Gold

But...but....but...How can that be? The gold bugs are always telling us that gold is a great hedge against inflation. :confused:

I guess it would be more accurate to say that gold is a great hedge against superior returns.

Oh, sure it's a great hedge against inflation... in that it tends to remain pretty constant in value against inflation. It just doesn't actually appear to outperform inflation overall, as it were.
 
Oh, sure it's a great hedge against inflation... in that it tends to remain pretty constant in value against inflation. It just doesn't actually appear to outperform inflation overall, as it were.

Perhaps, but the past 25 years would indicate otherwise. :)
 
But...but....but...How can that be? The gold bugs are always telling us that gold is a great hedge against inflation. :confused:

I guess it would be more accurate to say that gold is a great hedge against superior returns.


Anybody who was following the market at the time of Bunkie Hunt's idiocy knows what was going on there.
 
Gold was money at one time. With the interest rates so low I just see higher gold prices in the futrue. 70% of the world population thinks as gold is money thats why its has an asset value, cause of the demand. Question: will demand go higher with dollar weakness??

ok, say you are all right and gold is a bad hedge against the dollar. What would you to protect against inflation?
I infaltion protected bonds are tied to core rates!
does and one realy live by the core infaltion rate, the govermant say it about 3%...hmmm well everything i do, from food to fuel is up 10-20 % year over year!
 
ok, say you are all right and gold is a bad hedge against the dollar. What would you to protect against inflation?
I infaltion protected bonds are tied to core rates!
No, TIPS (US treasury inflation pretected securities) are indexed to the headline US consumer price index (with a lag)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps, but the past 25 years would indicate otherwise. :)

Hey now, if you plot a linear regression line on that data, I'm betting it's pretty level.

Not that it does anyone very much good. :D

Gold was money at one time. With the interest rates so low I just see higher gold prices in the futrue. 70% of the world population thinks as gold is money thats why its has an asset value, cause of the demand. Question: will demand go higher with dollar weakness??

Sure, it'll go higher versus the dollar, but so will every other commodity. Gold isn't special in this regard.

Also, it depends on your currency benchmark. If you mark it against a currency that is increasing in value, it'll go down. The question is whether or not the purchasing power of the investment tends to increase or not. I'd say gold isn't the best choice as far as that goes - its demand beyond being a store of value seems kind of limited. Other posters, correct me if I'm wrong!

ok, say you are all right and gold is a bad hedge against the dollar. What would you to protect against inflation?
I infaltion protected bonds are tied to core rates!
does and one realy live by the core infaltion rate, the govermant say it about 3%...hmmm well everything i do, from food to fuel is up 10-20 % year over year!

What Francesca said. They're tied to CPI, not core inflation. This is pretty easy stuff to check, you know.

Where are you getting 10-20% actual inflation? I haven't personally experienced (or read about, or heard of) cost increases of that magnitude except for gas prices. Food prices certainly haven't gone up that much, and most consumer goods seem to have remained mostly level.

The figures that put inflation around 3-6% are based on CPI, which includes both food and fuel in its calculations. Also, keep in mind that the CPI attempts to filter out factors like fuel price volatility due to supply issues. While those issues might increase the cost, they aren't actually due to inflation. The CPI is an attempt at measuring inflation only, not cost-of-living increases in general.

Fuel in particular has been subject to a lot of supply/demand-related price increases lately. While this may hurt the consumer, you can't very well claim it has to do with inflation or the Fed doing something.

Anyway, the bottom line is that you need to look at inflation as a separate issue from simple COL increases. There are other factors that feed into COL besides inflation.
 
Gold was money at one time. With the interest rates so low I just see higher gold prices in the futrue. 70% of the world population thinks as gold is money thats why its has an asset value, cause of the demand. Question: will demand go higher with dollar weakness??


Gold is compact, portable, easily identifiable, does not corrode, and has well understood economic value making it easy to redeem, convert, or trade. It also has the shiny appeal and making it into jewelry is an easy way of carrying it around.

In some parts of the world "phone minutes" is now a popular currency for most of the same reasons.

ok, say you are all right and gold is a bad hedge against the dollar. What would you to protect against inflation?
I infaltion protected bonds are tied to core rates!
does and one realy live by the core infaltion rate, the govermant say it about 3%...hmmm well everything i do, from food to fuel is up 10-20 % year over year!


It would have been foolish to buy gold in 1980 as an inflation hedge. Of course if you sold in 1980, you made a lot of money.

And the CPI, as a measure of inflation, is a joke. Deliberately so.
 
Diversification, mostly. To say you shouldn't ever buy gold or you should "load up" on gold are both equally stoopid.
 
Look at the trend line of Gold and Oil. You see that as oil goes so goes gold. Oil is going up up up, so gold will do the same. Inflation will destroy fiat currency but gold will hold its value. Why do you think that some of the richest men in the world have put hundreds of millions of dollars into Gold right now? I forget who it was who just bought 500 million dollars worth of Gold, but they are one of the richest men in the world. Commodities are where the rich are going.
 
Look at the trend line of Gold and Oil. You see that as oil goes so goes gold. Oil is going up up up, so gold will do the same. Inflation will destroy fiat currency but gold will hold its value. Why do you think that some of the richest men in the world have put hundreds of millions of dollars into Gold right now? I forget who it was who just bought 500 million dollars worth of Gold, but they are one of the richest men in the world. Commodities are where the rich are going.

Good theory, but the richest man is the one who says gold is a terrible investment. I'll listen to him.
 
Good theory, but the richest man is the one who says gold is a terrible investment. I'll listen to him.

A terrible investment? Are you kidding me? Gold is where to be right now. Especially if you live in the US commodities, Gold, Silver are where you should be. It's a hedge against inflation. The price of food right now is being driven up by speculators who are trying to protect their money they had in stocks before these economic problems began.
 
A terrible investment? Are you kidding me? Gold is where to be right now. Especially if you live in the US commodities, Gold, Silver are where you should be. It's a hedge against inflation. The price of food right now is being driven up by speculators who are trying to protect their money they had in stocks before these economic problems began.

:dl:

Good one!
 
Oh, sure it's a great hedge against inflation... in that it tends to remain pretty constant in value against inflation. It just doesn't actually appear to outperform inflation overall, as it were.

I remember G. Gordon Liddy shilling gold on his radio show in the mid-90s by flipping a Double Eagle onto a table and stating that you could buy a suit in 1930 for those $20, but you couldn't in 1995.

Logic fail. That ounce(ish) of gold was worth about $300 so 65 years later it would still buy you... a suit.

Gold should be an "extra" investment or, should be gotten into on the Numismatic end, otherwise it's a terrible investment these days.
 
A terrible investment? Are you kidding me? Gold is where to be right now. Especially if you live in the US commodities, Gold, Silver are where you should be. It's a hedge against inflation. The price of food right now is being driven up by speculators who are trying to protect their money they had in stocks before these economic problems began.

In that case, shouldn´t we invest in FOOD instead?
 
Look at the trend line of Gold and Oil. You see that as oil goes so goes gold. Oil is going up up up, so gold will do the same. Inflation will destroy fiat currency but gold will hold its value. Why do you think that some of the richest men in the world have put hundreds of millions of dollars into Gold right now? I forget who it was who just bought 500 million dollars worth of Gold, but they are one of the richest men in the world. Commodities are where the rich are going.

And...you can't bury oil in the back yard or a safe deposit box and expect it to maintain it's value. Gold has intrinsic value not just related to jewelry--it has great electrical, malleable properties that will always be in demand unless human society completely collapses (and if that's the worry, just invest in a high-quality assault weapon).

Gold is money, literally and casually. It's a small-volume definite value that isn't affected by an electronic virus or Wall Street rendering your 20,000 hypothetical barrels of oil moot.

It's a solid "fail-safe" investment that any rich person should have in addition to any market speculation or other non-physical values. I'm not rich but good God, if I were I'd buy me some (10% of worth or so of) gold (or platinum) and be content that I'll always have some physcial worth.

Why in the bloody hell would an investor solely rely on certificates and electronic wealth? Is 1929 completely forgotten? I mean sure, all things considered you wouldn't need it...but all things are not considered. That's the main point of investment in something like gold.
 
It's a solid "fail-safe" investment...

I can't speak for others who have responded to this thread and are, well, let's just say less than bullish on gold as an investment, but I think most of them, like me, will only concur with this assertion when it comes periods of economic downturn. There's also the issue of timing the market... and world economic conditions and the fact that I pointed out in a recent thread about gold - it does not pay dividends, interest or have any tax advantages like a mortgage.

If someone had invested heavily in gold in 1981 and sold it in 1999 they'd have not only have taken a bath in terms of absolute dollars, but inflation adjusted dollars and the loss of 18 years of interest/dividends. It is definately not a "fail-safe" investment.

That said, as in investment you can buy into at a decent or depressed price and hold for the years to decades it might take to show a great profit, it certainly is a better one than, say, fine art or vintage automobiles. And most gold bullion coins are stamped with a currency value so if we face some sort of economic armageddon that $50 gold Eagle might be worth more than $50 is today or the $800ish it's worth as a commodity.

With all the investment options out there, and despite the fact that I wish I didn't stock up on it in the late 90s, I continue to think buying gold - today - is folly.
 
It's worth nothing that the gold bugs never own any actual gold (or very little), but they'll spend all their time trying to convince others what a great investment it is. I think, deep down, they know it's a terrible investment, but the more people they can get to join them serves to reinforce their sense of worth. Sort of like the hard core bible bleevers.
 
And...you can't bury oil in the back yard or a safe deposit box and expect it to maintain it's value. Gold has intrinsic value not just related to jewelry--it has great electrical, malleable properties that will always be in demand unless human society completely collapses (and if that's the worry, just invest in a high-quality assault weapon).

Gold is money, literally and casually. It's a small-volume definite value that isn't affected by an electronic virus
None of which really has anything to do with its market value, which is all that really matters.

It's a solid "fail-safe" investment
As has already been explained, hardly.

Why in the bloody hell would an investor solely rely on certificates and electronic wealth?
Because it's been a tried and true method for many many years (assuming one invests soundly, eg diverisifes etc)?

I mean sure, all things considered you wouldn't need it...but all things are not considered. That's the main point of investment in something like gold.
I'm not even sure what this means...

But PS I am more bullish than most here on gold, it seems...
 
Last edited:
Gold values are at an all time high. This means sell, not buy.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom