GOP governors consider turning down stimulus money

I am happy to take the stimulus money for Alaska and Louisiana and use it in New York. If the people in those states want to starve...good for them.
 
BPSCG said:
And who speaks for the state? Is it the legislature? Or is it the governor? Do state legislatures have absolute power over spending? Do state governors have no veto power over spending appropriations?


That's up to the state to decide, isn't it?
That's quite correct. And what you are saying is that it is within the Congress's purview to say, "It doesn't matter what the state constitutions say, the states get the money as long as the legislatures agree. The governors and their vetoes can go take a long walk off a short pier."

If the state legislature decides that it wants the money, and the state governor decides that he doesn't, then the Fed is under no legal obligation to respect either of their decisions. If necessary, the state supreme court can sort out whether or not the state legislature has the authority under state statutes to overrule the governor.
That is generally already covered under the individual states' constitutions in the sections regarding veto power and overriding of vetoes.

The Fed has simply decided -- as is its right
Reform your language. Government has no rights. The people have rights. The government only has the powers which the people have ceded to it.
 
I'm pretty sure Article IV, Section 4 of the US Constitution, which compels the federal government to "guarantee to every state in this union a republican form of government" would prohibit the feds from rewriting State Constitutions (for example, to eliminate gubernatorial vetos) except where the State Constitution violates federal constitutional rights.

Of course, since nobody's ever tried to use federal law to rewrite how the State governments operate, this would be a question of first impression for the Supreme Court.
 
Last edited:
Just what part of the Constitution do you think puts this in shaky ground?

I must confess, I've been reading over Article I, as well as the Amendments, and I'm just curious as to what part of the Constitution you think a provision like this is coming close to violating.

The guarantee of a republican form of government?

edit: Damn, beaten by two hours...
 
The guarantee of a republican form of government?

edit: Damn, beaten by two hours...

Ok, but just what is it violating?

Article IV, Section 4 means actual republican government. It means that you can't have New Hampshire be a dictatorship, or let Nevada become a monarchy.
 
One could also reasonably expect it to guarantee the States the freedom to determine their own legislative procedures without interference from the rest of the States. If the laws of a State dictate a certain procedure to override a governor's veto, it is not the province of other States (via the federal government) to subvert those laws.
 
As I said, there's very little law on that clause, but my understanding of the intent behind it was two-fold:
1) The other States were afraid they'd become shackled to State that fell into despotism, so they authorized the federal government to ensure despotism wouldn't develop.
2) The States feared the federal government would interfere in the way their State was run, so they obligated the feds to ensure that the feds wouldn't do that.

Any attempt to rewrite State Constitutions would seem to fall under that second motivation. Of course, we won't know for certain until the Supreme Court opines on the matter.
 
As I said, there's very little law on that clause, but my understanding of the intent behind it was two-fold:
1) The other States were afraid they'd become shackled to State that fell into despotism, so they authorized the federal government to ensure despotism wouldn't develop.
2) The States feared the federal government would interfere in the way their State was run, so they obligated the feds to ensure that the feds wouldn't do that.

Any attempt to rewrite State Constitutions would seem to fall under that second motivation. Of course, we won't know for certain until the Supreme Court opines on the matter.

No, it actually refers to the type of government.

The government "interferes" with state governments all the time. They have the power to. They HAVE to have the power to.

That was the whole essence behind the Incorporation clause in the 14th Amendment.

Also, that's not what is happeneing. NO ONE is rewriting State Constitutions. The provision in question is giving state legislators the ability to get the money.
 
Last edited:
States can't secede from the Union.

The US Constitution doesn't say that. And all that the Civil War proved is that force of arms can prevent it. More important, the formation of the UNITED States was based on the principles set forth in the Declaration of Independence ... that governments "derive their just powers from the consent of the governed” and “whenever any form of government becomes destructive to these ends (BAC - securing Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness) , it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new government”. Also, “when a long train of abuses and usurpations ... snip ... evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.” That language would seem to grant the citizens of states the *right* to secede under some circumstances, regardless of what the federal government or anyone in it says. Not that I'm advocating it in this circumstance.
 
The US Constitution doesn't say that. And all that the Civil War proved is that force of arms can prevent it. More important, the formation of the UNITED States was based on the principles set forth in the Declaration of Independence ... that governments "derive their just powers from the consent of the governed” and “whenever any form of government becomes destructive to these ends (BAC - securing Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness) , it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new government”. Also, “when a long train of abuses and usurpations ... snip ... evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.” That language would seem to grant the citizens of states the *right* to secede under some circumstances, regardless of what the federal government or anyone in it says. Not that I'm advocating it in this circumstance.

Uh....what?

The Declaration is not applicable. It is not a governing document.

The Constitution is, though. And while nothing may EXPLICITLY discuss it, that does not mean that States have the POWER, nor the RIGHT, to secede.

Look up Texas v. White. It's a SCOTUS case from the 1860s.
 
So you don't think the Declaration of Independence is applicable any longer?

In terms of a governing document? No. It did what it needed to, provide a legal framework, with a list of our grievances, in regards to our Revolution.

Do you think that the colonies had any "right" to secede from Britain?

No. Then again, I'm not much for "rights" when applied to a government. Governments have power, but not rights.

What is your point, though? How does that apply to our Constitution?
 
The government "interferes" with state governments all the time. They have the power to. They HAVE to have the power to.

That was the whole essence behind the Incorporation clause in the 14th Amendment.
But they don't re-write State Constitutions. The Feds can only rewrite State Constitutions when the State Constitution violates the Federal Constitution (by, for example, denying people the right to vote).

But I don't believe that Congress could pass a law with a simple majority of both houses (and the President's signature) that would compel, for instance, New York's legislature to change from bicameral to unicameral. I don't believe that the Constitution affords the federal government that much power to interfere with how State's operate.

Also, that's not what is happeneing. NO ONE is rewriting State Constitutions. The provision in question is giving state legislators the ability to get the money.
If a State Constitution grants the governor a veto on legislative enactments, then yes, that's what is happening.
 
If a State Constitution grants the governor a veto on legislative enactments, then yes, that's what is happening.

Well, this leads back to the Nullification issue I mentioned earlier.

Are you referring to the concurrent resolution provision? Or to the actual money being doled out to a state?
 
Neither. I'm referring to the hypothetical raised in this thread of Congress passing a law that would deny a gubernatorial veto if the legislature passes a resolution accepting federal funds. I'm speaking hypothetically -- not of any specific proposal currently in or around Congress.
 
So they're not going to accept bailout money now? That's big of them but we're still in the early stages of the world depression. Its going to get a lot worse before it gets better and the grandstanders of today will be begging for funds later.

Oh? Which world depression would that be?
 
Neither. I'm referring to the hypothetical raised in this thread of Congress passing a law that would deny a gubernatorial veto if the legislature passes a resolution accepting federal funds. I'm speaking hypothetically -- not of any specific proposal currently in or around Congress.

Well, someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but if the states have somewhat similar rules to federal government, then it means nothing.

What I mean is this:

A concurrent resolution, within the Federal Government, does not make it to the President to be signed, meaning that the President can't veto.

If the states work in a similar manner, then the Governor wouldn't be able to veto, so long as the State legislature passes a concurrent resolution.

I could be wrong, as I'm not as familiar with state governments. I would assume, though, that most, if not all, have similar measures already in place for things like state budgets, etc.
 
A concurrent resolution, within the Federal Government, does not make it to the President to be signed, meaning that the President can't veto.
A concurrent resolution has no effect of law. It's just a way for Congress to declare how they feel about something, like honoring a war hero, or condemning a foreign massacre.

But the Congress cannot choose to accept money from, say Canada, with the caveat that tariffs be reduced (or even without that caveat) through a concurrent resolution.

I would assume, though, that most, if not all, have similar measures already in place for things like state budgets, etc.
You'd assume wrong. That's not how it works in Congress or in State legislatures. Concurrent resolutions do not have any legal effect and Congress cannot force States to treat concurrent resolutions as if they did.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom