Hillary Clinton is Done: Part 5 (The Doniest)

Amusing, coming from the side who constantly brings up Hillary to defend Trump.

But no, it's not fallacious to point out hypocrisy. If the crime is not a problem for you unless it's committed by a political opponent, then the crime itself is not the issue; it's a smokescreen.

Tu quoque (/tjuːˈkwoʊkwi, tuːˈkwoʊkweɪ/;[1] Latin for "you also"), or the appeal to hypocrisy, is an informal fallacy that intends to discredit the opponent's argument by asserting the opponent's failure to act consistently in accordance with its conclusion(s).

Appeal to hypocrisy (also known as Tu quoque, Latin for, ‘you also’) is an informal logical fallacy that tries to discredit the validity of the opponent’s argument by asserting the opponent’s failure to act consistently in accordance with its conclusion(s).

Tu quoque (pronounced like 'too kwoh kway") (Latin for 'you also') is a form of ad hominem fallacy that occurs when it is assumed that an argument is wrong if the source making the claim has itself spoken or acted in a way inconsistent with it. The fallacy focuses on the perceived hypocrisy of the opponent rather than the merits of their argument. This is a fallacy regardless of whether you really did it or not, but it helps if you really didn't do it.

Pronounced too-kwo-kwee. Literally translating as 'you too' this fallacy is also known as the appeal to hypocrisy. It is commonly employed as an effective red herring because it takes the heat off someone having to defend their argument, and instead shifts the focus back on to the person making the criticism.
 
Tu_quoque

Except that the tu quoque fallacy is a defense of the act by pointing out that the other person is doing it as well. That's not what's going on here, though I'm not surprised that your grasp of fallacies is weak. What I'm doing is pointing out that River most probably doesn't actually care about Clinton's e-mails. It's just an excuse to justify disliking her, and the real reason for that dislike is that she's not in the right tribe.

I'm well aware of what she did wrong.
 
Except that the tu quoque fallacy is a defense of the act by pointing out that the other person is doing it as well. That's not what's going on here, though I'm not surprised that your grasp of fallacies is weak. What I'm doing is pointing out that River most probably doesn't actually care about Clinton's e-mails. It's just an excuse to justify disliking her, and the real reason for that dislike is that she's not in the right tribe.

I'm well aware of what she did wrong.
Folks, lets take a look:

We have gone from "it's not fallacious to point out hypocrisy," to "Except that the tu quoque fallacy is a defense of the act by pointing out that the other person is doing it as well."

That is what we actual critical thinkers call "moving the goalposts" or "special pleading."

By the way, your definition of "tu quoque" as a "defense" is garbage.

Your accusations of hypocrisy and repeated ad hominems are fallacious.

I'm well aware of the fact that is all you have.
 
Folks, lets take a look:

I love it when you address your imaginary audience.

We have gone from "it's not fallacious to point out hypocrisy," to "Except that the tu quoque fallacy is a defense of the act by pointing out that the other person is doing it as well."

Those are the exact same claim! It's not fallacious to point out hypocrisy, and the second one is a rebuttal of your objection to it!

That is what we actual critical thinkers call "moving the goalposts"

Oh, another fallacy you don't understand. How surprising.

You simply don't like the fact that I'm correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy.
 
You do realize Trump said he fired Comey because the Russia thing was a hoax, don't you? I mean, he gave other reasons as well, but it's a fact that that was one of them.

Trump gave several conflicting reasons for firing Comey. I guess you can pick the one you like best and ignore the rest, if you want to.
 
You see guys this is why we never should have gotten into the habit of just "naming" bad arguments. People who don't understand them just think they are magic words to be invoked in a discussion when they are losing.
 
I love it when you address your imaginary audience.



Those are the exact same claim! It's not fallacious to point out hypocrisy, and the second one is a rebuttal of your objection to it!



Oh, another fallacy you don't understand. How surprising.

You simply don't like the fact that I'm correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy.

It's like micro-cephalic morons who still think that any insult is an ad hominem. If I call someone a mouth-breathing, knuckle-dragging, living breath proof of the link between man and ape, that's not ad hominem. If, however, I say that someone must be incorrect because they don't have enough brain cells to rub two together to spark an idea, that would be ad hominem. It's not just an insult, it's a type of red herring fallacy used to discredit an argument not because of problems in the argument, but by trying to associate it with unrelated matters about the arguer's character.

:D

ETA: Much like the claim that someone must be wrong because they're an atheist, or they must be wrong because they're a liberal.
 
Last edited:
I love it when you address your imaginary audience.



Those are the exact same claim! It's not fallacious to point out hypocrisy, and the second one is a rebuttal of your objection to it!



Oh, another fallacy you don't understand. How surprising.

You simply don't like the fact that I'm correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy.

I literally give four examples explaining what an appeal to hypocrisy/tu quoque is.

the "rebuttal" does not challenge those definitions but claims this isn't a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy because "River most probably doesn't actually care about Clinton's e-mails. It's just an excuse to justify disliking her, and the real reason for that dislike is that she's not in the right tribe" which: hoo boy.

Then goes back to claiming "correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy," in a thread about Hillary Clinton.

That folks is all you need to know about the depths to which critical thinking has fallen on this site.

"I'm correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy."

Drink it in boys, arguments don't get no worse than that.
 
Last edited:
So ongoing investigations into Clinton are damning, but ongoing investigations into Trump..No Problem!

Just checking to see if I have the talking points down pat.

One is not the same as the other. Can you tell me why?

In one case (Clinton) we have proof of her violating the law, several times publicly available. Felonies. Also, ongoing investigations.

In the other (Trump) we have the fbi going in search of crimes with no evidence of them. (collusion? election interference? Trump? Explain how those tie to trump) Also ongoing investigations.
 
I literally give four examples explaining what an appeal to hypocrisy/tu quoque is.

Yes and none of them applies to the discussion we're having. It's just that you don't understand what my point is even though I clarified it already. I can only surmise that you don't want to understand it.

the "rebuttal" does not challenge those definitions but claims this isn't a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy because "River most probably doesn't actually care about Clinton's e-mails. It's just an excuse to justify disliking her, and the real reason for that dislike is that she's not in the right tribe" which: hoo boy.

It's so sad. You're so close to getting it, but you can't bring yourself to.
 
Wake me up when the indictments begin.



And how do you feel about Trump leaking classified info to the Russians in the Oval Office?

Let's see how consistent you are.

And again, the FBI Comey did not recommend charges against Clinton. That should tell you something about how serious they think the 'crimes' were.

Comey did not recommend charges based on "intent" while the law does not mention intent. Those two things are one of the reasons why he was fired. He may go to jail for his handling of this. (opinions vary)

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-39931012

Also, Trump did not "leak" anything. He had a discussion with foreign officials in a professional and legal environment.

US National Security Adviser HR McMaster: "I was in the room, it didn't happen"
 
Last edited:
Comey did not recommend charges based on "intent" while the law does not mention intent.

She's still at large. Somehow no one thought she was worth going after.

Still don't know why NO ONE should support her. Because of e-mail transgressions, really?

Those two things are one of the reasons why he was fired.

According to Trump he fired him because of the Russia investigation.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-39931012

Also, Trump did not "leak" anything. He had a discussion with foreign officials in a professional and legal environment.

...in which he revealed information that he shouldn't have. What verb would you use, then? :rolleyes:
 
Comey did not recommend charges based on "intent" while the law does not mention intent. Those two things are one of the reasons why he was fired. He may go to jail for his handling of this. (opinions vary)

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-39931012

Also, Trump did not "leak" anything. He had a discussion with foreign officials in a professional and legal environment.

Not sure why you bother, the "But Trump" arguments are not made in good faith, but are a grossly fallacious
 
I literally give four examples explaining what an appeal to hypocrisy/tu quoque is.

the "rebuttal" does not challenge those definitions but claims this isn't a fallacious appeal to hypocrisy because "River most probably doesn't actually care about Clinton's e-mails. It's just an excuse to justify disliking her, and the real reason for that dislike is that she's not in the right tribe" which: hoo boy.

Then goes back to claiming "correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy," in a thread about Hillary Clinton.

That folks is all you need to know about the depths to which critical thinking has fallen on this site.

"I'm correct in pointing out right-wing hypocrisy."

Drink it in boys, arguments don't get no worse than that.

You probably think referencing Einstein in a discussion of the theory of relativity is a fallacious "appeal to authority" too, don't you? LOL!
 
In the other (Trump) we have the fbi going in search of crimes with no evidence of them. (collusion? election interference? Trump? Explain how those tie to trump) Also ongoing investigations.

Still confusing evidence with proof, eh? There's plenty of evidence, you simply refuse to acknowledge it.
 
This is all pointless.

She's done. She holds no positions or offices. She's no longer Secretary of State, she's no longer First Lady, she's not longer a Presidential Candidate.

What do people want for her to not have opinions that influence politics? To not speak publicly? To go live in a cave? To just literally not exist lest she butterfly effect the world in some way?
 
You probably think referencing Einstein in a discussion of the theory of relativity is a fallacious "appeal to authority" too, don't you? LOL!

Well, it technically would be in formal logic, but in reality we generally don't rely on formal logic, but instead informal. The practical considerations of the fact that no one can be an expert in all fields means the word of an acknowledged expert on subjects within their specialty is not considered fallacious.

Not that I consider the person you're talking to as one who understood this distinction.
 
This is all pointless.

She's done. She holds no positions or offices. She's no longer Secretary of State, she's no longer First Lady, she's not longer a Presidential Candidate.

What do people want for her to not have opinions that influence politics? To not speak publicly? To go live in a cave? To just literally not exist lest she butterfly effect the world in some way?

Oh she can, and does have them, and has not been shy in sharing them.

In this thread, some of us are endeavoring to discuss those opinions and her roles in trying to influence politics.

case in point, she just came out and echoed the calls for incivility which has been roundly criticized on both sides.
 
Well, it technically would be in formal logic, but in reality we generally don't rely on formal logic, but instead informal. The practical considerations of the fact that no one can be an expert in all fields means the word of an acknowledged expert on subjects within their specialty is not considered fallacious.

Not that I consider the person you're talking to as one who understood this distinction.

what did you base that on? his strawman or your earlier strawman about "insults" which of course no one mentioned?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom