How homeopathy does work? - 4 Years of DHMS course.

[Non-Sense Homeopath]

Silent Protest continues

 

[Nucular]

Re: Silent Protest continues

Good of you to drop by and remind us all that you're not here.

 

[flume]

Hello Non-sense Homeopath.
There was a post on the NCH Pakistan discussion board under the Dr. MAS login which said the ban was lifted.
The rules are different at that forum, so the person posting under the Dr. MAS login might not have been the actual Dr. MAS. So maybe the poster was joking, and the actual Dr. MAS has not lifted the ban? Or has the ban been lifted but you missed the information?

Or maybe you are using the ban as an excuse.

 

[Mojo]

Re: Silent Protest continues

Shhhhhh!

If you post, people might not realise you're being silent.

 

[Mojo]

It's too internally consistent and long-lived to be a joke.

But it's a joke nonetheless. Just not a very funny one, if they are, as they appear to be, defauding their "patients" (not to mention failing to respect their patients' confidentiality).

 

[wahrheit]

Re: Silent Protest continues

As a protest, we have decided not to discuss further with jref members / skeptics on homeopathic issues......

After this claim of skeptics that a medicine (not homeopathy) can not cure anything in 1x. We have received instruction from Dr. MAS that you (paki homeopaths) will not continue their discussion on homeopathic issues. After this it is useless to discuss this issue further. If you (all members) at any stage realize that a medicine in 1x (almost crude substance) can cure any one disease then we will think again to continue our discussion.

What a ridiculous statement. I'm afraid to repeat myself, but that's just embarrassing.

 

[wahrheit]

Um, by the way, does anybody remember the original subject of this thread? I think it was something along the lines of

"How homeopathy does work? - 4 Years of DHMS course."

Well...

 

[H'ethetheth]

It just means they still have the better part of 4 years to explain.

 

[Zep]

So far, Dr MAS has supplied just enough wibble to fill in 1 day of a real course and bore the arse off the more awake students. I wonder where the other 364+(365*3) days' worth of notes are...

 

[H'ethetheth]

Well, there's the knack, see. He never actually said it was a full time course.

 

[Zep]

Well, there's the knack, see. He never actually said it was a full time course.

Ah! Good point.

 

[Blue Bubble]

Dr. MAS continues his education !

From NCH -> How does homeopathy work it appears that MRC_Hans might be getting some progress in his attempt to educate the dear Dr. MAS.

I am unable to understand that when I am accepting everything even then you people have problem.

<!--QuoteBegin-->
<table border="0" align="center" width="95%" cellpadding="3" cellspacing="1"> <tbody><tr><td>
</td></tr><tr><td id="QUOTE"><!--QuoteEBegin-->Good. Now, as we decided to forget about Avogadro's limit for the time being, let us calculate the theoretical content of Arsenic in a 12C Ars Alba remedy:

Ok. I am with you and ready to follow. You may please Proceed.

Let us assume, rather arbitrarily, that the initial portion of crude substance contains 1000mg of Arsenic compound.

So, for each C potency, we get:

1C=10mg
2C=0.1mg
3C=0.001mg
4C=0.00001mg
5C=0.0000001mg
6C=0.000000001mg
7C=0.00000000001mg
8C=0.0000000000001mg
9C=0.000000000000001mg
10C=0.00000000000000001mg
11C=0.0000000000000000001mg
12C=0.000000000000000000001mg

Ok. I agree, then?

Now, toxiology is not my speciality, but I would guess the dose dependent reaction from arsenic in a human being would be roughly the following:

1000mg=Serious sickness, possibly fatal
100mg=Sickness, non-fatal
10mg=Distinct discomfort
1mg=Slight discomfort
0.1mg=Hardly any perceptible effect
0.01mg=No perceptible effect

Ok. I agree, then?
.
.
0.000000000000000000001mg=No effect at all

Ok. I 100 % agreed. Next?

In fact I would venture to say that already at one ppm level (0.001mg) the Arsenic would be without any effect.

Do you disagree?

No. What is the conclusion?

If yes, please specify where you disagree.

I am already agreed so no question of disagree
</td></tr></tbody> </table>

 

[Mojo]

Oh dear. All those zeros are hurting my eyes...

 

[MRC_Hans]

MAS is currently playing a small game at the NCH forum. First, he agrees with everything I say, then he says essentially: But you are wrong.

If it was not for the pictures of him apparantly showing a man in his thirties, I would be guessing that "Dr. MAS" is about 11 years old .

Hans

 

[Donks]

MAS is currently playing a small game at the NCH forum. First, he agrees with everything I say, then he says essentially: But you are wrong.

If it was not for the pictures of him apparantly showing a man in his thirties, I would be guessing that "Dr. MAS" is about 11 years old .

Hans

Seems like an accurate assessment of his mental age.

 

[Non-Sense Homeopath]

The man at the age 79 is a child?

 

[delphi_ote]

The man at the age 79 is a child?

Sounds accurate to me.

 

[Mojo]

The man at the age 79 is a child?

I thought Dr. MAS had told you not to post here.

Nice to see you back though.

 

[Qureshi1_78]

Delphie I have read your post at www.nch.ipbfree.com forum. Nice posts.

 

[Qureshi1_78]

MRC hans taken back his words at NCH forum.