How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dropping like a stone right now. It's at 500, and keeps dipping below that. So much for the $1200 peak.
 
It's bounced a bit, back to around $550. The way things are going, though, I wouldn't be surprised if it did go to $150. If it does, a blow will have been struck for chart analysis not being woo.

Eh. Maybe? While charts = woo is basically propaganda, it is a form of forecasting which is notoriously difficult in things like markets, albeit easier in the short term which is where wrs has mainly operated. And while wrs seems to have a better understanding of market fundamentals and forecasting than anyone I have ever conversed with, it certainly takes more than one data point to validate a model. Even then models like this are only right until they aren't.

In other words, I would be no quicker to claim that wrs has a valid model if it hits in his range as I would be to claim psions, were it to continue to expand exponentially. We have here is a data point.

What it DOES do pretty decisively is make the people who said that this was not a bubble wrong in their hypothesis.
 
523$ right now. That's pretty low, considering how high the thing went. I wonder if wrs' 150$ prediction will pan out.


China is currently at $423 my initial prediction of $150-500 has been met, it's now free to take out $150 by the end of the month. The low on China so far is $331 so I would think that the bitbubble is burst for sure and the west is going to catch down to China. Just might take longer.

ETA looks like Bit Stamp hit $382 and Gox hit $486.

I slept through all the action it appears. I figured this is how it would work out (big drop while I slept). Now the question is how the west will react today. The bounce is on right now and I think the big drop might be done but it's really hard to call bottoms so I won't. The bitbugs were so sure of how it would bounce anytime, they may be demoralized now. A bounce after a drop like this is certainly to be expected.

In addtion, whatever money is in the exchanges has more buying power at lower prices but it also may be trying to leave the exchanges instead of going back into a burst bubble.
 
Last edited:
It's bounced a bit, back to around $550. The way things are going, though, I wouldn't be surprised if it did go to $150. If it does, a blow will have been struck for chart analysis not being woo.
Ehh, the $150 figure comes from that being its stable value before the btchina bubble. The $500 figure was wrs hedging his bet. I don't recall charts being involved in either, though of course they were there with lines all over 'em regardless.
 
It's bounced a bit, back to around $550. The way things are going, though, I wouldn't be surprised if it did go to $150. If it does, a blow will have been struck for chart analysis not being woo.

Wouldn't his chart analysis have to be accurate in more situations and more often than chance? The possibility of Bitcoin's decline after 1200 was predicted by most posters with or without eldritch runes and Illuminati symbols on charts. wrs would have to put money in and let us know how much he makes using his chart method at various intervals like 1 year, 5 year, 10 years.
 
Ehh, the $150 figure comes from that being its stable value before the btchina bubble. The $500 figure was wrs hedging his bet. I don't recall charts being involved in either, though of course they were there with lines all over 'em regardless.

Here is the update to the bigger channel chart. So far it's working pretty well. It may have bottomed earlier but it didn't quite tag the bottom. There is also a steeper version of this that could be drawn. The bigger issue is where the top line is and how far BTC has to go in order to break the downtrend.
 

Attachments

  • btchanupd.jpg
    btchanupd.jpg
    22.4 KB · Views: 11
Wouldn't his chart analysis have to be accurate in more situations and more often than chance? The possibility of Bitcoin's decline after 1200 was predicted by most posters with or without eldritch runes and Illuminati symbols on charts. wrs would have to put money in and let us know how much he makes using his chart method at various intervals like 1 year, 5 year, 10 years.

Well, it's one blow; it's not a complete vindication of all things chart-analysis-wise. But, wrs did call the top (at least what now appears to be the top), and he did make a specific prediction (albeit within rather a wide range) about the bottom, and it has come to pass, at least temporarily. Granted, it was fairly apparent (to most of us, anyway) that the BTC bubble was bound to deflate, but credit must be given at least that far.

I agree that I'd want to see results over a longer period and in a less obviously dysfunctional market than Bitcoin before I'd subscribe to wrs's newsletter, but he's done pretty good so far.
 
Well, it's one blow; it's not a complete vindication of all things chart-analysis-wise. But, wrs did call the top (at least what now appears to be the top), and he did make a specific prediction (albeit within rather a wide range) about the bottom, and it has come to pass, at least temporarily. Granted, it was fairly apparent (to most of us, anyway) that the BTC bubble was bound to deflate, but credit must be given at least that far.

I agree that I'd want to see results over a longer period and in a less obviously dysfunctional market than Bitcoin before I'd subscribe to wrs's newsletter, but he's done pretty good so far.

I honestly didn't intend to sell any particular methodology here. I am just following this for entertainment, I have no dog in the fight. It is nice to get it right from time to time. The charts are as problematic as people point out and making money in trading involves far more than just doing a good job on the charts. It involves not getting emotional and following rules, neither of which I do so well. I do best when I don't have a dog in the fight and can remain objective.
 
Exponential growth isn't sustainable. Our model for the behaviour of the bitcoin price can't simply be "its exponential growth" when we know in the long run that that can't be how it turns out.

This article has some thoughts...

FTFA said:
"What is worrying about the Bitcoin economy [today]," Varoufakis said, "is the lack of balance between the demand for Bitcoins for speculative purposes as opposed to the demand for transaction purposes." There aren't enough people trading Bitcoins, and the majority of the currency is sitting idle in people's accounts, people like Nakamoto. This is creating a bubble.

In Greek and Roman times, change was made by literally cutting coins in half. Bitcoins can be subdivided as well, down to the 1/100,000,000, a denomination dubbed the "Satoshi." But Varoufakis says that when the last Bitcoin is mined there will be no more to go around, causing deflation. As the Bitcoin economy continues to grow, there will be the same amount of money shared in the system, and no amount of chopping it up will help it spread far enough.
What will emerge is an entrenched Bitcoin aristocracy, with Nakamoto and others playing the role of feudal lords, high level players who cannot be taken down until they choose to give away their loot. And their only incentive to give up that loot is, naturally, for profit.

I wonder how many people have made the point in this thread so far that an inherently deflationary currency is fail? I've never directly addressed it myself, but the point _is_ valid; there has to be a reason to spend money, not hoard it.
 
ETA looks like Bit Stamp hit $382 and Gox hit $486.

Someone(s) put a huge pile of money back in between 6 and 7am EST -- 6000+ coins' worth of artificial price increases dragging it back up from $382 to $550, which is where it's piddling around now. I strongly suspect this is from people with a bunch of Bitprofit already made trying to predict the bottom and make a quick buck on the bounce, but it's hard to say. I would be near certain almost none of that money that went 'in' was from fresh depositors though, only from people who've already been playing in Bitcoin.
 
I don't think so. First, it's not the end of the month, and second, your range was way too big to be useful. It has to hit 150$ or I won't give you the point.

Belz, whether you give me the point or not doesn't matter a bit to me. I satisfied my own prediction, not your interpretation of it. For myself, I am satisfied and that ultimately is all that matters in life.
 
I don't think so. First, it's not the end of the month, and second, your range was way too big to be useful. It has to hit 150$ or I won't give you the point.

Wasn't it around $1k when he made the prediction? You would've accepted the statement "Bitcoin will lose half its value by the end of the month" then -- I think $150-$500 is a perfectly valid prediction as well, largely because it was sufficiently far away from the original price and directly against the short-term trend. Someone saying "$100-$900" when it's at $1k is obviously not predicting anything that couldn't be satisfied by token market variation.

The JREF's MDC doesn't try to force applicants to perform beyond what they believe their own abilities are, and yet you're doing so here -- his prediction when pushed was "$150-$500", so that's what it is. A hit on that might not give you (or me) any particular confidence that he could hit a more narrow target, but he will have at least hit the barn -- next time you and he can put an actual bullseye on the side.
 
Wouldn't his chart analysis have to be accurate in more situations and more often than chance? The possibility of Bitcoin's decline after 1200 was predicted by most posters with or without eldritch runes and Illuminati symbols on charts. wrs would have to put money in and let us know how much he makes using his chart method at various intervals like 1 year, 5 year, 10 years.


I think a Bayesian approach to predictions is a good way to validate a model. That is, the more on track predictions it makes, and the greater accuracy it does so (with respect to timing and valuation), the more weight we can give it for future predictions. Conversely when it gets it wrong

I would caution against demanding a model predict 1 year in advance, let alone 10, especially if the model is specifically designed to make short term claims.
 
Wouldn't his chart analysis have to be accurate in more situations and more often than chance? The possibility of Bitcoin's decline after 1200 was predicted by most posters with or without eldritch runes and Illuminati symbols on charts. wrs would have to put money in and let us know how much he makes using his chart method at various intervals like 1 year, 5 year, 10 years.

Here was the top call which was within a few hours of the top. I am not sure I see a lot of others around it.

I am not selling any particular methodology here either and I think I have said that repeatedly. I just made some informed guesses that were right and in my expereince, that is really all one can hope for in analyzing markets.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom