How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
His prediction range can be considered to be "the broad side of a barn". Yours would be comparable to "landing anywhere within sight of the barn". Regardless, it's the prediction you've made, and if BTC happens to end up at 1900 by the end of the day, it's inappropriate for me to say "Yeah, but I was only counting if it was close to 0, those high numbers weren't real."

It's a prediction like one a psychic makes: broad and easy to hit. Well, at least BTC didn't go up. Yet.

The MDC does not require claimants to demonstrate abilities they don't claim; if someone claims to be able to project words into others' heads, asking them to send a picture is not a fair test of their claim.

Yes but by the same analogy, the MDC doesn't test for mundane abilities.

When pressed, he made a formal prediction that covered a wide (but not horribly unreasonable given short-term history) range.

Yes, I support that's better than his previous refusal to make one, despite his repeated claims that BTC was on its way to a crash when it wasn't.

You cannot unilaterally change the criteria for a "hit" just because you don't like the probability of him achieving it.

Fine, then: I don't accept his prediction as precise enough, and discard it entirely.

Reiterating: if anyone had said "BTC will lose half its value by the end of the month", you'd have accepted that as a valid prediction.

Yes. That wasn't the prediction.
 
I'm rarely pissed. And I don't consider that you were right yet. Let's say I'll consider 250 USD to be a near-hit.

China already hit $331 and Bitstamp hit $382. I think this thing is really just picking up steam now. The same way it built on itself going up, it will collapse on the way down. I have until the end of the month for $150.
 
It's a prediction like one a psychic makes: broad and easy to hit. Well, at least BTC didn't go up. Yet.

Hardly, I called the top correctly and then gave you a good prediction which has already come true.


Yes, I support that's better than his previous refusal to make one, despite his repeated claims that BTC was on its way to a crash when it wasn't.

Please define crash because in most definitions, bitcoin has already crashed by losing over half it's value from the top.
 
Time for a little thought experiment.

A little over half of all possible bitcoins have been mined so far. Imagine those who currently hold those bitcoins just hold onto them until all bitcoins have been mined, and don't do any further mining. They just sit on their massively deflationary asset, which is the rational thing to do when you have a massively deflationary asset.

Now imagine that everyone, every single person on Earth, simultaneously decides to go with bitcoins for their transactions. Since the people holding the current half are just sitting on them, the rest of the world has to mine, distribute, and then use the remaining half of the bitcoins space, to run the world's economy.

Let's ignore the dollar-bitcoin or whatever conversion rate for the moment. Assume that by the time the bitcoins space is mined out, the entire world economy is being denominated entirely in bitcoins itself.

Now, at this point, the holders of the first half of the bitcoins supply wake up from their hibernation, and realize that their dream has come true: They own half of the ENTIRE WORLD'S money supply.

In this sense, bitcoin-bugs and goldbugs are pretty much hoping for the same thing. If their little pet boutique currency becomes a dominant currency, then the demand for the currency goes WAY up, making it massively deflationary even beyond the built-in deflationary nature bitcoins. They are hoping for everyone else to get suckered into the market they have already stockpiled.

This hasn't actually happened with bitcoins. If you think the bitcoins price trajectory has been stratospheric so far, imagine what it would look like if it were actually taken seriously and it turned into a real currency, thus requiring billions of people to buy into it, in order to have some to use as currency. Imagine what that kind of buying pressure would do to the dollar (or whatever) to bitcoins' conversion price.

It's the hope of roping in those billions of suckers that is keeping bitcoin-bugs warm at night.
 
The facts are slowly getting out there.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/markets/2013/12/18/bitcoin-price/4107831/

The article mentions that money put in a bitcoin exchange may never come out again.

Gee, I bet most bitbugs didn't realize that when calculating their wealth. So when you get down to it, the amount of cash in an exchange divided by the number of bitcoins stored there is really what the coins are worth. I suspect that is down around $10 or less. The smart bitbugs are selling now and demanding cash which just makes that $10 number sink even lower.
 
The facts are slowly getting out there.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/markets/2013/12/18/bitcoin-price/4107831/

The article mentions that money put in a bitcoin exchange may never come out again.

Gee, I bet most bitbugs didn't realize that when calculating their wealth. So when you get down to it, the amount of cash in an exchange divided by the number of bitcoins stored there is really what the coins are worth. I suspect that is down around $10 or less. The smart bitbugs are selling now and demanding cash which just makes that $10 number sink even lower.

I don't know alot about the mechanics of currency, but this sounds like a pyramid scheme. Of course, the Zero Hedge comedian types claim that all fiat money systems are such, so...
 
This prediction was made a couple of posts later. Was there anything wrong with it?
Well, if you want to be picky, that wasn't so much a prediction as a description - it had already started moving back down, so your call of top was merely "it won't keep going up from here." Hardly a trendline associated with it. But I don't really feel the need to be picky, as I wouldn't want to rob you of your only "hit."

More recently you predicted a drop to $500 last Monday, and that had triangles and lines and all sorts of things drawn on it. Was there anything wrong with that?

I would also ask you to provide the basis for what I have highlighted in your statement.
That would be this post, where you said so outright.
 
Last edited:
His prediction range can be considered to be "the broad side of a barn". Yours would be comparable to "landing anywhere within sight of the barn". Regardless, it's the prediction you've made, and if BTC happens to end up at 1900 by the end of the day, it's inappropriate for me to say "Yeah, but I was only counting if it was close to 0, those high numbers weren't real."

The MDC does not require claimants to demonstrate abilities they don't claim; if someone claims to be able to project words into others' heads, asking them to send a picture is not a fair test of their claim.

When pressed, he made a formal prediction that covered a wide (but not horribly unreasonable given short-term history) range. You don't get to only pick part of that range and claim that it's only a hit if it matches that part. To be fair, you have to either accept the entire range or ask him to narrow it to a more specific value. He wouldn't narrow it, so that's the prediction we have: between $150 and $500 by the end of the month.

You cannot unilaterally change the criteria for a "hit" just because you don't like the probability of him achieving it. You can consider that particular "hit" to not be sufficiently representative of any particular predictive ability (as I noted above, all he'll have shown is that he can hit the barn IMO; next time you and he can decide on a much smaller range if you'd like), but like your anywhere-within-sight prediction above, it's still a hit; it just isn't a hit that means much.

Reiterating: if anyone had said "BTC will lose half its value by the end of the month", you'd have accepted that as a valid prediction. It's the same prediction as "BTC will be worth $500 or less by the end of the month" -- why do you want to penalize wrs now for shrinking that range to $150-$500?

This ^^^
 
I don't know alot about the mechanics of currency, but this sounds like a pyramid scheme.
Who is running this "pyramid scheme"? How many people are being recruited to sell bitcoins? How many levels are there in this "scheme"? What commission do the people at the top get from the bottom sellers? etc? etc?
 
I've been trying to start DogeCoin as a low entry experiment in these things, but it is really not noob friendly. Installing Arch Linux is easier.

Is BitCoin similarly esoteric?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom