Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

I quoted you right there!

Your quote doesn't demonstrate that I invented a new standard of evidence.

Yep. As usual you're completely unwilling to support your own claims.

Not so. For example, I already supported my claim about Hillary's entitlement. But the evidence for Broaddrick's accusations are well-trodden territory, and if you actually care about the subject, create a new thread and I'll swing by.

I asked, didn't I? People have been screaming about Bill's guilt for years but have never provided evidence.

That's really not true. Hell, we could even stick to just Lewinsky where the proof was actual DNA and Bill comes out badly.

Sorry, your disagreement about what's reasonable doesn't invalidate my argument.

Correct. What invalidates your argument is that you're wrong about what's reasonable. Me pointing it out doesn't actually change anything.
 
Oh well we'll just sit here and in only a few thousand pages perfectly define "feminism" as singular thing with a singular, approved opinion about everything and then we can continue the discussion. No sweat.

If Hillary had won she'd have been the first female President. That would have kind of been a big deal for "feminism" of any definition. She could of wiped her ass with a copy of the "Feminist Manifesto" at her inauguration and shown up to every press conference barefoot and pregnant in a gingham dress and only passed legislation about which member of One Direction is the cutest and still been a "Feminist Icon."
 
Last edited:
Oh well we'll just sit here and in only a few thousand pages perfectly define "feminism" as singular thing with a singular, approved opinion about everything and then we can continue the discussion. No sweat.

If Hillary had won she'd have been the first female President. That would have kind of been a big deal for "feminism" of any definition. She could of wiped her ass with a copy of the "Feminist Manifesto" at her inauguration and shown up to every press conference barefoot and pregnant in a gingham dress and only passed legislation about which member of One Direction is the cutest and still been a "Feminist Icon."

To the extent that this is true (and note that I'm not disputing it), it reveals the absurdity of identity politics.
 
To the extent that this is true (and note that I'm not disputing it), it reveals the absurdity of identity politics.

I don't get your point. You seem to be taking Hillary Clinton to task for not living up to an "identity" you've foisted on her.

Hillary Clinton didn't run on a campaign of "Real Feminist don't Tolerate Infidelity!" so I don't get your "gotcha."
 
Cards on the table: I'm agnostic about the Bill Clinton sexual assault allegations. As far as I'm concerned, about the only things we reasonably know are that he had an affair with Monica Lewinsky, and he lied about it under oath. Up until recently, I would have said it was wrong to hold any of the other allegations against him.

There are people who talk with metaphysical certainty about similar allegations against Donald Trump and Brett Kavanaugh (to name two recent examples). I think that certainty is mistaken, for the same reason I think it would be mistaken to talk about Clinton with the same certainty.

However. Some people insist on being that certain. And I think if you're going to insist on certainty about Trump and Kavanaugh, then we should insist that you express the same certainty towards Clinton. In fact, we should insist on the same certainty towards Clinton as a prerequisite for expressing that certainty about others in a similar situation. Otherwise it's just special pleading.

And I think that's one of the problems Hillary Clinton created for herself. Everybody could see her double standard, her empty words. "Believe the victim." Sure, Hillary. Unless they're accusing your husband. Then it's an exercise in how quickly you can line them up against the wall.

Conservatives see that double standard, and know what's in it for them, if they vote for Hillary. They know they're in for hypocrisy - not just the hypocrisy that excuses one's own bad behavior, but a hypocrisy that does not hesitate to use the tools of power to behave badly against you. I think this perception probably cost Hillary at least as many moderate votes as any Russian ad campaign.

I think it probably cost her some progressive votes as well.

Is Bill Clinton a rapist? I don't know. Should we talk about him as if he is a rapist? I kinda think that right here, right now, we probably should.

And I think that Hillary Clinton and her fans especially need to take a close look at her double standard, what it's costing them, and what she needs to do to fix it.
 
Last edited:
I don't get your point. You seem to be taking Hillary Clinton to task for not living up to an "identity" you've foisted on her.

I didn't foist it upon her. She tried to claim it herself.

Hillary Clinton didn't run on a campaign of "Real Feminist don't Tolerate Infidelity!" so I don't get your "gotcha."

Pay more attention then. It's not that feminists cannot "tolerate" infidelity (which is really only part of the problem with Bill's actions), it's that feminism doesn't consider these issues to be purely personal. And that's why the issue has to be addressed, and not simply brushed aside as being a private matter.
 
I didn't foist it upon her. She tried to claim it herself.

Hillary Clinton might have, within contexts, promoted herself as a "Feminist Icon" but not as some crusader against infidelity or anything like that.

You're the one pointing at the two things saying there has to be a connection, not her.

Pay more attention then. It's not that feminists cannot "tolerate" infidelity (which is really only part of the problem with Bill's actions), it's that feminism doesn't consider these issues to be purely personal. And that's why the issue has to be addressed, and not simply brushed aside as being a private matter.

What? "Feminism doesn't consider...." what does that even mean?
 
However. Some people insist on being that certain. And I think if you're going to insist on certainty about Trump and Kavanaugh, then we should insist that you express the same certainty towards Clinton.

You're speaking about this as if it was binary: either you don't know anything, or you know things with 100% certainty. But that's not realistic.

In fact, we should insist on the same certainty towards Clinton as a prerequisite for expressing that certainty about others in a similar situation. Otherwise it's just special pleading.

Belz is trying to make this argument, but he's wrong. And he's wrong because the situations really aren't the same. Yes, Broaddrick's accusations haven't been proven beyond any doubt. But unlike Ford's accusations, for which there is zero corroboration, there is in fact corroboration for much of Broaddrick's accusations. They really aren't similar in that regard. It doesn't require special pleading to understand that difference.
 
Okay and? Fine I believe you, whatever. Every side is horrible and full of evil rapist. That means all sides are horrible it doesn't mean that your side wins.

I will never, never understand this whole "If I can prove the other side is a hypocrite everything bad they said about my side goes away" thing.

Proving Hillary or Bill the the Democratic 3rd Assistant Dog Walker from Skokie, Illinois eats babies doesn't make everything a Democrat has said about Trump or Kavanaugh untrue.
 
Last edited:
Hillary Clinton might have, within contexts, promoted herself as a "Feminist Icon" but not as some crusader against infidelity or anything like that.

Once again, infidelity is only part of it, and in the current political atmosphere, not even the most important part.

What? "Feminism doesn't consider...." what does that even mean?

In short, she can't hide behind privacy. Her husband's actions have public and political significance. She has to address them publicly if she wants to run for office.
 
Okay and? Fine I believe you, whatever. Every side is horrible and full of evil rapist. That means all sides are horrible it doesn't mean that your side wins.

Not at all. This is quite specific to Bill and Hillary, I never claimed anything about Democrats in general. I have a lot of complaints about Obama, and overall I think he was a lot worse as a president than Bill was, but I've never heard of any sexual misbehavior on his part.
 
You're speaking about this as if it was binary: either you don't know anything, or you know things with 100% certainty. But that's not realistic.
I agree. However, I think it's important to stake out the boundary-lines of the debate. Once we agree on the approximate placement of the lines, we can have a good-faith debate about where inside the lines we reasonably land.

Belz is trying to make this argument, but he's wrong. And he's wrong because the situations really aren't the same. Yes, Broaddrick's accusations haven't been proven beyond any doubt. But unlike Ford's accusations, for which there is zero corroboration, there is in fact corroboration for much of Broaddrick's accusations. They really aren't similar in that regard. It doesn't require special pleading to understand that difference.
There are real differences, and it isn't special pleading to note those differences and reason accordingly.

It is however, special pleading to condemn Kavanaugh over allegations that you dismiss in Clinton's case, even though those allegations are more credible in Clinton's case.
 
:rolleyes:;)

LnKZOe3.jpg
 
One thing Hillary is winning, though, is your eternal and undivided attention.

I seriously think she said that to piss off Trump. Either that or the DNC asked her to say it so she could run interference for all the other candidate hopefuls.




Hill and Bill on Tour next month!! Be sure and get your tickets while they last!!!
 
I love how after saying "no" twice, and the audience not getting it, she gave a more political answer which was pretty much "I'd have liked to do it think I can, but it's not happening" and now everyone is like "Hillary id running for 2020!"

Oh well, at least the GOP will keep looking the wrong way for the next two years. I am sure that some will keep believing she will run until Nov 6th 2020.
 
SNIP
And I think that Hillary Clinton and her fans especially need to take a close look at her double standard, what it's costing them, and what she needs to do to fix it.

The allegations against Clinton were investigated for far longer in far greater depth.

'Believe' is not a binary, but a spectrum. Argument by slogan pitfalls abound yet again.

Bill Clinton wasn't running for office, making the standard at best one level abstracted.

But yes, the optics are an issue. It is amusing that even though the Dems are FAR ahead of the Republicans on this issue, the faults that the latter have hurt them more.
 
Oh well we'll just sit here and in only a few thousand pages perfectly define "feminism" as singular thing with a singular, approved opinion about everything and then we can continue the discussion. No sweat.

If Hillary had won she'd have been the first female President. That would have kind of been a big deal for "feminism" of any definition. She could of wiped her ass with a copy of the "Feminist Manifesto" at her inauguration and shown up to every press conference barefoot and pregnant in a gingham dress and only passed legislation about which member of One Direction is the cutest and still been a "Feminist Icon."
Technically, I doubt she could show up pregnant, but that's mere biology.
 
Cards on the table: I'm agnostic about the Bill Clinton sexual assault allegations. As far as I'm concerned, about the only things we reasonably know are that he had an affair with Monica Lewinsky, and he lied about it under oath. Up until recently, I would have said it was wrong to hold any of the other allegations against him.

There are people who talk with metaphysical certainty about similar allegations against Donald Trump and Brett Kavanaugh (to name two recent examples). I think that certainty is mistaken, for the same reason I think it would be mistaken to talk about Clinton with the same certainty.

However. Some people insist on being that certain. And I think if you're going to insist on certainty about Trump and Kavanaugh, then we should insist that you express the same certainty towards Clinton. In fact, we should insist on the same certainty towards Clinton as a prerequisite for expressing that certainty about others in a similar situation. Otherwise it's just special pleading.

And I think that's one of the problems Hillary Clinton created for herself. Everybody could see her double standard, her empty words. "Believe the victim." Sure, Hillary. Unless they're accusing your husband. Then it's an exercise in how quickly you can line them up against the wall.

Conservatives see that double standard, and know what's in it for them, if they vote for Hillary. They know they're in for hypocrisy - not just the hypocrisy that excuses one's own bad behavior, but a hypocrisy that does not hesitate to use the tools of power to behave badly against you. I think this perception probably cost Hillary at least as many moderate votes as any Russian ad campaign.

I think it probably cost her some progressive votes as well.

Is Bill Clinton a rapist? I don't know. Should we talk about him as if he is a rapist? I kinda think that right here, right now, we probably should.

And I think that Hillary Clinton and her fans especially need to take a close look at her double standard, what it's costing them, and what she needs to do to fix it.
I mostly agree, but it is Kavanaugh's performance which sealed the deal for me. He was overtly partisan, which is not appropriate for a justice, and he literally lied under oath, by insisting that others denied this happened, rather than that they denied recalling it.

This is not a subtle point for a judge. Perhaps forgivable be a layman but not a judge.

Not positive about what happened that night, but I'm sure this man shouldn't be on the highest bench.

ETA: not sure why we should pretend that Clinton is a rapist. That bit seems self indulgent.
 
Last edited:
MOD: “Cory Booker… What do you think about him saying kick them in shins essentially?” HILLARY: “That was Eric Holder.”
MOD: “Oh, Eric Holder, I’m sorry.”
HILLARY: “I know they all look alike.”

HOLY ****. Racist piece of ****
 
MOD: “Cory Booker… What do you think about him saying kick them in shins essentially?” HILLARY: “That was Eric Holder.”
MOD: “Oh, Eric Holder, I’m sorry.”
HILLARY: “I know they all look alike.”

HOLY ****. Racist piece of ****


Kara Swisher: "What do you think of Cory Booker saying kick them?"

Hillary Clinton: "Well that was Eric Holder. Yeah, I know they all look alike."

[Video Clip] (Oct 26, 2018)


If Trump had said the exact same thing, liberal heads would explode.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom