GOP governors consider turning down stimulus money

This sounds to me to be of questionable constitutionality. Can the federal government force states to accept federal money through the mechanism of interfering in the states' legislative processes?

Not the way I read it.

It seems to me that this provision was put in to help prevent the very kind of thing we are seeing with the governors. As in, it was put in to help out state legislators who want the money but who get blocked by a governor. Instead of going through what could be a fairly long veto-type battle in the state, they just have to adopt the measure and they'll get the money.
 
Not the way I read it.

It seems to me that this provision was put in to help prevent the very kind of thing we are seeing with the governors.
Oh, no doubt.

As in, it was put in to help out state legislators who want the money but who get blocked by a governor. Instead of going through what could be a fairly long veto-type battle in the state, they just have to adopt the measure and they'll get the money.
So the federal government is taking away state governors' veto powers.

And you're okay with this?
 
Last edited:
Below is the federal return on each tax dollar paid by the the six states mentioned in the article.

Texas: $0.97
Mississippi: $2.02
Louisiana: $1.85
Alaska: $1.83
South Carolina: $1.35
Idaho:$1.19

All but one already receive more money than they pay and Texas is pretty close to break even. That doesn't necessarily invalidate their positions, but I think it's fair to say these states already receive "economic stimulus".
 
This sounds to me to be of questionable constitutionality. Can the federal government force states to accept federal money through the mechanism of interfering in the states' legislative processes?

No one's forcing anything or interfering in anything. If "the state" doesn't want the money, it won't get any.

You are confusing "the governor" with "the state." An easy confusion, I suppose -- but here's a hint. The "state" is much larger.
 
No one's forcing anything or interfering in anything. If "the state" doesn't want the money, it won't get any.
And who speaks for the state? Is it the legislature? Or is it the governor? Do state legislatures have absolute power over spending? Do state governors have no veto power over spending appropriations?

Look up the term "checks and balances." See why James Madison thought it was such a good idea, he made a very public case for its being in the Constitution.
 
And who speaks for the state? Is it the legislature? Or is it the governor? Do state legislatures have absolute power over spending? Do state governors have no veto power over spending appropriations?

Look up the term "checks and balances." See why James Madison thought it was such a good idea, he made a very public case for its being in the Constitution.

Look, I love James Madison's views on the Constitution as much as the next guy (I think he's my favorite writer of the Federalist Papers), but let me ask you this:

Just what part of the Constitution do you think puts this in shaky ground?

I must confess, I've been reading over Article I, as well as the Amendments, and I'm just curious as to what part of the Constitution you think a provision like this is coming close to violating.
 
I must confess, I've been reading over Article I, as well as the Amendments, and I'm just curious as to what part of the Constitution you think a provision like this is coming close to violating.
I'm no constitutional scholar, but the 10th amendment?

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
I don't see where the Constitution gives the federal government the power to tell the states how to spend money, or how their legislative processes are supposed to work. Aren't those powers that are reserved to the states?

And what about that phrase, "nor prohibited by [the Constitution] to the states..." Does the Constitution prohibit anywhere the states from determining how to spend their money? If not, then it seems to me the federal government does not have the power to do force states to spend money.
 
New Hampshire Constitution, Article 10

Oh, you mean the evil empire will roll in the tanks? Well, if it comes to that... I personally have no moral qualms about nuking Washington DC. Not one bit.

Huh?

The Right of Revolution as discussed does not provide any means of secession. It provides a Right of Revolution in regards to the STATE government. It's not applicable to the FEDERAL government.

Again, states can't secede from the Union.
 
I'm no constitutional scholar, but the 10th amendment?

I don't see where the Constitution gives the federal government the power to tell the states how to spend money, or how their legislative processes are supposed to work. Aren't those powers that are reserved to the states?

And what about that phrase, "nor prohibited by [the Constitution] to the states..." Does the Constitution prohibit anywhere the states from determining how to spend their money? If not, then it seems to me the federal government does not have the power to do force states to spend money.

How so?

Specifically, what power would a state be exercising in this matter?

Also, this is setting up a potential nullification issue. We all know what happened the last time....
 
Specifically, what power would a state be exercising in this matter?
The power to set its own budget?

Also, this is setting up a potential nullification issue. We all know what happened the last time....
Well, you and I do. Someone needs to explain it to Alex Libman.

Actually, it would only be a nullification issue if the stimulus law was ruled constitutional. If the states take the issue to the Supreme Court, and win...
 
The power to set its own budget?

Well, you and I do. Someone needs to explain it to Alex Libman.

Actually, it would only be a nullification issue if the stimulus law was ruled constitutional. If the states take the issue to the Supreme Court, and win...
AS I read it, Gov. Perry (Texas) is very leery of another big blooddy damn Unfunded Federal Mandate--I.e., a program that the US G'bmint starts, then requires the state to finish (or maintain) whether it works or not...
 
I'm no constitutional scholar, but the 10th amendment?

I don't see where the Constitution gives the federal government the power to tell the states how to spend money, or how their legislative processes are supposed to work. Aren't those powers that are reserved to the states?

The point you raise is a good and interesting one. I have not read the bill, but if it does try to alter the manner in which a state can accept the money by changing the state's own laws, that would almost certainly be a constitutional violation. Congress does not have the power to change a state's own laws.

Congress has tried things like this in the past. For example, there was a case (the name I forget but will search for it if anyone really wants to know) where congress passed a law regulating superfund sites. Lots of the provisions were ok as the state had to expressly agree to get funds, but one of the provisions would have forced a state to have its legislature pass a new state law. SCOTUS said no, Congress cannot try to alter a state's own laws. If that's what the provision in question tries to do, that would seem to be a clear consitutional violation.

The only question would be if the proposals that Congress typically gets a state to agree to usually include in their own language by what method the money can be accepted. If that is the case and this is simply broadening that method so that a state can IF IT WANTS TO have the legislature accept it, then it might be consitutional. But again, I would think there would be some state rule governing how the money could be accepted, and Congree could not override that.
 
And who speaks for the state?

That's up to the state to decide, isn't it?

Is it the legislature? Or is it the governor? Do state legislatures have absolute power over spending? Do state governors have no veto power over spending appropriations?

That's up to the state to decide, isn't it?

If the state legislature decides that it wants the money, and the state governor decides that he doesn't, then the Fed is under no legal obligation to respect either of their decisions. If necessary, the state supreme court can sort out whether or not the state legislature has the authority under state statutes to overrule the governor.

The Fed has simply decided -- as is its right -- that it will make money available to any state that asks for it via a concurrent resolution. Since the money is the Fed's and it can make it available in any way it sees fit (including dropping it from a helicopter), let the states fight it out.

Similarly, the Fed could have decided to allow cities to ask for the money, bypassing the state government altogether. That's their perogative. If that really bothered the governor, he could certainly ask the legislature for a special bill prohibiting cities for applying for federal aid without the approval of the governor's office -- that's his perogative. Hell, the Fed could have decided to let me apply for the money as an individual (my front fence is a "shovel-ready project"). It's their money and they can make it available as they see fit.
 
The point you raise is a good and interesting one. I have not read the bill, but if it does try to alter the manner in which a state can accept the money by changing the state's own laws, that would almost certainly be a constitutional violation. Congress does not have the power to change a state's own laws.

State legislatures have always had the authority to pass concurrent resolutions. Nothing new there. Congress isn't changing any of the states' laws or forcing them to do anything.

Lots of the provisions were ok as the state had to expressly agree to get funds,

Bingo. If the state legislature expressly agrees to getting the new funds, Congress will make those funds available, even if the governor objects.

Whether or not they actually get them will (of course) depend on the powers given to the governor under state law.
 
Actually, it would only be a nullification issue if the stimulus law was ruled constitutional. If the states take the issue to the Supreme Court, and win...

Is this assuming that there was a challenge to that very provision of the law that made it to the SCOTUS, who then ruled it was Constitutional?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom