Help with Shanksville question

Please post the evidence that the container of scrap metal is actually from Flight 93. Are any of those scraps serially charged?

why don't you contact the volunteers who picked that stuff up?
 
So it's "impossible" for an UAV to fly that low but completely possible for a 757 to fly close enough to the ground as to hit car antenna's in DC.

I see the logic at play here.......

Nice plea from incredulity here. Which ignores the substance of the original argument.

If you read Mackey's post, the reasons the specific UAV he's referring to would not fly that low is because it's programmed not to. Whereas a 757 being actively controlled by a pilot is under no such restraints. Recall that in business and commuter jets, the pilot gets an audio ground warning, but the system does not actively interfere with the pilot's inputs. Beachnut, Mackey, or any other pilots out there: Mind verifying that info? That's the best of my understanding on the topic.

At any rate, that's a weak attempt to paint the truth as contradictory. Saying a UAV is programmed not to fly below a certain altitude does not subtract or contradict a single detail of an aircraft deliberately being flown to crash. A UAV is not a Boeing passenger jet. You'd have to prove that passenger jets have programming similar to a Global Hawk's that intervenes as Mackey says to make the argument you tried to make in that statement.
 
If you read Mackey's post, the reasons the specific UAV he's referring to would not fly that low is because it's programmed not to. Whereas a 757 being actively controlled by a pilot is under no such restraints. Recall that in business and commuter jets, the pilot gets an audio ground warning, but the system does not actively interfere with the pilot's inputs. Beachnut, Mackey, or any other pilots out there: Mind verifying that info? That's the best of my understanding on the topic.

I Am Not A Pilot, but that is correct. A Boeing 757 cannot override pilot inputs to fly it close to the ground. It's not even fly-by-wire. (Airbus, on the other hand...)

Boeing 757's have something that Global Hawk doesn't: A pilot. Global Hawk can't see the ground to avoid hitting it. A 757 can.
 
I Am Not A Pilot, but that is correct. A Boeing 757 cannot override pilot inputs to fly it close to the ground. It's not even fly-by-wire. (Airbus, on the other hand...)

Boeing 757's have something that Global Hawk doesn't: A pilot. Global Hawk can't see the ground to avoid hitting it. A 757 can.

Actually, I just realized that there are jets that override pilot input to a degree, but they're not Boeings (Yup, we're talkin' Airbus, Mackey):

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/business/boe202.shtml

At any rate, that's merely a comment to round out the topic of pilots being overridden. A 757 is a Boeing, not an Airbus product.

Back to the topic: My overall point is that it is a weak response to point out that an argument about a UAV is supposedly contradictory to a point about the jet that hit the Pentagon. Not only is it an argumentum ad ignorantiam, it is also a false comparison. That is the danger of using snark over substance. That argument:

So it's "impossible" for an UAV to fly that low but completely possible for a 757 to fly close enough to the ground as to hit car antenna's in DC.



I see the logic at play here.......


... should not have been made. There is no substance to it, it is merely an attempt to paint as false an event which has been substantiated by testimony and evidence.
 
Now you're getting the idea. That's a great question. I would like to know.

Hmmmmm let's speculate....

1. A Falcon F20 flying much higher than the witnesses estimated and viewed by them from below....

.....or....... (deep breath)....

2. A sooper seekrit never seen before or since drone aircraft flying low but making no sound.

Anyone got a razor?

IT IS NOT A GLOBAL HAWK. IT IS ONLY SIMILAR IN APPEARANCE TO ONE.

Please describe the similarities positively identified by your witnesses, i.e shape of nose, angle of wings, position of engines, shape of tail, colour, etc etc.

Oh and don't forget the position of the engines and shape of the tail.

Cheers
 
Another interesting quote:

"Pennsylvania state police officials said on Thursday debris from the plane had been found up to 8 miles (13 km) away in a residential community where local media have quoted residents as speaking of a second plane in the area and burning debris falling from the sky." http://investor.cnet.com/investor/news/newsitem/0-9900-1028-7147291-0.html

This is so fascintating.

JREF Theory for flight 93

95% of the plane went into the 6-15' deep crater and the other 5% spread over an 8 mile radius creating 3 debris fields. One engine went into the 'soft soil' but another engine bounced off the 'hard ground'. 95% of the plane went into the soft soil but the plane shattered into pieces no bigger than a phone book and spread over an 8 mile radius because the ground is so hard.

Ed Felt reported the explosion he heard and the smoke that he saw which was caused by either "boiling water" or the plane "twisting in flight".

All the eyewitnesses reports describing the little white plane are wrong. Even though those people were really there and we weren't they aren't qualified to describe the type of plane they saw.
 
Nice plea from incredulity here. Which ignores the substance of the original argument.

If you read Mackey's post, the reasons the specific UAV he's referring to would not fly that low is because it's programmed not to. Whereas a 757 being actively controlled by a pilot is under no such restraints. Recall that in business and commuter jets, the pilot gets an audio ground warning, but the system does not actively interfere with the pilot's inputs. Beachnut, Mackey, or any other pilots out there: Mind verifying that info? That's the best of my understanding on the topic.

At any rate, that's a weak attempt to paint the truth as contradictory. Saying a UAV is programmed not to fly below a certain altitude does not subtract or contradict a single detail of an aircraft deliberately being flown to crash. A UAV is not a Boeing passenger jet. You'd have to prove that passenger jets have programming similar to a Global Hawk's that intervenes as Mackey says to make the argument you tried to make in that statement.

I don"t know how many times i have to say this but its not a ****ing global hawk. it is similar in appearance.
 
whom we've shown to be mistaken in her description. care to try again terror?
 
Exactly the same as Susan McElwain did.
IIRC correctly she described a "double tail" which could imply the horizontal stabilizers on a falcon 20, and "uprights at the wingtips" which would almost seem to describe a learjet, but im sure a falcon model could have them as well, she also said the engines were at the back, also consistant with a falcon

anything else?
 
whom we've shown to be mistaken in her description. care to try again terror?

How did you show she was mistaken in her description????

Please list all the members who were at the intersection of Bridge St & Buckstown Rd in Stoystown on the morning of 9/11 just after 10AM.

She isn't mistaken.
 
IIRC correctly she described a "double tail" which could imply the horizontal stabilizers on a falcon 20, and "uprights at the wingtips" which would almost seem to describe a learjet, but im sure a falcon model could have them as well, she also said the engines were at the back, also consistant with a falcon

anything else?


No she didn't describe a "double tail". Are you intentionally lying or are you speaking out of complete ignorance?

She also laughed when I showed her the F20 and said it definitely wasn't that.
 
after posting i looked up her comments, she doesnt mention a double tail, but im sure that came up at some point when we were discussing this with killtown, but i was mistaken about susan mcelwain saying it

“There’s no way I imagined this plane—it was so low it was virtually on top of me. It was white with no markings but it was definitely military, it just had that look. It had two rear engines, a big fin on the back like a spoiler on the back of a car and with two upright fins at the side. I haven’t found one like it on the Internet. It definitely wasn’t one of those executive jets. The FBI came and talked to me and said there was no plane around.… But I saw it and it was there before the crash and it was 40 feet above my head. They did not want my story—nobody here did.”

i bolded the two bits i found most interesting, how did it "have that look" generally when i think military look i think battleship gray, or olive drab, not white, so what "look" did it have?

also, what military plane has upright fins at the sides?
 
this is the only plane I could find that matches her description. It's a Learjet 45.
 

Attachments

  • Learjet45_2.jpg
    Learjet45_2.jpg
    14.6 KB · Views: 2
95% of the plane went into the 6-15' deep crater and the other 5% spread over an 8 mile radius creating 3 debris fields. One engine went into the 'soft soil' but another engine bounced off the 'hard ground'. 95% of the plane went into the soft soil but the plane shattered into pieces no bigger than a phone book and spread over an 8 mile radius because the ground is so hard.

A lot of this is inaccurate. By no means was it spread over an "8-mile radius", a term that means 8 miles outwards in every direction. The only extra debris was found southeast of the crash site, which was the direction that the flight was traveling when it hit the ground. Yes, it created 3 debris fields, but they were small, confined spaces and make sense when considering the wind present that day. No debris was found BEHIND the crash site.

As for the other engine bouncing, nobody said that it bounced, necessarily. It's possible that it could have been forced out of the crater by the explosion. If you're wondering why the other engine didn't get sent to the pond, then maybe you can remember that an explosion is by no means a clean, proper, symmetrical event.

By the way, that "engine" in the pond is not actually a whole engine. The engines on Flight 93 weigh 4 1/2 tons. The engine piece found in the pod 300 yards away reportedly weighed between 1000 and 2000 lbs, i.e. less than 1 ton, or approximately 20% of the engine. Certainly not a whole engine.

As far as the ground goes...why is it not feasible for the ground to be soft on the surface and harder under the surface? Why is it not feasible that as the plane burrowed into the ground, it would compact the dirt, making it harder? This means it penetrates the surface easily, but as it gets farther into the ground, it meets more resistance and begins to fall apart. Then it blows up and creates an explosion that rocks the ground, and a number of people in the area feel it. It almost completely destroys the engine piece that flew away in the explosion, that piece being just 1/5 of the original engine.

Ed Felt reported the explosion he heard and the smoke that he saw which was caused by either "boiling water" or the plane "twisting in flight".
If you have a better theory, please give it!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom