How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Where is Napster now?

Cute quick snarky reply.

If you actually read the article, and have understood the discussions in this thread, you might realize that where Napster is now is not relevant.

The music industry business model was changed immeasurably by direct file sharing.

The financial industry is in for a similar upheaval from peer to peer value transactions.
 
Cute quick snarky reply.

If you actually read the article, and have understood the discussions in this thread, you might realize that where Napster is now is not relevant.

The music industry business model was changed immeasurably by direct file sharing.

The financial industry is in for a similar upheaval from peer to peer value transactions.

Where are Netscape and AOL now? It's not a snarky response. If bitcoin follows the path of Napster, it will be worthless while something else will be making the money. It's not always best to be first unless you can stay there. Obviously Napster couldn't do it nor did AOL and Netscape.
 
1. If that happened, Bitcoin would effectively be functioning as a currency, backed by an encrypted, distributed peer-to-peer network (if I understand correctly?) instead of the government of a particular country.

By Jove, I think you've got it :)

It is interesting, (is it not?) that all that needs to happen for bitcoin to start functioning as a currency, is for enough merchants to adopt it as a payment system. If you can buy the same goods or services in bitcoin that you would buy with dollars, why would you convert any received bitcoins to dollars in order to spend them?

I can't imagine those governments aren't going to intervene to somehow neutralize or co-opt the technology if it threatens their power.

Well, that might be the start of a very interesting discussion. What do you think those governments are capable of doing? What do you think they might do? Will do? Is there any particular government you think is likely to make the first move? Do you think a federally backed digital currency might be on the horizon?

2. The higher cost of credit and debit card processing is passed on to the consumer by the merchant, so who is really paying? Ultimately, the processing costs should achieve parity.

What do you mean by achieve parity? Do you think credit card and other payment processors will lower their rates to compete with bitcoin transactions? Do you think bitcoin exchanges will raise their rates to similar to credit card and other payment processors?

So far, I am in the camp that sees no compelling advantage to adopting Bitcoin as a payment processing system, beyond the novelty and appeal to a niche market.

And as an investment, here is where chart reading tells the story: recent parabolic move indicating a classic bubble likely to collapse, therefore extremely risky.

I don't really care what “camp” anyone chooses to declare for themselves. I don't understand why so many people feel it's important to declare their “camp”. Is the first rule of “niche market with a bubble” camp that one must end every post with “I'm in the niche market with a bubble camp”? If bitcoin continues to grow in acceptance will you have to change to “I'm in the minor but growing market share camp”?

We're not in Politics over here, and bitcoin is not a proposed amendment for which the answer is “yea” or “nay”. Bitcoin is a technology that already exists and is evolving and growing and affecting other industries, completely oblivious and regardless to your camp or whatever your camp slogan may be.
 
Where are Netscape and AOL now? It's not a snarky response. If bitcoin follows the path of Napster, it will be worthless while something else will be making the money. It's not always best to be first unless you can stay there. Obviously Napster couldn't do it nor did AOL and Netscape.

You continue to miss the point of the analogy, which was about innovation and decentralization, not financial success. That doesn't even make any sense, unless you want to suggest that early innovators are all financially doomed. But even if you acknowledge the analogy from that perspective, at least you seem to agree that cryptocurrency has a strong future, just like p2p networking which Napster popularized. Even if bitcoin plummets. Maybe you are more partial to DogeCoin? NameCoin, FeatherCoin? I myself am more of a LiteCoin man.
 
You continue to miss the point of the analogy, which was about innovation and decentralization, not financial success. That doesn't even make any sense, unless you want to suggest that early innovators are all financially doomed. But even if you acknowledge the analogy from that perspective, at least you seem to agree that cryptocurrency has a strong future, just like p2p networking which Napster popularized. Even if bitcoin plummets. Maybe you are more partial to DogeCoin? NameCoin, FeatherCoin? I myself am more of a LiteCoin man.


I get the point but I am waiting to see how it plays out. Why bet on a horse that loses? Cryptocurrency needs to be proven to work first. So far it's too dependent on existing currency for it to succeed on it's own.
 
By Jove, I think you've got it :)

It is interesting, (is it not?) that all that needs to happen for bitcoin to start functioning as a currency, is for enough merchants to adopt it as a payment system. If you can buy the same goods or services in bitcoin that you would buy with dollars, why would you convert any received bitcoins to dollars in order to spend them?


That's a pretty big "if" at this time. I disagree "that all that needs to happen for bitcoin to start functioning as a currency, is for enough merchants to adopt it as a payment system." Unless and until Bitcoin's price stabilizes, it can't function as a viable currency. Are you saying that more merchants adopting it as a payment system will help the price to stabilize?


Well, that might be the start of a very interesting discussion. What do you think those governments are capable of doing? What do you think they might do? Will do? Is there any particular government you think is likely to make the first move? Do you think a federally backed digital currency might be on the horizon?

China has already taken steps to regulate it, as have Singapore, Denmark and Finland, and probably some others I've not heard about.

There is already a federally backed digital currency, the US dollar. I spend my digital US dollars every day by using my credit cards, and by digitally transferring dollars into and out of my financial accounts to receive payments, pay bills, invest in stocks, and set aside reserves for a rainy day. It remains to be seen whether bitcoin will develop into something with enough of a compelling advantage to displace government-backed currencies.


What do you mean by achieve parity? Do you think credit card and other payment processors will lower their rates to compete with bitcoin transactions? Do you think bitcoin exchanges will raise their rates to similar to credit card and other payment processors?

I don't know. Maybe the analogy of ebooks and digital music works here. The price of digital media has increased as it's become more widely adopted, putting pressure on the prices of print books and audio CDs.


I don't really care what “camp” anyone chooses to declare for themselves. I don't understand why so many people feel it's important to declare their “camp”. Is the first rule of “niche market with a bubble” camp that one must end every post with “I'm in the niche market with a bubble camp”? If bitcoin continues to grow in acceptance will you have to change to “I'm in the minor but growing market share camp”?

Probably. :)

We're not in Politics over here, and bitcoin is not a proposed amendment for which the answer is “yea” or “nay”. Bitcoin is a technology that already exists and is evolving and growing and affecting other industries, completely oblivious and regardless to your camp or whatever your camp slogan may be.

Politics will rear its head, won't it? We the people are hashing it out, so to speak, on Internet forums around the world. The Libertarians seem to be enamored of it for various reasons, other segments of society are intrigued by its underground uses, while still others envision a veritable revolution in economics being birthed before our eyes.

We certainly live in interesting times. ;)
 
; and even data-conditional transactions, in which a script uses a data input such as a regular Google search to monitor real-world events that would automatically trigger disbursements or other actions.

:eek:
This is starting to sound like a Philip K. Dick story, or a scene out of William Gibson's "Neuromancer."
 
I get the point but I am waiting to see how it plays out. Why bet on a horse that loses? Cryptocurrency needs to be proven to work first. So far it's too dependent on existing currency for it to succeed on it's own.

Ironically when it comes to transaction numbers from here the most currency like of the cryptocurrencies is DogeCoin.
 
That's a pretty big "if" at this time. I disagree "that all that needs to happen for bitcoin to start functioning as a currency, is for enough merchants to adopt it as a payment system." Unless and until Bitcoin's price stabilizes, it can't function as a viable currency. Are you saying that more merchants adopting it as a payment system will help the price to stabilize?

While I do believe that more merchants adopting bitcoin may have a stabilizing force on the price, I'm not certain that it will. And I used believe in that sentence intentionally, to differentiate it from think. I'm not sure why I believe that. It's more a vague hunch. Some kind of wibbley wobbley markety warkety sort of idea, rather than something I know.

What I guess I am wondering lately is if the “rules” might be different for a currency that is neither backed by any government, nor the only currency that any people anywhere must use. I am wondering if the only rule an optional currency must have is that it has to be useful to some people in some circumstances.

As an individual person, I have several payment tools available to me to use at my discretion. I can pay cash, write a check, use a debit card, use a number of different credit cards, get a money order, have money transferred directly out of one of my bank accounts, or more. When I lived for a short time near the Canadian border, I also kept a small amount of Canadian money on hand, because it was also useful to have in certain circumstances.

And each method has its own merits and problems. I make my decision as to which one to use based on a number of different factors. What the person I want to pay accepts, how much money I have in the bank, how many other bills I have to pay this week (using whatever method they require), whether I have cash on hand, how quickly I want to pay it off, what interest rate they charge, etc. There are a lot of different things we think about when we choose one method over another.

Bitcoin, is just another payment option that I have. If someone pays me in bitcoin and I turn around and spend those bitcoins to get something else that I want, I'm using it as a currency. If someone pays me in bitcoin and I turn around and exchange it into dollars, I'm using it as a payment method.

I think you sort of moved the goalpost when first you said that if people turned around and spent their received bitcoins rather than exchange them it would be functioning as a currency, but now you say “it can't function as a viable currency” unless the price stabilizes. Who says it has to be viable? It is not the single currency of any singular economy. It's an extra one. An option. A choice.

And I can see at least one circumstance in which the price volatility might actually encourage its use as a currency. If I receive a bitcoin when the exchange rate is $750/1btc, but the price rises next week to $1000/btc, the value of what's in my wallet just increased by 25%. So if I go shopping at Overstock.com, it's like I'm getting 25% off. Last week that $75 down comforter was .10btc. This week that $75 down comforter is .075btc. As the price of bitcoin is volatile, it behooves me, who was planning on buying that down comforter this week either way to go ahead and spend my bitcoins on it, rather than dollars.

Not only did I not need the price to be stable in order to spend the bitcoins, I was able to actually take advantage of the instability in my favor.

I grant you that if I had to use bitcoins all the time, it would be horrible for the price to be unstable, because it often would work against me. But I don't have to use bitcoins. I only use them when I choose to.
 
But I don't have to use bitcoins. I only use them when I choose to.

Because those old-fashioned fiat currencies that are due to collapse any moment now are still working. I am aware that imminent fiat collapse is not one of your arguments, meg. :)
 
Do you really think that the United States Federal Government does not know the answers to "legal questions" surrounding bitcoin?

Do you really think that the United States Federal Government does anything with a "Oh, we'll just deal with questions as they come up." kind of attitude?

The Federal Government is a large and complicated organization, of which the FBI is only one important part. Compound that with the nebulous legal status of bitcoin, and I imagine the FBI doesn't want to jump in with both feet.

It's also possible they are auctioning off this chunk now because it's not directly related to the investigation, and they'll hold onto the rest untilthe case is resolved.
 
Because those old-fashioned fiat currencies that are due to collapse any moment now are still working. I am aware that imminent fiat collapse is not one of your arguments, meg. :)

Is imminent fiat collapse anyone's argument? Who are you arguing with?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom