Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

It's almost as if there are shades of nuance between a healthy, consensual relationship and forcible rape.

Somewhere along that scale, it stops being about sex and instead it's about power. Rapists aren't just horny; they are trying to compensate for feelings of inadequacy by exercising dominance over the victim.
 
Somewhere along that scale, it stops being about sex and instead it's about power.

This is an article of feminist dogma, but it's not supported by evidence. Whatever role power may play in rape, there was never actually any reason to think it stops being about sex as well. That was simply asserted as an article of faith, and it's contradicted by the actual evidence.
 
That's well after the facts, though. You said "from the start".

For the sake of argument, let's suppose that's the case, that Lewinsky never felt any pressure at the start of the affair. She felt it at the end (or, if you insist, after). That pressure did her harm.

It sure will for me. Whether it will for you is not my business.

Then why did you bother telling me? You obviously thought I should know because you told me, but why would I care if it's only something that happens inside your head?
 
For the sake of argument, let's suppose that's the case, that Lewinsky never felt any pressure at the start of the affair. She felt it at the end (or, if you insist, after). That pressure did her harm.

Yeah well, that happens in life. People feel pressure and do stuff and regret it. If the pressure came from him, especially if he pressured her into the relationship, we'd be talking. But so far that's not in evidence.

Then why did you bother telling me?

I'm sorry, what?
 
So Hillary Clinton should be removed from the office she doesn't hold because 20 years ago her husband had consensual sex with the chubby intern who brought him the mail which proves hypocrisy between feminism and... other feminism I guess so Hillary Clinton would be a hypocrite for being the first female President which would make her a feminist icon.
The word "chubby" is unnecessary and insulting. You are attacking Lewinsky's appearance for no reason.
 
Yeah well, that happens in life. People feel pressure and do stuff and regret it. If the pressure came from him

And it did.

But so far that's not in evidence.

I just gave you evidence of that. How can I take your requests for evidence seriously when you simply ignore the evidence I provide?

I'm sorry, what?

Figures. Never mind, your pique isn't worth further investigation.
 
So far it appears that we can't vote for Hillary because Bill had a consensual affair decades ago. Affairs are usually desired to be kept secret by both parties, so because Bill asked Lewinsky to be evasive this constitutes evidence of harm...somehow. So Hillary is the worst because of it...somehow. So we shouldn't vote for her despite the fact that she is not running.

Man, you would think that after decades of practice, conservatives would be better at making their case against Hillary.
 
So far it appears that we can't vote for Hillary because Bill had a consensual affair decades ago. Affairs are usually desired to be kept secret by both parties, so because Bill asked Lewinsky to be evasive this constitutes evidence of harm...somehow. So Hillary is the worst because of it...somehow. So we shouldn't vote for her despite the fact that she is not running.

Man, you would think that after decades of practice, conservatives would be better at making their case against Hillary.

May I rebut:

304 to 227

mayhap they are much better than one gives them credit for
 
So far it appears that we can't vote for Hillary because Bill had a consensual affair decades ago.

You can vote for whomever you like. Voting for her because she's a feminist icon is purified stupidity, but you can still do it, and you can also have other more sensible reasons for voting for her.

Of course, she's never going to win, but that's a separate matter.
 
You can vote for whomever you like. Voting for her because she's a feminist icon is purified stupidity, but you can still do it, and you can also have other more sensible reasons for voting for her.

Of course, she's never going to win, but that's a separate matter.

It's quite hard to win when you don't run. But hey, it's almost Halloween, and I know people like to bring out their scary boogeymen, so carry on.
 
Bwahahahahahaha!

Have you not been paying any attention to feminist concepts of consent and power?

Do you know why sex between prison guards and inmates is automatically and always considered rape?

Note that I’m not saying Bill raped Lewinsky, but he absolutely abused her.

A White House intern is equivalent to an inmate, and the President equivalent to a prison guard??:confused:
 
A White House intern is equivalent to an inmate, and the President equivalent to a prison guard??:confused:

Do keep up.

Prison guards cannot legally have sex with prisoners. It is always rape. And it is always rape because the power that guards have over prisoners makes consent impossible.

Bill's power over Monica wasn't as extreme, which is why his affair wasn't a crime. But that power differential does still make the claim of her consenting a bit problematic.
 
This is an article of feminist dogma, but it's not supported by evidence. Whatever role power may play in rape, there was never actually any reason to think it stops being about sex as well. That was simply asserted as an article of faith, and it's contradicted by the actual evidence.
That's not actual evidence, that's an extended assumption of what evidence means. Actual evidence would be physiological response testing of men in a state of mind where they expect an opportunity to rape.
 
That's not actual evidence, that's an extended assumption of what evidence means. Actual evidence would be physiological response testing of men in a state of mind where they expect an opportunity to rape.

It's indirect evidence, and it's not proof, but it is absolutely still evidence.

Your choice of analogy was absurd.

It was an extreme example of how power can affect consent. I never said it was a direct parallel to Clinton and Lewinsky, but if one is sensible (perhaps an unjustified assumption in this forum), one can extrapolate from an extreme condition to a less extreme one where power differentials don't totally negate consent but certainly weaken it.
 
See, implications rather than evidence.

It could have been improper because there's a higher chance than it was than in usual relationships.

That's pretty weak.
 
See, implications rather than evidence.

It could have been improper because there's a higher chance than it was than in usual relationships.

That's pretty weak.

That's not how it works. It's not a probability of being OK or not OK. It's 100% not OK for a president to be having sex with an intern, it's just a less bad not OK than the extreme example, one which doesn't require legal sanctions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom