Split Thread How are MDC protocols designed and carried out? (Split from FAQ thread)

"I recommend that the JREF _not_ test people who claim to be able to make people have to urinate. Stick to matters of a more purely probabilistic nature, where more time is spent merely determining the odds of numerical success, and far less time is spent making sure that the rest of the test is fair."

So, telekinesis, clairvoyance, and a host of other paranormal abilities shouldn't be testable under your ruling?

Telekinesis would be a simple and fine thing to test, if anybody ever actually made such a claim. It sounds to me like a test of clairvoyance is much more like to fall into the category of testing probability, like I said before.
 
Why don't they specify (and reveal) the exact terms beforehand? Why do they turn this into a guessing-game?
This has been explained to you multiple times. I really don't see how anyone could make the explanation any clearer.

Telekinesis would be a simple and fine thing to test, if anybody ever actually made such a claim
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=97889

If you have a suggestion as to how exact terms could be specified in the rules which would be applicable to both this claim and the Patricia Putt claim I linked to earlier by all means share it.
 
Telekinesis would be a simple and fine thing to test, if anybody ever actually made such a claim.

What are the odds that someone could successfully move an item telekinetically? How would you figure that out?

Ward

ETA: Pixel42 beat me to it (as usual). What are the odds?
 
Last edited:
"Perhaps even more importantly, such odds should remain the same for ALL such tests."

All tests of the same claimed ability *do* have, *must* have the same odds.

You appear to want the same odds regardless of what the ability is, and that is not possible.

If the claimed ability is to be able to levitate unassisted 12 feet off the ground indefinitely, the odds approach unity against. The odds of knowing a 2 digit number, randomly chosen are 1:100 against. What would be fair in the first case would be grossly unfair in the second.

You appear to be confused. I thought it was obvious that I was referring specifically to tests of a purely probabilistic nature; examples would be someone who claims to "sense" the next drawing of a card from a shuffled deck; which side of a coin is going to occur after being "flipped", etc. If somebody comes along who claims to be able to levitate, or fly like a bird, then that's a much simpler claim to test, and doesn't involve probability at all.
 
What Bryan Shelton seems to be saying is that levitation should not be tested. Only tests that are essentially guessing games should be allowed.

Please correct me if I'm wrong.

I don't really have a problem with making simple physical tests. I was only momentarily thrown for a loop when somebody talked about testing a person who claimed to be able to make somebody have to urinate! :)
 
"Why don't they specify (and reveal) the exact terms beforehand? Why do they turn this into a guessing-game?"

This has been explained to you multiple times. I really don't see how anyone could make the explanation any clearer.

I think there's a great deal of misunderstanding going on in this thread. What I was specifically referring to in my quote above has to do with stating the EXACT ODDS that a person without any special abilities at all would have in passing both the "preliminary test", and the "formal test". One person (I'm forgetting his or her name) has talked about suggested probabilities for those tests, but hasn't responded to the question I gave him or her about calculating those odds. I'd hardly call that "multiple times"! :)
 
I think there's a great deal of misunderstanding going on in this thread.
I think you're right.

What I was specifically referring to in my quote above has to do with stating the EXACT ODDS that a person without any special abilities at all would have in passing both the "preliminary test", and the "formal test". One person (I'm forgetting his or her name) has talked about suggested probabilities for those tests, but hasn't responded to the question I gave him or her about calculating those odds.
I mentioned that the JREF rule of thumb seems to be that applicants should typically beat chance odds of 1:1000 in the preliminary test, in cases where such probabilistic success criteria are applicable, and said why that seems reasonable to me. As no-one has ever done so there is no precedent for the final test but the expectation seems to be that the success criteria would be set higher, though I've always thought a simple repeat of the first test would be adequate as that gives combined odds beaten of 1: 1,000,000.

As for how these odds are calculated: I assume you're not asking which formulae are used, but how it is decided what a reasonable success criteria should be. I can't speak for JREF, but clearly a compromise between odds high enough that they won't end up mistakenly awarding the prize to someone who was just extremely lucky and low enough that a true paranormal ability won't be excluded is required. That compromise is a judgement call, which is why negotiation is necessary with each applicant to agree success criteria which are mutually acceptable.
 
I don't really have a problem with making simple physical tests. I was only momentarily thrown for a loop when somebody talked about testing a person who claimed to be able to make somebody have to urinate! :)

How was the test for induced urination not a simple physical test? And just so I can plan ahead, will this be a no true Scotsman response or more of a goalpost relocation (which you already just did in the above quote, by the way)?


That aside, though, it seems like your unrequited desire is that the Million Dollar Challenge be fair (whatever that means) to people with no claimed ability whatsoever. "I have no special power, but I'd like a shot at $1,000,000 on pure luck." That is not the purpose; it would be foolish to expect the JREF to cater to such a requirement.
 
You appear to be confused. I thought it was obvious that I was referring specifically to tests of a purely probabilistic nature; examples would be someone who claims to "sense" the next drawing of a card from a shuffled deck; which side of a coin is going to occur after being "flipped", etc. If somebody comes along who claims to be able to levitate, or fly like a bird, then that's a much simpler claim to test, and doesn't involve probability at all.

And yet your proposal is that it be subject to odds by dint of those odds have been established before the claim is even made.

Which why they are not.

All paranormal, I would go so far as to say most paranormal claims are not of a probabilistic nature -- and *that* is why those odds are not spelled out prior to a claim.
 
How big is the object, and how far would it move?

That's exactly the kind of questioning that goes on in the negotiations between the JREF and the subject. Not so easy to state definite odds ahead of time, is it?

There was a contestant who claimed to be able to make a candle flame move by telekinesis. I don't think she even got to official negotiation levels, just informal self-testing and discussion, but a forum search should bring it up. The odds were almost impossible to figure, because of course the candle flame was always flickering--and that's how she was fooling herself into thinking she was affecting it with her mind. I think the discussion was getting down to marked quadrants and amount of time leaning toward each quadrant or something, compared to random odds.

One generally thinks of telekinesis, like levitation, as a 100%, do-it-or-don't kind of ability, but she managed to reduce it to one of those 55% situations.
 
What I was specifically referring to in my quote above has to do with stating the EXACT ODDS that a person without any special abilities at all would have in passing both the "preliminary test", and the "formal test". One person (I'm forgetting his or her name) has talked about suggested probabilities for those tests, but hasn't responded to the question I gave him or her about calculating those odds.

I mentioned that the JREF rule of thumb seems to be that applicants should typically beat chance odds of 1:1000 in the preliminary test, in cases where such probabilistic success criteria are applicable, and said why that seems reasonable to me. As no-one has ever done so there is no precedent for the final test but the expectation seems to be that the success criteria would be set higher, though I've always thought a simple repeat of the first test would be adequate as that gives combined odds beaten of 1: 1,000,000.

I'm glad you're admitting that "there is no precedent for the final test". I've had SCADS of people complaining that this issue has supposedly been explained to me numerous times, even though I thought I had made it perfectly clear to everybody that I want the odds of successfully completing the entire thing (both the "preliminary" and the "final" tests) fully and completely stated. I hope this is now FINALLY understood, so I can stop having to go over this, over and over and over ad nauseum...

As for how these odds are calculated: I assume you're not asking which formulae are used, but how it is decided what a reasonable success criteria should be. I can't speak for JREF, but clearly a compromise between odds high enough that they won't end up mistakenly awarding the prize to someone who was just extremely lucky and low enough that a true paranormal ability won't be excluded is required. That compromise is a judgement call, which is why negotiation is necessary with each applicant to agree success criteria which are mutually acceptable.

I think if an applicant clearly states his claim at the beginning, that will automatically help determine the necessary parameters of the subsequent tests, assuming that they're always intended to achieve the same odds of success for a person who doesn't really have any "special abilities". For example, if a person says that he can "sense" a card drawn from a shuffled deck of playing cards, and he can do it correctly 1 out of every 30 times, it can be calculated straight away how many times he needs to do it correctly, to achieve better than 1:1000 odds. That's why I just don't like the word "negotiation" in this context. Don't "negotiate" with the guy, just listen to his claim, then plug the appropriate numbers into a mathematical formula, which then determines how long the tests will last.
 
"I don't really have a problem with making simple physical tests. I was only momentarily thrown for a loop when somebody talked about testing a person who claimed to be able to make somebody have to urinate! :) "

How was the test for induced urination not a simple physical test? And just so I can plan ahead, will this be a no true Scotsman response or more of a goalpost relocation (which you already just did in the above quote, by the way)?

I don't understand the second sentence of your question. Sorry.

That aside, though, it seems like your unrequited desire is that the Million Dollar Challenge be fair (whatever that means) to people with no claimed ability whatsoever. "I have no special power, but I'd like a shot at $1,000,000 on pure luck." That is not the purpose; it would be foolish to expect the JREF to cater to such a requirement.

I don't want it to be "fair" to a person who has no special ability. Not in the sense that he has a significant possibility of actually winning.
 
"How big is the object, and how far would it move?"

That's exactly the kind of questioning that goes on in the negotiations between the JREF and the subject. Not so easy to state definite odds ahead of time, is it?

No, of course not. But how many applicants ever make such claims? Do some of them ever stare at Brownian (sp?) motion through a microscope, and claim to be able to affect with their minds exactly how the microscopic particles of matter are colliding with each other, and changing each other's trajectories??

No, I doubt that happens very often. I think the typical claims by applicants have to do with more mundane issues, like they did with all the people on that TV show I talked about a few days ago; like that pretty woman who was given the set of keys (or whatever those things actually were), and told to "sense" the properties of each one. Every single applicant on that show was just like that.
 
Last edited:
Why don't they specify (and reveal) the exact terms beforehand? Why do they turn this into a guessing-game?

I'll give this one last try and then give up. There can be no exact terms beforehand because there are different paranormal claims. Mind-reading and dowsing and telekinesis and card-guessing et al are all different claims and cannot be proved or disproved using the same test. What part of that don't you understand?
 
It seems to me that your issue is that the test needs hard numbers attached to it before the applicant has even applied. People have tried to point out to you why that isn't in the applicant's best interest, and perhaps you just don't see it.


But, if you're interested, here are some threads on MDC statistics and probablility, and how they could be handled when an applicant realizes they aren't perfect.



http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=177657

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=133513

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=69495

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=61257

In the last one of these, you were there pretty much asking the same question you are now, so none of this may be new to you.
 
Bryan,

There are so many misunderstandings in this thread, but everybody who have have followed the MDC over the years should able to explain them to you. In fact, I think everything has already been said, but I will try to do it in my way.

First of all, the applicants hardly ever regard their abilities in terms of probabilities. Most of the times they claim they can do whatever they do all the time. But they also have a curious inability to explain just what they can do. Most of the correspondence with the applicants is used to pinpoint what it is that they claim. It happens all the time that they change their claims during the correspondence, particularly when the protocol is negotiated.

It has happened several times that the JREF negotiator is lowering the odds that the applicants suggests, because the JREF sees no need to make a huge number of tests when fewer will do. Odds lower than 1:1000 have also been offered by the JREF.

Although no applicant has ever reached the final test, it has been stated several times that the final test will be performed exactly as the preliminary test (presumably barring that obvious deficiencies in the protocol have been found). This means that the final odds will be 1:1,000,000, based on two tests at 1:1000 each.

The JREF is committed to test every paranormal claim, not just those of a probabilistic nature, which is why they test even silly things like psychically induced urination. They only reject claims that brings the claimant in danger, and breatharianism because testing it is cumbersome, and breatharians are invariably cheating. Previous exposure of breatharians has also not made these frauds less popular.

When calculating the odds it must be kept in mind that the JREF is testing people who usually claim they have this ability for sure. This is like testing if people can ride a bicycle. The test is constructed so that the odds of taking the test are extremely low if you cannot ride a bicycle, but if you can, there should be no problem whatsoever.
 
No, of course not. But how many applicants ever make such claims? Do some of them ever stare at Brownian (sp?) motion through a microscope, and claim to be able to affect with their minds exactly how the microscopic particles of matter are colliding with each other, and changing each other's trajectories??

No, I doubt that happens very often. I think the typical claims by applicants have to do with more mundane issues, like they did with all the people on that TV show I talked about a few days ago; like that pretty woman who was given the set of keys (or whatever those things actually were), and told to "sense" the properties of each one. Every single applicant on that show was just like that.

I mentioned the candle flame telekinesis applicant.

http://www.internationalskeptics.co...hp?t=31133&highlight=candle+flame+telekinesis

Enjoy. There was more discussion like that, but that's a sample.
 
I want the JREF to clearly state the chances of success (by ALL people) right up front. This business of "negotiation" is for the birds.

Why? The JREF can do whatever the hell they want. It's their challenge. The way it's done now is just fine; many tests have had protocols negotiated and tested.
 
"Why don't they specify (and reveal) the exact terms beforehand? Why do they turn this into a guessing-game?"

I'll give this one last try and then give up. There can be no exact terms beforehand because there are different paranormal claims. Mind-reading and dowsing and telekinesis and card-guessing et al are all different claims and cannot be proved or disproved using the same test. What part of that don't you understand?

I've repeated this over and over; I'll give this one last try to explain to you, and then give up: when I talk about "exact terms" like I did in that quotation above, I'm mostly referring to the EXACT ODDS OF WINNING (by a person with no special abilities). That would apply to mind-reading, dowsing, and card-guessing (not sure about telekinesis).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom