Gold will go $1,500/oz

There's a pretty picture, subsistence farming.

No, it's not a metaphor. But it's also not subsistence farming, either. It's one investment among many.

Or if you want to live with modern luxuries such as electricity you may need to up the acreage and invest another few tens (or hundreds) of thousands in fertilizer, pest management, harvesting machines and marketing.

.... or put some of the rest of your money into Caterpillar and use the dividend checks to pay for electricity.

Sure, your son can have an ounce of gold to remember you by. Personally, I think that's a lousy remembrance, and I think he'd prefer to remember how much fun you had together playing catch in the field where the potatoes grew. The nice thing about that is that you can leave that to all six of your sons and all four of your daughters. Along with a sack of potatoes each.
 
Gold is pretty, it does have that going for it. I don't think there's anything wrong with given an ounce of gold as a keepsake or wearing gold jewelry. I'm partial to gold watches myself but they aren't investments (although my rolex has actually held it's value over the last 10 years).
 
So, when gold does crash, how far will it likely drop? I've got half a mind to long term short gold on the ol' Forex.

Nobody knows. Nobody knows when, either. J. Maynard Keynes is credited with saying something like "The market can stay irrational for longer than you can stay liquid," which is a fair warning for shorting any bubble. Cheap put options would be good, though, your losses would be limited no matter how long the mania continues.
 
No, it's not a metaphor. But it's also not subsistence farming, either. It's one investment among many.

No big disagreement. Just that I see the precious metals as one investment among many.

....
Sure, your son can have an ounce of gold to remember you by. Personally, I think that's a lousy remembrance, and I think he'd prefer to remember how much fun you had together playing catch in the field where the potatoes grew. The nice thing about that is that you can leave that to all six of your sons and all four of your daughters. Along with a sack of potatoes each.

Both sons will get a share of the small portable assets and both have memories of the things we've enjoyed doing together in the state of yo. We've always thought that playing catch was a lousy way to spend time.

I know my sons well enough to know that they will not think of the gold as a lousy remembrance. Even if gold goes down in relative value from todays' market they will appreciate the effort I made to make sure they get the benefit of what I have earned.

Is there any magic in the stuff? Certainly no magic in the way JREF might be concerned. Yet there is some power and mystery in holding, in your hand, something that your father held and valued. That's how it is for us anyway.

More to the point of the OP. Is physical gold a good investment now? I'm not buying any currently but if I had a larger liquid portfolio I probably would.
 
More to the point of the OP. Is physical gold a good investment now? I'm not buying any currently but if I had a larger liquid portfolio I probably would.

Don't think of gold as an investment. It's a scarce commodity that has long been convertable to, and from, currencies du jour at a fairly level value exchange rate.

In 1980 I bought a 5 MB hard drive for about $500. Ten years later I bought a 2 TB (400,000 times more storage) for $200. This happened because people invested in business instead of buying gold to bury in the back yard.

In 1965 I bought a gallon of gas for $0.25. In 2010 It cost $3.00. This is the closest match within these examples to CPI.

In 1965 I could have bought an toz of gold (if in the Au biz) for about $35. In 2010 it would cost me $1300. This is way more than inflation by virtually any measure and never sustains in the very long term. It simply reflects fear - not that there is anything wrong with that.

If I had put $1000 in the matress in 1965 I would have $1000 today. Easily the most liquid "investment" but also the worst thing to do long term. Had I put it in a demand savings account, FDIC insured, it would be worth more but would not have performed as well as petroleum let alone gold.

Gold's big advantage is that it is a form of wealth stable over centuries and empires.

Right now it is, IMO, overpriced. However, if currencies collapse, it is underpriced, possibly by a lot. You pays your money and takes your chances.
 
Last edited:
Don't think of gold as an investment. It's a scarce commodity that has long been convertable to, and from, currencies du jour at a fairly level value exchange rate.

In 1980 I bought a 5 MB hard drive for about $500. Ten years later I bought a 2 TB (400,000 times more storage) for $200. This happened because people invested in business instead of buying gold to bury in the back yard.

In 1965 I bought a gallon of gas for $0.25. In 2010 It cost $3.00. This is the closest match within these examples to CPI.

In 1965 I could have bought an toz of gold (if in the Au biz) for about $35. In 2010 it would cost me $1300. This is way more than inflation by virtually any measure and never sustains in the very long term. It simply reflects fear - not that there is anything wrong with that.

Huh? Let's see -- gas goes from $0.25 to $3.00, an increase of about a hundred-fold, and you say that's the match for the CPI.

Gold goes from $35 to $1300, an increase of about forty-fold, and you say that's way more than inflation?

Inflation, historically, has been running about 5%; this means that prices overall double about every fourteen years. In fifty years, that's four doublings, so we'd expect to see prices about 16 times higher now than they were fifty years ago. So gas has actually gone up more than general inflation. So has gold, but most of that is the bubble. As recently as 2004, gold was trading at only about $400, which was actually substantially less than the expected inflation increases.

Of course, there's a very good reason for that. People don't need to buy gold, and when times are good people don't want to buy gold, because it's a lousy investment. When times are bad, people panic and buy gold at vastly inflated prices....
 
More to the point of the OP. Is physical gold a good investment now? I'm not buying any currently but if I had a larger liquid portfolio I probably would.

Buying into a well-established bubble is almost never a good investment.

Think of it this way. If gold really were a good investment, who would be selling it to you?
 
I do agree with one thing, gold is currently a bubble. I do think it will go higher before it goes back down. It could easily have seen it's peak though if the economy can get chugging a bit more.

Therein lies the danger.

If you have piles of cash to invest real estate is on sale right now too.

This would be a significantly wiser thing to do---depending on the location, location, location, of course.
 
Huh? Let's see -- gas goes from $0.25 to $3.00, an increase of about a hundred-fold, and you say that's the match for the CPI.

Gold goes from $35 to $1300, an increase of about forty-fold, and you say that's way more than inflation?

Read what I wrote. I did not write that. I was providing examples of other products to illustrate relative variation and to provide some indication why I think gold is currently overpriced.

.... As recently as 2004, gold was trading at only about $400, which was actually substantially less than the expected inflation increases.

Of course, there's a very good reason for that. People don't need to buy gold, and when times are good people don't want to buy gold, because it's a lousy investment. When times are bad, people panic and buy gold at vastly inflated prices....

Exactly my point. Arguably, gold was worth even less than $400 then. Didn't Tony Blair sell a fairly large amount of the UK's gold at about $200/toz not long before that? Obviously it was thought to be overpriced at the time.

Gold's value is classic supply and demand where the supply is effectively fixed and the demand fluctuates with fear.
 
Last edited:
Gold (priced in USD) will continue to go up until the economy rebounds which may be quite a while.

The downside is how any profits are taxed by Uncle Sam.

Normally, when you sell a capital asset you've owned for more than one year, your tax rate is capped at 15%.

But when you sell a collectible, tax law caps your maximum rate on long-term capital gains at 28%, not 15%. In other words, on a $100,000 gain (lucky you!), that means you don't pay $15,000 to Uncle Sam, you pay $28,000 -- an extra $13,000.

If you hold the asset for less than a year, it gets worse. Your gain becomes a short-term gain, and it's taxed at regular income tax rates. That means a rate of as much as 35%. On a $100,000 gain, that's $35,000 you pay to the government.

http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Taxes/CutYourTaxes/taxes-can-take-the-shine-off-gold.aspx


Surprised nobody has pointed this out!
 
Gold (priced in USD) will continue to go up until the economy rebounds which may be quite a while.

No, it won't.

It will go up until people think that there's better returns to be made from investment in other areas. The stock market, in particular, is a leading indicator and is likely to pick up well before the economy rebounds. But when analysts decide they can make 12% or so RoI on stock price growth, plus whatever dividend yield they can get, some of them will start to pull money out of gold and put it into equities. As soon as this happens, this means that demand for gold will weaken and supply will strengthen, lowering the price of gold. And at this point the house of cards will collapse.

And it will happen well before the economy rebounds.

Surprised nobody has pointed this out!

It's not really relevant. The reason gold is a lousy investment is because it doesn't generate wealth, not because of the tax treatment. There are always ways to game the system (hell, buy gold in your IRA), but there aren't often ways to make a money-losing investment show a profit.
 
For some reason I think the gold hounds think that it's going to do down something like this:
1) Buy gold
2) we get hyperinflation and gold goes to $500,000,000 an ounce.
3) Profit!

Of course there are a lot of idiots out there buying iraqi dinars as well with similar reasoning.

I think it's even stranger than that. I've seen a few clips of Beck trying to sell the stuff, and he's tied it into this whole doomsday scenario. Hyper inflation is certainly part of it, but he thinks all of society will disintegrate. That's why he puts on adds for that doomsday seed garden on right after the gold.

I think there's probably an Apocalyptic foundation to all of this nonsense, but it's so coded and vague (me not being versed enough in doomsday theology to really understand it) that it's hard to tell.

THat's why I find the gold stuff so amusing (in addition to the fact that it's just a trick for the companies selling the gold to take insane commissions off the sale): why would you want a pile of soft, not particularly useful metal when society has deteriorated.

Wouldn't you want a few tons of steel to armor your El Camino?
 
I think it's even stranger than that. I've seen a few clips of Beck trying to sell the stuff, and he's tied it into this whole doomsday scenario.

I think that's it.

I think this is basically Survivalism for Dummies. In the sense of "it is morally wrong to allow a sucker to keep his money" (W.C. Fields) "dummies." Lots of people are expecting society to disintegrate; lots of people want society to disintegrate, because society has not been particularly good to them and they feel that they've been unjustly deprived of the wealth and status that is their due.

So, if you think about what made barbarian kings rich,.... it's gold, right? So if you have enough gold, you can become a barbarian king when It All Goes To Hell, right?

Of course, what really made barbarian kings rich is the fact that they were awesome swordsmen who could take the gold from rich schnucks who didn't realize that in the hands of the right person, steel is much more valuable than gold. Conan the Cimmerian was indeed a barbarian king with rooms full of gold, but he got that way by taking over the palace where the rooms were already.
 
I think it's even stranger than that. I've seen a few clips of Beck trying to sell the stuff, and he's tied it into this whole doomsday scenario. Hyper inflation is certainly part of it, but he thinks all of society will disintegrate. That's why he puts on adds for that doomsday seed garden on right after the gold.

I think there's probably an Apocalyptic foundation to all of this nonsense, but it's so coded and vague (me not being versed enough in doomsday theology to really understand it) that it's hard to tell.

THat's why I find the gold stuff so amusing (in addition to the fact that it's just a trick for the companies selling the gold to take insane commissions off the sale): why would you want a pile of soft, not particularly useful metal when society has deteriorated.

Wouldn't you want a few tons of steel to armor your El Camino?

Do you really think people who may be preparing for various possible future scenarios as you describe are just purchasing gold? Apparently certain advertisers also think they'd be interested in buying seeds ...
 
I think that's it.

I think this is basically Survivalism for Dummies. In the sense of "it is morally wrong to allow a sucker to keep his money" (W.C. Fields) "dummies." Lots of people are expecting society to disintegrate; lots of people want society to disintegrate, because society has not been particularly good to them and they feel that they've been unjustly deprived of the wealth and status that is their due.

So, if you think about what made barbarian kings rich,.... it's gold, right? So if you have enough gold, you can become a barbarian king when It All Goes To Hell, right?

Of course, what really made barbarian kings rich is the fact that they were awesome swordsmen who could take the gold from rich schnucks who didn't realize that in the hands of the right person, steel is much more valuable than gold. Conan the Cimmerian was indeed a barbarian king with rooms full of gold, but he got that way by taking over the palace where the rooms were already.

It does seem like it would make more sense to buy guns and ammo than gold in a meltdown type scenario.

However the idea of society completely disintegrating on a global level is pretty silly.
 
No, it won't.

It will go up until people think that there's better returns to be made from investment in other areas. The stock market, in particular, is a leading indicator and is likely to pick up well before the economy rebounds. But when analysts decide they can make 12% or so RoI on stock price growth, plus whatever dividend yield they can get, some of them will start to pull money out of gold and put it into equities. As soon as this happens, this means that demand for gold will weaken and supply will strengthen, lowering the price of gold. And at this point the house of cards will collapse.

And it will happen well before the economy rebounds.



It's not really relevant. The reason gold is a lousy investment is because it doesn't generate wealth, not because of the tax treatment. There are always ways to game the system (hell, buy gold in your IRA), but there aren't often ways to make a money-losing investment show a profit.


Hey... call a top, then. I really would like to know.
 
Hey... call a top, then. I really would like to know.

Can't be done. There are too many open political questions for economics to give you an answer.

For example, the Fed has been trying to engineer an economic recovery by increasing the money supply to pull us out of the liquidity trap we seem to be in now. The Japanese experience, however, suggests that monetary policy alone can't do that, and there will need to be some active government stimulus as well. When will we see a real jobs bill? That's the sort of thing that could be passed on Monday by the lame-duck legislature, or could be delayed for years by Tea Party obstructionism.

Similarly, they discuss on another thread how the most anti-Fed legislator in history, Ron Paul, has just been appointed to chair the subcommittee that oversees the Fed; if he manages to push through policy changes that strip the Fed of it's authority to increase the money supply, no one knows exactly how much damage that would do to the economy.

As a third example, Gov. Christie just killed the tunnel project that would have put 6,000 construction workers to work in New Jersey and created 50,000 jobs on project completion. With only about four million jobs in New Jersey to begin with, that's 0.15% higher unemployment rate increase at the stroke of a pen. It wouldn't surprise me to learn that he had managed to put the recovery off (in the New Jersey region, at least) by six months to a year.

That kind of policy decision is one of the reasons that long-term economic forecasting is difficult. I can tell you what will happen with the current situation, and I can tell you what the likely consequences of any proposed policy change might be. But I can't tell you what policy changes will be proposed, and I can't tell you which proposed changes will be enacted. That's not economics, but politics. I can tell you that defunding the Department of Education will cost hundreds of thousands of teachers their jobs and thereby raise the unemployment rate. But I can't tell you whether the current legislature will really follow through on the threats by a few (e.g. Rand Paul) to do that.
 
I'm putting all my money in Uranium Pu-36. Explosive space modulators are the next big thing!
 
Can't be done. There are too many open political questions for economics to give you an answer.

For example, the Fed has been trying to engineer an economic recovery by increasing the money supply to pull us out of the liquidity trap we seem to be in now. The Japanese experience, however, suggests that monetary policy alone can't do that, and there will need to be some active government stimulus as well. When will we see a real jobs bill? That's the sort of thing that could be passed on Monday by the lame-duck legislature, or could be delayed for years by Tea Party obstructionism.

Similarly, they discuss on another thread how the most anti-Fed legislator in history, Ron Paul, has just been appointed to chair the subcommittee that oversees the Fed; if he manages to push through policy changes that strip the Fed of it's authority to increase the money supply, no one knows exactly how much damage that would do to the economy.

As a third example, Gov. Christie just killed the tunnel project that would have put 6,000 construction workers to work in New Jersey and created 50,000 jobs on project completion. With only about four million jobs in New Jersey to begin with, that's 0.15% higher unemployment rate increase at the stroke of a pen. It wouldn't surprise me to learn that he had managed to put the recovery off (in the New Jersey region, at least) by six months to a year.

That kind of policy decision is one of the reasons that long-term economic forecasting is difficult. I can tell you what will happen with the current situation, and I can tell you what the likely consequences of any proposed policy change might be. But I can't tell you what policy changes will be proposed, and I can't tell you which proposed changes will be enacted. That's not economics, but politics. I can tell you that defunding the Department of Education will cost hundreds of thousands of teachers their jobs and thereby raise the unemployment rate. But I can't tell you whether the current legislature will really follow through on the threats by a few (e.g. Rand Paul) to do that.


And the uncertainty you invoke will act to suppress gold prices? I doubt that.

I'm not here to argue politics with you by the way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom