ktesibios
Worthless Aging Hippie
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2002
- Messages
- 1,493
I saw the Global Hawk mentioned somewhere above, along with a claim that the mystery aircraft was no more than 40' above the ground. this made me curious enough to do some simple math.
A Global Hawk is 44' 5" long and has a wingspan of 116' 2". If one flew directly overhead at an altitude of 40', the fuselage would subtend an angle of 58.08 degrees. That's just about 1/3 of the angular distance from horizon to horizon. The wings would subtend an angle of 110.89 degrees. That's 60% of the distance from horizon to horizon.
If an aircraft that size flew over at 40', it would fill the @#$% sky.
When an aircraft is flying up in the sky, away from familiar objects that can give size and distance cues, the only ways to estimate its altitude with anything resembling accuracy are:
Be lucky enough to have an optical rangefinder in your possession and the presence of mind to use it.
Identify the aircraft, so that you can look up its dimensions later. Then, if you have the presence of mind and the skill to estimate its angular dimensions and your angle of view (to correct for foreshortening if you're not looking perpendicular to the fuselage or wings), you can estimate the height with some simple trig.
Absent those data, eyewitness estimates of altitude are worse than useless.
A couple of other things:
Having a day off today, I spent a few hours at Lake Balboa Park, reading, watching the waterfowl and occasionally watching the planes passing over after taking off from the Van Nuys airport a couple of blocks away. I saw at least half a dozen private jets that would fit the description in the "Susan McElwein Interview" thread very nicely. None of them were UAVs or even military.
Finally, I've been trying to think of a scenario in which it would make sense for the eevil gummint to shoot down UA93 and then cover up that fact. All of them founder on the fact that three hijacked aircraft were flown into buildings that day, killing thousands of people. If the gummint had shot UA93 down and openly announced that they had done it, my own "man in the street" reaction would have been something like "Man, that's really a terrible thing to have to do. Now what can be done to prevent such a dreadful necessity from arising in the future?"
Claims that the passengers had to be killed to prevent them from exposing some crucial aspect of the conspiracy won't make it; with the other events of 9/11 widely known, a shootdown could still easily be justified, hence there's no need for a clover-up, especially one so clumsy that a lot of amateur Sherlock Holmeses could expose it by peering at jpegs on the Internet.
Conspiracy theorists generally love to make arguments based on the putative motives of the evildoers rather than on objective evidence, so, troofers- what's the motive?
A Global Hawk is 44' 5" long and has a wingspan of 116' 2". If one flew directly overhead at an altitude of 40', the fuselage would subtend an angle of 58.08 degrees. That's just about 1/3 of the angular distance from horizon to horizon. The wings would subtend an angle of 110.89 degrees. That's 60% of the distance from horizon to horizon.
If an aircraft that size flew over at 40', it would fill the @#$% sky.
When an aircraft is flying up in the sky, away from familiar objects that can give size and distance cues, the only ways to estimate its altitude with anything resembling accuracy are:
Be lucky enough to have an optical rangefinder in your possession and the presence of mind to use it.
Identify the aircraft, so that you can look up its dimensions later. Then, if you have the presence of mind and the skill to estimate its angular dimensions and your angle of view (to correct for foreshortening if you're not looking perpendicular to the fuselage or wings), you can estimate the height with some simple trig.
Absent those data, eyewitness estimates of altitude are worse than useless.
A couple of other things:
Having a day off today, I spent a few hours at Lake Balboa Park, reading, watching the waterfowl and occasionally watching the planes passing over after taking off from the Van Nuys airport a couple of blocks away. I saw at least half a dozen private jets that would fit the description in the "Susan McElwein Interview" thread very nicely. None of them were UAVs or even military.
Finally, I've been trying to think of a scenario in which it would make sense for the eevil gummint to shoot down UA93 and then cover up that fact. All of them founder on the fact that three hijacked aircraft were flown into buildings that day, killing thousands of people. If the gummint had shot UA93 down and openly announced that they had done it, my own "man in the street" reaction would have been something like "Man, that's really a terrible thing to have to do. Now what can be done to prevent such a dreadful necessity from arising in the future?"
Claims that the passengers had to be killed to prevent them from exposing some crucial aspect of the conspiracy won't make it; with the other events of 9/11 widely known, a shootdown could still easily be justified, hence there's no need for a clover-up, especially one so clumsy that a lot of amateur Sherlock Holmeses could expose it by peering at jpegs on the Internet.
Conspiracy theorists generally love to make arguments based on the putative motives of the evildoers rather than on objective evidence, so, troofers- what's the motive?
