GOP governors consider turning down stimulus money

So now you are reading his mind. Ok.

He is talking in the past tense, i.e. what most states already do. I know of no state where you can currently collect unemployment after being terminated with cause, hence my assumption he is using the generic term, 'fired' to mean people terminated without cause, what most people call, 'laid-off'.

It is really pretty simple.
 
Okay. So you have an argument made by someone who bias'd... and after reading the article, the requiremetns are.

. Among actions required to qualify, states would have to provide benefits to people who quit a job for a "compelling family reason" such as caring for a sick or disabled member of their immediate family, or because of domestic violence. Workers could collect benefits only when they started looking for a new job.

Hm. Gee, I wonder why this isn't that bad as RUINING THE SMALL BUISNESS market.
 
He is talking in the past tense, i.e. what most states already do. I know of no state where you can currently collect unemployment after being terminated with cause, hence my assumption he is using the generic term, 'fired' to mean people terminated without cause, what most people call, 'laid-off'.

It is really pretty simple.
Then maybe you should tell him. That being said I noticed that you didn't address the real problem i.e. unemployment insurance to those that quit voluntarily and what that means to the costs of every business but especially small businesses.
 
Okay. So you have an argument made by someone who bias'd... and after reading the article, the requiremetns are.



Hm. Gee, I wonder why this isn't that bad as RUINING THE SMALL BUISNESS market.
You are making no sense.
 
Did you read the restrictions on that?
Yes I read them and they are not restrictions they are excuses to fund a new welfare benefit at the expense of private employers. Welfare is the responsibility of the government.
 
Then maybe you should tell him. That being said I noticed that you didn't address the real problem i.e. unemployment insurance to those that quit voluntarily and what that means to the costs of every business but especially small businesses.

Tell him what? That someone in Texas has a reading comprehension problem?

What does it mean to the costs of small businesses? maybe a 1% increase in payroll taxes?
 
Damn I'm dumb.

Heh, I just wanted to make sure because my future Brother in law is in Texas and he went on a rant a few days ago about how unemployment is a good thing for the company he works for but her couldn't explain what he meant. I just saw that and was wondering if (in Texas) it was a good thing and you could explain it better than he. :o

ETA: I'm also gonna feel like a jackass if you aren't from Texas and just really like the state.
 
Tell him what? That someone in Texas has a reading comprehension problem?

What does it mean to the costs of small businesses? maybe a 1% increase in payroll taxes?
Let's say it is only 1% which is ridiculously low given the unpredictable effect it will have. The Federal government is trying to force private business to fund a new welfare benefit and that is why GOP governors are up in arms. The Texas economy is doing fine and the government is running a surplus so Perry is just saying keep your money and give it to California or Massachusetts. We DON'T need it. If Obama wants to create a new welfare benefit then pass a law in congress that funds it. My reading comprehension is fine. I can read the word "fired" without imagining it actually read "laid off".
 
Heh, I just wanted to make sure because my future Brother in law is in Texas and he went on a rant a few days ago about how unemployment is a good thing for the company he works for but her couldn't explain what he meant. I just saw that and was wondering if (in Texas) it was a good thing and you could explain it better than he. :o

ETA: I'm also gonna feel like a jackass if you aren't from Texas and just really like the state.
I am a Texan originally from Oklahoma. That is something I am very quiet about.
 
Let's say it is only 1% which is ridiculously low given the unpredictable effect it will have. The Federal government is trying to force private business to fund a new welfare benefit and that is why GOP governors are up in arms. The Texas economy is doing fine and the government is running a surplus so Perry is just saying keep your money and give it to California or Massachusetts. We DON'T need it. If Obama wants to create a new welfare benefit then pass a law in congress that funds it. My reading comprehension is fine. I can read the word "fired" without imagining it actually read "laid off".

So if he means 'fired', which states is he talking about?

I am not arguing that Texas needs it, just that it will not crush small businesses.
1% might also be ridiculously high, as it would be more than double the current rates.
 
Last edited:
Yes. Unemployment insurance is always a state program funded by the state's employers. Emergency extensions are Federally funded but they are temporary. This new mandate is not temporary and if Texas or any other state accepts stimulus dollars then it is a permanent tax levied on employers. As I said earlier it would crush small business.

Of course, the flip side of our current unemployment insurance funding scheme is that if an employer is looking to downsize or replace staff with lower paid workers, they have a financial incentive to look for (or invent) reasons to "fire" their employees. The employee (deserving or not) gets kicked to the curb without unemployment benefits, but the employer doesn't have to worry about increased unemployment insurance rates.

I don't directly work with employer/employee issues in my branch of the government, but I do get calls about them on a regular basis. Every other week or so, I get a call from a baffled nurse who (to hear them tell it) was fired for bizzare or trumped up reasons. The calls didn't make any sense to me for a long time. Why would an employer fake a reason to fire an employee, especially when they all sign "at will" contracts? And if they were fired for cause, why is the nurse calling us to complain?

Then I realized that under certain circumstances, a nurse with several years seniority under them can be let go and replaced with a cheaper, less experienced nurse who can be quickly trained into the position. Lettting the expensive nurse go in order to hire a cheaper nurse will cause the employers UI rate to rise however. If they are "fired" for incompetence however, it is pure gravy for the employer.

The unjustly fired employee can try to appeal the loss of unemployment benefits, but any employer can spin out that process long enough to make it a losing proposition for an employee who has recently lost their source of income...
 
Of course, the flip side of our current unemployment insurance funding scheme is that if an employer is looking to downsize or replace staff with lower paid workers, they have a financial incentive to look for (or invent) reasons to "fire" their employees. The employee (deserving or not) gets kicked to the curb without unemployment benefits, but the employer doesn't have to worry about increased unemployment insurance rates.

I don't directly work with employer/employee issues in my branch of the government, but I do get calls about them on a regular basis. Every other week or so, I get a call from a baffled nurse who (to hear them tell it) was fired for bizzare or trumped up reasons. The calls didn't make any sense to me for a long time. Why would an employer fake a reason to fire an employee, especially when they all sign "at will" contracts? And if they were fired for cause, why is the nurse calling us to complain?

Then I realized that under certain circumstances, a nurse with several years seniority under them can be let go and replaced with a cheaper, less experienced nurse who can be quickly trained into the position. Lettting the expensive nurse go in order to hire a cheaper nurse will cause the employers UI rate to rise however. If they are "fired" for incompetence however, it is pure gravy for the employer.

The unjustly fired employee can try to appeal the loss of unemployment benefits, but any employer can spin out that process long enough to make it a losing proposition for an employee who has recently lost their source of income...

That is not an issue. If an employee is downsized i.e laid off that, by definition, makes the elegible for Unemplyment benefits. There are many laws against wrongful termination. In a right to work state an emplyee can be fired for any reason other than discrimination. As to your nurse, there are always 2 sides to a story and she has recourse through the EEOC.
 
If a state "doesn't need the money", should they still accept it, or just let other, less fortunate states, get a little more cash to help them along?
 
So they're not going to accept bailout money now? That's big of them but we're still in the early stages of the world depression. Its going to get a lot worse before it gets better and the grandstanders of today will be begging for funds later.
 
From today's Wall Street Journal (Sanford is South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford, Perry is Texas's Rick Perry):
The tens of billions of dollars of aid for health care, welfare and education will disappear in two years and leave states with no way to finance the expanded programs. Mr. Perry sent a letter to President Obama last week warning that Texas may refuse certain stimulus funds. "If this money expands entitlements, we will not accept it. This is exactly how addicts get hooked on drugs," he says.

Consider South Carolina. Its annual budget is roughly $7 billion and the stimulus will send about $2.8 billion to the state over two years. But to spend the hundreds of millions of dollars allocated to the likes of Head Start, child care subsidies and special education, the state will have to enroll thousands of new families into the programs. "There's no way politically we're going to be able to push people out of the program in two years when the federal money runs out," Mr. Sanford says.

The Medicaid money for states is also a fiscal time bomb. The stimulus bill temporarily increases the share of state Medicaid bills reimbursed by the federal government by two or three percentage points. High-income states now pay about half the Medicaid costs, and in low-income states the feds pay about 70%. Much of the stimulus money will cover health-care costs for unemployed workers and single workers without kids. But in 2011 almost all the $80 billion of extra federal Medicaid money vanishes. Does Congress really expect states to dump one million people or more from Medicaid at that stage?
Of course, there's a solution:
The problem for these Governors is that they may be forced to spend the federal money whether they want it or not. Representative James Clyburn of South Carolina slipped a little-noticed provision into the stimulus bill giving state legislatures the power to overrule Governors and spend the money "by means of the adoption of a concurrent resolution." Most state legislatures are versions of Congress; they can't say no to new spending.
This sounds to me to be of questionable constitutionality. Can the federal government force states to accept federal money through the mechanism of interfering in the states' legislative processes?
 
Tell him what? That someone in Texas has a reading comprehension problem?

What does it mean to the costs of small businesses? maybe a 1% increase in payroll taxes?

Yeah it's only 1%, right? Lets have some facts to back that up. Where did you get that number?


Lets saddle small business with more tax. They can afford it. We all know how well small business is doing in this economy. Hey it's only 1%. Tell me, which 1% will be the straw that breaks the camel's back?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom