So who determines the ultimate success of my ability to identify random cards from a shuffled deck? James Randi, or somebody else? What is the required degree of success OVER what would be expected purely from chance? Why is all this material (the exact rules of the test) left completely unexplained by the JREF? Who exactly would I be dealing with??
Have you emailed the JREF this question? People here (well, the vast majority of them) are mere mortal forum users. We do not speak for the JREF.
I think I read somewhere that a general rule of thumb was that the preliminary and the final test should only be passed by mere chance in about 1/1000 cases each - so your chances of submitting the protocol about predicting the card without any paranormal ability would be at about one in a million.
Personally, I think they should be much higher.
People are essentially claiming they can do the impossible.
Say, e.g. I was posing my challenge to a group of tragically blind-from-birth three year olds. They cannot see, and they have no concept of seeing and they cannot read or have a concept that such a thing as letters exist.
Now I propose that i can tell what is on one of their audio-CDs without any of the usual methods: I will not play it, or even have access to a player, I will not know how or where the CD has been sorted, etc.
Of course, all I have to do is look at the CD and read what it says on top of the disk. How reliably would you think I could identify a CD that way - if it was assured that the selection that each CD was chosen from would be heterogeneous enough to make mix-ups and confusions highly unlikely?
Say there would be 20 CDs. Bringing them into some pre-defined order or naming each one correctly by chance alone would be 1:20! or 2.43290201 × 10
18.
My one-in-a-million chance would allow me to try and get only 10CDs sorted right, and I would get three tries and I would only have to get it all right once.
So, that being said, whenever someone starts arguing about their chances here, I can only conclude one of two things:
They do not understand the test procedures or they want to cheat.