Gold will go $1,500/oz

In his opinion gold is currently in a bubble and he thinks the price is going to collapse. Too bad he doesn't know when ;)

I'd be worried if he did. Market manipulation is one of those things that can get you a lengthy vacation in a government-run motel. :D
 
I've read Mark Twain once said:

A gold mine is a hole in the ground with a liar standing next to it.
 
I remember when gold was about $800/oz in the 80's, and silver was pushing $50. At the time everyone thought $1,000/oz was inevitable - very few predicted it would ever pull back to the $200's, which it did.

Timing markets and commodities is very difficult - perhaps even impossible in principle. A year from now gold could be $2,000/oz or $200/oz - anyone who claims to know what it will do is blowing smoke.

Holding some gold is a time honored hedge against inflation. 10% of one's holdings in precious metals is considered about right.

I own some gold coins, bought over the years for prices between just under $300 to a couple at just over $1,000. Its best thought of not as an investment, per se', but as insurance.
 
Holding some gold is a time honored hedge against inflation. 10% of one's holdings in precious metals is considered about right.

By who?

I own some gold coins, bought over the years for prices between just under $300 to a couple at just over $1,000. Its best thought of not as an investment, per se', but as insurance.

Insurance against what?
 

I was thinking "weasel words" as I wrote that. You know, "some say..."

I've heard that 10% figure a lot, but I've also heard we use 10% of our brains!:blush:

Insurance against what?

Inflation. When dollars are worth less, commodities tend to rise. Its not so much that you hope to make money - its just something to hold that will help you store value.

It could be run-of-the-mill inflation over time - gold was $35/oz in the not-too-distant past. I'm 61 and the prices of most things have gone up by about a factor of ten since I was young - it insidious, but in my formative years a basic car was about $2,000 - now its about $20,000 (for instance).

Or it could be hyper-inflation. Other countries have seen it and there's no reason to think the US is immune.

As others have said here, if we have anarchy, then food and water and guns and ammo look pretty good.

No one has to own gold - but it helps some people sleep at night to have at least some of one's assets in something other than paper.
 
Last edited:
Google can get one started on the 10% figure...

5165249833_c2e5cfa643_b.jpg
 
Inflation. When dollars are worth less, commodities tend to rise. Its not so much that you hope to make money - its just something to hold that will help you store value.

Personally, I own blue chip stocks as a hedge against inflation.

No one has to own gold - but it helps some people sleep at night to have at least some of one's assets in something other than paper.

I'm glad I'm not one of them!
 
Google can get one started on the 10% figure...

[qimg]http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4065/5165249833_c2e5cfa643_b.jpg[/qimg]

No offense, but I'll stick with my guys:

"Gold gets dug out of the ground in Africa, or someplace. Then we melt it down, dig another hole, bury it again and pay people to stand around guarding it. It has no utility. Anyone watching from Mars would be scratching their head." - Warren E. Buffett

"Owning gold is dumb." - Charles T. Munger

:)
 
Unless you have the money to hire a bigger armed mob.

such a shame you would have to pay such a mob. And then, sometimes, the size of your mob is nothing compared to the size of the mob that believes utopia is right around the corner, as soon as you are out of the way. Whether it is true or not really doesn't matter once your neck is on the chopping block.

and sometimes, you cant pay a mob more, because the other mob is offering your mob everything you have in return for joining them. either way, you lose everything.

once again, power comes from the barrel of a gun, and not from some old man's feeble attempts to hand out a share of his coin.
Personally, I own blue chip stocks as a hedge against inflation.

Industrial corporations are susceptible to commodity price spikes.
Financial corporations are susceptible to widespread profit losses due to rising commodity prices of the industrial corporate stocks they own.
Insurance corporations are susceptible to the contract payouts for portfolio losses from both.
 
Last edited:
I remember when gold was about $800/oz in the 80's, and silver was pushing $50. At the time everyone thought $1,000/oz was inevitable - very few predicted it would ever pull back to the $200's, which it did.

Volker stepped in and made the overnight lending rate 17.5%, IIRC.
That was a fed chairman with cahones.

The current, and safe bet, is the fed will keep interest rates at or below zero, and will continue to buy US treasuries.
 
Personally, I own blue chip stocks as a hedge against inflation.

To be sure, owning quality blue chip stocks, either individually or in a mutual fund, is a good idea to have as part of an overall investment strategy.

But its not specifically an inflation hedge. If the value of the dollar gets cut in half via inflation, there's no reason a specific stock would benefit, unless its product or service was one that somehow benefited from a weak dollar.
 
Industrial corporations are susceptible to commodity price spikes.

True

Financial corporations are susceptible to widespread profit losses due to rising commodity prices of the industrial corporate stocks they own.

True

Insurance corporations are susceptible to the contract payouts for portfolio losses from both.

True

You forgot a few:

The sun rises in the east.
Lionel Messi plays football
Barack Obama is the US president

Were you trying to make some sort of point?
 
owning quality blue chip stocks [is] not specifically an inflation hedge.
Yes it is. Equity is the residual claim on a real asset, where both the cash flow and the discount rate are equally affected by inflation (or deflation)

If the value of the dollar gets cut in half via inflation, there's no reason a specific stock would benefit, unless its product or service was one that somehow benefited from a weak dollar.
. . . or if its product or service was traded with a floating price. Which they almost all are (utilities being a bit of an exception)
 
To be sure, owning quality blue chip stocks, either individually or in a mutual fund, is a good idea to have as part of an overall investment strategy.

But its not specifically an inflation hedge. If the value of the dollar gets cut in half via inflation, there's no reason a specific stock would benefit, unless its product or service was one that somehow benefited from a weak dollar.

Explain this whole "gold as a hedge against inflation" thing. What that means to me is that if inflation is 3%, the price of gold will rise by 3% or more. Are you saying that is always true?
 
If the value of the dollar gets cut in half via inflation, there's no reason a specific stock would benefit, unless its product or service was one that somehow benefited from a weak dollar.

But there's also no reason that a specific stock would be hurt, either. I mean, if a $3 tube of toothpaste suddenly costs $6, I still want to brush my teeth, which means that JNJ is still selling toothpaste.

Which is why, historically, stocks have been a much better inflation hedge than precious metals. Stocks and useful commodities -- anything that people actually want and use.

I'm always amused at people who claim they want to own gold as an inflation hedge. That's like owning toothpaste as an adhesive and eschewing glue.
 
I'm always amused at people who claim they want to own gold as an inflation hedge.

Glad I can be amusing!

If you want, you can read the Wikipedia entry on hyperinflation. Look at prior examples.

It's just that, let's say, it took one silver dollar 50 years ago to buy a given item. Today, that same item may cost $20 or so in paper money, but still could be bought for a silver dollar.

That would seem to be an inflation hedge. The value of the coin remains relatively constant in relation to what it can buy, while the currency devalues. As I said, a way to store value, not make money.

But there's also no reason that a specific stock would be hurt, either.

I don't think I said or even implied that.
 
Glad I can be amusing!

If you want, you can read the Wikipedia entry on hyperinflation. Look at prior examples.

It's just that, let's say, it took one silver dollar 50 years ago to buy a given item. Today, that same item may cost $20 or so in paper money, but still could be bought for a silver dollar.

That would seem to be an inflation hedge. The value of the coin remains relatively constant in relation to what it can buy, while the currency devalues. As I said, a way to store value, not make money.

Huh??? A silver dollar is worth 1 dollar, when used in commerce. Meaning, if a bottle of Coke costs a dollar, I can buy it with a paper dollar printed yesterday, or a silver dollar minted 100 years ago. Both are worth 1 dollar.

Now of course, I would be foolish to do that, because the silver content, when melted down, would make the silver dollar worth more than a dollar. But unless you melt it down or sell it to a collector, to the clerk at the 7-11, it is still 1 dollar.
 
I'm always amused at people who claim they want to own gold as an inflation hedge. That's like owning toothpaste as an adhesive and eschewing glue.

Well - a 1 oz. gold coin in 1970 worth $35 (which was not a market value, but rather a value set by the US Government), according to the bls.gov inflation calculator http://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm, should be $197.05. It seems gold has protected against inflation and then some. It needs to drop below $197.05 to cease being a hedge against inflation for the set price of $35 for gold.

Toothpaste could also be a hedge against inflation. Just stockpile the toothpaste at today's prices and use them in the future. You then don't pay the inflated prices.
 
Well - a 1 oz. gold coin in 1970 worth $35 (which was not a market value, but rather a value set by the US Government), according to the bls.gov inflation calculator http://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm, should be $197.05. It seems gold has protected against inflation and then some. It needs to drop below $197.05 to cease being a hedge against inflation for the set price of $35 for gold.

Toothpaste could also be a hedge against inflation. Just stockpile the toothpaste at today's prices and use them in the future. You then don't pay the inflated prices.

If a young investor had decided in 1980 to put 10% of their portfolio in gold, they would have purchased it for close to $700 an ounce. That $700, when adjusted for inflation is today worth roughly $2000. Gold is worth $1400 an ounce.

Now, I may have flunked economics, but perhaps someone could explain to me exactly how that is a hedge against inflation. Sounds more like a hedge against making money!
 
Now, I may have flunked economics, but perhaps someone could explain to me exactly how that is a hedge against inflation.

Let me try. (As a reducto ad absurdo analogy, let me play fast and loose with the numbers - it's the concept and not the particulars that matter).

Two citizens of Germany in early 1923 are given a choice in payment types for services rendered. One accepts a paper mark, the other takes a silver coin worth one mark.

Then this happens:

weimar_hyperinflation2.gif


At the end of the year, both are thirsty for a bottle of wine. They go to a wine shop. A bottle of wine had sold for one mark a year ago, but no longer. The one with a paper mark is told he's short about 999,999,999 marks, and is offered the use of a wheelbarrow if he wants to try to round up that much. The other fellow presents the silver mark coin. The shopkeeper knows the value of the silver in a silver mark coin, and trades the fellow a bottle of wine for the coin.

This seems clear and obvious on the surface. I'd say the fellow that took the silver mark successfully "hedged" against inflation. What applies in times of hyperinflation would be true to a lesser extent in times of humdrum inflation - as we've seen in the price of gold and silver over the recent past.

Sounds more like a hedge against making money!

If I want to make money, I don't choose gold or silver. I earn it or try to invest in securities (stocks and bonds) or even real estate, and over time I've been pretty successful. Taking 10% of one's assets "off the table" to put into precious metals is not unreasonable.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom