Gold will go $1,500/oz

If a young investor had decided in 1980 to put 10% of their portfolio in gold, they would have purchased it for close to $700 an ounce. That $700, when adjusted for inflation is today worth roughly $2000. Gold is worth $1400 an ounce.

Now, I may have flunked economics, but perhaps someone could explain to me exactly how that is a hedge against inflation. Sounds more like a hedge against making money!

The gold thing is a myth for apocalypse fetishists who don't realize that they're being bilked by smooth snake-oil salesmen that are taking ENORMOUS commissions off of the purchases.

Remember, they're not worried about the past performance of gold, they think Obama is going to cause Zimbabwe-esque inflation (despite the ten-year bond rate being below 3% and our major problem being one of potential deflation).

It's not going to make sense, it's stupid, as your calculations have shown.
 
It's just that, let's say, it took one silver dollar 50 years ago to buy a given item. Today, that same item may cost $20 or so in paper money, but still could be bought for a silver dollar.

That would seem to be an inflation hedge. The value of the coin remains relatively constant in relation to what it can buy, while the currency devalues. As I said, a way to store value, not make money.

So, you're saying that precious metals are a better investment than keeping currency in a cookie jar?

If you took that dollar and used it to buy a blue chip stock fifty years ago, you'd likely have substantially more than $20 in stock today, and you would have been getting dividend payments for the past fifty years as well.
 
If a young investor had decided in 1980 to put 10% of their portfolio in gold, they would have purchased it for close to $700 an ounce. That $700, when adjusted for inflation is today worth roughly $2000. Gold is worth $1400 an ounce.

Now, I may have flunked economics, but perhaps someone could explain to me exactly how that is a hedge against inflation. Sounds more like a hedge against making money!

The investor only purchased one gold coin - ever? And he bought at a market peak and never bought again? Sounds like he flunked investing 101.
 
(despite the ten-year bond rate being below 3% and our major problem being one of potential deflation).

I'd welcome deflation at the moment. It'd be the only anyone at my company could get anything even approximating a raise.
 
If a young investor had decided in 1980 to put 10% of their portfolio in gold, they would have purchased it for close to $700 an ounce. That $700, when adjusted for inflation is today worth roughly $2000. Gold is worth $1400 an ounce.

Cherry picking.

I could cherry pick as well and have the young investor in gold at $250/oz in the 80's, or even $35 not long before. I'll let you run those numbers if you're so inclined.
 
So, you're saying that precious metals are a better investment than keeping currency in a cookie jar?

I think investment is the wrong work here. In the past 100 years how much has the dollar been devalued?

If you took that dollar and used it to buy a blue chip stock fifty years ago, you'd likely have substantially more than $20 in stock today, and you would have been getting dividend payments for the past fifty years as well.

You have to pick the correct stock, of course.

Stocks can become worth $0.

Paper Money can become worth $0.

Have gold and silver ever been worth $0?

If anyone here has gold and silver valued at $0 I'll happily buy it from you.
 
Cherry picking.

I could cherry pick as well and have the young investor in gold at $250/oz in the 80's, or even $35 not long before. I'll let you run those numbers if you're so inclined.

Well - your numbers would be more accurate since for most of the past 40 years gold has been below the peaks, and still above inflation.
 
The gold thing is a myth for apocalypse fetishists who don't realize that they're being bilked by smooth snake-oil salesmen that are taking ENORMOUS commissions off of the purchases.

I buy non-collectible "bullion" coins - Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, Double Eagles, that sort of thing.

The commission on these, and the premium over the gold content, is very reasonable if you know where to shop.
 
I buy non-collectible "bullion" coins - Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, Double Eagles, that sort of thing.

The commission on these, and the premium over the gold content, is very reasonable if you know where to shop.

Sure, but those sorts of investments aren't driving the bubble.

There were a lot of people who took out mortgages from honest lenders and paid them in the last 10 years as well.
 
The investor only purchased one gold coin - ever? And he bought at a market peak and never bought again? Sounds like he flunked investing 101.

OK, let's pick a time when the market wasn't at a peak. A young investor plunk down $125 for an ounce of gold in 1973. That $125 is now worth $716. An ounce of gold is worth $1400.

Congratulations, you've doubled your money!!! :)


It only took 40 years.... :rolleyes:
 
Let me try. (As a reducto ad absurdo analogy, let me play fast and loose with the numbers - it's the concept and not the particulars that matter).

Two citizens of Germany in early 1923 are given a choice in payment types for services rendered. One accepts a paper mark, the other takes a silver coin worth one mark.

Then this happens:

http://www.thepeoplesvoice.org/cgi-bin/blogs/media/weimar_hyperinflation2.gif

At the end of the year, both are thirsty for a bottle of wine. They go to a wine shop. A bottle of wine had sold for one mark a year ago, but no longer. The one with a paper mark is told he's short about 999,999,999 marks, and is offered the use of a wheelbarrow if he wants to try to round up that much. The other fellow presents the silver mark coin. The shopkeeper knows the value of the silver in a silver mark coin, and trades the fellow a bottle of wine for the coin.

This seems clear and obvious on the surface. I'd say the fellow that took the silver mark successfully "hedged" against inflation. What applies in times of hyperinflation would be true to a lesser extent in times of humdrum inflation - as we've seen in the price of gold and silver over the recent past.




I'll let Tranewreck take this one:

The gold thing is a myth for apocalypse fetishists who don't realize that they're being bilked by smooth snake-oil salesmen that are taking ENORMOUS commissions off of the purchases.

Remember, they're not worried about the past performance of gold, they think Obama is going to cause Zimbabwe-esque inflation (despite the ten-year bond rate being below 3% and our major problem being one of potential deflation).

It's not going to make sense, it's stupid, as your calculations have shown.

As too the last point:

If I want to make money, I don't choose gold or silver. I earn it or try to invest in securities (stocks and bonds) or even real estate, and over time I've been pretty successful. Taking 10% of one's assets "off the table" to put into precious metals is not unreasonable.

If I really thought there was a chance, any chance whatsoever, of German or Zimbabwaen style inflation in the US at any time in the next 40 years, I'd have 100% of my money in gold (or more accurately, guns and canned goods). Why limit it to 10%?
 
Last edited:
Cherry picking.

I could cherry pick as well and have the young investor in gold at $250/oz in the 80's, or even $35 not long before. I'll let you run those numbers if you're so inclined.

Done:

OK, let's pick a time when the market wasn't at a peak. A young investor plunk down $125 for an ounce of gold in 1973. That $125 is now worth $716. An ounce of gold is worth $1400.

Congratulations, you've doubled your money!!! :)


It only took 40 years.... :rolleyes:
 
OK, let's pick a time when the market wasn't at a peak. A young investor plunk down $125 for an ounce of gold in 1973. That $125 is now worth $716. An ounce of gold is worth $1400.

Congratulations, you've doubled your money!!! :)


It only took 40 years.... :rolleyes:

Well - since your goal was not to double your money but to preserve your wealth I'd think the timeframe shouldn't matter. And since a person doing this is probably making multiple gold purchases throughout the 40 years the dollar-cost averaging will help smooth out the volatility. But again - it's about preserving wealth. And gold would only be one part of your strategy. I'd recommend stocking up toothpaste first or maybe at the same time as buying gold. :)
 
Well - since your goal was not to double your money but to preserve your wealth I'd think the timeframe shouldn't matter. And since a person doing this is probably making multiple gold purchases throughout the 40 years the dollar-cost averaging will help smooth out the volatility. But again - it's about preserving wealth. And gold would only be one part of your strategy. I'd recommend stocking up toothpaste first or maybe at the same time as buying gold. :)

I'd rather create wealth than preserve it.
 
Well - since your goal was not to double your money but to preserve your wealth I'd think the timeframe shouldn't matter. And since a person doing this is probably making multiple gold purchases throughout the 40 years the dollar-cost averaging will help smooth out the volatility. But again - it's about preserving wealth. And gold would only be one part of your strategy. I'd recommend stocking up toothpaste first or maybe at the same time as buying gold. :)

Ask yourself this question - take a look at the Forbes 400 sometime. Buffett, Gates, Walton's, etc. Do you really, truly, honestly believe that any of them have 10% of their money in gold? Really, truly, honestly. And if the answer is no, why do you think that is?

Why is it that the only people who push for 10% gold are nuts on internet conspiracy forums or hucksters on late night TV?

If it was such a great investment, wouldn't Buffett, Munger, Gates, Walton, et al, be advising all of us to invest in gold?

Just wondering.....
 
I'll let Tranewreck take this one:



As too the last point:



If I really thought there was a chance, any chance whatsoever, of German or Zimbabwaen style inflation in the US at any time in the next 40 years, I'd have 100% of my money in gold (or more accurately, guns and canned goods). Why limit it to 10%?

Do you know 100% that high inflation will not be coming? It doesn't even need to approach hyperinflation to be a burden. But then again - do you know 100% hyperinflation will not be happening in America - ever? It's happened before. But of course now we have Bernanke to protect us ....
 
Do you know 100% that high inflation will not be coming? It doesn't even need to approach hyperinflation to be a burden. But then again - do you know 100% hyperinflation will not be happening in America - ever? It's happened before. But of course now we have Bernanke to protect us ....

No. Nor do I "know" 100% that the Earth won't explode tomorrow. Do you?
 
Ask yourself this question - take a look at the Forbes 400 sometime. Buffett, Gates, Walton's, etc. Do you really, truly, honestly believe that any of them have 10% of their money in gold? Really, truly, honestly. And if the answer is no, why do you think that is?

Why is it that the only people who push for 10% gold are nuts on internet conspiracy forums or hucksters on late night TV?

If it was such a great investment, wouldn't Buffett, Munger, Gates, Walton, et al, be advising all of us to invest in gold?

Just wondering.....

I don't know where the 10% comes from. I don't follow it. I have my own strategy which doesn't come out to that 10%. In fact, gold is rather low on my prioritized list. I watch what other super-wealthy investors do and I see some recommend for precious metals and some against. I also watch what nations are doing. And banks. You seem to have some inside information on those people's portfolio's- care to share what they are investing in?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom