Help with Shanksville question

believing something that is absent from a report is NOT contradicting said report.

TAM:)
 
Are you insinuating Ed Felt's call may not be genuine?

Are you saying that a missile struck the plane...and Felt kept talking long enough to report the colour of the smoke?

What do you think happens to a plane after it takes an AIM-9?
 
My "theory" is more along the lines of the blood and bodies were mainly at a different debris field.

So.....the plane was shot down and the people inside spilled out at one site and then the plane itself crashed somewhere else? Wow.

TC, in a thread where you've ignored almost every question posed to you, can you at least tell me what kind of debris the locals found in Indian Lake - according to them, not you?
 
I know what happens to a plane when a PATRIOT hits it; I'm sure an AIM-9 is similar.
 
So it was not a Predator - too slow, has weapons but only had hellfire tested in 2001, not air to air Sraams, reasonable match for looks

It was not Global Hawk - no weapons, too slow, would have had to have been have been prototype at that time, close match for looks

It made no noise even at 40 feet (look at videos on youtube of Global Hawks taking off and hear the noise)

It was not a Tomahawk cruise missile - not even close on looks, fast enough but no air to air capability, very noisy

It was not an AGM-86 cruise missile possible match for looks, fast enough but no air to air capability, very noisy

There is no unmanned vehicle that could have taken down this flight

It must have been a fighter jet with a long range air to air missile, noisy plane and noisy missile and explosion, missile probably too fast to see at mach 4 and would not be at 40ft

If so this flight would have been spread for miles in large and small pieces like Pan Am 103 was, it was spread over 845 square miles and had large pieces still intact even from miles higher
 
So what aircraft make no noise?

Now you're getting the idea. That's a great question. I would like to know.

And how does this prove a missile took down flight 93?

It doesn't. What it does do though is prove a cover up is taking place which then casts doubt on the credibility of the official story.

IT IS NOT A GLOBAL HAWK. IT IS ONLY SIMILAR IN APPEARANCE TO ONE.
 
There are numerous very bizarre ideas being discussed here. I think it is absolutely hilariously ludicrous to believe that a remote controlled drone could or would fly at 20'-40' (depends on which statement is correct) and below telephone and/or utility lines. Now, that is a feat that could only be accomplished in a video game. No don't think a movie director would even try this type of feat except in "The Flight of the Loony Bird".

Not only is this fictitious UAV flying at an impossibly low altitude, but I've yet to see a purpose stated for this miraculous achievement. Why was it there? What possible purpose would it serve?

I probably shouldn't ask such pertinent questions as it is quite entertaining to witness this supreme level of buffoonery continue! I wouldn't want to spoil the fun for everyone else....

So it's "impossible" for an UAV to fly that low but completely possible for a 757 to fly close enough to the ground as to hit car antenna's in DC.

I see the logic at play here.......
 
What kind of propulsion system does an aircraft use to move at a good rate of speed without making any kind of noise?


Seeing that I actually designed the propulsion system for it this isn't really hard to describe..... :boggled:
 
Gravy some Flight 93 True & False's for you :

1) The plane flew over Val McClatchey's house.
2) Over 95% of the plane was recovered from the crater.
3) Debris spread over a 2-4 mile radius.
4) A debris field was at Shanksville.
5) A debris field was at Indian Lake.
6) A debris field was at New Baltimore.
7) Ed Felt called 911 reporting an explosion on the plane and white smoke.
8) There are countless eyewitnesses to the "little white plane".
9) The "little white plane" was seen before and after the crash.
10) WestMoreland 911 County personnel are under gag orders and the FBI confiscated Ed Felt's phone call.



Noted - Gravy ducks and dodges.
 
TC, in a thread where you've ignored almost every question posed to you, can you at least tell me what kind of debris the locals found in Indian Lake - according to them, not you?

"Residents and workers at businesses outside Shanksville, Somerset County, reported discovering clothing, books, papers and what appeared to be human remains. Some residents said they collected bags-full of items to be turned over to investigators. Others reported what appeared to be crash debris floating in Indian Lake, nearly six miles from the immediate crash scene."
http://post-gazette.com/headlines/20010913somersetp3.asp


Will someone hazard a guess and tell me how debris travels six miles upon impact with "soft" dirt?
 
Or maybe he has a life and hasn't had time to catch up on this thread. :rolleyes:
 
Hi Gravy,

My original problem was this. I was under the impression that the plane buried into the ground on impact is this correct? The reason i ask is because after posting that on a forum someone said thats not in the 911 commission report and therefore me as a believer of the official story am actually contradicting it.
Warner, your statement is partially correct. Much of the plane did bury itself, some of it quite deep in the soil of the reclaimed mine (no bedrock to stop it just beneath the surface). Other parts would have fractured, sheared, and rebounded from the impact forces, and other parts were blasted up and away by the exploding fuel, mostly in the direction of the plane's travel (southerly).

Here's a post about a high-speed airliner crash that produced similar effects.

Flight 93 was traveling at about 850 feet per second at impact: as fast as a bullet fired from a .45 ACP. Below are photos of small debris in the crater, and debris covering the road and cabin on the other side of the trees. The third photo is of a dumpster partially filled with plane debris collected by 300 volunteers three weeks after the crash. This was done because storms had come through and shaken debris loose from the trees.

87904679178f6d9fc.jpg


87904679178fd6592.jpg


8790462a8afd17aeb.jpg
 
So it's "impossible" for an UAV to fly that low but completely possible for a 757 to fly close enough to the ground as to hit car antenna's in DC.

I see the logic at play here.......

Where's that antenna? I need one is why I'm asking.

Yes, you're correct about the 757 as there is was a wreckage into the side of a building very shortly after it flew close to the ground to prove it.

Now, where's that UAV wreckage again?

You wouldn't recognize logic if it bit you in the #$@%!
 
How does that explain putting people on ignore who he refuses to address?

I've seen him "address" ErrorCell's rambling stew of lies at least ten times, myself. The Ignore feature is quite appropriate in this situation.

You, on the other hand... Did you ever find a claim that Dr. Griffin got right in his latest book, or are you still refusing to address that? Feel free to put me on Ignore, if you haven't already. :D
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/8790462a8afd17aeb.jpg[/qimg]​

Please post the evidence that the container of scrap metal is actually from Flight 93. Are any of those scraps serially charged?

Is it possible that the container of scrap came from the Rollock Scrap Metal company less than half a mile away?

rollock-map.jpg


"Some visitors to the Flight 93 temporary memorial look across the abandoned strip mine in Stonycreek Township and mistake the pile of scrap they see for debris from the hijacked jetliner.

The mangled heap of iron and steel actually belongs to Rollock Inc., a scrap metal business owned and managed by the father-and-son team of Tony and Chris Kordell of Bedford County.

The property they purchased three years ago abuts the crash site, which lies just several yards beyond the perimeter of the Kordells' land." – Pittsburgh Live (09/11/02)
 
You, on the other hand... Did you ever find a claim that Dr. Griffin got right in his latest book, or are you still refusing to address that? Feel free to put me on Ignore, if you haven't already. :D


Yes! I did, and it went completely unaddressed.

I don't put people on ignore because I can literally ignore a post if I don't want to read it.

Putting people on ignore is a sign of defeat and cowardliness.

Short of abusive, malicious behavior, there is no reason to do it other than admit not having a rebuttal for my statements and questions.
 
Yes! I did, and it went completely unaddressed.

I don't put people on ignore because I can literally ignore a post if I don't want to read it.

Putting people on ignore is a sign of defeat and cowardliness.

Short of abusive, malicious behavior, there is no reason to do it other than admit not having a rebuttal for my statements and questions.


Now you're lying.

So why should we listen to your opinions on why Gravy chooses to ignore someone? It's clearly not worth much, even if you knew the guy, which you don't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom