Help with Shanksville question

I saw the Global Hawk mentioned somewhere above, along with a claim that the mystery aircraft was no more than 40' above the ground. this made me curious enough to do some simple math.

A Global Hawk is 44' 5" long and has a wingspan of 116' 2". If one flew directly overhead at an altitude of 40', the fuselage would subtend an angle of 58.08 degrees. That's just about 1/3 of the angular distance from horizon to horizon. The wings would subtend an angle of 110.89 degrees. That's 60% of the distance from horizon to horizon.

If an aircraft that size flew over at 40', it would fill the @#$% sky.

When an aircraft is flying up in the sky, away from familiar objects that can give size and distance cues, the only ways to estimate its altitude with anything resembling accuracy are:

Be lucky enough to have an optical rangefinder in your possession and the presence of mind to use it.

Identify the aircraft, so that you can look up its dimensions later. Then, if you have the presence of mind and the skill to estimate its angular dimensions and your angle of view (to correct for foreshortening if you're not looking perpendicular to the fuselage or wings), you can estimate the height with some simple trig.

Absent those data, eyewitness estimates of altitude are worse than useless.

A couple of other things:

Having a day off today, I spent a few hours at Lake Balboa Park, reading, watching the waterfowl and occasionally watching the planes passing over after taking off from the Van Nuys airport a couple of blocks away. I saw at least half a dozen private jets that would fit the description in the "Susan McElwein Interview" thread very nicely. None of them were UAVs or even military.

Finally, I've been trying to think of a scenario in which it would make sense for the eevil gummint to shoot down UA93 and then cover up that fact. All of them founder on the fact that three hijacked aircraft were flown into buildings that day, killing thousands of people. If the gummint had shot UA93 down and openly announced that they had done it, my own "man in the street" reaction would have been something like "Man, that's really a terrible thing to have to do. Now what can be done to prevent such a dreadful necessity from arising in the future?"

Claims that the passengers had to be killed to prevent them from exposing some crucial aspect of the conspiracy won't make it; with the other events of 9/11 widely known, a shootdown could still easily be justified, hence there's no need for a clover-up, especially one so clumsy that a lot of amateur Sherlock Holmeses could expose it by peering at jpegs on the Internet.

Conspiracy theorists generally love to make arguments based on the putative motives of the evildoers rather than on objective evidence, so, troofers- what's the motive?
 
I've been reading these boards for a year. I've listened to talk of space beams and live holograms and buildings lined with C4 at the time of their construction.

And I have to say, that of all those theories, TC's theory that a lack of blood at the site of the plane crash proves that the plane was shot down by jet fighters, because only jet fighters would have the ability to somehow evaporate the blood from the passengers, has to be by far the most bizarre thing I've ever read on these boards.

That is not my "theory". My "theory" is more along the lines of the blood and bodies were mainly at a different debris field.
 
I saw the Global Hawk mentioned somewhere above, along with a claim that the mystery aircraft was no more than 40' above the ground. this made me curious enough to do some simple math.

A Global Hawk is 44' 5" long and has a wingspan of 116' 2". If one flew directly overhead at an altitude of 40', the fuselage would subtend an angle of 58.08 degrees. That's just about 1/3 of the angular distance from horizon to horizon. The wings would subtend an angle of 110.89 degrees. That's 60% of the distance from horizon to horizon.

If an aircraft that size flew over at 40', it would fill the @#$% sky.

Another excellent, conspiracist-befuddling observation from ktesibios. I also have the feeling that a Global Hawk passing 40 feet above would be, you know, loud.
 
And I have to say, that of all those theories, TC's theory that a lack of blood at the site of the plane crash proves that the plane was shot down by jet fighters, because only jet fighters would have the ability to somehow evaporate the blood from the passengers, has to be by far the most bizarre thing I've ever read on these boards.

There are numerous very bizarre ideas being discussed here. I think it is absolutely hilariously ludicrous to believe that a remote controlled drone could or would fly at 20'-40' (depends on which statement is correct) and below telephone and/or utility lines. Now, that is a feat that could only be accomplished in a video game. No don't think a movie director would even try this type of feat except in "The Flight of the Loony Bird".

Not only is this fictitious UAV flying at an impossibly low altitude, but I've yet to see a purpose stated for this miraculous achievement. Why was it there? What possible purpose would it serve?

I probably shouldn't ask such pertinent questions as it is quite entertaining to witness this supreme level of buffoonery continue! I wouldn't want to spoil the fun for everyone else....
 
Last edited:
Similar in appearance. Not one witness says anything about a wing span even remotely close to that size.

Oh for the love of Dowie and Ella Wheeler Wilcox, how the devil can an eyewitness estimate the linear dimensions of an unfamiliar object if they don't know how far away it is? And how can they estimate how far away it is if they don't already know how big it is?

Remember, there are no flying yardsticks or anything else to provide distance or size cues for flying objects. That's the whole point- an eyewitness' estimate of how high a plane is flying, absent data on its angular dimensions plus an identification of the plane, is nothing more than a crude guess and highly unlikely to be anywhere near correct.

The troofers "investigating" this have, as is common, failed utterly to gather observations that could be useful because they have placed entirely too much credence in uninformed interpretations of what could have been useful observations.
 
Another excellent, conspiracist-befuddling observation from ktesibios. I also have the feeling that a Global Hawk passing 40 feet above would be, you know, loud.

All the witnesses that were close to it said they did not hear a single noise. It was silent.
 
Another excellent, conspiracist-befuddling observation from ktesibios. I also have the feeling that a Global Hawk passing 40 feet above would be, you know, loud.

Actually, a Global Hawk at 40 feet AGL is impossible.

The control laws won't allow it. Its normal air data sensors aren't accurate enough and don't update fast enough to fly nap-of-the-earth. It knows this, so an attempt to fly as such would be overridden by commands to seek altitude. If this automatic response was disabled, it would probably crash.

When Global Hawk lands, it first must overfly the landing strip to take a high-resolution SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) scan of the area, calibrated against its on-board GPS. Only then does it have enough knowledge of the terrain to attempt a landing.

It does not have the electrical power or the processor power to run this continuously. There is, therefore, no way for it to operate at low altitude, particularly THAT low.

TerrorCell, in addition to being stark raving wrong, really showed his class earlier today by calling me a "Nazi." What a swell poster-child for the flailing "Truth Movement," eh? ;) He fits in fine with the rest of my Ignore portfolio...
 
Last edited:
All the witnesses that were close to it said they did not hear a single noise. It was silent.

So what aircraft make no noise?

And how does this prove a missile took down flight 93?

But then, why start answering questions now...
 
Another excellent, conspiracist-befuddling observation from ktesibios. I also have the feeling that a Global Hawk passing 40 feet above would be, you know, loud.
I further wonder what the top speed of a Global Hawk is at low altitude. The long, slender wings it has are of a design that is optimal for high altitude cruising; I would expect its aerodynamics would not be particularly good it it was zipping around at high speed less than a hundred feet off the ground.

All the witnesses that were close to it said they did not hear a single noise. It was silent.
What kind of propulsion system does an aircraft use to move at a good rate of speed without making any kind of noise?
 
All the witnesses that were close to it said they did not hear a single noise. It was silent.

hmmmmm. Do you ever wonder if maybe they were alot further away from it and that is why they thought it was silent?

What's more logical TC....?

1. A small white private jet travelling high above the witnesses, viewed from below against a bright sky after a commercial jet has just crashed and exploded next to some woods

or

2. A small white unidentified (possibly never seen before) silent (alien technology??) craft travelling about 40 foot above their heads, viewed from below against a bright sky after a commercial jet has just crashed and exploded next to some woods

See how important the witnesses ability to accurately judge height, distance and scale is? Doesn't the lack of sound make you suspicious about their judgement?

What are the similarities between the two drones your witness thought the plane looked like?

Bulbous 'cockpit' and thin wings appear to be all there is, and your witness only saw the craft from below. The tails and the means of propulsion are completely different.
 
I further wonder what the top speed of a Global Hawk is at low altitude. The long, slender wings it has are of a design that is optimal for high altitude cruising; I would expect its aerodynamics would not be particularly good it it was zipping around at high speed less than a hundred feet off the ground.

What kind of propulsion system does an aircraft use to move at a good rate of speed without making any kind of noise?

Gravity, just after they run out of fuel at 40,000 feet :boxedin:
 
"Little Killtown," aka TC329/Terrorcell, on body parts at the flight 93 crash scene:

"no body parts or blood were found at the scene"


"I said there was no blood or body parts at the scene"

"There were no body parts nor blood at the "crash" site. Period."

How very disturbing and sad.

Warner, the remains of every flight 93 passenger were recovered and positively identified. Miller personally identified 12 of the victims through dental records and fingerprints. One of the first things he saw at the scene was a piece of spinal cord with five vertebrae attached. He spent two weeks on his hands and knees collecting body parts. More info here: Flight 93 / Shanksville Summary of Evidence, many links



Yes, that's very amusing. What good fun this all is. Lost Walllace Miller's number already, TC? I guess that appointment you made with him was canceled, huh?

TC329/Terrorcell's theories about flight 93:

  • Fiight 93 was shot down in PA, passenger remains were recovered. Evidence from the scene is real. The other three flights contained CIA agents and crew, not the passengers on the manifests. Phone calls from passengers and crew were faked. Investigation into "passengers" needed.
  • Flight 11 was shot down in PA.
  • Flight 93 was shot down in PA after passengers regained control of the plane from hijackers, necessitating, for some reason, that it be shot down.
  • Flight 93 landed in Cleveland.
  • "The plane in Shanksville hit its target," whatever that means.
  • Flight 93's disposition unknown. Some other plane crashed at Shanksville, all evidence to the contrary is faked. First responders and investigators are liars.
  • Currently: flight 93 shot down at Shanksville by unknown USAF plane. Human remains found near the crash site but not in the crater. Invisible fighters and UAV's flitted about the scene. Investigators are liars. Nothing can change his mind.
How very disturbing and sad.

Hi Gravy,

My original problem was this. I was under the impression that the plane buried into the ground on impact is this correct? The reason i ask is because after posting that on a forum someone said thats not in the 911 commission report and therefore me as a believer of the official story am actually contradicting it.
 
Hi Gravy,

My original problem was this. I was under the impression that the plane buried into the ground on impact is this correct? The reason i ask is because after posting that on a forum someone said thats not in the 911 commission report and therefore me as a believer of the official story am actually contradicting it.

Get them to prove you wrong. It should be very easy for them if they're right. If they do, you will have learned something.

Chances are they've misread something, or are interpreting an omission as evidence that something didn't happen. Twoofers seem to think the 911 commision was tasked with proving beyond doubt the movements of every atom on 9/11.
 
Get them to prove you wrong. It should be very easy for them if they're right. If they do, you will have learned something.

Chances are they've misread something, or are interpreting an omission as evidence that something didn't happen. Twoofers seem to think the 911 commision was tasked with proving beyond doubt the movements of every atom on 9/11.

Thats exacly it because i say it buried in the ground and the report according to him does not either one or both must be wrong. He puts it down as a contradiction even though i pointed out there has to be two opposing views for there to be a contradiction.

I just wanted to check am i right saying it went into the ground?

Mind you this guy is a true woo woo. He will not except that it buried in the ground and it buried under the ground mean the same thing.
 
Actually, a Global Hawk at 40 feet AGL is impossible.

The control laws won't allow it. Its normal air data sensors aren't accurate enough and don't update fast enough to fly nap-of-the-earth. It knows this, so an attempt to fly as such would be overridden by commands to seek altitude. If this automatic response was disabled, it would probably crash.

When Global Hawk lands, it first must overfly the landing strip to take a high-resolution SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) scan of the area, calibrated against its on-board GPS. Only then does it have enough knowledge of the terrain to attempt a landing.

It does not have the electrical power or the processor power to run this continuously. There is, therefore, no way for it to operate at low altitude, particularly THAT low.

TerrorCell, in addition to being stark raving wrong, really showed his class earlier today by calling me a "Nazi." What a swell poster-child for the flailing "Truth Movement," eh? ;) He fits in fine with the rest of my Ignore portfolio...

Yes I would have to put TC up there with Lyte in terms of his "class". As for his typical juvenile comments concerning people not answering his questions, let me say this...

TC:

If I wanted to answer your questions, I would. Not answering them is more like me not following the soaps. Just like I have no desire to watch or discuss the soaps, I have no desire to answer certain elements of your diatribe. I pick and choose what I respond to...that is my right, it is not an examination. Just as you and many truthers ignore 75% of those questions thrown out there, and that is your right. Now if you ask me a question directly, I will answer it if I can, or tell you I do not know enough on a given subject if I cannot.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom