Why are so many Libertarians I meet always so eager to offer advice on how to cheat "The Man," yet they inevitably take such a cold and arrogant "blame the victim" stance when somebody suffers the backfire of one of their half-baked scams?
If you think the Fed is a racket and Bernanke a master swindler, yet Bitcoin is on the up-and-up and Satoshi is an idealistic saint working to free the world from economic repression, then you're really in for a rude awakening I'm afraid.
Bitcoin is every bit as "imaginary" as any fiat currency issued by a government could ever be, but it's even worse because it's illegal tender. There's no intrinsic value to it at all. The entire system is based in confidence, and when that confidence is lost or betrayed, you're outta luck my friend.
There's no real-world commodity backing Bitcoin. Its value is not tied to any stocks, bonds, Fort Knox gold, or any country's GDP, and there's no FDIC insurance to protect investors. There will be no bailouts to save
this economy. Lending institutions and victims of theft have absolutely no recourse to mitigate losses. If you put your hard-earned money into Bitcoin currency and it tanks, you've lost. If you spend tens of thousands on a "mine" consisting of racks and racks of computers, and Bitcoin fails, you're stuck with no returns and all that expensive, rapidly-depreciating videogame hardware with thousands of hours of hard-duty service on it.
Secondly, there's absolutely no incentive for consumers to spend, or legitimate merchants to accept, Bitcoin as tender. There are no specific features in the entire Bitcoin business model that encourage trade, the primary function of a currency. Quite the contrary in fact.
There are actually several disincentives to using Bitcoin as a currency:
- It's illegal: Bitcoin is illegal tender, the use of which is a crime in many countries. Simply having the program or a wallet file on one's computer could conceivably get a user arrested. It complicates the issue of taxes, and users might be in danger of prosecution for tax fraud for the simple possession or conducting of business in Bitcoin. Likewise, transactions might not be covered by law, with no legal recourse available in cases of theft or fraud.
- It's inconvenient: Currencies ought to be readily-available and easily-transferable, which is not at all the case with Bitcoin. Transactions are slow and clunky, a simple monetary exchange taking several minutes to several hours to complete. You can't get a one-to-one transfer from Bitcoin to any other currency without paying service fees.
- Its deflationary economic model hurts its purchasing power: As others have pointed out, deflationary economics are bad for most economies. Runaway deflation is very bad for encouraging trade and growth. In a state of deflation, the buyer is always getting the short end of the stick in transactions, not at all a good way to stimulate exchange.
Why would any person or institution invest or loan their money, or purchase nonessential goods and services, if their money grew on its own by just sitting under their mattress? A low, steady rate of inflation is essential for economic growth, yet Bitcoin is engineered to create astronomical deflation rates through artificial scarcity.
What are we seeing now? Are most Bitcoin adopters actually spending their bitcoins? No. How many people do you actually know who regularly use Bitcoin for purchases, online or not? A few idiots mail-ordering dope on the Internet are spending Bitcoin; everybody else is hoarding it in the hopes of beating the market and getting rich.
- Its excessive volatility makes it too unreliable for business: In addition to deflation, overvalued currencies tend to be volatile, and Bitcoin is the most overvalued currency in the world, with absolutely zero intrinsic value at all. All it would take is a few Bitcoin high-rollers to cash in their virtual "chips" for the whole house of cards to tumble. Mt. Gox would look like the online version of the "Building and Loan" from It's a Wonderful Life, with Jimmy Stewart going bonkers, "But we don't have your money if ya all wanna draw it all out at once! The money is on your computer, and your computer! If it was up to old man Bernanke there wouldn't be another decent computer built in this town!" Except there's no value in any of those computers at all, just a bunch of tiny switches flipping on and off a few billion times a second.
Just look at how its valuation bounces all over the place from day to day, minute to minute. What serious businessman would want to deal in such a "currency" that could become worthless overnight? It's too unreliable to trust. For a business to operate, it's got to balance its debits against its credits, and that's impossible when your basic capital is so unstable.
- By making all transactional computations a function of speculation, the system is preprogrammed to fail: The business of processing transactions is handled by the computers employed to do the "mining" of bitcoin. But that model makes absolutely no sense from the sustainability perspective. What happens when the bitcoin supply reaches its prescribed limit of 21 million bitcoins? No more new bitcoins means no more mining opportunity. With noting left to mine, there will be no more incentive to contribute to the transaction workload.
As time goes on and more new bitcoins are added to the market, you'd expect trade to increase instead of decrease, but at the same time the incentive to process monetary transactions is rapidly dwindling! Why would the creators have made such an obviously flawed, time-bomb of a system if they intended it to last? If that isn't damning evidence that Bitcoin is a big scam with absolutely no intention of persisting as a real currency, I don't know what is.
- Its adoption is very limited: One of the most important features of a successful currency is universality, and Bitcoin will most likely never achieve market penetration beyond the criminal underground and a few small businesses owned by ideologues. Despite its wide exposure in the media and enthusiastic adoption by tech nerds and anti-government fringe groups, no large corporations have adopted Bitcoin, only a few small businesses. Not even the porno websites will touch it.
The disincentives outlined above, plus its association with crime and the black market, will likely thwart its adoption as a legitimate currency.
What does that tell you about Bitcoin's viability as a currency? The fact that it's engineered not to create stability and encourage trade, but to skyrocket in value, is the first tipoff that it's not really intended as a viable currency.
On the other hand, engineered, runaway valuation of a worthless, imaginary commodity makes perfect sense as a scam. Think about it. Trade is the primary function of a currency, and Bitcoin ignores that function in favor of being an investment product with no intrinsic value, yet programmed to skyrocket in value for no good reason.
So, if this system is a scam, engineered to create artificial value and then fail, then what's the business model? How does Bitcoin make money for the swindlers who created it?
The organizations that offer bitcoin-to-real-actual-money conversions charge fees, so there's one source of income. Do you think Satoshi and his cohorts really have no financial interest in that industry? They might also be heavily invested in companies like NVidia and ATI. I don't know, but I'd be interested to find out.
From everything I've read about the mechanics of this system, it seems obvious that it's not at all what it purports to be. The more I learn about it, the more it looks like a really clever pyramid scheme intended to dupe gullible malcontents and greedy opportunists.