How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope. Read the Constitution (that you claim to love). CONGRESS has the only lawful authority to coin money and fix it's value. For you to tout Bitcoin as "legitimate" or "superior" currency" is to commit a Federal crime (counterfeiting). For you to (in your blog) tout its use to avoid paying taxes is also criminal (tax evastion, inciting crime).

I think your analysis is a little off. The Constitution gives the federal government the authority to coin money, and denies that authority to the states, but it doesn't say anything about whether private citizens can. I'd be very surprised if the counterfeiting laws actually bar people from circulating something as a medium of exchange, as long as it doesn't purport to be official currency or backed by the government. Otherwise people trading virtual currencies from World of Warcraft and similar games would be violating the law. But I haven't researched that point.
 
anduin said:
I do not care, I am simply giving my humble opinion that I think the system is deeply flawed.
I would call it flawed, but not deeply, and certainly not fatally.

A thought question for the haters: suppose someone rejiggered the difficulty curve such that coins were produced at a constant rate, e.g. 3% inflation. Doing do would be pretty easy to do, just match Moore's Law and knock off a bit. We even can set the initial difficulty pretty high to prevent the gold rushing behavior that infested bitcoin with libertards.

Would that solve the ponzi-esque problems inherent with bitcoin's early adoption and deflationary nature? What problems (apart from being completely unadopted by anyone) would still remain?

I think it might even make for a fun competition/economy fight. Will bitcoin's chronic hoarding make it more or less useful than an inflationary sibling?
 
A thought question for the haters

I stopped reading here. Calling critics of something "haters" is a lazy and boring way to dismiss them. It's possible to criticize and disapprove of something for rational reasons that are a sight less childish than "hatred"
 
I... dunno. It used to, but my windows client is now missing the "generate" option. Could be that CPU based mining is so inefficient they removed it entirely for simplicity's sake.

Check out poclbm's opencl code, that should have all you need to reverse engineer the encryption. Lemme know if you find something juicy, I want to watch the tears.
 
So, if I wanted to make a bitcoin, what software would you need for a radeon gpu and xp?

I am looking at analyzing this so I can come up with the cryptographic flaw I know must be there. (Amateurs never get cryptography right...)

Bitcoin is open source, the GitHub repo for the code is linked from the home page. From what I've heard/read Bitcoin did the crypto implementation correctly.
 
A thought question for the haters: suppose someone rejiggered the difficulty curve such that coins were produced at a constant rate, e.g. 3% inflation.

You can only do that if you can correctly predict (and adjust for) the increase in processing power per dollar in the forseeable future. I don't think that's a realistic assumption.
 
I stopped reading here.
Not my problem.

Leif Roar said:
You can only do that if you can correctly predict (and adjust for) the increase in processing power per dollar in the forseeable future. I don't think that's a realistic assumption.
Yes, this would be operating under the assumption that Moore's Law (the colloquial usage, not its original application to transistor density) will hold for the foreseeable future. You may have your doubts about that, and you're welcome to them. Personally, I'm hoping ol' Gordon's Observation is going to stick around until at least 2060, for a completely different reason.
 
I would call it flawed, but not deeply, and certainly not fatally.

A thought question for the haters: suppose someone rejiggered the difficulty curve such that coins were produced at a constant rate, e.g. 3% inflation. Doing do would be pretty easy to do, just match Moore's Law and knock off a bit. We even can set the initial difficulty pretty high to prevent the gold rushing behavior that infested bitcoin with libertards.

Would that solve the ponzi-esque problems inherent with bitcoin's early adoption and deflationary nature? What problems (apart from being completely unadopted by anyone) would still remain?

I think it might even make for a fun competition/economy fight. Will bitcoin's chronic hoarding make it more or less useful than an inflationary sibling?

I would be more interested in such a model, since it was not so purposefully advantageous to early 'miners'.
 
Does the bitcoin app from the bitcoin site generate bitcoins on its own, or do you need a miner for that?

You need a miner for that, the Bitcoin app is just a purse. The purse will give you a unique address that you can give others, which is how you conduct transactions. You tie your miner to your purse, so when the block is mined the coins are deposited into your account.
 
A thought question for the haters: suppose someone rejiggered the difficulty curve such that coins were produced at a constant rate, e.g. 3% inflation. Doing do would be pretty easy to do, just match Moore's Law and knock off a bit. We even can set the initial difficulty pretty high to prevent the gold rushing behavior that infested bitcoin with libertards.

I'm not a hater, just a realist.

What you describe might work, but it would require a complete reset of the scheme. I also think that the idea of creating new value into the economy with nothing to support it other than processor time is flawed, but if people start to accept it widely and to exchange, then why not?

In my opinion Bitcoin should not try to be a currency, and should just strive to be an anonymous and secure payment system, sort of like a cryptographic version of PayPal.
 
Bitcoin exchange is down from $19 USD to $15.7 USD from yesterday! Things not looking good with the latest transaction recorded at 13.651 in mtgoxUSD.

I think that the news about the 25,000 BTC theft, and today's report of malware targeting BTCs might have sent speculators running scared.

However, looking at the volumes, afternoon traffic is heavier than it has been in the last 5 days, but nothing that would indicate panic selling.

Stay tuned.
 
I would be more interested in such a model, since it was not so purposefully advantageous to early 'miners'.

In a system without a dramatic fall in return-of-investment on the mining you'd end up with one or two situations. Either it's profitable to mine for bitcoins, in which case you'll get more and more computer power assigned to mining for bitcoins and thus runaway inflation, or it will not be profitable, in which hardly any mining will be done, and you'll get deflation (particularly as the system will "bleed" bitcoins in hard-drive crashes, people dying or forgetting the password to their bitcoin wallets.)

It's perhaps theoretically possible to hit a sweet spot where the roi of bitcoin-mining is just right for the amount of bitcoins mined to correspond to, say, 2% inflation. This isn't a stable system though, not even assuming an even, steady rate of increase in computing power, so there's no way this could ever occur without regulatory oversight -- which would rather defeat the point of bitcoins in the first place.

Then there's the issue of sudden breakthroughs in computer technology or mathematics or for that matter the discovery of a flaw in the bitcoins algorithm or implementation (not exactly unheard of in the field of cryptology.)

Then there is the issue of computer power actually being very unevenly distributed. A few large actors such as IBM, Google, the US government, IBM own the vast majority of the world's CPU power and there are huge thresholds of entry on computer power at those scales. (And if we look at it from the point of view of macro economics, all that computer power is located in a handful of countries. How would Nigeria or Pakistan fare in a bitcoin economy?)

All of those are minor concerns compared to the elephant in the room, though. Without backing -- whether in a commodity such as gold or the power and credibility of an authority -- the value of a "currency" is solely speculative.
 
Leif Roar said:
In a system without a dramatic fall in return-of-investment on the mining you'd end up with one or two situations.
The scenarios you describe, barring the flaw in cryptography, form an attractor network; a stable equilibrium.

If interest is suddenly piqued and a tide of GPU power washes in, more coins than expected would be generated, yes, but they'd soon be abutting Moore's Law again. Runaway inflation can't run for very long.

If mining is unprofitable, it'll taper off until Moore's Law catches up and it's profitable again. This is similar in function to the transaction fee idea that the bitcoin network uses, but it takes the form of new coins instead of siphoning off already anemic transfers.

All of those are minor concerns compared to the elephant in the room, though. Without backing -- whether in a commodity such as gold or the power and credibility of an authority -- the value of a "currency" is solely speculative.
Agree completely. You'll notice I've said as much many times over the course of this thread. If it's adopted, though, it becomes a commodity in its own right. If not, it remains a silly exchange on the fringes of the economy, and in the more dank parts of the interwebs.
 
This is a good reason to not accept bitcoins: As a business, you would want to accept only currencies that you can easily use after selling stuff for the currency and you want your income to be stable.

Is it hard to convert bitcoins to cash? Looks pretty easy to me. Just charge a little extra for the convenience to your customers. I do not see how this would negatively affect your business.
 
13yfksh.jpg


slgxfc.jpg


Looks to me like we're just entering the "mania" phase... or is it the blow-off?!?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom