Haig and his Sun caused earthquakes

jimbob said:
The largest earthquake in the Pacific Northwest occurred in 1700 (we know this from Japanese records describing the resulting Tsunami). This was in the middle of the Maunder Minimum, which was a period of low solar activity.

Meanwhile - whilst googling for the largest known solar storm in the previous 200 years (the Carrington Superstorm, I wanted to see if there were any notable earthquakes that occurred in September 1859)

I came across this link that has some good plots in it and access to the data, so that one can perform more detailed analysis if one wants to waste time.

It is worth clicking through to see the plots, but I will just leave this quote - which is what many people have been saying, but not with these exact words.



http://www.thesuntoday.org/solar-facts/flares-and-earthquakes/
Click to expand...


If you look into it further, you will find that for a period of low solar activity, such as during the Little Ice Age, that major earthquakes, volcanoes and storms were a feature of that time ;)

In times of low solar activity coronal holes can leave the solar poles and frequently enter into the lower solar latitudes hosing the Earth and the other planets with much faster solar wind. :eek:


Just today a coronal hole impact hit the earth triggering major earthquakes ;)

Impact/Magnetic Storm, Space Shockwaves | S0 News Jan.6.2016
 
Last edited:
Haig said:
...
Just today a coronal hole impact hit the earth triggering major earthquakes ;)
...
Click to expand...

Unfortunately for you, you have no data supporting solar activity actually triggering an earthquake.
You just have your gullible belief and your irrational youtube kook.
 
Daylightstar said:
I suspect you are confusing claims with data. Same kook as in your youtube videos on that Vimeo video, right?
Click to expand...

you have to love such cool scientific insights like:

There is a long-term average of three M6 earthquakes per week but there is almost never 3 in any given week.
 
Haig said:
Yes there is data supporting solar activity actually triggering an earthquake...]
Click to expand...
That is a lie - there are only fantasies on that web page by an idiot cherry picking coronal holes to fit earthquakes :jaw-dropp! The most idiotic thing is that the author (Ben Davidson or a mindless follower) presents no evidence that the fast solar wind from these coronal holes actually came anywhere near the Earth. Even if the fast solar wind hit the Earth there is no evidence that it would have any effect - the Earth has a magnetic field that is really good at diverting the solar wind.
Haig: The many years of ignorance, delusions and lies from a Thunderbolts cultist parroting other Thunderbolts cultists.

ETA: It may be that the emissions from coronal holes often hit the Earth. SpaceWeather
Coronal Holes: 06 Jan 16
Earth is inside a stream of solar wind flowing from the indicated coronal hole.
Click to expand...
Coronal holes seem to last for a day or more so it is should not be a shock if an strong (>M6)earthquake happened during that period :eek:!

ETA: The author lies abut coronal holes impacting the Earth- what a surprise!
They mention "February 27, 2010: I am relying on the diligence of Dr. Tony Phillips at SpaceWeather.com and his historical archives" but what does SpaceWeather.com say for the dates in that web page?
  • Coronal Holes: 30 May 15 There are no large coronal holes on the Earthside of the sun.
  • Coronal Holes: 25 Apr 15 There are no large coronal holes on the Earthside of the sun.
  • Coronal Holes: 23 Jun 14 There are no large equatorial coronal holes on the Earthside of the sun.
  • Coronal Holes: 02 Apr 14 There are no large coronal holes on the Earthside of the sun.
  • Coronal Holes: 24 May 13 Solar wind flowing from this coronal hole could brush past Earth's magnetic field on May 27-28
    M8.3 in Russia on 24 May 2014 :eek:!
  • Coronal Holes: 06 Feb 13 Solar wind flowing from this coronal holes could brush against Earth's magnetic field on Feb. 8-9.
    M8.0 in the Solomon Islands on 6 February 2013!
  • Coronal Holes: 11 Apr 12 Solar wind flowing from this coronal hole should reach Earth on April 13-14.
    M8.6 and M8.2 in Sumatra on 11 April 2012!
  • Coronal Holes: 11 Mar 11 A solar wind stream flowing from the indicated coronal hole is likely to brush past Earth's magnetic field on or about March 14th.
    M9.0 in Japan on 11 March 2011!
  • Coronal Holes: 25 Oct 10 Earth is entering a solar wind stream flowing from the indicated coronal hole.
  • Coronal Holes: 27 Feb 10 A solar wind stream flowing from the indicated coronal hole could reach Earth on or about March 2nd.
    M8.8 in Chile on 27 February 2010!
  • Coronal Holes: 24 Dec 04 A solar wind stream flowing from the indicated coronal hole might hit Earth's magnetic field on Dec. 26th, but the impact will not likely spark bright auroras.
As soon as the economist Ben Davidson starts to use his incompetence about astronomy to analyze SDO data he gets it spectacularly wrong which results in lies about coronal holes impacting the Earth.
 
Last edited:
It seems that this hypothesis lacks predictive power.
All it claims is 'The sun did something! That means an Earthquake!' This lacks information.

I want to see: The sun did x. It was at strength y. The effect will reach the earth at z time. This will produce an earthquake of a given magnitude in that region.

So, Haig. Show us the above. Make predictions given the power of solar storms, as to where an earthquake will occur, and at what magnitude it will occur at.

Without solid predictive power, there is nothing.
 
Shalamar said:
It seems that this hypothesis lacks predictive power.
Click to expand...

No, there has been earthquake predictions made and the success rate has been 90% +

All it claims is 'The sun did something! That means an Earthquake!' This lacks information.
Click to expand...

No, I think that means you haven't quite understood the hypothesis.

I want to see: The sun did x. It was at strength y. The effect will reach the earth at z time. This will produce an earthquake of a given magnitude in that region.
Click to expand...

There has been significant progress towards that goal.

So, Haig. Show us the above. Make predictions given the power of solar storms, as to where an earthquake will occur, and at what magnitude it will occur at.
Click to expand...

Sure, just follow Qwake Watch.

Without solid predictive power, there is nothing.
Click to expand...

I agree but to get there you HAVE to explore the hypothesis !


The hypothesis is: Relationship Between M8+ Earthquake Occurrences and the Solar Polar Magnetic Fields pdf
Davidson said:
Abstract
The solar polar fields (SPF) data, as measured by the Wilcox Solar Observatory (WSO), has been studied and compared with the large magnitude earthquake record from the United States Geological Survey. The time period covers the 38 years (+13,600 days) that the WSO has collected the SPF data. This study reveals a dependence of M8.0+ seismicity on the oscillations of the SPF; the results and analysis is reported.
Click to expand...


A good explanation of evidence for the Sun - Earth connection triggering earthquakes is in this short video ... The Sun and Earthquakes

So far so good :)

CORONAL HOLES AND EARTHQUAKES
Strange waves, interplanetary magnetic fields, modulation of the solar wind current sheet… Coronal Holes play a role in many electromagnetic phenomena. There is a long-term average of three M6 earthquakes per week but there is almost never 3 in any given week. There is an ebb and flow of above and below average activity; using coronal holes as the primary factor, we have a +90% success rate in predicting those time periods in our daily news posted at Suspicious0bservers.org.
Click to expand...


Hopefully the purpose of the daily Suspicious 0bservers videos will be a little clearer now ;)




Something else to consider when looking at the Sun - Earth connection triggering earthquakes

The effects of seasonal and diurnal variations in the Earth's magnetic dipole orientation on solar wind-magnetosphere-ionosphere coupling
Changes in solar wind-magnetosphere coupling also affect the field-aligned currents, but these are influenced as well by variations in the conductance associated with variations in mu, more so than the cross-polar cap potential. This may be the case for geomagnetic activity too.
Click to expand...


AND importantly ...

Earth's Magnetic Field Is Weakening 10 Times Faster Now
Earth's magnetic field, which protects the planet from huge blasts of deadly solar radiation, has been weakening over the past six months, according to data collected by a European SpaceAgency (ESA) satellite array called Swarm.
Click to expand...
The Swarm satellites not only pick up signals coming from the Earth's magnetic field, but also from its core, mantle, crust and oceans. Scientists at the ESA hope to use the data to make navigation systems that rely on the magnetic field, such as aircraft instruments, more accurate, improve earthquake predictions and pinpoint areas below the planet's surface that are rich in natural resources. Scientists think fluctuations in the magnetic field could help identify where continental plates are shifting and help predict earthquakes.
Click to expand...
 
Haig said:
No, there has been earthquake predictions made and the success rate has been 90% +
Click to expand...
That is a lie parroted from Ben Davidson: Haig: The many years of ignorance, delusions and lies from a Thunderbolts cultist parroting other Thunderbolts cultists.

And a couple of more lies from Haig:
The effects of seasonal and diurnal variations in the Earth's magnetic dipole orientation on solar wind-magnetosphere-ionosphere coupling is not about earthquakes.
And more importantly Earth's Magnetic Field Is Weakening 10 Times Faster Now is also not about earthquakes :eek:!
 
Last edited:
I see no predictions.

Show me a solid prediction.

Sun activity associated with a place, and earthquake magnitude on earth, BEFORE it happens.

I will not watch youtube videos. Post the prediction here.
 
Haig said:
...
They are clear and to the point also giving links to source material so you can think for yourself and draw your own opinions ;)
...
Click to expand...

Those videos are clear and to the point to such an extent that they allow me to form my own opinion or draw my own conclusion, which ever way you prefer to express it.

And as you know, I already did:
Daylightstar said:
They exist to express unsubstantiated, irrational belief.
Very clear :)
Click to expand...
I even said it was very clear :p

Of course your posts here help me in that regard as well, enormously ;)
 
You're helping me, Haig, and probably others reading this forum in the same way. I'm not sure you're really helping Ben Davidson though.
 
Daylightstar said:
You're helping me, Haig, and probably others reading this forum in the same way. I'm not sure you're really helping Ben Davidson though.
Click to expand...


Don't worry Ben is doing fine :D

QuakeWatch.net
(Jan 6 2202UTC) HELIOSPHERIC DISRUPTION WARNING: Synced solar eruptions today follow up a powerful blast yesterday to offer a significant disruption to the heliosphere that will effect the 1AU ring beginning tomorrow. The earthquake watch index dropped to nearly its lowest levels, however, with a coronal hole coming in and Venus/Saturn 2 days from conjunction, now it will rise early!
Click to expand...


The latest vid on our Sun - Earth connection triggering earthquakes and a vid on how it works ;)

Heliospheric Disruption Warning, Electric Waves | S0 News Jan.7.2016


EARTHSPOTS: Storms and Earthquakes [Update]
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom