Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

What about it needs supporting? Do you not understand the power he had over her? Do you not know about the sexual relationship they had?

You really just can't answer a straight question, can you?

Ok then. Your claim is dismissed.

Do you not know what negative consequences she experienced?

Completely irrelevant, as I stated earlier and you ignored.
 
You really just can't answer a straight question, can you?

It isn’t a straight question at all. It’s an ambiguous question, perfect for moving the goalpost if I address one aspect but not another, and your refusal to clarify it proves that it was asked dishonestly.
 
It isn’t a straight question at all. It’s an ambiguous question, perfect for moving the goalpost if I address one aspect but not another, and your refusal to clarify it proves that it was asked dishonestly.

What the **** are you on about? I asked a specific question about how he abused her, over and over, and you kept moving the discussion to other things, making vague implications and asking questions rather than answering mine. Calling me dishonest when you're refusing to support your own claims is pretty damned low, even for you.

Remember that little incident a short while ago when you lost your **** because I guessed at your reaction in a hypothetical and you acted all outraged and stuff? I gave you the benefit of the doubt then, but it's clear that all this is just a game for you. Don't expect any quarter in the future. War.
 
So Hillary Clinton should be removed from the office she doesn't hold because 20 years ago her husband had consensual sex with the chubby intern who brought him the mail which proves hypocrisy between feminism and... other feminism I guess so Hillary Clinton would be a hypocrite for being the first female President which would make her a feminist icon.
 
So Hillary Clinton should be removed from the office she doesn't hold because 20 years ago her husband had consensual sex with the chubby intern who brought him the mail which proves hypocrisy between feminism and... other feminism I guess so Hillary Clinton would be a hypocrite for being the first female President which would make her a feminist icon.

She can't have consensual sex with him, apparently, because he was POTUS. I wonder if that applied to his wife, too.
 
What the **** are you on about? I asked a specific question about how he abused her

And I told you, but you didn't accept my answer and won't say what about my answer either confuses or doesn't satisfy you. How can I possibly respond?

Remember that little incident a short while ago when you lost your **** because I guessed at your reaction in a hypothetical and you acted all outraged and stuff? I gave you the benefit of the doubt then, but it's clear that all this is just a game for you. Don't expect any quarter in the future. War.

I have never accused you of doing anything even remotely like what you accused me of doing. If you want war, fine. But don't even pretend that this is in any way equivalent.
 
She can't have consensual sex with him, apparently, because he was POTUS. I wonder if that applied to his wife, too.

It's almost as if there are shades of nuance between a healthy, consensual relationship and forcible rape.
 
And I told you, but you didn't accept my answer and won't say what about my answer either confuses or doesn't satisfy you. How can I possibly respond?

With evidence of abuse. You didn't, or won't, so I can only reach one conclusion.

I have never accused you of doing anything even remotely like what you accused me of doing. If you want war, fine. But don't even pretend that this is in any way equivalent.

I'm not saying it's equivalent. I'm saying that you have no desire to discuss honestly and with the goal of clarification and mutual understanding in mind. It's a game where you score points, and I won't play that.

And obviously you shouldn't expect tanks at your doorsteps any time soon. But from this time forward all of your claims and arguments are considered false and self-serving. This is your doing, not mine.
 
So Hillary Clinton should be removed from the office she doesn't hold

What the hell are you talking about? Nobody said anything about removing Hillary from any office.

because 20 years ago her husband had consensual sex with the chubby intern who brought him the mail which proves hypocrisy between feminism and... other feminism I guess so Hillary Clinton would be a hypocrite for being the first female President which would make her a feminist icon.

Again, it's not Bill's affair which is the problem for Hillary. It's her own response to the affair which is the problem. She won't even acknowledge the harm that Bill did to Lewinsky. If you think that isn't a problem for someone claiming feminist credentials, then you don't actually have any standards.
 
With evidence of abuse. You didn't, or won't, so I can only reach one conclusion.

When someone exercises their power to harm someone else, that's abuse. Bill harmed Lewinsky by having an affair with her, an affair in which his power over her was inextricably entwined. What about that confuses you?

And obviously you shouldn't expect tanks at your doorsteps any time soon. But from this time forward all of your claims and arguments are considered false and self-serving. This is your doing, not mine.

And how is that any different from how you've always behaved?
 
Last edited:
Oh save it. You're holding up one strawman version of feminist against another strawman version of feminism to trap someone in a "gotcha" of hypocrisy. Don't lecture me on my standards.

You're one step from "The only standard that matters is faithless devotion to whatever I define your category as" Bobbing.
 
When someone exercises their power to harm someone else, that's abuse. Bill harmed Lewinsky by having an affair with her, an affair in which his power over her was inextricably entwined. What about that confuses you?

I'm not confused. You're just wrong. The very fact that she was, in your words, harmed by the publicity doesn't retroactively make his relationship with her abuse.

And how is that any different from how you've always behaved?

Completely.
 
Oh save it. You're holding up one strawman version of feminist against another strawman version of feminism to trap someone in a "gotcha" of hypocrisy. Don't lecture me on my standards.

You're one step from "The only standard that matters is faithless devotion to whatever I define your category as" Bobbing.

Considering that I'm not working with more than one version of feminism, your response doesn't even make any sense.
 
I'm not confused. You're just wrong. The very fact that she was, in your words, harmed by the publicity doesn't retroactively make his relationship with her abuse.

You seem to think that if the affair had remained a secret, no harm would have resulted. I do not believe this is true. From the start, I think she was under pressure to try to keep it a secret, and that this pressure was itself harmful, and would have continued to be even had it remained a secret to this day.

But regardless, this is a disagreement about my conclusion, it's no longer a claim that I haven't provided evidence for my position. So I'm glad you've finally managed to move past that nonsense.

Completely.

Evidence?
 
You seem to think that if the affair had remained a secret, no harm would have resulted. I do not believe this is true. From the start, I think she was under pressure to try to keep it a secret, and that this pressure was itself harmful, and would have continued to be even had it remained a secret to this day.

Wow, pressure to keep an affair with the married President of the United States a secret? I guess that pressure can only come from him! :rolleyes:

But regardless, this is a disagreement about my conclusion, it's no longer a claim that I haven't provided evidence for my position.

Oh, it's still that. You haven't. You've played with words and definitions in order to make it inevitable, but don't think I haven't noticed.

Evidence?

Well we already have evidence from your behaviour and mine, and since I know that I don't play this nonsense game, and I don't care for your own interpretation of my own thoughts, and that I'm satisfied by years of evidence that you do play that game, there.
 
Wow, pressure to keep an affair with the married President of the United States a secret? I guess that pressure can only come from him! :rolleyes:

It doesn't have to only come from him. Are you seriously claiming that there was no pressure from him to keep the affair a secret?

Well we already have evidence from your behaviour and mine

Your claim was about how you would respond to me in the future, and it supposedly being different from how you have responded to me in the past. That claim is solely about your own behavior, and as such my behavior, no matter what it is, cannot possibly constitute evidence for it.

You keep demanding evidence from me, but you don't even understand what evidence is.
 
It doesn't have to only come from him.

No but it has to come from him at least in part. But we both know you have no evidence of this. You just assume that it's there because he has power.

Your claim was about how you would respond to me in the future, and it supposedly being different from how you have responded to me in the past.

Ah, yes. Well, in the past I gave you the benefit of the doubt that if I, somehow, found the right way to approach the questions and arguments, I could, maybe, expect an honest answer that would address facts and set aside partisan politics. That benefit is lost now. Is that clearer?

You keep demanding evidence from me, but you don't even understand what evidence is.

That's just an attack without substance. Since you have not provided evidence, you're in no position to say this.
 
Hillery Clinton is not done. I am actually going to go look at her position other than the one laughing and pointing on a roll of toilet paper.

Where she stands on the issues right now. I am going to do a total of each one and see how closely we align. Then I will do President Trump to see how closely I align.http://ontheissues.org/hillary_clinton.htm

I am 45/30 in agreement with Hillary's position on abortion
7/1 in agreement with her position on contraception
8/2 on voting record on abortion and contraception
12/1 in favor of her position on the economy
I like her overall position on the national debt
Am in agreement with her voting record on economy and debt
Am in agreement with her stance on civil rights and her voting record

Yes, I might vote again for her.
President Donald trump

http://www.ontheissues.org/Donald_Trump.htm
 
Last edited:
No but it has to come from him at least in part.

And it did.

But we both know you have no evidence of this.

You're wrong, as usual. For example:
http://www.cnn.com/ALLPOLITICS/1998/resources/lewinsky/timeline/
"Dec. 28: Lewinsky makes her final visit to the White House, according to White House logs, and was signed in by Currie. Lewinsky reportedly met privately with Clinton and he allegedly encouraged her to be "evasive" in her answers in the Jones' lawsuit."

You just assume that it's there because he has power.

How on earth could she NOT feel pressure to keep quiet? Even if he never said anything, she would know that since the affair was secret and would cause him problems if it became public that he would want her to keep it secret. The mere possibility that he might react badly if she exposed it would create pressure. It's intrinsic to the situation.

Ah, yes. Well, in the past I gave you the benefit of the doubt that if I, somehow, found the right way to approach the questions and arguments, I could, maybe, expect an honest answer that would address facts and set aside partisan politics. That benefit is lost now. Is that clearer?

And will this produce any observable change? I'll accept your word that something inside your head changed, but I see no evidence that anything external will.

That's just an attack without substance.

Wrong again. It is an attack with substance.
 
You're wrong, as usual. For example:
http://www.cnn.com/ALLPOLITICS/1998/resources/lewinsky/timeline/
"Dec. 28: Lewinsky makes her final visit to the White House, according to White House logs, and was signed in by Currie. Lewinsky reportedly met privately with Clinton and he allegedly encouraged her to be "evasive" in her answers in the Jones' lawsuit."

That's well after the facts, though. You said "from the start".

How on earth could she NOT feel pressure to keep quiet?

That was my question to you. Affairs are, generally, secret. Both participants will want that. So in and of itself it doesn't support your claim that he was pressured by him.

And will this produce any observable change?

It sure will for me. Whether it will for you is not my business.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom