To predict (a result or an event) without sufficient information.
b.*To assume, presume, or assert (a fact) without sufficient information.

However, you said:
Like I said, the indicators are about guessing right, not predicting.


Now, what you said before, which you now say is not a guess, was
All this is happening at the most opportune time in the technical situation if you want to knock the price down. I know people here don't believe that technical analysis is meaningful but that doesn't mean it isn't. The fact is, I find it quite interesting that each of these govt sponsored announcements is timed when the technical indicators are at a critical point. The 2hr 50ma just crossed the 200ma last night and the daily close yesterday was under the 50dma. So this is the perfect time to attack the price because traders that do pay attention to technical indicators may sell and thus simply make the technical story into a self-reinforcing self-fulfilling predictor.

I do not believe it is unreasonable to think that someone could read your statement and think that it meant that you believed that the Fed intentionally made their statements at that time to intentionally influence the bitcoin price downward. I have no doubt whatsoever that if the price had gone down, you would be pointing back to that statement, say “See? I told you so!”.

However, not only did the announcements not cause a panic sell among technical traders, the price has barely moved for over a week.

Therefore:

What you thought was a critical point was not actually a critical point at all.
And other technical traders do not follow the same rules as you, and you are not as able to predict their behavior as you thought.

OR

There are other factors affecting the price of bitcoin, strong enough to overcome even critical points, or the rules that technical traders follow, that you do not understand.

EITHER WAY, it means that your technical analysis was useless there. You guessed wrong.

BTW, bitcoin is currently down 35% from it's high of late November, that qualifies as a crash. I tried to start a bitcoin crash thread where we could be discussing this back when bitcoin was at it's highs. That was merged back into this thread. I am still looking for bitcoin to hit 150 before it makes new highs. TWT and that is a guess you can hang on to.

Just want to make sure we're clear on what you're saying here.

I understand this to mean that bitcoin must drop to 150 before it reaches above 1163. If it does so, you will have “guessed right”.

If bitcoin reaches above 1163 without having dropped to 150, you will be wrong.

Is that correct?

Edited to add: I am/was using the numbers from BitStamp found here: http://thegenesisblock.com/markets/ . Is there a different exchange or chart you would rather use?
 
Last edited:
Cherry picking out only your correct guesses is not how it works. You've got to add up ALL your guesses to see if your system is actually worth anything.

You will need to come up with all my guesses that you claim are guesses then. Like I said repeatedly, I have posted some charts and made some comments.


I put “guess” into quotations because I was trying to use the word the same way you did, which apparently is differently from how the word is defined.

Yes, try not cherry picking your definition of guess.

guess

verb
1.
estimate or suppose (something) without sufficient information to be sure of being correct.

noun: guess; plural noun: guesses
1.
an estimate or conjecture.

So with technical analysis, I am adding information to inform my guess. I still don't have that crystal ball that will allow me to predict with certainty, therefore I am guessing. I am simply trying to be correct when stating what I am doing, I am making a prediction without sufficient information to be certain of being correct. However, the technical info may help me to be correct more often.

What is your exact problem with any of that? Why the hostility? I am not trying to sell you on anything.

I do not believe it is unreasonable to think that someone could read your statement and think that it meant that you believed that the Fed intentionally made their statements at that time to intentionally influence the bitcoin price downward. I have no doubt whatsoever that if the price had gone down, you would be pointing back to that statement, say “See? I told you so!”.

Actually go look at the announcement and the price action. It dropped about 10% as a result of the announcement. From around 847 to 765.


However, not only did the announcements not cause a panic sell among technical traders, the price has barely moved for over a week.

Therefore:

What you thought was a critical point was not actually a critical point at all.
And other technical traders do not follow the same rules as you, and you are not as able to predict their behavior as you thought.

I didn't say it would cause panic selling, only that it could reinforce traders to sell based on the negative cross. IT was a critical point because in a bullish market the 50 will bounce off the 200 and price will move higher. In a bearish market, the 50 will drop through the 200 and produce a negative cross. It did that as a result of the announcement (the price dropped to 765 after the announcement from 847 prior to it) and it seems that it has cemented the downward trend. The price has not exceeded the price prior to the announcemnt. The trend in the 2hr is now down. If that holds long enough, the trend in the daily will change to down and that is when the heavier selling begins.

This stuff takes time to play out. It took the 2hr a long time to roll over and that is what must happen to get price trending down.
OR

There are other factors affecting the price of bitcoin, strong enough to overcome even critical points, or the rules that technical traders follow, that you do not understand.

EITHER WAY, it means that your technical analysis was useless there. You guessed wrong.

The technical analysis wasn't useless at all. The negative cross remains in place, the trend is now down on the 2hr. Anyway, as I said, I didn't guess, it's only you claiming I did. Anyway, what makes you think if I am guessing that I will always be right? I only have to be right enough to make money on the trades I place. Lot's of people guess right and still lose money because they fail to take a profit.

Just want to make sure we're clear on what you're saying here.

I understand this to mean that bitcoin must drop to 150 before it reaches above 1163. If it does so, you will have “guessed right”.

If bitcoin reaches above 1163 without having dropped to 150, you will be wrong.

Is that correct?

I have already made this guess earlier on the thread. I will reiterate it but why should I care if it turns out wrong, it's a guess, not a prediction of certainty.


Edited to add: I am/was using the numbers from BitStamp found here: http://thegenesisblock.com/markets/ . Is there a different exchange or chart you would rather use?

Nope, bitstamp is fine. I will say also that I don't think MtGox is going to get above 1242 before any exchange price hits 150.
 
Is imminent fiat collapse anyone's argument? Who are you arguing with?

That was (one of) MichaelSuede's argument (s). You know, the guy who started this thread.

BTW:
I'm getting first-hand experience of this crypto stuff. I'm in the Dogecoin system. The mining pool I'm with was just attacked. Apparently there was no damage. But it isn't even a large pool. I don't think this stuff is safe enough to use as a real currency yet.
 
Last edited:
BTW:
I'm getting first-hand experience of this crypto stuff. I'm in the Dogecoin system. The mining pool I'm with was just attacked. Apparently there was no damage. But it isn't even a large pool. I don't think this stuff is safe enough to use as a real currency yet.

So vulnerability! Much hack!
 
That was (one of) MichaelSuede's argument (s). You know, the guy who started this thread.

Ah. Thank you. I thought he left in 2012.

I've thought about starting another thread about bitcoin, just to try to avoid the whole guilt by association thing, but I figured the mods would probably just merge it into this one anyway, so why bother.

BTW:
I'm getting first-hand experience of this crypto stuff. I'm in the Dogecoin system. The mining pool I'm with was just attacked. Apparently there was no damage. But it isn't even a large pool. I don't think this stuff is safe enough to use as a real currency yet.

Glad to hear there's another miner here. :) Also glad to hear you were unharmed by the hackers. Of all the cryptocurrencies, I find dogecoin the most interesting. Mostly because of the light hearted humor of the thing. And it seems like the dogepeople are the first ones to really be trying the whole micropayments idea, by happily spending small amounts of coins as “tips” for a good answer to a forum question, or as a “thank you” for an informative article somewhere, etc.

I wonder if that's where we are headed in the future. Away from content subscriptions and toward micropayments for each small bit of the internet that you use. It's interesting to watch this develop on the dogecoin forums. I was tickled to see people pulling together to reimburse folks that lost a bunch of coins in a hack last month. ( http://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/dogecoin-dogewallet-hack-save-dogemas/ )

It will be interesting to see if something that started as such a silly bit of fun can turn into something with real value, simply because enough people like it and enjoy using it.
 
That was (one of) MichaelSuede's argument (s). You know, the guy who started this thread.
That's what it is all about. The merits or otherwise of bitcoin or its clones is completely irrelevant.

All that matters is who writes in favour of it and who writes against it and which side you are going to take regardless of the validity of any of the arguments offered.
 
That was (one of) MichaelSuede's argument (s). You know, the guy who started this thread.

And mhaze (good riddance to bad rubbish), and Tippit. There are some others who pass through but those were the only three "fiat is dying" fantasists that immediately spring to mind.

Bitcoin's utility or lack thereof will have next-to-zero impact on fiat currencies, because for it (or any other digital payment system) to become commonly used, it's going to have to be pegged to an actual currency somewhere along the way. Right now we have payment processors (Bitpay, Coinbase) who are assuming the risk themselves of holding Bitcoin, but there's quite a bit of risk involved.

...Alternately, if you think of it a _different_, slightly more cynical way, there's almost no risk at all. Set up payment processor with angel/venture capital, skim as much as you can on transaction fees/membership fees off the top, and if Bitcoin crashes enough that you take a big hit, you've still got everything you've collected that _wasn't_ Bitcoin. You'd be rapidly converting BTC to USBGBPEURRMB all the while, of course, because you can't afford to _yourself_ get caught short on ability to push out money... but depending on how fast you moved the shells, you could keep it up for quite a long time and all that time you're collecting fees. Be sure you don't mix the fee pile and the funding pile though.

I've thought about starting another thread about bitcoin, just to try to avoid the whole guilt by association thing, but I figured the mods would probably just merge it into this one anyway, so why bother.

Dunno. You might be able to do it, to be honest -- the title of this one has really run its course as far as getting the OP beat up for ludicrous hyperbole, even long after he's vanished. Also, two of the three anti-fiat souls are gone, so you can probably manage to get everyone else to focus on actually discussing Bitcoin rather than quibbling over doomsday predictions and wading through reams of donkey-like braying (one particular poster comes to mind).

If you tried something such as "Practical future uses of Bitcoin" you could manage to peel off the day-to-day speculative stuff, perhaps. That could stay here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom