How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who is running this "pyramid scheme"? How many people are being recruited to sell bitcoins? How many levels are there in this "scheme"? What commission do the people at the top get from the bottom sellers? etc? etc?

Your questions sound like you might be confusing multi level marketing with a pyramid scheme. While similar, a pyramid scheme does not require commissions or levels.
 
More recently you predicted a drop to $500 last Monday, and that had triangles and lines and all sorts of things drawn on it. Was there anything wrong with that?


That would be this post, where you said so outright.

That was simply in accordance with my earlier prediction of $500 before the end of the month. I never said I knew what day and minute it would get there. That is not something anyone can really do. What you are attempting to do is to confuse a comment about how the triangles could play out with a specific claim. I believe I said that it looks like if a miracle doesn't happen it's going to $500 by Monday. The miracle happened, someone came in and bought the market back up even though they probably lost money by doing so because it ultimately failed to hold those gains.

The top call was actually the best one of all the predictions that I have made. This is something you would understand if you were a trader. Calling tops and bottoms is a favorite pastime in trading and 90% of the time, they are wrong calls. That was pretty good to get that one right. I lost a lot of money shorting Apple on a failed top call, mostly because I was impatient. The top call on BTC even if it's just a temporary top, was a good one and could have been traded for big gains if there were a way to short it in a real market.

Finally, what I have done in this thread is simply provide a running commentary to track the market. I was egged into making a prediction by Belz which has now been met pretty much in the middle of the range I predicted. I absolve myself from making anymore predictions about bitcoin.

ETA
Here is the updated channel chart. Not a prediction, just a guide as to the market trend. Still in the channel but moved back above the mid line.
 

Attachments

  • btchanupd.jpg
    btchanupd.jpg
    22.6 KB · Views: 9
Last edited:
Now they are all up except one.

ETA: Bitcoin regained the $200 I saw it lose yesterday (It was down below $450 at one point). Around $650 again.


Yeah, nothing like a currency that varies 30% in value each day. Funny how crappy ole US fiat has barely moved in the last couple of weeks but bitcoin which is supposed to be so much better, just jumps around like a cat on a hot tin roof. Which one is the currency and which one is the fantasy?
 
I'll take your word for it, because I missed that. Mind you, I only check the one link, which seems to be an average of sorts.

Which is one flaw in the whole thing.
Not defining which set of figures to use, otherwise it would be possible to take the high from one set of figures, and the low from another.
 
Your questions sound like you might be confusing multi level marketing with a pyramid scheme.
Only Amway reps claim that there is a difference.

While similar, a pyramid scheme does not require commissions or levels.
It most certainly does require levels. It's about people at the at the top of the pyramid recruiting and selling to those at a lower level on the pyramid. The only way the new recruits can make money is to recruit others and thereby move up the pyramid.
 
Last edited:

Key point from the article

Guardian said:
Bitcoin remains legal to use in China, and the central bank is standing by an announcement that individuals are free to trade it at their own risk. But without third party payment providers, new purchases of the currency are virtually impossible.

That raises doubts about the future of bitcoin. The large boom in value that the currency has seen this autumn is widely thought to be a result of Chinese users adopting it. As Chinese support has since waned, so too has the price.

Bitcoin's supporters have consistently argued that the currency is impossible to fully ban, since it exists as a decentralised network of transactions. But if it can be rendered useless to merchants and customers, an actual ban may be unnecessary.

Basically nothing left to pump the bubble with and no way for merchants to buy goods for RMB and sell them for BTC and then get RMB back. So it's curtains for BTC in China. Wonder how long before the exchange dies?
 
Only Amway reps claim that there is a difference.


It most certainly does require levels. It's about people at the at the top of the pyramid recruiting and selling to those at a lower level on the pyramid. The only way the new recruits can make money is to recruit others and thereby move up the pyramid.

The bitcoin phenomenon is more like a "pump and dump" scheme. This website has some interesting definitions of various schemes such as Ponzi, pyramid, etc. There are subtle differences.
 
Only Amway reps claim that there is a difference.


It most certainly does require levels. It's about people at the at the top of the pyramid recruiting and selling to those at a lower level on the pyramid. The only way the new recruits can make money is to recruit others and thereby move up the pyramid.

Multi Level Marketing scheme is a type of pyramid scheme. Not all pyramid schemes are MLM.

But you are right in the sense that if BTC is a scam* it is probably more like a Ponzi scheme, not a pyramid scheme. Although there are some minor quibbles with that classification too, as there is no central organizer to the scam, no Madoff if you will. Satochi does not qualify, as he is not redirecting funds (afaik).

*I do think BTC was not set up as a scam, but there is the distinct possibility that it has become one as people with large investments and who can control the market need to draw in new investors or face losing it all. But even without the market manipulation, it is certainly a bubble - one that has popped.
 
Last edited:
So what is the fraudulent information being put out by bitcoin promoters to entice people to buy them?

I don't think that is a requirement of the scheme. All it takes is the promise that an investment will rise indefinitely, and a plan to profit off the speculation.
 
I don't think that is a requirement of the scheme. All it takes is the promise that an investment will rise indefinitely, and a plan to profit off the speculation.
Who is putting out that fraudulent information about bitcoin and how do they convince people that the price charts are wrong?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom