Gold

While I would certainly never own gold, just because something is at an all time high is no reason to sell it. Unless you need the money or have a better investment.

It certainly depends on your strategy, but I just wanted to point out a basic concept. I personally don't find it a great idea to jump into a market when the asset in question is selling at an all time high.
 
It certainly depends on your strategy...

Mine strategy is to maximize returns! :)

...but I just wanted to point out a basic concept. I personally don't find it a great idea to jump into a market when the asset in question is selling at an all time high.

This is generally good advice. A prudent investor buys when everyone else is selling.
 
Please Tell my why or why not to own gold??
Please real answers only. I don't want to hear any of this hoarding crap. Gold used to be tied to the dollar and the central banks still hold lots of gold!! Gold is up 400% in 7-8 years. please some one tell me why.
I have a mutual fund Ivy Asset Strategy (WASYX) that is fairly heavy (20%) in Gold. It has a 5 year average return of 21% with 41% last year. It is a world allocation fund also heavy into China. The buy-in is a bit stiff. 10 million initial. I got in for a minuscule fraction of that because my portfolio is with Merrill Lynch. I wouldn't advise trying to trade any commodity directly unless you really know what you are doing. Commodities can go up fast but they can drop even faster as in minutes.
 
70% of the world population thinks as gold is money thats why its has an asset value, cause of the demand.

Really? Go into any store and offer to pay in either gold or cash and you'll see what they trust the most.
 
Last edited:
It certainly depends on your strategy, but I just wanted to point out a basic concept. I personally don't find it a great idea to jump into a market when the asset in question is selling at an all time high.

hmmmm, when did you sell in the tech run?? 1996???
Im still buying oil, gold, silver and food futures and will won't stop buying till they the Fed starts to raise rates. Thats the only tool the Fed gov. can use to kill the commodity bull market.
 
hmmmm, when did you sell in the tech run?? 1996???
Im still buying oil, gold, silver and food futures and will won't stop buying till they the Fed starts to raise rates. Thats the only tool the Fed gov. can use to kill the commodity bull market.

This will not end well for you.
 
True but i can go to any bank in the fomc and they will buy it as long as it assay gold certified.

But with cash, I don´t need to go to the bank to convert it into something I can spend in the store.
 
True but i can go to any bank in the fomc and they will buy it as long as it assay gold certified.

I'm not aware of any bank in my neck of the woods that will do this. There are a number of retailers that will buy them.

When Dallas Gold and Silver had a store near my I used to buy Silver Eagles from them for spot plus a small premium. I guess because they mainly dealth with processed metals (jewelry, watches) they didn't realize that mint year added value so I was buying $12 coins for $8. I wish I'd baught more.
 
Look at the trend line of Gold and Oil. You see that as oil goes so goes gold. Oil is going up up up, so gold will do the same. Inflation will destroy fiat currency but gold will hold its value. Why do you think that some of the richest men in the world have put hundreds of millions of dollars into Gold right now? I forget who it was who just bought 500 million dollars worth of Gold, but they are one of the richest men in the world. Commodities are where the rich are going.

Yes, commodities have similar things impacting pricing that will cause them to show similar fluctuations due to fluctuations in the currency being used as the benchmark. There are a lot of other factors that will affect inidividual commodities for different reasons. To say that "oil is going up up up, so gold will do the same" is to misunderstand the underlying factors.

Gold primarily increases in value, as you can see from the inflation-adjusted graph, because the currency the benchmarks it is experiencing inflation. There can be demand-induced spikes and dips as well, but the overall trend is to adjust for inflation.

Oil adjusts with the benchmarking currency as well, but there are other supply- and demand-related factors at work as well. Oil's price is also impacted by supply issues (e.g. the current conflict in the Middle East) and demand issues, so it doesn't peg to gold very much at all, except they both happen to be trending up right now.

If inflation were to stop tomorrow (which is stupid, but for the sake of an example), then the price of gold would likely remain level. Oil, on the other hand, would probably experience price increases due to continuing demand and supply issues.

There is a lot of complexity to the commodities market. We've mostly been talking about commodities as investments, but there are whole other aspects to the market we haven't discussed. There are a lot of people that try to use commodities futures to make money off of short-term price fluctuations, and people that use the commodities futures as a way of hedging against price fluctuation. To say that the rich are moving to commodities is simplistic, and probably incorrect in many cases.

And diggy, the Fed has no interest in killing the commodity bull market. You have a very distorted view of what the Fed actually does if you think this.
 
And diggy, the Fed has no interest in killing the commodity bull market. You have a very distorted view of what the Fed actually does if you think this.

What im trying to say is the Fed. is the one causing the inflation. They are growing the money supply too fast. If you held gold for the last few years in stead of US dollars then oil ain't up that much. what am i missing?

This is just the start inflation, intrest rates where too low for to long. We have a inflated housing market that is cracking, and they are lowering rates, what happens when they have to raise in a year or so. We have high gas prices, and the start of higher food prices. The Feb is killing the dollars buying with money printing. jonny five please tell me what im missing here?
 
What im trying to say is the Fed. is the one causing the inflation. They are growing the money supply too fast. If you held gold for the last few years in stead of US dollars then oil ain't up that much. what am i missing?

No, the actions of the Fed are one of the causes of inflation, but that isn't the goal of those actions (which is what the post I quoted seemed to imply, sorry if that wasn't intended). Whether or not they are growing the money supply "too fast" remains to be seen.

I'm not sure what the second-to-last sentence is supposed to say, could you rephrase it? Do you mean the fluctuation in oil due to non-inflation factors is insignificant?

This is just the start inflation, intrest rates where too low for to long. We have a inflated housing market that is cracking, and they are lowering rates, what happens when they have to raise in a year or so. We have high gas prices, and the start of higher food prices. The Feb is killing the dollars buying with money printing. jonny five please tell me what im missing here?

Well, the food and gas prices are not primarily increasing due to inflation, but largely due to supply/demand issues. You keep conflating cost of living with inflation, but the two things are not the same (although they're connected, for hopefully obvious reasons). The power of the dollar to buy food and fuel might be down, but this isn't due primarily to a dropping dollar.

Housing price inflation is also a slightly different issue than that of monetary inflation. Also, the breaking of the market actually means increased purchasing power per dollar, although much tighter underwriting standards and loss of investment value for those who had used their homes as a significant investment (and whose homes lost value, obviously).

It's not just an issue of the Fed trying to inject money into the economy - because that isn't new - but the problem of that money not doing enough to stimulate the economy to counteract the inflationary effect of the increase in the money supply. This sort of thing has happened before (when the term "stagflation" was coined to describe the combination of stagnant growth and high inflation), and will almost certainly happen again.
 
Last edited:
Housing price inflation is also a slightly different issue than that of monetary inflation. Also, the breaking of the market actually means increased purchasing power per dollar, although much tighter underwriting standards and loss of investment value for those who had used their homes as a significant investment (and whose homes lost value, obviously).

It's not just an issue of the Fed trying to inject money into the economy - because that isn't new - but the problem of that money not doing enough to stimulate the economy to counteract the inflationary effect of the increase in the money supply. This sort of thing has happened before (when the term "stagflation" was coined to describe the combination of stagnant growth and high inflation), and will almost certainly happen again.

So i guess we agree that there is inflation.
I also concur that there are different types of inflation. But the Fed has the biggest Effect on creation of inflation. Money is just like oil,all based on supply and demand. Too many dollars in the system less demand(= higher prices, more dollars chasing the same amount of goods and services)
I also agree with with stagflation soon to come. How would you portect you money in a stagflation environment? Would not gold or some other commodity do well? I think so, but i do not think housing will benefit. It is al ready so inflated and high leveraged.


With all the Fed injections
 
It's worth nothing that the gold bugs never own any actual gold (or very little), but they'll spend all their time trying to convince others what a great investment it is. I think, deep down, they know it's a terrible investment, but the more people they can get to join them serves to reinforce their sense of worth. Sort of like the hard core bible bleevers.


Why did our old buddy Dash/Dave come to mind when I read this?
 
Why do I think the Name "Ron Paul" will soon come up in this thread?
In fact, I am amazed it has not shown up already.
 
btw, I failed to see the OP's caveat of "no talking of gold hoarding" or such. That was basically my argument so I concede. I also am not sure that 10% of wealth should be spent on intrinsic quality goods as I said, but...owning something is always dependent on the certifier guaranteeing the goods. As a matter of physical volume:intrinsic worth goes, not much can beat gold. A piece of paper or electronic hard-drive certificate certainly can't.

So, invest in gold? Not if you want to make any profit or if "investment" means "maximizing returns". As a very small fall-back fail-safe insurance? sure.
 
So i guess we agree that there is inflation.
I also concur that there are different types of inflation. But the Fed has the biggest Effect on creation of inflation. Money is just like oil,all based on supply and demand. Too many dollars in the system less demand(= higher prices, more dollars chasing the same amount of goods and services)

I'm sorry, I think I may have been confusing. When I say "inflation" without qualifying it I'm referring to currency inflation. Otherwise I'd say something like "inflated housing prices," so as not to confuse a technical term ("inflation" in the sense of reduced per-unit purchasing power of a currency) with a more casual one.

Only in the roughest possible sense of the word "like" is money "just like oil." There are very different factors impacting the supply and demand of the two items. It's like comparing apples and cars. No, that's a stupid analogy on my part. It's more like comparing apples and ten-year T-bills.

I also agree with with stagflation soon to come. How would you portect you money in a stagflation environment? Would not gold or some other commodity do well? I think so, but i do not think housing will benefit. It is al ready so inflated and high leveraged.

No, housing as an investment will likely not benefit. My point was that now would be a good time to buy if you wanted to purchase a house, in cash, with the intent of living in that house. Prices are down a bit, and will probably fall some more in the future. With all the Fed injections[/quote]

I'd protect my money by moving it into a relatively secure, steady investment. TIPS would be a good choice, or you could try holding a commodity. I don't think gold would be the best commodity, as it has seen speculative bumps and dips over time. Maybe something more level and less subject to speculation. Gold is a sexy investment to some people, and sexy makes for a potentially unstable investment if enough investors suddenly get it in their heads that it's the next big thing. If I bought in a level period I'd be less concerned, but you'd really have to track the prices when you buy and sell so as to not end up buying in the middle of a speculative bubble (like in the 80's) and then getting stuck with a commodity you paid too much for.

All said, I'd really rather go with the TIPS or a secure investment (mutual fund, high-grade bonds, whatever) I figured could generally beat the average rate of inflation.

As far as the Fed's role in the housing situation, it remains to be seen what the Federal government (not just the Federal Reserve) will do with that. I don't think any housing-specific bailouts are through yet, but the issue is bigger than the current money supply and inflation rate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom