How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
But isn't that the case with all new technologies or investments? That the early adopters/investors have the potential to reap the highest rewards? My uncle invested in Xerox in the 1960s and made quite a bundle. I really don't see much difference. The early adopters also took the most risk, dedicating their own computers and network time and personal time to work the bugs out of the system and to create coins that might have turned out to be completely worthless.

I don't consider this a complete response, because I never objected to early adopters having an advantage. I'm referring to the founding adopters possibly having an overwhelming and persistent advantage. "Cornering the market" as I said, is not just having an advantage, such as being the first to own a patent.
 
True Identity of Bitcoin Founders Revealed

I don't consider this a complete response, because I never objected to early adopters having an advantage. I'm referring to the founding adopters possibly having an overwhelming and persistent advantage. "Cornering the market" as I said, is not just having an advantage, such as being the first to own a patent.

trading-place-bitcoin.jpg
 
I think if the govt is trying to have an impact on bitcoin, it will make announcements such as this when there is the best chance of causing the price to behave as the govt desires. I would think the govt wants the price of bitcoin to go down since it's viewed as a dollar alternative and thus, the lower the $ price, the less value bitcoin has.

Or perhaps the federal government was just following the law which requires that they file a judicial forfeiture action within 90 days of receiving an administrative claim.* The coins were seized Sept 30, 2013. While I do not know this is true, it is reasonable to assume that someone, (perhaps Ulbricht himself?) might have filed a claim to some of those bitcoins in October. The announcement hit the news within 24 hours of the forfeiture being signed by a judge, so obviously the “announcement” was not timed.

The 2hr 50ma just crossed the 200ma last night and the daily close yesterday was under the 50dma.

How many times has this happened in the history of bitcoin, wrs? Is this some kind of once in a lifetime happening? Or has it happened multiple times? Can you show us where this has happened in the past and what the result was?

What I find pretty unbelievable is that the federal government, given all the various things they could or might do to negatively affect the bitcoin market, would choose something only certain traders would be spooked by AND that they would choose to make the price of bitcoins drop significantly with their first sale of 30k forfeited bitcoins, while they still have 144k in storage they will need to liquidate later.


*IANAL, and I don't understand all this stuff.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/983
 
There are a lot of legal questions surrounding bitcoin, so I would imagine that they are auctioning them off in the chunks that they found them so those questions can be dealt with as they arise.
 
Hmm I am just wondering if bitcoin is demonstrating the problems of a highly deflating currency. It isn't being used because people don't want to spend it and view the currency as an investment.
 
I don't consider this a complete response, because I never objected to early adopters having an advantage. I'm referring to the founding adopters possibly having an overwhelming and persistent advantage.
Does that even mean anything?

ETA I notice you never acknowledged my rebuttal to this claim in post #4100. It is a common trick in this forum to pretend a rebuttal never occurred then repeat your original claim.
 
Last edited:
I don't consider this a complete response, because I never objected to early adopters having an advantage. I'm referring to the founding adopters possibly having an overwhelming and persistent advantage. "Cornering the market" as I said, is not just having an advantage, such as being the first to own a patent.


Well, other than possibly having lots of coins, exactly what do you think these founding adopters might be doing, or planning to persistently do?

You or others have already shown that it is a concern in other markets when one person owns 4% or more of a stock, so I understand now that you might be concerned that some one person may try to tank the price by dumping all their coins at once.

Is there something else are you worried about? You (I think it was you) brought up the De Beers, however the De Beers achieved their monopoly by buying up diamonds and mines and coercing small mines to join their consortium. They effectively controlled 90% of the world supply of diamonds.

Bitcoin miners have grown exponentially, and the supply of bitcoins is growing at a steady rate, the early adopters do not control the supply of bitcoins. Nor does their alleged early hoard of bitcoins limit other people from buying bitcoins or mining bitcoins or selling their bitcoins. Bitcoins are divisible to .00000001. Bitcoins are not rare or difficult to get. As a matter of fact, it gets easier to buy them every day.

There are no corporate boards that they can attempt to control. Nor can they use their stock of coins to somehow control the “management” of bitcoins, obviously, because bitcoin is not a company.

Having a large pile of bitcoins does not give you any influence over other coins or other coin holders.

What exactly do you mean by “cornering the market”?
 
There are a lot of legal questions surrounding bitcoin, so I would imagine that they are auctioning them off in the chunks that they found them so those questions can be dealt with as they arise.

Do you really think that the United States Federal Government does not know the answers to "legal questions" surrounding bitcoin?

Do you really think that the United States Federal Government does anything with a "Oh, we'll just deal with questions as they come up." kind of attitude?
 
Hmm I am just wondering if bitcoin is demonstrating the problems of a highly deflating currency. It isn't being used because people don't want to spend it and view the currency as an investment.

The transaction volume has more than tripled in the last three months. And merchants transactions reported by services like Coinbase or Bitpay are climbing at a rate of 150% or higher every month.

How does this translate into “it isn't being used” or “people don't want to spend it”?
 
Bitcoin: Boom or Bubble?

The baffling Bitcoin boom is either an exercise in self-delusion -- a high-tech Ponzi scheme that will come crashing down -- or an imaginative new Internet technology that will ultimately change how millions of people around the world conduct everyday business. There is little middle ground.

The author is biased, as the opening paragraph indicates with its polarizing and somewhat inflammatory tone, but the comments section contains some worthwhile discussion. Someone points out the inherent problem of limited-by-design quantity of Bitcoin, another one says that transaction costs will rise if the payment method is more widely adopted. Food for thought.
 
Last edited:
Tried with two different browsers, but I seem to be unable to see the comments. I keep getting a "Disqus seems to be taking longer than usual. Reload?" error.

Any particular comment(s) you'd like to discuss more here?
 
And what a pain to have to convert your Bitcoin to real currency just to do basic day-to-day transactions. It will also get expensive. Every conversion carries a transaction cost. Currently, there is essentially no fee because of the way the program incentivizes mining, but because of the limit, that free ride is going to end -- after all, the network will still have to be secured.

The price for maintaining that security will be transaction and conversion fees, until it hits some sort of equilibrium between the cost of security and competition from traditional currencies. At that point, what will make Bitcoin special? It's just another currency.

From the comments section of the linked article
 
And what a pain to have to convert your Bitcoin to real currency just to do basic day-to-day transactions. It will also get expensive. Every conversion carries a transaction cost. Currently, there is essentially no fee because of the way the program incentivizes mining, but because of the limit, that free ride is going to end -- after all, the network will still have to be secured.

The price for maintaining that security will be transaction and conversion fees, until it hits some sort of equilibrium between the cost of security and competition from traditional currencies. At that point, what will make Bitcoin special? It's just another currency.
From the comments section of the linked article

This person appears to not be able to understand the difference between what miners do (verify transactions and maintain the blockchain) and what exchanges do (change bitcoins into other currencies for a fee).

So..

1. As bitcoin becomes more popular and adopted more widely, the need to convert bitcoin into other currencies diminishes. If one receives bitcoins, one could simply turn around and spend the bitcoins on whatever it is they need or want, rather than convert it to dollars to buy what they need or want.
2. Miners do have a transaction fee now, it is just voluntary. However even now, those people that voluntarily pay a miner fee get their transactions verified faster. Yes, it is likely that as the reward for mining diminishes, transaction fees will climb. What will that eventual fee be? I don't know. I have read estimates that 1% is likely.

Every credit or debit card transaction now also has a cost, much higher than 1%, however this author appears to be unaware of it because the cost is paid by the merchants.
 
The transaction volume has more than tripled in the last three months. And merchants transactions reported by services like Coinbase or Bitpay are climbing at a rate of 150% or higher every month.

How does this translate into “it isn't being used” or “people don't want to spend it”?

Considering the track record of claims in this thread, I wouldn't be surprised if something entirely else was meant by that. Maybe that bitcoin isn't being used as much as fiat currency.

"You can't get your bitcoins into real money" (or alternatively "they are stealing your monies!") means that one exchange has delays. "No vendor will accept bitcoin" means not enough vendors accept bitcoin, and "bitcoin is going to crash" means bitcoin is volatile. "Bitcoin is a ponzi scheme" means early miners are rich and that is not acceptable, "bitwhales are manipulating the market" means rich entities are selling and buying bitcoins to make profit (duh), and "bitcoin has no inherent value" means... well I'm not really sure.

You'd almost need a translator.
 
This person appears to not be able to understand the difference between what miners do (verify transactions and maintain the blockchain) and what exchanges do (change bitcoins into other currencies for a fee).

So..

1. As bitcoin becomes more popular and adopted more widely, the need to convert bitcoin into other currencies diminishes. If one receives bitcoins, one could simply turn around and spend the bitcoins on whatever it is they need or want, rather than convert it to dollars to buy what they need or want.
2. Miners do have a transaction fee now, it is just voluntary. However even now, those people that voluntarily pay a miner fee get their transactions verified faster. Yes, it is likely that as the reward for mining diminishes, transaction fees will climb. What will that eventual fee be? I don't know. I have read estimates that 1% is likely.

Every credit or debit card transaction now also has a cost, much higher than 1%, however this author appears to be unaware of it because the cost is paid by the merchants.

1. If that happened, Bitcoin would effectively be functioning as a currency, backed by an encrypted, distributed peer-to-peer network (if I understand correctly?) instead of the government of a particular country. I can't imagine those governments aren't going to intervene to somehow neutralize or co-opt the technology if it threatens their power.

2. The higher cost of credit and debit card processing is passed on to the consumer by the merchant, so who is really paying? Ultimately, the processing costs should achieve parity.

So far, I am in the camp that sees no compelling advantage to adopting Bitcoin as a payment processing system, beyond the novelty and appeal to a niche market.

And as an investment, here is where chart reading tells the story: recent parabolic move indicating a classic bubble likely to collapse, therefore extremely risky.
 
Interesting article here:

Bitcoin is not just digital currency. It's Napster for finance.
http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2014/01/21/bitcoin-platform/

The Bitcoin protocol (crucially distinct from bitcoin, the currency it underlies) was built from the ground up to support far more complex transactions and relationships than simple value transfers. (Example: "Send five bitcoins to Steve.") Some of the kinds of transactions that Bitcoin can support include so-called M of N transactions, which require agreement between a certain subset of a group, and can be used for escrow, mediation, or shared financial management; time-locked transactions, in which bitcoins are distributed on a strict schedule, useful for trusts or wills; and even data-conditional transactions, in which a script uses a data input such as a regular Google search to monitor real-world events that would automatically trigger disbursements or other actions. More conditional on infrastructure development is the possibility of "smart property," with contracts enforced by digital locks interacting with the Bitcoin blockchain to manage real-world leases, mortgages, and purchase contracts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom