Split Thread How are MDC protocols designed and carried out? (Split from FAQ thread)

What will you do if the JREF changes nothing and continues on without making answers to your questions abundantly clear beforehand to your satisfaction. Will this continue to bother you for the rest of your life? If so, how will you possibly deal with this? Is your level of botheredness something psychological therapy might be able to help with? How will you cope?
I'd be a lot happier if they simply made it clear at the start (before any testing at all) what the requirements for success actually are; somelike like: "You must beat a 1-in-1,000 odds test in the Preliminary, followed by a 1-in-5,000 odds test (or whatever) in the Final."
 
I recommend that the JREF _not_ test people who claim to be able to make people have to urinate.

I am sure every employee or supporter of the JREF has been waiting on your valuable advise on what to test. How did they ever get on without your wisdom?

Stick to matters of a more purely probabilistic nature, where more time is spent merely determining the odds of numerical success, and far less time is spent making sure that the rest of the test is fair.

And why the ******* should they or anyone else listen to you?
 
Bryan, if you have a specific paranormal ability you would like tested, just state your ability clearly and succinctly...If you have an ability, spit it out and let people help you figure out how to demonstrate it.

I don't have anything I'd like tested. I'm sorry if my general skepticism about JREF led you to suspect otherwise.
 
Last edited:
And what exactly does "pinning down" mean in this context? You mean PROVING his ability? Or simply explaining what his ability is supposed to be?

Explaining what his ability was supposed to be, as in how many different pictures, how many guesses, how many trials, whether runs would be counted as so many separate incidents or whether all guesses would be lumped together, that kind of thing.

He started out with a simple claim to be able to see hidden things, at well above chance levels, but gradually lowered his claim down to closer to chance, so it became more like the 55% ability you're talking about, thus requiring more trials to get an acceptable significance level.

I haven't read the threads since they were new, a few years ago, but as I recall, it was a lot of negotiations over probability theory, in response to self-tests that gave varying results. The threads should be all there to read, by searching on his name.
 
Bump for Bryan, who apparently missed this: [snip] No, JREF *negotiates* the answers to these questions beforehand (before the applicant agrees that the protocol is fair and the test something they can do -- and only *then* is the test scheduled).

Why does this bother you?

I'll be happy if they make the odds of success (by somebody with no "special" abilities at all) perfectly clear before every test. Perhaps even more importantly, such odds should remain the same for ALL such tests.
 
I'd be a lot happier if they simply made it clear at the start (before any testing at all) what the requirements for success actually are; somelike like: "You must beat a 1-in-1,000 odds test in the Preliminary, followed by a 1-in-5,000 odds test (or whatever) in the Final."

I'll have to look it up, but I read recently about the MDC that the preliminary was 1:1000 and the final was 1:1000000. If I have time I'll see if I can find the reference.

[ETA -- Here's a guy whining about it here: http://dailygrail.com/features/the-myth-of-james-randis-million-dollar-challenge

What everyone complaining about the odds is forgetting, is that the odds provided apply to success by chance! If the odds of randomly rolling 6 a die (d6) 10 times out of 100 is 1 in 10, the odds are significantly different for someone manipulating the die as it is being rolled (i.e. telekinetically.)]
 
Last edited:
Point 1:

Having re-read this thread from the beginning, I note that there has not been any discussion of this:

"[...] When random choices are a clear and obvious element of such a test (as many of them truly are) [....]"

Mr. Shelton, could you please explain what you mean by the highlighted statement?

Do you, for instance, mean that the applicant makes random choices?

That the JREF makes random choices?

That during a test, some random elements are introduced by the applicant or the JREF or just good old Ma Nature?

I was referring to the applicant. Since I don't believe in "special abilities" by any of them, I think ALL of their choices are random.

Point 2:

In any case, I am confused about why it is unfair to set a standard that in most cases is much lower that the applicants claim to be able to meet.

I say, "I can detect Substance Y, by whatever method, infallibly, 100% of the time. Never miss. Never. Not even when I have a hangover and a bad cold. Never."

JREF says, "That's fine. But we will be generous to you. We will allow 1 miss per 10 trials, for 10 10-trial sequences." *

How is that unfair? Does the answer relate to Point 1, above?

I want the JREF to clearly state the chances of success (by ALL people) right up front. This business of "negotiation" is for the birds.
 
I am sure every employee or supporter of the JREF has been waiting on your valuable advise on what to test. How did they ever get on without your wisdom?

And why the ******* should they or anyone else listen to you?

You're off my Christmas list! :D
 
I'll have to look it up, but I read recently about the MDC that the preliminary was 1:1000 and the final was 1:1000000. If I have time I'll see if I can find the reference.
Surely they realize, don't they, that the COMBINED chance of winning 1:1000 in the preliminary and 1:1000 in the final is 1:1000000?? Are they just playing it SUPER-safe with their money? :)
 
Surely they realize, don't they, that the COMBINED chance of winning 1:1000 in the preliminary and 1:1000 in the final is 1:1000000?? Are they just playing it SUPER-safe with their money? :)

You still seem to be missing the point that those odds only apply to winning the prize by chance. The applicants are claiming to have an ability that means they perform a lot better than chance. If they can do anything remotely like what they claim, they will pass the test easily, because of the way the test is designed and agreed between the JREF and the applicant.
 
I'd be a lot happier if they simply made it clear at the start (before any testing at all) what the requirements for success actually are; somelike like: "You must beat a 1-in-1,000 odds test in the Preliminary, followed by a 1-in-5,000 odds test (or whatever) in the Final."
Thanks for your reply, Bryan.

Please understand that your happiness is something the JREF is probably not too interested in. Mr. Randi has challenged those who make extraordinary claims. It is his challenge and he gets to make the rules, as he and his organization have put up the substantial amount of money for the prize. That you don't like the terms is something you'll have to deal with. Good luck.
 
I recommend that the JREF _not_ test people who claim to be able to make people have to urinate. Stick to matters of a more purely probabilistic nature, where more time is spent merely determining the odds of numerical success, and far less time is spent making sure that the rest of the test is fair.

So, telekinesis, clairvoyance, and a host of other paranormal abilities shouldn't be testable under your ruling?

I don't have anything I'd like tested. I'm sorry if my general skepticism about JREF led you to suspect otherwise.

I haven't notice much general skepticism, just mostly kvetching from you. I'm not sure why you'd mistake one for the other.
 
I'd be a lot happier if they simply made it clear at the start (before any testing at all) what the requirements for success actually are; somelike like: "You must beat a 1-in-1,000 odds test in the Preliminary, followed by a 1-in-5,000 odds test (or whatever) in the Final."
Which is exactly what happens.

What doesn't happen is making clear what the requirements are before they even know what the paranormal claim is.
 
I'll be happy if they make the odds of success (by somebody with no "special" abilities at all) perfectly clear before every test.
Which they do.
Perhaps even more importantly, such odds should remain the same for ALL such tests.
All tests of the same claimed ability *do* have, *must* have the same odds.

You appear to want the same odds regardless of what the ability is, and that is not possible.

If the claimed ability is to be able to levitate unassisted 12 feet off the ground indefinitely, the odds approach unity against. The odds of knowing a 2 digit number, randomly chosen are 1:100 against. What would be fair in the first case would be grossly unfair in the second.
 
Last edited:
Which they do.

All tests of the same claimed ability *do* have, *must* have the same odds.

You appear to want the same odds regardless of what the ability is, and that is not possible.

If the claimed ability is to be able to levitate unassisted 12 feet off the ground indefinitely, the odds approach unity against. The odds of knowing a 2 digit number, randomly chosen are 1:100 against. What would be fair in the first case would be grossly unfair in the second.

What Bryan Shelton seems to be saying is that levitation should not be tested. Only tests that are essentially guessing games should be allowed.

Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Ward
 
It seems perfectly reasonable to me that the JREF would first do a "preliminary test" (as "Pixel42" talked about in a later post this morning) which would require approximately a 1 in 1,000 chance (or less) of passing purely by chance. If the applicant passes it, a somewhat more rigorous test could then be part of the "formal test", which determines the fate of the million dollar prize. The first "preliminary test" would be the obvious way to avoid "wasting time" by applicants who don't have any real ability.

Well, Bryan, this would be entirely reasonable if not for the fact that... no, wait... YOU JUST DESCRIBED THE EXACT JREF TESTING PROCEDURE!
 
I was referring to the applicant. Since I don't believe in "special abilities" by any of them, I think ALL of their choices are random.

But surely you see that the applicants do believe in their "special abilities." That means that for them these are not random choices. They think they are being guided by their special abilities.

That's why they claim -- at least initially -- that they never miss an identification of a photo or of a substance, or that they can dowse for water reliably (by which they usually mean much higher than 55% of the time), or can always make a spoon bend by mental ability alone.

The goal of the statistical design of the test is to eliminate success by pure luck or chance. The goal of the physical design of the test is to eliminate success by cheating.

This is the equivalent of saying that the JREF wants any success to be a clear demonstration of the claimed ability. Looked at in that light, one could say that the JREF is giving the applicant every opportunity to clearly and unequivocally demonstrate his or her ability.

That's different from saying that the JREF is setting out to ensure that the candidate fails the test.

If I have misrepresented your meaning or if I have not been clear, please correct me or ask for clarification.

Xterra
 
Last edited:
But surely you see that the applicants do believe in their "special abilities." That means that for them these are not random choices. They think they are being guided by their special abilities.

That's why they claim -- at least initially -- that they never miss an identification of a photo or of a substance, or that they can dowse for water reliably (by which they usually mean much higher than 55% of the time), or can always make a spoon bend by mental ability alone.

The goal of the statistical design of the test is to eliminate success by pure luck or chance. The goal of the physical design of the test is to eliminate success by cheating.

This is the equivalent of saying that the JREF wants any success to be a clear demonstration of the claimed ability. Looked at in that light, one could say that the JREF is giving the applicant every opportunity to clearly and unequivocally demonstrate his or her ability.

That's different from saying that the JREF is setting out to ensure that the candidate fails the test.

If I have misrepresented your meaning or if I have not been clear, please correct me or ask for clarification.

Xterra

Well said, that's about as clear as I think anyone could possibly make it.
 
"Surely they realize, don't they, that the COMBINED chance of winning 1:1000 in the preliminary and 1:1000 in the final is 1:1000000?? Are they just playing it SUPER-safe with their money? :)"

You still seem to be missing the point that those odds only apply to winning the prize by chance. The applicants are claiming to have an ability that means they perform a lot better than chance. If they can do anything remotely like what they claim, they will pass the test easily, because of the way the test is designed and agreed between the JREF and the applicant.

Of course! That's obvious!! I personally don't believe that the applicants have any special ability; if their claim is actually correct, then they DESERVE to win the prize and collect the million dollars. So what exactly is YOUR point? :confused:
 
"I'd be a lot happier if they simply made it clear at the start (before any testing at all) what the requirements for success actually are; somelike like: 'You must beat a 1-in-1,000 odds test in the Preliminary, followed by a 1-in-5,000 odds test (or whatever) in the Final.' "

Thanks for your reply, Bryan.

Please understand that your happiness is something the JREF is probably not too interested in. Mr. Randi has challenged those who make extraordinary claims. It is his challenge and he gets to make the rules, as he and his organization have put up the substantial amount of money for the prize. That you don't like the terms is something you'll have to deal with. Good luck.

Why don't they specify (and reveal) the exact terms beforehand? Why do they turn this into a guessing-game?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom