Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

2 pages of "here's a youtube video proving hillary is a felon"
followed by "no you committed a fallacy"

...
 
Do you seriously not understand that it was not being used merely as an insult, have you not followed the arguments at all?

Do you understand that I was giving posters credit for at least making an argument, albeit fallacious, rather than engaging in mere name calling??

I have them at level 1, you have them at level zero

But if you want to assert that they were not making an argument at all but just lobbing barnyard insults, by god y'all go for it!

It's not mere name calling, nor is it claiming your argument is fallacious.

It's making the point that your ethical standards are inconsistent and partisan. You judge not according to a code of ethics, you judge by a hypocritical partisan standard.

But that's your prerogative.
 
It's not mere name calling, nor is it claiming your argument is fallacious.

It's making the point that your ethical standards are inconsistent and partisan. You judge not according to a code of ethics, you judge by a hypocritical partisan standard.

But that's your prerogative.

That is beautiful, I mean how can you type that out and not realize that is an ad hominem fallacy of the tu quoque variety??

"It's making the point that your ethical standards are inconsistent and partisan. You judge not according to a code of ethics, you judge by a hypocritical partisan standard."
 
Last edited:
That is beautiful, I mean how can you type that out and not realize that is an ad hominem fallacy of the tu quoque variety??

It's an objective observation. You apply different standards depending on whether the subject has a "D" or an "R" by their name. If you were a Democrat, I would say the same thing--So on what do you base your accusation of me being a hypocrite? Where have you seen me apply a double standard? Looks to me this false accusation is merely an extension of your own hypocrisy. LOL!

Nevermind about the latter comment: I see now you weren't throwing my comment back at me, just repeating it with highlighted words.

So: You think the inclusion of the words "you" "your" and "partisan" demonstrate that it's a tu quoque? Looks like you're still not understanding. It's a valid point to be made.

You're welcome to continue whining about it if you want. LOL!
 
Last edited:
It's an objective observation. You apply different standards depending on whether the subject has a "D" or an "R" by their name. If you were a Democrat, I would say the same thing--So on what do you base your accusation of me being a hypocrite? Where have you seen me apply a double standard? Looks to me this false accusation is merely an extension of your own hypocrisy. LOL!

what in the name of God are you talking about? i did not accuse you of hypocrisy... just, wow.
 
Sounds like she's not 'done', then.

Good, now you'll get to keep talking about her for years on end.

Personally, I don't care about her enough to pop back in this thread, except to watch you guys display your love-hate relationship with her. Quite entertaining, actually.

Sorry, you've expended all of your credibility with regards to logical fallacies.

'k.
 
In short:

Sometimes an accusation of hypocrisy is used as a distraction.

On the other hand, sometimes a hypocrite is a legitimate hypocrite.

The big dog is the latter.

He acts as if EVERY time the word "hypocrite" is invoked it's a fallacy.

That simply means he doesn't understand what a tu quoque really is.
 
Last edited:
That someone would think that responding to another's argument by accusing them of being partisan or a hypocrite is a "valid point" is simply remarkable.
 
That someone would think that responding to another's argument by accusing them of being partisan or a hypocrite is a "valid point" is simply remarkable.

Why?

Let me give you an example:

Suppose someone claims Democrats and only Democrats are lashing out in violent ways. They then go on to cherry pick names like Hodgkinson and other such cases.

Pointing out they are hypocritically cherry picking and reminding them of someone like Timothy McVeigh is a valid point.

Do you disagree with it being a valid point in that specific example? If so, why?
 
Arg: Hillary Clinton violated the espionage act by storing classified emails on her server.
Response: You are a partisan hypocrite because Donald trump violated the law when he gave documents to Russia and you never said anything about him!

Analysis: the response is an ad hominem, tu quoque, because the response simply attacks the original poster without rebutting the actual argument being made Hillary Clinton violated the espionage act.

Say... you learned something folks.
 
So you choose not to answer my question.

Ok

I preferred to deal with the actual discussion, and not the hypothetical you ginned up but no matter:

"Suppose someone claims Democrats and only Democrats are lashing out in violent ways. They then go on to cherry pick names like Hodgkinson and other such cases.

Pointing out they are hypocritically cherry picking and reminding them of someone like Timothy McVeigh is a valid point."

Look, I struck out the invalid unnecessary word, and the response still stands, actually you should take out the accusation of cherry picking because you actually put that in your "hypothetical" which was silly, but whatever.

lets change that:

"Suppose someone claims Democrats are lashing out in violent ways. They then go on to cite Hodgkinson and other such cases."
response: You are a hypocrite because you did not mention Tim Mcveigh

Analysis: the response is an ad hominem, tu quoque, because the response simply attacks the original poster without rebutting the actual argument being made that Democrats are lashing out.
 
Last edited:
I preferred to deal with the actual discussion, and not the hypothetical you ginned up but no matter:

"Suppose someone claims Democrats and only Democrats are lashing out in violent ways. They then go on to cherry pick names like Hodgkinson and other such cases.

Pointing out they are hypocritically cherry picking and reminding them of someone like Timothy McVeigh is a valid point."

Look, I struck out the invalid unnecessary word, and the response still stands, actually you should take out the accusation of cherry picking because you actually put that in your "hypothetical" which was silly, but whatever.

lets change that:

"Suppose someone claims Democrats are lashing out in violent ways. They then go on to cite Hodgkinson and other such cases."
response: You are a hypocrite because you did not mention Tim Mcveigh

Analysis: the response is an ad hominem, tu quoque, because the response simply attacks the original poster without rebutting the actual argument being made that Democrats are lashing out.

So you'll pretend to answer the question, only to end up dodging it.

Ok
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom