Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

None of this supports the claim. What about Obama's message? Did that convey the idea that he deserved the be president? Yes, of course, because that's the whole point of political campaigns.

Try harder.

There's a big difference between "wants" and "deserves." Clinton's own staff was unable to explain why she should be President. Believe whatever you want.
 
You say that like courtroom verdicts are the only way to figure out anything.

It's interesting how the standard of evidence changes depending on if the accused is a Republican or a Democrat.

It almost sounds as if the standard is "Do I want to believe this?". If we don't condemn Kavanaugh for accusations that are unproven, why should we treat Clinton differently?
 
There's a big difference between "wants" and "deserves." Clinton's own staff was unable to explain why she should be President. Believe whatever you want.

Who said anything about "want"? You're the one who just added that to the conversation. My question is simple: at any point, did Clinton herself ever indicate that she thought she was "due" the Presidency? Not that she wanted it or deserved it, as I assume that almost all presidential candidates think both.
 
It's interesting how the standard of evidence changes depending on if the accused is a Republican or a Democrat.

It almost sounds as if the standard is "Do I want to believe this?". If we don't condemn Kavanaugh for accusations that are unproven, why should we treat Clinton differently?

You claim that the standard of evidence has changed, but ironically you provide no evidence of any such change.

Unlike Ford, Broaddrick actually had corroborating evidence for her accusations. The two cases are not actually remotely similar in that regard.
 
Who said anything about "want"? You're the one who just added that to the conversation. My question is simple: at any point, did Clinton herself ever indicate that she thought she was "due" the Presidency? Not that she wanted it or deserved it, as I assume that almost all presidential candidates think both.

Her campaign did (see my previous links). It's a reasonable inference that she did as well.
 
Who said anything about "want"? You're the one who just added that to the conversation. My question is simple: at any point, did Clinton herself ever indicate that she thought she was "due" the Presidency? Not that she wanted it or deserved it, as I assume that almost all presidential candidates think both.

She is certainly smart enough not to say anything like that explicitly. If that's the "evidence" you require, then you can ignore the tone of her entire campaign and the multiple subsequent accounts by her staffers and the journalists who covered her.
 
An interesting way to characterise forgiveness
Can't forgive an innocent person.

I wasn't aware that Bill was guilty until proven innocent.
Hillary's forgiveness proves his guilt.

An interesting way to characterize attacking Bill's victims.

I'm thinking it's a bit of both: Forgive Bill for victimizing women. Attack his victims to mitigate their damage to the Clintons' political careers.
 
You claim that the standard of evidence has changed, but ironically you provide no evidence of any such change.

No, actually I have it right here: you just made up a new standard of evidence for the discussion. Which is odd, since you then go on to state that the two aren't the same in terms of evidence. Why not open with that, instead?

I'd ask for what corroborating evidence there is, but I suspect you'll instead say it's off topic.

Her campaign did (see my previous links). It's a reasonable inference that she did as well.

A reasonable inference, yes, but that doesn't actually demonstrate the claim. You know, like it's a reasonable inference that Kavanaugh actually commited the assault he was accused of, but no one demonstrated that he did.
 
Can't forgive an innocent person.


Hillary's forgiveness proves his guilt.

Surely, her forgiveness has more to do with his failure to fulfill his vows and not an admission that he is guilty of sexual assault.

Honestly, this is a poor argument.
 
Can't forgive an innocent person.

Infidelity is not the same as rape.

Hillary's forgiveness proves his guilt.

See above. We're getting to pretty interesting word-twisting here.

I'm thinking it's a bit of both: Forgive Bill for victimizing women.

And bam. Guilty until proven innocent. Apparently having sex with women is the same as raping them.
 
Any infidelity is between Bill and Hillary and whatever agreement or conclusion they came to is between them.

None of this however has anything to do with the tone of Hillary's Campaign.
 
No, actually I have it right here: you just made up a new standard of evidence for the discussion.

Now you're simply making things up.

Which is odd, since you then go on to state that the two aren't the same in terms of evidence. Why not open with that, instead?

Because this is already common knowledge, and I didn't think I'd have to explain it to you.

I'd ask for what corroborating evidence there is, but I suspect you'll instead say it's off topic.

It is off topic. If you actually care, it's easy to google it. But you don't actually care. You're just desperate to claim hypocrisy even though there is none.

A reasonable inference, yes

Well, then, we should be done here.

but that doesn't actually demonstrate the claim.

It doesn't prove the claim with 100% certainty, but that's not necessary.

You know, like it's a reasonable inference that Kavanaugh actually commited the assault he was accused of, but no one demonstrated that he did.

No, Belz, that actually isn't a reasonable inference in that case. And because it's not, everything you've tried to argue on that basis crumbles.
 
Any infidelity is between Bill and Hillary and whatever agreement or conclusion they came to is between them.

It's not just between them if you're trying to turn her into a feminist icon. Then it pretty much has to be addressed.

None of this however has anything to do with the tone of Hillary's Campaign.

True, but it came up for other reasons.
 
It's not just between them if you're trying to turn her into a feminist icon. Then it pretty much has to be addressed.

If you say so. I wasn't aware forgiveness of infidelity was a declared feminist position.
 
Any infidelity is between Bill and Hillary and whatever agreement or conclusion they came to is between them.

None of this however has anything to do with the tone of Hillary's Campaign.

In the context of #metoo and people re-evaluating the actions of powerful men when it comes to sexual misconduct, Bill Clinton doesn't come out looking very good. Hilary was part of the administration and it is fair that she should answer for the smearing of Lewinsky in the media.

It's pretty gross that Bill's career went on and Monica was largely seen as a dumb bimbo given the tremendous power imbalance that obviously existed during their affair.

I think the party could use some fresher blood.
 
Now you're simply making things up.

I quoted you right there!

Because this is already common knowledge, and I didn't think I'd have to explain it to you.

It is off topic. If you actually care, it's easy to google it.

Yep. As usual you're completely unwilling to support your own claims.

But you don't actually care.

I asked, didn't I? People have been screaming about Bill's guilt for years but have never provided evidence. I won't hunt it down for you.

It doesn't prove the claim with 100% certainty, but that's not necessary.

Strawman.

No, Belz, that actually isn't a reasonable inference in that case. And because it's not, everything you've tried to argue on that basis crumbles.

Sorry, your disagreement about what's reasonable doesn't invalidate my argument.
 
The personal is political. Have you heard that before? Do you know where it comes from?

Yes, and it's nonsense wherever it comes from. It would've been seen as a plus, had she been on the Republican ticket. But she's a Democrat, so forgiveness is bad. Of course, it's assumed that Bill is guilty.
 
Yes, and it's nonsense wherever it comes from. It would've been seen as a plus, had she been on the Republican ticket. But she's a Democrat, so forgiveness is bad. Of course, it's assumed that Bill is guilty.

First, Bill's guilt isn't an assumption.

Second, the issue isn't about whether forgiveness is good or bad. It's about whether Hillary is a feminist icon. And while "the personal is political" may be nonsense, it's at the heart of feminism. You cannot make Hillary a feminist icon without using feminist standards. That's how it works.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom