How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anybody who believes that bitcoin is just a flash in the pan is indulging in wishful thinking. As long as the algorithm is uncrackable, there will be a role for bitcoin. The role hasn't been clearly defined yet but that often happens when new technology is introduced.

Would you mind turning down the derp a notch, please? You're arguing for a sea change using what is, at best, a very quaint and picturesque pond. It clearly isn't working here.

Nothing hurts a revolution more than revolutionaries who don't know when to stop waving around the torches and pitchforks.
 
Before anyone gets overly confident in the security of the exchanges on Bitcoin, one should consider this:
I just got hacked - any help is welcome! (25,000 BTC stolen)

The 28 pages since that time suggest that this is a hoax. The "thief's" bitcoin address appears to be the same as a new donation address set up five days ago (ie right around the time of the "theft"). It's the internetz, you know, and people do have a habit of making **** up on forums.
 
From the comments on the Slashdot submission that was posted pages back:

timholman said:
Skarecrow77 said:
The short and dirty version is "If you asked a bunch of libertarians to design a digital currency, this is what you'd get".


I'd amend that to "If you asked a bunch of libertarians who wanted to put the world's economies back on the gold standard ...". Because really, when you think about it, that's what bitcoin is supposed to be - digital gold.

Consider the parallels to gold coinage: a finite worldwide supply, "mining" becomes more difficult as time goes by, and the amount of money in circulation can be reduced by coins being hidden or lost, but never artificially increased. Furthermore, the statements you'll hear from the BTC crowd are exactly like the statements from the gold money crowd - bitcoins will herald in a new era of economic prosperity, bitcoins cannot be manipulated by governments creating more of them, etc. In effect, you've got a community of speculators who are trying to make their own "gold", and get rich by doing it, provided they can make the rest of us buy into the idea. (The historical failure of gold-backed currency in modern economies seems to completely escape all of them.)

However, there is a very big difference between BTC and gold. While it is true that you cannot create more BTC, anyone (or any government) can certainly create a competing digital currency that has as much "value" as bitcoins. Who is to say that a bitcoin has more or less value than any other cryptographically-signed digital coinage? Nothing more than public opinion, and that can be manipulated.

Ultimately, I expect the BTC standard to fail, and when it does, you'll hear exactly the same claims of government / commercial manipulation / sabotage that you hear from believers in gold currency. In that respect, there will be no difference in BTC and gold at all.


(direct link)
 
Would you mind turning down the derp a notch, please? You're arguing for a sea change using what is, at best, a very quaint and picturesque pond. It clearly isn't working here.

Nothing hurts a revolution more than revolutionaries who don't know when to stop waving around the torches and pitchforks.
I talk of a "role" and you talk of "revolution"?
 
Any comments on this article?

Bitcoin collapses on malicious trade

The fragility of the Bitcoin peer-to-peer crypto-currency has been thrown into sharp relief when a large sell transaction sent the trade value of Bitcoins to zero.

According to the Mt Gox exchange, the sell order came from a compromised account. Mt Gox has taken its exchange offline (however, a screen grab of Bitcoins’ collapse is here) and is attempting to recover.

Its approach is to roll back all transactions to their state before the sell order was placed.

“The bitcoin will be back to around 17.5$ / BC after we rollback all trades that have happened after the huge Bitcoin sale that happened on June 20th near 3:00am (JST)”, (sic) says the Mt Gox posting.

As the comments beneath that posting reveal, not all users are pleased about the rollback attempt – for example, those who spotted the collapse happening and decided to load up with cheap Bitcoins.
 
If bitcoins were secure, untraceable and anonymous - then how could anyone just "roll back" various trades?

If I'd buy bitcoins on such an exchange and paid for them - how can the site just take them away from me again?

And, really, what is the justification here?

I have no idea, but it sounds like these things are not as secure as they were hyped to be.

Also, man it does seem like a lot of people are getting hacked these days. Is no-one safe anymore?
 
Are you guys talking about bitcoin or bitcoin repositories? There is a difference. (See post #252).

yes, that's it, keep furiously vamping and trying to move the failure as far as possible from the thing you've been cheerleading.
 
yes, that's it, keep furiously vamping and trying to move the failure as far as possible from the thing you've been cheerleading.

How is he vamping? People in this thread do keep conflating bitcoin and bitcoin-related-websites. Some people stored their bitcoin on mt gox, which was dumb because mt gox was a poorly secured website. No one has to use mt gox, there are plenty of places to trade bitcoin.

I don't have any bitcoins, and don't plan on using them, but blaming this mt gox hack on bitcoin is like blaming the psn hacks, paypal scams, and lost wallets on the US dollar.
 
yes, that's it, keep furiously vamping and trying to move the failure as far as possible from the thing you've been cheerleading.

He's right, I did confuse the two.

It's not the fault of my credit card if i keep the pin on a post-it note in my wallet.
 
But, your credit card company can protect you from fraud even in such a case.
 
But, your credit card company can protect you from fraud even in such a case.
Your credit card company also doesn't pretend that they are issuing currency. If I acquire $1,000 today because of a fluctuation in the value of that currency, the US government isn't going to reclaim that money tomorrow (though they obviously have various means to change the value of my $1,000).
 
But, your credit card company can protect you from fraud even in such a case.

Which is what mt gox did, by reversing the fraudulent trades.

Your credit card company also doesn't pretend that they are issuing currency. If I acquire $1,000 today because of a fluctuation in the value of that currency, the US government isn't going to reclaim that money tomorrow (though they obviously have various means to change the value of my $1,000).

But they hopefully would, if you obtained that $1000 through hacking a bank's website. Also, mt gox doesnt claim to issue currency either, so again mt gox and bitcoin are being conflated.
 
Amazing that some people have to re-learn all of the lessons they were taught with internet banking and doing taxes on-line.

Caveat emptor / Caveat venditor.

You say this like it isn't a huge flaw in the bitcoin system.

If someone wants to get this 20 dollar bill i have, they have to come and get it from me. Which is going to be quite the task, and people half way around the world are probably not going to go through the effort.

To steal bitcoins one has to be a semi competent hacker, by the looks of it.

Essentially your argument is that if it didn't have all these flaws, it would be a great system , and even that is simply wrong.

The only way this is going to be an alternative is if governments collapse, but if governments collapse, something epic enough to "turn off the lights" has happened, making your bitcoins nothing but useless data. You would do better investing in guns, knives and food, and selling them when said massive event happens.
 
But making a block at the moment on your own will take you two years, and I will be extremely surprised if the price is still $20 per BTC.

So if you want to generate blocks now, you have to join a pool, and the larger the pool, the less money you will get.

130 posts since 2001, and we get 4 from you in a row? You must be interested in the topic!
 

As was mentioned multiple times in this thread, this was a 3rd party site that was hacked. Their data base got compromised and accounts sold off tons of bitcoins. This site has safety measures, such as a maximum amount of withdrawal per day and the ability to roll back the trades in the case of fraud. No bitcoin user has to use this site, it is their choice.

yes, that's it, keep furiously vamping and trying to move the failure as far as possible from the thing you've been cheerleading.

The failure is the 3rd party site...I guess it's lucky for the users of that site that was hacked can roll back the trades. I suppose of your ebay account was hacked that would be a failure in all online auctions?

Your credit card company also doesn't pretend that they are issuing currency. If I acquire $1,000 today because of a fluctuation in the value of that currency, the US government isn't going to reclaim that money tomorrow (though they obviously have various means to change the value of my $1,000).

There is no central authority on bitcoins as a currency. This site that is rolling back trades is just one site...not the whole market.

To steal bitcoins one has to be a semi competent hacker, by the looks of it.

Same thing to steal CC#s and peoples money from online accounts. Don't compare a digital currency to one that is physical.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom