"Surely they realize, don't they, that the COMBINED chance of winning 1:1000 in the preliminary and 1:1000 in the final is 1:1000000?? Are they just playing it SUPER-safe with their money?

"
You still seem to be missing the point that those odds only apply to winning the prize
by chance. The applicants are claiming to have an ability that means they perform a lot better than chance. If they can do anything remotely like what they claim, they will pass the test easily, because of the way the test is designed and
agreed between the JREF and the applicant.