Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

Well, it technically would be in formal logic, but in reality we generally don't rely on formal logic, but instead informal. The practical considerations of the fact that no one can be an expert in all fields means the word of an acknowledged expert on subjects within their specialty is not considered fallacious.

Not that I consider the person you're talking to as one who understood this distinction.

How would it be an appeal to authority fallacy in formal logic? I don't think it is. If we referenced Einstein on fashion trends in east Asia, sure, but not in relativity.
 
Last edited:
How would it be a appeal to authority fallacy in formal logic? I don't think it is. If we referenced Einstein on fashion trends in east Asia, sure, but not in relativity.

There's disagreement. In formal logic, many consider any appeal to an authority is fallacious...the argument must stand on it's own.

The first paragraph of the Wiki entry under "Forms" covers it pretty well https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority

ETA: Just to clarify, there is an argument to be made that, instead of presenting Einstein's conclusion on something relativity-related, it would be better to present his argument. I can see the logic there. But in reality, you'd have to have an understanding of the physics leading up to and used in that argument, and the math for the same, and expecting everyone to be that conversant with any possible topic is impractical, to say the least :)
 
Last edited:
Oh she can, and does have them, and has not been shy in sharing them.

Well yeah because she's a human being and she gets to do that. Sorry that bothers you so much that former Secretary of State, First Lady, and candidate for President still has opinions that some people want to listen to.
 
Well yeah because she's a human being and she gets to do that. Sorry that bothers you so much that former Secretary of State, First Lady, and candidate for President still has opinions that some people want to listen to.

"Sorry it bothers you so much" that people are posting in this forum that have opinions on the actions of the former Secretary of State, First Lady, and candidate for President.

Are we not human beings too that "get to do that"?
 
Well yeah because she's a human being and she gets to do that. Sorry that bothers you so much that former Secretary of State, First Lady, and candidate for President still has opinions that some people want to listen to.

But that's capitalism, and capitalism is wrong. When democrats do it.

(see my comment above about Laura Bush and her daughters)
 
Oh wow! Oh for two in understanding fallacies!

Good job! LOL!

Yes, the "strawman" characterization when no one ascribed a position to him? Yep. While I strongly implied a certain position to him, it was not then used as a strawman position as if it were his arguments...it was simply an aside to craft an analogy of the misunderstanding of fallacies, and the folly in calling them out simply by name without detailing the actual error.
 
Clintons aren’t going away yet, as upcoming speaking tour shows

Republicans have long been skeptical of Hillary Clinton but she’s also generated anger from the left. “Democrats hold her responsible for the 2016 defeat,” Berry said. “There’s a belief that a better campaign would have beaten a weak candidate in Donald Trump.”

Her approval rating stands at 38 percent, according to a September 2018 Gallup poll. The survey showed that the former first lady’s standing dropped with Democrats after the 2016 election and hasn’t recovered.

The most recent public polling for her husband put his favorability rating at 45 percent, but that was nearly a year ago in December 2017.

Putting Bill Clinton into the spotlight next to his wife amid the national reckoning on how powerful men have treated women could also be awkward. The post-Clinton Democratic Party has largely embraced the #MeToo movement, but it raises uncomfortable questions for the former president about the women who have accused him of sexual assault.

“If Bill Clinton is going to reinsert himself into the political process, every Democrat should be asked if they believe Bill Clinton or his accusers,” said Andy Surabian, a Republican strategist and former official with the Trump White House.

say, maybe will we see Hillary slip the knife into the back of the #metoo movement... well at least if you got at least $120 bucks
 
Yes, the "strawman" characterization when no one ascribed a position to him? Yep. While I strongly implied a certain position to him, it was not then used as a strawman position as if it were his arguments...it was simply an aside to craft an analogy of the misunderstanding of fallacies, and the folly in calling them out simply by name without detailing the actual error.

"While I strongly implied a certain position to him..."

A straw man is a common form of argument and is an informal fallacy based on giving the impression of refuting an opponent's argument, while actually refuting an argument that was not presented by that opponent.

Hmmm....

Oh dear, there I go addressing your actual statements and countering them with actual definitions from third party sources. Silly me.
 
Clintons aren’t going away yet, as upcoming speaking tour shows



say, maybe will we see Hillary slip the knife into the back of the #metoo movement... well at least if you got at least $120 bucks

Sounds like she's not 'done', then.

Good, now you'll get to keep talking about her for years on end.

Personally, I don't care about her enough to pop back in this thread, except to watch you guys display your love-hate relationship with her. Quite entertaining, actually.
 
Seriously would the Republicans and Hillary just bang already and get it over with. The tension is taking over the room.
 
"While I strongly implied a certain position to him..."

A straw man is a common form of argument and is an informal fallacy based on giving the impression of refuting an opponent's argument, while actually refuting an argument that was not presented by that opponent.

Hmmm....

Oh dear, there I go addressing your actual statements and countering them with actual definitions from third party sources. Silly me.

It's not a strawman because you actually are misunderstanding the term "appeal to hypocrisy". Pointing that out is a fact, not a strawman.
 
It's not a strawman because you actually are misunderstanding the term "appeal to hypocrisy". Pointing that out is a fact, not a strawman.

It is a strawman, as I have shown, and I have also explained with citations why arguments braying about "right-wing hypocrisy" are fallacious.

let me know if y'all need any more explanation.
 
It is a strawman, as I have shown, and I have also explained with citations why arguments braying about "right-wing hypocrisy" are fallacious.

let me know if y'all need any more explanation.

Oh dear, you still don't get it, do you?
 
Oh dear, you still don't get it, do you?

well, I guess we are just gonna have to take your word for it. Type something about Einstein, apropos of absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with this thread again.

Thanks for posting
 
well, I guess we are just gonna have to take your word for it. Type something about Einstein, apropos of absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with this thread again.

Thanks for posting

No, it was apropos of your misuse of the term "appeal to hypocrisy". Not all accusations of hypocrisy are fallacious "appeals to hypocrisy".

Do you seriously not understand that?
 
No, it was apropos of your misuse of the term "appeal to hypocrisy". Not all accusations of hypocrisy are fallacious "appeals to hypocrisy".

Do you seriously not understand that?

Do you seriously not understand that it was not being used merely as an insult, have you not followed the arguments at all?

Do you understand that I was giving posters credit for at least making an argument, albeit fallacious, rather than engaging in mere name calling??

I have them at level 1, you have them at level zero

But if you want to assert that they were not making an argument at all but just lobbing barnyard insults, by god y'all go for it!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom