Gold

If you buy shares of stock, the business may send you a dividend (which is money) from time to time. If the company does really well, the company may split the stock, causing each share to become two or more shares. Eventually, you may be able to sell the stock for more money than you bought it for. If you buy real estate, tenants may pay you rent between the time you buy it and the time you sell it. I've heard that investment portfolio managers don't like precious metals because they generate no dividends and no rent and certainly won't split. They sit like inert lumps until you sell them.

When I listen to a local talk radio station, between ads for dubious health care products and the Star Registry, there are ads urging people to buy gold. If gold is such a wonderful investment, why do they have to pay money for radio ads? In my experience, the best investments don't have to advertise much. The people with lots of money to invest seek them out.
 
I'm sorry, I think I may have been confusing. When I say "inflation" without qualifying it I'm referring to currency inflation. Otherwise I'd say something like "inflated housing prices," so as not to confuse a technical term ("inflation" in the sense of reduced per-unit purchasing power of a currency) with a more casual one.

Only in the roughest possible sense of the word "like" is money "just like oil." There are very different factors impacting the supply and demand of the two items. It's like comparing apples and cars. No, that's a stupid analogy on my part. It's more like comparing apples and ten-year T-bills.


As far as the Fed's role in the housing situation, it remains to be seen what the Federal government (not just the Federal Reserve) will do with that. I don't think any housing-specific bailouts are through yet, but the issue is bigger than the current money supply and inflation rate.

Here’s what I disagree with. Oil is money. All fiat money is based on exponential growth and more debt. For e.g. an economy with 10% growth will double in 7 years. How do you get this growth? Cheep energy.
Now the supply of money growth is the only cause of inflation(supply –Demand). Money is not backed any thing. So that means that money is confidence in a central banks and ones government. When you lose confidence in your government then the dollar can get volatile. Why does the FED use words like the core rate of inflation, and inflation expectations? All this say to me is the public has not clued in that there are inflation problems.

Now I’m not saying we are going to go back to a gold standard. But gold window in the US was closed 37 years ago not hundreds. Since then, look at the loss of buying powering the Us dollar . I am not saying to put all you money in gold either. Some probably would not be a bad idea. Yes gold went down or flat since 1980. But they crush inflation with high interest rates and went to look for oil everywhere.
Now 2008 we have 2 twice the population and expensive energy and slowing growth.
The fed trying to do is stimulation the economy thought money injections? The problem where is all this money supposed to go: the housing market is still way over heated. Financial economy is still dealing with the credit problems, with more losses to come. So you have a trillion dollars plus sitting in money markets sniffing out where to go next. Commodities are probably the next bubble. Here’s the problem, commodities are valued at these prices based on supply and demand. So the bubble has not even started. Go ask you friends how much gold they have bought (stocks) or oil, coal, power, food (agriculture). There are not even look at this sector. But when they do it will go to the moon. There is 40 times the amount of US dollar floating around the world and this # does not include housing dollars. So when 10% to 20% of this money flows in to commodities. To the moon we go. Why you say, because the commodity market is tiny and just a little moeny can more the market.
Conclusion: Gold is money.
 
Is this what you need? :D

0470130873.jpg
 
Here’s what I disagree with. Oil is money. All fiat money is based on exponential growth and more debt. For e.g. an economy with 10% growth will double in 7 years. How do you get this growth? Cheep energy.

Yes, that's one way to grow the economy. It's not the only way - nor is it the only way that we've done it in the past few years. Increasing production technology has been a big factor as well. It's all tied together, sure, but you can't simply say it's one thing or another.

Oil is not "money" under any understanding of the word in economics.

Now the supply of money growth is the only cause of inflation(supply –Demand). Money is not backed any thing. So that means that money is confidence in a central banks and ones government. When you lose confidence in your government then the dollar can get volatile. Why does the FED use words like the core rate of inflation, and inflation expectations? All this say to me is the public has not clued in that there are inflation problems.

Because those words convey specific concepts in economics. Core inflation, for example, is inflation based on price changes net of food and fuel, which are historically volatile commodities.

Certainly the confidence in the government issuing a currency and the underlying national economy relates directly to the value of a fiat currency. Just like anything else (including gold), something is only worth what other people are willing to invest in it. Gold may have more natural usefulness than fiat currency (you can't conduct electricity with dollar bills, last I checked), but value is another concept entirely. The fact that this value is being benchmarked with fiat currency complicates things further.

Now I’m not saying we are going to go back to a gold standard. But gold window in the US was closed 37 years ago not hundreds. Since then, look at the loss of buying powering the Us dollar .

Per unit, sure, but inflation-adjusted wages has increased. I would say that standard of living has increased across the board too, but that's largely anecdotal.

I don't think we're ever going back to a backed standard of currency any time soon, no.

I am not saying to put all you money in gold either. Some probably would not be a bad idea. Yes gold went down or flat since 1980. But they crush inflation with high interest rates and went to look for oil everywhere.

Who is "they?" The current economic situation is the result of thousands of interconnected factors, both human and other, that have interacted in thousands of different ways. I think the main reason gold went down after the '80s is because the price increase was due to a speculative interest in the commodity. Speculative bubbles tend to crash eventually - look at the dotcom boom in the mid to late 1990's for a good example of that.

Now 2008 we have 2 twice the population and expensive energy and slowing growth.

Yes, that appears to be the case. We have energy issues we need to address.

The fed trying to do is stimulation the economy thought money injections? The problem where is all this money supposed to go: the housing market is still way over heated. Financial economy is still dealing with the credit problems, with more losses to come. So you have a trillion dollars plus sitting in money markets sniffing out where to go next. Commodities are probably the next bubble. Here’s the problem, commodities are valued at these prices based on supply and demand. So the bubble has not even started. Go ask you friends how much gold they have bought (stocks) or oil, coal, power, food (agriculture). There are not even look at this sector. But when they do it will go to the moon. There is 40 times the amount of US dollar floating around the world and this # does not include housing dollars. So when 10% to 20% of this money flows in to commodities. To the moon we go. Why you say, because the commodity market is tiny and just a little moeny can more the market.

I think the hope of the Fed is that the money put into the market will go into, at least, consumer spending to help with general business stimulation as a way of compensating for the crap housing market. I think this is also the reasoning behind the whole Economic Stimulus Act.

You think that there will be an increase in commodity investment/speculation to compensate for the decline in other markets, I take it?

Conclusion: Gold is money.

Depending on what you mean by "money," sure. It's a possible medium of exchange, which is a sufficient enough definition of "money" if you want to be casual. When economists talk about "the money supply" they aren't including gold, but that's a technical issue.
 
Yes we can!

Can you eat gold?

Pure gold can be pounded into an extremely thin foil that may be used to decorate food. Moderate consumption is not harmful. I put some on my last birthday cake. I can eat gold. See the book Gastronaut by Stefan Gates for more details.
 
Can you eat gold?

I'm sure gold can be ingested in copious quantities with no ill effects. I'll prove it, back in a minute.

eeditt adss: I jstts Eateedded sunmmm gulldd aneed it was tastesswtes gold,,,,,

I ddddut fel tuuuu goodddd//////
 
Last edited:
If you buy shares of stock, the business may send you a dividend (which is money) from time to time. If the company does really well, the company may split the stock, causing each share to become two or more shares. Eventually, you may be able to sell the stock for more money than you bought it for. If you buy real estate, tenants may pay you rent between the time you buy it and the time you sell it. I've heard that investment portfolio managers don't like precious metals because they generate no dividends and no rent and certainly won't split. They sit like inert lumps until you sell them.

Not to mention that, not only does it sit there like a lump, there are storage and insurance costs for gold.

When I listen to a local talk radio station, between ads for dubious health care products and the Star Registry, there are ads urging people to buy gold. If gold is such a wonderful investment, why do they have to pay money for radio ads? In my experience, the best investments don't have to advertise much. The people with lots of money to invest seek them out.

Precisely.
 
Last edited:
Against your paper money and skill at buying/selling being worthless due to an enormous contraction or devaluing. It's not likely to happen, but if it does please don't make confused faces at me as you're flying past my window.

If my paper money (US) ever becomes worthless, I, and the rest of the world, will have problems that no amount of gold will solve.
 
Oil is money.
No, it isn't. Oil is not a medium of exchange--it is a commodity with present/deferred consumption value. Oil is backed by nobody and nothing other than the intrinsic value it can provide, once only. There is no need to hump financial lexicon.

All fiat money is based on exponential growth and more debt.
Incorrect. Gross public debt is low and or falling (relative to GDP) in many economies that use fiat money.

For e.g. an economy with 10% growth will double in 7 years. How do you get this growth? Cheep energy.
I assume you mean China. Well China has demonstrated that this growth is achievable with expensive energy which cracks your theory fast. Growth--especially in emerging economies--is primarily due to massive leaps in total factor productivity, which is not necessarily nor always energy intensive.

I'm sorry but the rest of your post looks like it is copied out of somebody's ill-thought-out rant and it does not display, to me, much knowledge of economics or the behaviour of economic agents. And it is thus mildy annoying. I don't mean to be rude, and I probably am being. Sorry.
 
No, it isn't. Oil is not a medium of exchange--it is a commodity with present/deferred consumption value. Oil is backed by nobody and nothing other than the intrinsic value it can provide, once only. There is no need to hump financial lexicon.

Incorrect. Gross public debt is low and or falling (relative to GDP) in many economies that use fiat money.

I assume you mean China. Well China has demonstrated that this growth is achievable with expensive energy which cracks your theory fast. Growth--especially in emerging economies--is primarily due to massive leaps in total factor productivity, which is not necessarily nor always energy intensive.

I'm sorry but the rest of your post looks like it is copied out of somebody's ill-thought-out rant and it does not display, to me, much knowledge of economics or the behaviour of economic agents. And it is thus mildy annoying. I don't mean to be rude, and I probably am being. Sorry.

Are you kidding me, what do you think our world economies run on, Brain power? Well last time I checked its oil and there is not any alternative to replace it. And well I think we are maxed out productivity, I don’t think we can make much more leaps and bounds with productivity. Unless you have some ideas for free energy.
Growth is not achievable with high energy costs. Our whole system is based on computational growth and suburbia. Also a money system that depends on debt growth.

You are right gross public debt is low to GDP, but who cares is ridiculous high to wages.


You are right you can get increased productivity, but for what more consumption with equals more energy use. And everything is energy intensive. Please tell me what we do on this planet that is so energy efficient.

We have a liquid fuel problem. 135 dollar oil. 900 gold and there is no stopping this bull.
You need to look at the fundamentals.
 
We have a liquid fuel problem. 135 dollar oil. 900 gold and there is no stopping this bull.
You need to look at the fundamentals.

Anyone else get the feeling that a year or two from now (if not sooner), diggy will have lost everything, and have no idea how the hell it happened?
 
Are you kidding me, what do you think our world economies run on, Brain power? Well last time I checked its oil and there is not any alternative to replace it. And well I think we are maxed out productivity, I don’t think we can make much more leaps and bounds with productivity. Unless you have some ideas for free energy.

Which part of the economy? Oil is important to a lot of things, yes, but there are potential alternatives. The problem is that they are not economically viable for one reason or another.

You're simplifying productivity too much. There are other ways of increasing productivity besides using more energy.

Actually, using more energy isn't even what increases productivity. It allows the use of the things that enable productivity to increase, but in and of itself simply adding more energy doesn't necessarily increase production.

The real bugaboos right now are transportation and environmental concerns. We have viable alternatives to produce power without using oil (hydro-electric, nuclear, natural gas, etc.), but currently lack a real alternative to gas-powered vehicles. Even with the bitching about $4 gas in the US, we're still a ways away from the point where an alternative fuel (or high-efficiency vehicle) is economically viable for most consumers.

Growth is not achievable with high energy costs. Our whole system is based on computational growth and suburbia. Also a money system that depends on debt growth.

That's simply not true. Growth is perfectly achievable with high energy costs, it just may be slower. Computational growth shows no signs of slowing, and there are plenty of ways to step around computational limitations (e.g. the use of multi-core processors and threading to remove limitations on single-core clock speeds).

You are right gross public debt is low to GDP, but who cares is ridiculous high to wages.

I'm not sure what you're saying. You mean that debt is high relative to wages? I'm assuming you're talking about personal debt, which is considered private debt and is separate from the issue Francesca was talking about. Comparing public debt to average wages isn't very useful.

You are right you can get increased productivity, but for what more consumption with equals more energy use. And everything is energy intensive. Please tell me what we do on this planet that is so energy efficient.

This is confusingly written.

Energy efficiency is a matter of three issues: cost, conservation of scarce resources (tied to cost, obviously), and environmental concerns. It is highly relative, and something like that last sentence there is pretty meaningless.

"Energy intensive" is also highly relative. Are you talking cost/performance? Use/performance?

We have a liquid fuel problem. 135 dollar oil. 900 gold and there is no stopping this bull.

Why are you trying to link oil and gold like this? Other than price increases due to the inflation of a benchmark currency, there are a number of very different factors influencing their prices.

Bear (no pun intended) in mind that this gold "bull" is largely a function of the inflation of the benchmark currency. Take away that, and the performance is pretty flat. So why is gold so special and not, say, silver or steel or beef futures?

(Stupid financial joke: You want a real bull market? Buy beef futures! HAW!)
 
Which part of the economy? Oil is important to a lot of things, yes, but there are potential alternatives. The problem is that they are not economically viable for one reason or another.

You're simplifying productivity too much. There are other ways of increasing productivity besides using more energy.

Actually, using more energy isn't even what increases productivity. It allows the use of the things that enable productivity to increase, but in and of itself simply adding more energy doesn't necessarily increase production.

The real bugaboos right now are transportation and environmental concerns. We have viable alternatives to produce power without using oil (hydro-electric, nuclear, natural gas, etc.), but currently lack a real alternative to gas-powered vehicles. Even with the bitching about $4 gas in the US, we're still a ways away from the point where an alternative fuel (or high-efficiency vehicle) is economically viable for most consumers.



That's simply not true. Growth is perfectly achievable with high energy costs, it just may be slower. Computational growth shows no signs of slowing, and there are plenty of ways to step around computational limitations (e.g. the use of multi-core processors and threading to remove limitations on single-core clock speeds).



I'm not sure what you're saying. You mean that debt is high relative to wages? I'm assuming you're talking about personal debt, which is considered private debt and is separate from the issue Francesca was talking about. Comparing public debt to average wages isn't very useful.


Bear (no pun intended) in mind that this gold "bull" is largely a function of the inflation of the benchmark currency. Take away that, and the performance is pretty flat. So why is gold so special and not, say, silver or steel or beef futures?

(Stupid financial joke: You want a real bull market? Buy beef futures! HAW!)

oil/energy the economy, no other sectors can exsit with out oil in some way or another.
Yes I get productivity increase will use less energy. But all that encourages is more consumption or population growth. Which in turn, the product may use less energy to produce. There for producer will not most likely produce less but causes more consumption there for cause more energy use.

You are right transportation is the problem, and it a liquid fuel problem. its 4 dollar a gallon where do you see it stopping?

How fast do you think the economy will grow with 150 to 200 dollar oil?

I under stood what Francesca was saying but how does that effect the average person, well its a nice sounding. But people are hurting out there and soon the economy will have to contract. what about slowing wages growth and high debt? how does that effect her statment. How do you pay debt of if you can't grow?

Commodity bull market is running,so where ever you think the best place to make money is beef, copper, coal. I do think gold will catch on with inflationary presure to help move gold, even faster and higher than oil. But black gold is a safe bet to.
Jonny Thank you for the posts, you bring up some good points.
 
Why to buy gold:

It's a real investment. If you purchase Euros as a hedge against a failing US Dollar, you may end up showing a profit, or you may not, but in the end you're just playing a game of paper-shuffling. Euros like Dollars are not instruments of wealth, they are instruments of debt. Gold is truly an instrument of wealth: rather than representing work which is, in theory, to be performed at some later date, it represents work that has already been done.

You can lose money investing in gold, but you will never go broke buying gold. Buying stocks, bonds, currencies, and other debt-based financial instruments is an inherently risky proposition. But as any gambler knows, you have to go out on a limb if you want to get the fruit.

Check to see how much it is "up" over the last 25 years. Then tell me if it is a good idea to own gold.
Oh give me a break. Interesting that you would say "25 years" and not "30 years" or "35 years". Had you only said "35 years" then the profit margin would be in the thousands of percent--even adjusting for inflation. If I didn't know better I would swear you just glanced at a gold chart, found the absolute worst time to invest in it, and then use that as a basis point for your analysis. But you wouldn't stoop to such disingenuity. Would you?
 
Last edited:
oil/energy the economy, no other sectors can exsit with out oil in some way or another.
Yes I get productivity increase will use less energy. But all that encourages is more consumption or population growth. Which in turn, the product may use less energy to produce. There for producer will not most likely produce less but causes more consumption there for cause more energy use.

Oil is important, yes, but I don't think our current economy is going to cease to exist as it becomes more scarce. The important thing is to seriously research and develop alternatives to it, especially for transportation, and look at more efficient ways of generating power.

The reason you don't see more effort to develop alternatives to oil is because they aren't yet cheaper than simply using more oil. People are lazy, cheap bastards... a fundamental principle of economics. :)

You are right transportation is the problem, and it a liquid fuel problem. its 4 dollar a gallon where do you see it stopping?

I don't. It'll keep getting more expensive because the stuff gets scarcer. Eventually it'll be expensive enough that the alternatives look good - or the alternatives will get cheaper.

Oh sure, maybe the price will dip down a bit if the Middle East calms down or whatever, but it's not going back down to $1 a gallon ever.

You think $4 a gallon is bad, the folks in the UK have been paying like $8 a gallon for a while now.

How fast do you think the economy will grow with 150 to 200 dollar oil?

That price isn't really unthinkably high, so I doubt it would have a catastrophic effect on economic growth. Slowing, yes, but oil prices aren't the sole reason the economy is slowing down.

I under stood what Francesca was saying but how does that effect the average person, well its a nice sounding. But people are hurting out there and soon the economy will have to contract. what about slowing wages growth and high debt? how does that effect her statment. How do you pay debt of if you can't grow?

Well, that issue is not really connected to the idea of public debt versus GDP, which she didn't raise. You're talking about a much more micro situation. It's a valid concern, but not precisely the same.

I think the economy is contracting as it is. High consumer debt is a big issue - unfortunately it's not one I'm too familiar with the technicalities of, sorry.

Commodity bull market is running,so where ever you think the best place to make money is beef, copper, coal. I do think gold will catch on with inflationary presure to help move gold, even faster and higher than oil. But black gold is a safe bet to.

Like I've said before, commodities are decent enough hedges against inflation, but that doesn't make them necessarily runaway investments. If you want to park some money in gold, you go right ahead.

Jonny Thank you for the posts, you bring up some good points.

Sure. I always appreciate a conversation about gold that doesn't morph into some Federal Reserve/The Jews conspiracy theory.

You can lose money investing in gold, but you will never go broke buying gold. Buying stocks, bonds, currencies, and other debt-based financial instruments is an inherently risky proposition. But as any gambler knows, you have to go out on a limb if you want to get the fruit.

You're oversimplifying a lot. Risk of various financial instruments can be calculated, and many of them are quite secure. For example, Federal Bonds are basically considered to be the closest to risk-free that an investment can get.

Oh give me a break. Interesting that you would say "25 years" and not "30 years" or "35 years". Had you only said "35 years" then the profit margin would be in the thousands of percent--even adjusting for inflation. If I didn't know better I would swear you just glanced at a gold chart, found the absolute worst time to invest in it, and then use that as a basis point for your analysis. But you wouldn't stoop to such disingenuity. Would you?

How do you figure, anyway? Looking at inflation-adjusted data going back to 1913, the only way you would see those kinds of returns is if you were to invest prior to the big bump in 1980, then sell at the peak. If you invested 35 years ago and sold now, you would see a decent return when adjusted for inflation, but nothing in the "thousands of percent" range at all.

This chart goes back to 1913, and includes both nominal and inflation-adjusted prices. I'm not seeing any "thousands of percent" except for those that sold at the height of the speculative rush in the late 70's and very early early 80's. Also, those that invested prior to the early 70's made a decent return. But, like I said, not in the thousands of percent.

Of course, if you use nominal price, then anyone who invested prior to the late 70's is making big, big returns and the price is near the all-time high. However, that would be highly dishonest to do, so I'll stick with the inflation-adjusted figures.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom